Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be outraged about fee-paying schools and social inequality?

469 replies

coffeerevelsrule · 10/04/2023 16:45

I have a ds in Y11 who has been researching potential careers and degrees and it has brought home to me what a horribly unequal society we still have in this country. Apparently 70% of barristers went to public school and there are similar stats for other desirable non-stem roles like journalism and the civil service, as well as medicine. It's a bloody disgrace - what a joke for a supposedly modern society.

And it seems that certain schemes like blind recruitment might also feed into this as although going to Oxbridge might have become slightly more attainable recently thanks to contextual offers and an awareness that those institutions shouldn't be filled with people from certain schools, now blind recruitment means the advantage a state school student may have got from going there is pretty much cancelled out.

To me it seems that ds is most disadvantaged in a way as he wouldn't qualify for schemes aimed at people who are the first in their families to go to uni and we aren't in a deprived area, but he has none of the advantages that would have come from going to an independent school. Everything about us is just average!

He is very bright (predicted all 9s and got that in his mocks) and wants to achieve but it seems that the odds are against people like him having prestigious roles. Obviously when he is quoting these stats at me I'm telling him not to be defeatist and that he has every chance of doing something amazing as long as he keeps working hard, but inside I'm wondering if how true that is.

I've always been against fee-paying schools but him reeling off all these stats at me has just been sickening and yet when Labour make noises about doing something about it there's outrage when in my opinion there should be daily outrage about the current situation.

Can anyone who cares about fairness honestly say I'm BU?

OP posts:
MarshaBradyo · 11/04/2023 09:46

Bumpitybumper · 11/04/2023 09:29

You might but countless studies have proven that accent influences how intelligent we perceive someone to be. I have experienced this first hand so know for a fact it is definitely still a thing, especially with British accents that are viewed as working class. Studies also suggest ethnic minority accents are also perceived negatively.

Just to be clear, I'm not an advocate of this at all but simply pointing out that something as seemingly irrelevant as the way you pronounce words can have an impact on your access to opportunity. So just being born in an area that has a nice southern accent could play to your advantage, whilst being born in an equivalent area in other regions may have the opposite effect.

The state school near has a kind of selection by house price. It does very well, the dc have a range of next places they go on to as would be expected from mixed cohort at entry. But if you have 9 / A star / Oxbridge dc they can reach that aim. It’s a comp not a grammar.

Many parents make sacrifices or put a lot of effort in to being near that school. What would the anger look like in reality?

They won’t be asking to mix up who goes eg through a lottery system. They don’t want it to be a more difficult environment. They’re not going to argue for it. The opposite is more likely.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 11/04/2023 09:43

And OP, the fact that you have started a thread worrying about this absolutely does mean that your ds has at least one supportive parent, regardless of how crap the other parent might be. That makes a huge difference.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 11/04/2023 09:40

yypppp · 11/04/2023 09:29

@coffeerevelsrule I agree it’s unfair. But honestly, if you had the money, would you truly not have sent your son?

I did have the money and chose not to send dd. Not out of some kind of noble notion of fairness, but rather because I didn't feel that it was worth it.

I agree with those posters who say that family background/wealth are the factors that really determine outcomes for children, not private schools per se. Educated, aspirational parents, a strong work ethic and enough money to facilitate extracurricular/supercurricular activities.

There will be some kids who no doubt benefit from extra attention/extra pushing etc that they get at a private school, but lots of private school pupils would probably do just as well wherever they went.

To be clear, I'm not trying to suggest that there isn't huge inequality in the system, and we absolutely need to try to tackle that. However, I think it's about wealth and aspiration rather than private schooling per se.

Stellanotbud · 11/04/2023 09:37

WheelsUp · 10/04/2023 18:13

Your son comes from a supportive household and predicted straight 9s.

If you'd paid for his education then he'd still be from a supportive household and predicted straight 9s.

Yabu to think he's disadvantaged. With the 2 main advantages that he has, he has every chance of being a state school educated barrister/medic/whatever.

My kids went to the local comp and achieved good qualifications etc and I see and hear of kids where there are proper hurdles to a happy life and success. For example my son has a friend whose parents have been in and out of prison pretty much his whole life. When he was in primary school, his dad's mugshot was plastered on the front page of the local paper. It's amazing that he was able to continue to go to school never mind so A-levels and go to university. Him and his siblings have had a chaotic upbringing with different family carers and foster families but he's going to do great. He was actually in the school newsletter photographed with the KC that they'd had in as a careers guest. Some kids are just going to be fine regardless of the easier ride that others have.

I suspect that things are even more extreme in places like the US hence everyone chasing Ivy League spaces. At least in the UK they don't need extra curriculars and the right expensive summer schools to get a spot at a top uni. Even if 99% were public school educated, what kind of people do you think that 1% are like ? Stellar grades like your son.

You are completely correct about the Ivies. I have Irifg-Amererican cousins on the East Coast (New York& Connecticut). They are all very wealthy but their children's lives have been so carefully planned. Right neighbourhood (Rye, Scardsdale etc) private catholic school, loads of enrichment camps, carefully chose activities (2 instrument's, hockey, lacrosse, rowing, debating, languages), lots of foreign travel. They have pumped serious money & social & cultural capital into the kids who are now heading for the Ivies..

Ladybowes · 11/04/2023 09:37

MorrisZapp · 11/04/2023 09:25

What would wealthy parents 'not standing for' poorer schools look like?

Loads of very articulate people, some of whom work in journalism, have direct experience of the current NHS shit show, and are shouting it from the rooftops. Only the government can actually effect change though.

It's a myth that good schools exist at random and rich people can afford to move near them. 'good schools' ie those with consistently high exam pass rates are schools lucky enough to be in areas of high parental engagement.

My DS goes to a high rated state school. The teachers are fine but I don't see them waving any magic wands. They just have well fed, well slept kids from mostly middle class homes to work with.

The worst rated schools are in areas of deprivation. If you swapped over the staff, you wouldn't swap the exam passes. It's the parents that would do that.

Absolutely people do move to areas where there are 'good' schools - just pop over to the education section on here and you will see many threads where people are talking about just that. I live in SW London and trust me - our house prices have rocketed in part due to parents moving into the area trying to be in the catchment of the local grammar schools.

Yes only the government can change things but we know the main political parties use focus groups to develop policies that make them electable.. maybe if more of us got active and angry about the state of the system - change would happen. This in my opinion is the only reason the current government has not completely privatised our NHS yet - as they know public opinion is against it. If I was cynical I might think they are deliberately run down the NHS into the ground to make it easier to be completely privatised.

yypppp · 11/04/2023 09:29

@coffeerevelsrule I agree it’s unfair. But honestly, if you had the money, would you truly not have sent your son?

Bumpitybumper · 11/04/2023 09:29

Dassams · 11/04/2023 09:06

Culturally we expect a doctor, barrister or even politician to talk and act a certain way and will be suspicious and unnerved when they don't align with the stereotypes.

I don't think that's right - in an increasingly global world I hope to hear lots of accents!

You might but countless studies have proven that accent influences how intelligent we perceive someone to be. I have experienced this first hand so know for a fact it is definitely still a thing, especially with British accents that are viewed as working class. Studies also suggest ethnic minority accents are also perceived negatively.

Just to be clear, I'm not an advocate of this at all but simply pointing out that something as seemingly irrelevant as the way you pronounce words can have an impact on your access to opportunity. So just being born in an area that has a nice southern accent could play to your advantage, whilst being born in an equivalent area in other regions may have the opposite effect.

MorrisZapp · 11/04/2023 09:25

What would wealthy parents 'not standing for' poorer schools look like?

Loads of very articulate people, some of whom work in journalism, have direct experience of the current NHS shit show, and are shouting it from the rooftops. Only the government can actually effect change though.

It's a myth that good schools exist at random and rich people can afford to move near them. 'good schools' ie those with consistently high exam pass rates are schools lucky enough to be in areas of high parental engagement.

My DS goes to a high rated state school. The teachers are fine but I don't see them waving any magic wands. They just have well fed, well slept kids from mostly middle class homes to work with.

The worst rated schools are in areas of deprivation. If you swapped over the staff, you wouldn't swap the exam passes. It's the parents that would do that.

Ladybowes · 11/04/2023 09:23

Drfosters · 11/04/2023 09:08

@Ladybowes

This is true but as I said earlier in this thread - if private schools were abolished tomorrow people with money would have to send their darling children to the local secondary - you would soon seen a massive improvement in many of these schools - as the moneyed classes would not stand for the poor resources that many of state school currently have to deal with. Classes would also be smaller like in private it would be a massive benefit to all our children.

I disagree. What will happen is that the tutoring industry will explode. My kids go to private secondary but they could have just as easily gone state, we were not ideologically wedded to the idea of private . However I would have employed as many tutors as they needed with the money saved should they have needed them if we had gone down the state route. I would have invested the money I saved into music lessons/ sport etc which would have given them an advantage. But I’m not going to be lobbying the government for better schools- I would just take their enrichment out of school time. Like most private school parents we aren’t super rich, we hold average middle class jobs. We would just do the best we can with what resources we have as is every single parent. I don’t think for a second that state schools will get better in the slightest sadly, education for the wealthier will just be off-grid.

You might not lobby the government but you might vote differently.. currently the main parties approaches to education is pretty much more of the same - don't rock the boat kind of policies. I would suggest we need more imaginative ways of tackling inequalities in education. As while on the whole the current system might be good for those with money vast numbers of the population don't have money or resources to help their children and rely completely on their local schools.

I appreciate that many who send their children to private schools have worked super hard to do this and I admired this - but at the same time I know many who work super hard and never in a month of Sundays could even dream of a private education or a tutor for their children. As I said earlier in the thread - I am most likely an idealist but I wish people could get angry about this unfairness and try to do something rather than shrugging their shoulders and that's life suck it up..

coffeerevelsrule · 11/04/2023 09:22

Drfosters I hate all this 'sadly' it will never get better...There have been huge improvements in teaching and education in my lifetime and even within my career and this could continue and grow if the government would fund it adequately. I agree with Ladybowes that if everyone had to use state schools there would be higher expectations of them and things would have to radically change. Talk about me and ds being defeatist - the amount of people on here who are happy to accept massive inequalities being baked into our system, probably because they are on the 'right' side of it, is really depressing. Look at what happened in Finland. But too many people here don't want an equal society.

OP posts:
Dassams · 11/04/2023 09:14

if private schools were abolished tomorrow people with money would have to send their darling children to the local secondary - you would soon seen a massive improvement in many of these schools

How can a huge influx into already overcrowded classrooms be an improvement? It will get much worse imo.

Parents will just spend money on tutoring and extra teaching and/or will help them themselves.

Lapland123 · 11/04/2023 09:10

Dassams · 11/04/2023 09:06

Culturally we expect a doctor, barrister or even politician to talk and act a certain way and will be suspicious and unnerved when they don't align with the stereotypes.

I don't think that's right - in an increasingly global world I hope to hear lots of accents!

I agree- I hope so too
English is my second language, this is the case for many, many of my medical colleagues.
However it’s worth the OP rethinking what she considers to be some great profession for her son… I would exclude medicine from that, wouldn’t recommend it to anyone young now. At least not in this country.
Juniors striking this week, consultants strike ballot in a few weeks as vast majority have indicated to BMA wish to strike due to 35%+ pay erosion.

Drfosters · 11/04/2023 09:08

@Ladybowes

This is true but as I said earlier in this thread - if private schools were abolished tomorrow people with money would have to send their darling children to the local secondary - you would soon seen a massive improvement in many of these schools - as the moneyed classes would not stand for the poor resources that many of state school currently have to deal with. Classes would also be smaller like in private it would be a massive benefit to all our children.

I disagree. What will happen is that the tutoring industry will explode. My kids go to private secondary but they could have just as easily gone state, we were not ideologically wedded to the idea of private . However I would have employed as many tutors as they needed with the money saved should they have needed them if we had gone down the state route. I would have invested the money I saved into music lessons/ sport etc which would have given them an advantage. But I’m not going to be lobbying the government for better schools- I would just take their enrichment out of school time. Like most private school parents we aren’t super rich, we hold average middle class jobs. We would just do the best we can with what resources we have as is every single parent. I don’t think for a second that state schools will get better in the slightest sadly, education for the wealthier will just be off-grid.

Dassams · 11/04/2023 09:06

Culturally we expect a doctor, barrister or even politician to talk and act a certain way and will be suspicious and unnerved when they don't align with the stereotypes.

I don't think that's right - in an increasingly global world I hope to hear lots of accents!

Bumpitybumper · 11/04/2023 08:54

Equality of opportunity is a complex thing. In reality there is only so much opportunity available in society, only so many top jobs and place at elite institutions etc.

As other PPs have pointed out, you can never make the system fair. OP may dislike private schools because it ostensibly gives people an advantage over her offspring but her own children will benefit from many things that other children won't have. In the state system, you have grammar schools, OFSTED outstanding and good schools, mediocre schools and some absolutely awful schools. If you have money you can buy your way into a better catchment than if you don't. You can also afford to pay for tutors, buy the latest IT equipment and books and pay for extra curricular activities that will make your kids more rounded.

All of this extends way beyond money too, as one of the biggest determining factors that impacts the outcome for children is parental input. If your parents are well educated and have the time and inclination to help their children then those kids will have a pretty big advantage over those who have very little input from their parents.

I always think the real final death knell to the idea of achieving 'equality of opportunity' is the unconscious bias we all have towards things that are difficult to measure and articulate. It's been proven that accent will affect how intelligent we perceive people to be and there are undoubtedly non verbal cues and mannerisms that we all pickup on that influence how we view others and the amount of opportunity they will therefore be afforded. Culturally we expect a doctor, barrister or even politician to talk and act a certain way and will be suspicious and unnerved when they don't align with the stereotypes.

Worldgonecrazy · 11/04/2023 08:52

I’ve spent my working life as PA to directors and chief execs of multi million turnover companies. Out of all the execs only a tiny proportion have been from private education or privileged backgrounds (most of those at the BBC!) Many of them have worked up from entry level jobs. Intelligence, hard work and a huge heap of luck are important.

Your don sounds bright so there is no reason he couldn’t aim for one of the more prestigious universities to help him get a headstart.

Ladybowes · 11/04/2023 08:46

Lapland123 · 11/04/2023 08:38

Sorry but explain how the state schools would improve and the classes get smaller if parents of kids in private school were to rock up looking for a state school place.

is it back to some daft idea that they would ‘demand’ more?
teachers are doing all they can. ‘demanding’ more and ‘demanding’ small classes - how would that happen?

State schools are funded by government/ taxpayer and locally demanding parents will get absolutely nowhere with school budgets as they are.

Your suggestion makes no sense.

Here is a recent article showing how rubbish these private schools are at being charities. More teachers are needed already so that's nothing new and something the government should be working on anyway - but that's a whole new thread. Maybe there would be a radical change in how schools are funded I don't know - neither do you - but that's not an excuse to sit back and say - so is life... suck it up.

.https://www.opendemocracy.net/en/private-school-charity-status-labour/

Top private schools’ ‘paltry’ charity work revealed

Occasional tours of a WW2 bunker are among the ways private schools justify their billion-pound charitable status

https://www.opendemocracy.net/en/private-school-charity-status-labour

yellin · 11/04/2023 08:43

@coffeerevelsrule tell your son that when he looks at employment stats, e.g. for barristers, he's looking back in time to the inequities of 20-40 years ago. They tell you nothing about recruitment practices of the present time, and serve no purpose other than to create a chip on his shoulder.

There are plenty of jobs, and bright, motivated young people who have skills that are relevant to the modern economy will do well. Tell him that at his age he doesn't need to decide what he will be in 20 years time, because that job title may not have been invented yet, but just focus on one or more broad paths that suit his interest and personality and see where they lead.

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 11/04/2023 08:41

This is true but as I said earlier in this thread - if private schools were abolished tomorrow people with money would have to send their darling children to the local secondary - you would soon seen a massive improvement in many of these schools - as the moneyed classes would not stand for the poor resources that many of state school currently have to deal with.

I don't disagree, but the students that come from money will still have a massive advantage over the ones that don't. ''Twas ever thus.

Society will never be equal. There will always be people who have more and there will always be people that have less.

You can't tell rich parents that they're not allowed to pay for tutors, or piano lessons, or riding lessons or big houses - and those are all things that improve chances in life.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 11/04/2023 08:39

A lot more are going to state schools! (memo to self, check before posting!)

Lapland123 · 11/04/2023 08:38

Ladybowes · 11/04/2023 08:32

This is true but as I said earlier in this thread - if private schools were abolished tomorrow people with money would have to send their darling children to the local secondary - you would soon seen a massive improvement in many of these schools - as the moneyed classes would not stand for the poor resources that many of state school currently have to deal with. Classes would also be smaller like in private it would be a massive benefit to all our children.

The best and quickest thing we could to level the playing field is take away the charitable status of these private schools. We need to raise the standards of all schools to the same level and by keeping private schools this will be difficult. Parents of private school children should be happy to send their children to state school simply as that but we know currently they are not.

Sorry but explain how the state schools would improve and the classes get smaller if parents of kids in private school were to rock up looking for a state school place.

is it back to some daft idea that they would ‘demand’ more?
teachers are doing all they can. ‘demanding’ more and ‘demanding’ small classes - how would that happen?

State schools are funded by government/ taxpayer and locally demanding parents will get absolutely nowhere with school budgets as they are.

Your suggestion makes no sense.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 11/04/2023 08:37

Look on the bright side, OP - because fees are relatively so much less affordable than they were say 30 years ago, a lot fewer of the sort of children who’d have attended independent schools, are now going to state schools.

The biggest advantage IMO for children at whatever school, is parents who care about their education, who encourage them and expect them to work reasonably hard, who read to them when younger, etc. Not to mention who expect certain standards of behaviour, both at home and at school. And none of those are dependent on having loadsamoney.

MorrisZapp · 11/04/2023 08:35

Gruelle · 10/04/2023 17:04

No one cares where you went to school at the Bar. Chambers do like Oxbridge Firsts and academic prizes. However, what distinguishes a large proportion of practising barristers (as opposed to those who left after Bar exams or after pupillage) is (still) having sufficient independent income to survive the first few years when fees are slow to come in but Chambers rent is constantly rising. These people may well have come from independent schools - but that’s because they’re from wealthy families, not because the school somehow magicked a career for them.

People don’t (f’rinstance) go skiing because they went to private school, or own huge houses in quaint villages because they went to private school, or remember lockdown as a lovely peaceful time of long walks and gardening and family togetherness because they went to private school - they have access to these things because they have money, probably across generations.

Not sure what else to say to you …

I think this nails it. Private school is just school, the kid still has to do the exams themselves. But they are more likely to come from wealth that creates all kind of other privileges.

gogohmm · 11/04/2023 08:34

You are not incorrect op with the stats but it's far more complicated, partly there's a time lag, 60 year old barristers we're at school in the 60's, a very different world when working class kids left school at 15. Things have got better but it takes 2 full generations to work through changes. Second issue with your barrister example is that pay is incredibly low at the beginning meaning it favours those who have parents to support them, thirdly good old nepotism, barristers often have family who are barristers so they got the right work experience etc. Banking would be a far better example of how things have changed - since they brought in university blind recruitment the number of entrants from poorer backgrounds have shot up, as they were at the once discriminated against universities.

Ladybowes · 11/04/2023 08:32

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 11/04/2023 08:19

It's not private school that gives you these advantages, it's money. You could ban private schools tomorrow and it wouldn't make much (if any) difference.

Money buys you a nice house with space, so your children have their own rooms and a quiet area to study, sleep and do homework.

It buys you nice holidays and lots of educational, cultural experiences abroad.

It pays for lots of extra curricular sports and activities that look good on UCAS applications.

It means your parents can pay for tutors and private lessons if you're struggling.

It means you don't need to work through school or university, giving you more time to focus on work.

It means you have access to things like cars and lessons, so you immediately have access to all those jobs that require you to have a driving license.

You can't ban people from having money and spending it on their children.

This is true but as I said earlier in this thread - if private schools were abolished tomorrow people with money would have to send their darling children to the local secondary - you would soon seen a massive improvement in many of these schools - as the moneyed classes would not stand for the poor resources that many of state school currently have to deal with. Classes would also be smaller like in private it would be a massive benefit to all our children.

The best and quickest thing we could to level the playing field is take away the charitable status of these private schools. We need to raise the standards of all schools to the same level and by keeping private schools this will be difficult. Parents of private school children should be happy to send their children to state school simply as that but we know currently they are not.