Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be outraged about fee-paying schools and social inequality?

469 replies

coffeerevelsrule · 10/04/2023 16:45

I have a ds in Y11 who has been researching potential careers and degrees and it has brought home to me what a horribly unequal society we still have in this country. Apparently 70% of barristers went to public school and there are similar stats for other desirable non-stem roles like journalism and the civil service, as well as medicine. It's a bloody disgrace - what a joke for a supposedly modern society.

And it seems that certain schemes like blind recruitment might also feed into this as although going to Oxbridge might have become slightly more attainable recently thanks to contextual offers and an awareness that those institutions shouldn't be filled with people from certain schools, now blind recruitment means the advantage a state school student may have got from going there is pretty much cancelled out.

To me it seems that ds is most disadvantaged in a way as he wouldn't qualify for schemes aimed at people who are the first in their families to go to uni and we aren't in a deprived area, but he has none of the advantages that would have come from going to an independent school. Everything about us is just average!

He is very bright (predicted all 9s and got that in his mocks) and wants to achieve but it seems that the odds are against people like him having prestigious roles. Obviously when he is quoting these stats at me I'm telling him not to be defeatist and that he has every chance of doing something amazing as long as he keeps working hard, but inside I'm wondering if how true that is.

I've always been against fee-paying schools but him reeling off all these stats at me has just been sickening and yet when Labour make noises about doing something about it there's outrage when in my opinion there should be daily outrage about the current situation.

Can anyone who cares about fairness honestly say I'm BU?

OP posts:
MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 11/04/2023 11:00

Ladybowes · 11/04/2023 10:58

Don't get me started on faith schools that's whole new thread! 😂

Grin
Ladybowes · 11/04/2023 10:58

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 11/04/2023 10:55

Yes, I agree, I would get rid of state grammar schools. And state-funded faith schools as well tbh.

I wouldn't ban private schools, though I would take away charitable status for those that aren't doing enough to warrant this.

Don't get me started on faith schools that's whole new thread! 😂

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 11/04/2023 10:55

Ladybowes · 11/04/2023 10:43

I agree with you that wealth inequalities is the bigger factor.. however, I would suggest that if wealth was more fairly spread out - we might not need private schools at all - obviously I don't know this would happen - but the system is so unfair and so few seem that bothered by it - well they're not bothered enough to do anything about it about (although I appreciate many may feel helpless) - I think that is what bothers me the most.

Just as a matter of principle I am against education being so divided - grammar schools in particular where children are in essence label as not smart enough at 11, many private schools also have very few SEND children and I have heard albeit anecdotal stories about parents with SEND children being pushed out of private schools as the children may not the get the 'results' an academic school should be getting.

Yes, I agree, I would get rid of state grammar schools. And state-funded faith schools as well tbh.

I wouldn't ban private schools, though I would take away charitable status for those that aren't doing enough to warrant this.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 11/04/2023 10:53

I can’t work out how you think medicine is not a STEM subject.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 11/04/2023 10:50

TapestryTeddy · 11/04/2023 10:41

@TheaBrandt absolutely agree with this. There is also a very big difference between an air of confidence and actual confidence. Scrape the surface and the air soon disappears. Real confidence is not like that. I'm not saying private school DC can't have real confidence, more that it depends so much on the individual and it doesn't come from school type.

Yes, I agree with this too. A veneer of confidence is not the same as true confidence.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 11/04/2023 10:49

Sugarfree23 · 11/04/2023 10:39

The kids who get into the top classes in state schools in a lot of ways are removed from the disruption that goes on in the lower classes.
They are in with like minded kids who are expected to do well and want to learn.

It's the middle and lower classes where kids have little ambition.
Undiagnosed SEN or SEN that's not bad enough for extra help.
Those are the kids who are bored and need extra support who end up just being disruptive together.

X post but yes, I agree with you.

chanceofpear · 11/04/2023 10:48

You yourself have said your not in a deprived area. Your son i guess (given your are posting at all) has a supportive family. You and your family are privileged and not disadvantaged. Get over yourself.

I'm all for levelling up but you are being totally ridiculous.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 11/04/2023 10:48

Sugarfree23 · 11/04/2023 10:35

It's not just wealth that makes the difference.
Private school kids seem to have an air of confidence about them that state kids don't.

There has to be less disruption in the classrooms, if a child is upsetting other paying customers they will be removed from the school - better to remove customer than to have another 5 or 6 disgruntled and take business elsewhere.

Do you not think that wealth can produce that air of confidence without private schooling? If a child is exposed to a wide variety of people and opportunities, they will develop that air of confidence regardless. Though I would argue that it's the true inner confidence that parents really ought to be aiming for, rather than just the "air" of it.

And re disruption in classrooms. Yes, kids might be removed from private schools if they are disruptive, but not always. To some extent, it may depend on the state of the school's finances as to whether they can afford to be too strict. The private schools near us certainly aren't free from problematic behaviour in some pupils.

And in any case, it isn't a given that there will be lots of disruption in state schools. My dd's school set pupils for every subject from Y7, and there was very little disruption in the top sets - certainly not to the extent that it affected her learning in any way. I accept that there was probably more in the lower sets which is one reason why kids who are struggling academically might benefit more from private schools than very academic children.

faffadoodledo · 11/04/2023 10:48

That's pretty unusual @SchoolQuestionnaire , to know no one with a part time job. My DC went to the local comp and it was rare to find a pupil who didn't work during term time in some capacity - waitressing (like DD) or in a supermarket (like DS) or in a variety if other jobs.

Ladybowes · 11/04/2023 10:47

Sugarfree23 · 11/04/2023 10:35

It's not just wealth that makes the difference.
Private school kids seem to have an air of confidence about them that state kids don't.

There has to be less disruption in the classrooms, if a child is upsetting other paying customers they will be removed from the school - better to remove customer than to have another 5 or 6 disgruntled and take business elsewhere.

I agree that behaviour is most likely better in private schools and part of this is about as you say paying customers.. but aren't we all paying customers! I pay my taxes to send my children to state school. I think the bigger factor here are the resources available - as a teacher managing the behaviour of 15 students is a totally different ball game to managing the behaviour of 30!

SchoolQuestionnaire · 11/04/2023 10:45

For many of these top flight careers you seem to need to be able to do unpaid/low paid internships etc, which I would be totally unable to support him in as a divorced teacher with two kids and an ex who doesn't contribute.

My kids are in independent school but that doesn’t mean we’ll be supporting them through life. Ds already has a part time job in a local supermarket at 17 and is the only one of his friends at state or indi school to do so. He pays for his car, phone and social life by working extra hours in the holidays. We could afford to support him but that isn’t life and it’s good for children to understand that the world doesn’t owe them a living. If he was to undertake an unpaid internship I’d expect this to continue as a minimum.

I was raised by my dm as my df was widowed when she was only 40. She was left with 3 kids to raise by herself but we never felt for a second that we were disadvantaged or not privileged. Your negative attitude is clearly rubbing off on your ds and in the long run it is that that will disadvantage him the most. It seems that you are so busy focusing on how unfair life is to your ds that you aren’t helping him to explore the myriad of ways he can help himself.

Ladybowes · 11/04/2023 10:43

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 11/04/2023 10:29

To be clear @Ladybowes, I'm not saying that aspiration without wealth is enough to create a level playing field. I think that wealth is absolutely a factor in determining outcomes for children.

I just think that wealth is the defining factor rather than private education. Children if wealthy parents at state schools do every bit as well as children who are privately educated in my experience.

So the real issue that we need to tackle is not private education imo, but rather wealth inequality more generally.

I agree with you that wealth inequalities is the bigger factor.. however, I would suggest that if wealth was more fairly spread out - we might not need private schools at all - obviously I don't know this would happen - but the system is so unfair and so few seem that bothered by it - well they're not bothered enough to do anything about it about (although I appreciate many may feel helpless) - I think that is what bothers me the most.

Just as a matter of principle I am against education being so divided - grammar schools in particular where children are in essence label as not smart enough at 11, many private schools also have very few SEND children and I have heard albeit anecdotal stories about parents with SEND children being pushed out of private schools as the children may not the get the 'results' an academic school should be getting.

TapestryTeddy · 11/04/2023 10:41

@TheaBrandt absolutely agree with this. There is also a very big difference between an air of confidence and actual confidence. Scrape the surface and the air soon disappears. Real confidence is not like that. I'm not saying private school DC can't have real confidence, more that it depends so much on the individual and it doesn't come from school type.

Sugarfree23 · 11/04/2023 10:39

The kids who get into the top classes in state schools in a lot of ways are removed from the disruption that goes on in the lower classes.
They are in with like minded kids who are expected to do well and want to learn.

It's the middle and lower classes where kids have little ambition.
Undiagnosed SEN or SEN that's not bad enough for extra help.
Those are the kids who are bored and need extra support who end up just being disruptive together.

TheaBrandt · 11/04/2023 10:38

It’s not private school kids. It’s middle class confident kids.

Sugarfree23 · 11/04/2023 10:35

It's not just wealth that makes the difference.
Private school kids seem to have an air of confidence about them that state kids don't.

There has to be less disruption in the classrooms, if a child is upsetting other paying customers they will be removed from the school - better to remove customer than to have another 5 or 6 disgruntled and take business elsewhere.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 11/04/2023 10:29

To be clear @Ladybowes, I'm not saying that aspiration without wealth is enough to create a level playing field. I think that wealth is absolutely a factor in determining outcomes for children.

I just think that wealth is the defining factor rather than private education. Children if wealthy parents at state schools do every bit as well as children who are privately educated in my experience.

So the real issue that we need to tackle is not private education imo, but rather wealth inequality more generally.

PleaseJustText · 11/04/2023 10:27

I'm not sure it's all about the private school. I think it's more that those students are more likely to have the money behind them to take the risk of joining competitive industries.

TapestryTeddy · 11/04/2023 10:26

@faffadoodledo you are preaching to the converted. NC here but I am a long time advocate of WP and understand and fully support the intracacies of contextual applications and offers. I have said exactly the same as you regarding dispelling the myth of Oxbridge contextual offers as they just don't exist and have been corrected with examples that Cambridge have recently started to make some contextual offers. I checked their website and it says what I quoted in my previous post, which I interpret as they can adjust offers down or up from standard depending on contextual circumstances. This is a whole different section on the website from where they talk about their pre-offer contextual flagging mechanisms, this section is purely about offers. I am fully supportive of that if it happens and I suspect it would only be in situations of very extenuating circumstances. There must be some cases where DC have had such disadvantaged educational circumstances that it could impact their grades to an extent that they wouldn't meet their offer and that being no reflection of their potential or suitability for Cambridge. If Cambridge tutors are confident that they can teach them from quite a lot of information - their grades in context, admissions tests and their interview - what is the issue? It is simply one little step further in levelling the playing field.

Dassams · 11/04/2023 10:23

You might but countless studies have proven that accent influences how intelligent we perceive someone to be. I have experienced this first hand so know for a fact it is definitely still a thing, especially with British accents that are viewed as working class. Studies also suggest ethnic minority accents are also perceived negatively.

Well I have an accent from a (northern) European country. So I am an ethnic minority in the UK.

I think I'm pretty intelligent and do not at all feel held back by your suggested prejudices.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 11/04/2023 10:23

Ladybowes · 11/04/2023 09:48

Yes I agree with some of this wealth and aspiration are important - the problem with private schools is many with aspirations don't get the chance of private school as they haven't got the wealth. If private schools were not offering something special/ additional to state schools why would the wealthy send their children to them... private schools sadly in my opinion don't ameliorate the problem of inequalities but add to them.

It's a good question as to why the wealthy send their kids to private schools.

In many cases, I think there is just an assumption that private schools are better, perhaps because people look at results without also looking at the cohort. However, bright kids can do just as well in state schools.

In some cases, I think people believe that they're buying access to a better peer group, ie less disruption etc. Not necessarily the case!

Some people are attracted by the wide range of extracurricular activities on offer, or lots of sport etc. But there is no reason why these can't be facilitated outside school if a parent is willing.

Some people believe that private schools confer confidence. But again, nothing that can't be developed and nurtured by a canny parent facilitating access to a range of opportunities.

Some people value the network that private schools offer. That may be valid in some cases, but only where the parents don't already have a wide network of their own.

Some people are attracted by the nice environments and superior facilities in private schools. This is fair enough, I suppose, if you prioritise that kind of thing.

Some people value the longer school days/one-stop-shop approach to extracurricular activities because it fits around their work commitments etc. Fair enough if that's what suits them.

Some people feel that their kids are struggling either academically, and that they would benefit from more attention/smaller class sizes etc. Fair enough if they feel that's what their kids need.

Some kids feel that their kids are struggling socially and that they would benefit from being in a smaller, more nurturing environment. Fair enough.

Some people feel that their kids lack self motivation and would benefit from being in a pushier environment. Again, fair enough.

Some people feel that their children's SEN will be better supported by a private school. Fair enough, if they have researched this and found it to be the case.

Some people have significant concerns about the specific state schools that are available to them, and choose private schools as a last resort. That may or may not be valid, depending on the schools in question.

I think there are lots of different reasons why people might choose to go private, but not all of the reasons are equally valid imo. And not all kids would necessarily benefit. Some kids thrive within the state sector, and simply don't need any of the "extras" that private schools are able to offer.

Sugarfree23 · 11/04/2023 09:52

There is a bit of me thinks one sure way of making sure state schools are the best they can be is to make all MPs kids attend state schools.

Now I know it will never happen, and you'll end up with some state schools having ££££ houses around them.

But it means they'd be an incentive to make sure all schools were properly funded, repars all up to date, well equipped, the SEN kids would have proper help as they won't want their kids education being compromised by wee dyslexic or ASD Johnny taking up far more of the teachers time than they should.

But it's a pipe dream that will never happen. Or they'd send their kids abroad for the best education.

Lapland123 · 11/04/2023 09:50

MorrisZapp · 11/04/2023 09:25

What would wealthy parents 'not standing for' poorer schools look like?

Loads of very articulate people, some of whom work in journalism, have direct experience of the current NHS shit show, and are shouting it from the rooftops. Only the government can actually effect change though.

It's a myth that good schools exist at random and rich people can afford to move near them. 'good schools' ie those with consistently high exam pass rates are schools lucky enough to be in areas of high parental engagement.

My DS goes to a high rated state school. The teachers are fine but I don't see them waving any magic wands. They just have well fed, well slept kids from mostly middle class homes to work with.

The worst rated schools are in areas of deprivation. If you swapped over the staff, you wouldn't swap the exam passes. It's the parents that would do that.

The whole idea that new - to- state school parents would demand some radical change is a pipe dream.

look at the mess theNHS is in, NHS dentistry etc too. The government aren’t listening to what most people want and need.

‘Demanding’ parents will do nothing aside from upset and further demoralise school staff who are doing their absolute best already

Ladybowes · 11/04/2023 09:48

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 11/04/2023 09:40

I did have the money and chose not to send dd. Not out of some kind of noble notion of fairness, but rather because I didn't feel that it was worth it.

I agree with those posters who say that family background/wealth are the factors that really determine outcomes for children, not private schools per se. Educated, aspirational parents, a strong work ethic and enough money to facilitate extracurricular/supercurricular activities.

There will be some kids who no doubt benefit from extra attention/extra pushing etc that they get at a private school, but lots of private school pupils would probably do just as well wherever they went.

To be clear, I'm not trying to suggest that there isn't huge inequality in the system, and we absolutely need to try to tackle that. However, I think it's about wealth and aspiration rather than private schooling per se.

Yes I agree with some of this wealth and aspiration are important - the problem with private schools is many with aspirations don't get the chance of private school as they haven't got the wealth. If private schools were not offering something special/ additional to state schools why would the wealthy send their children to them... private schools sadly in my opinion don't ameliorate the problem of inequalities but add to them.

yypppp · 11/04/2023 09:47

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 11/04/2023 09:40

I did have the money and chose not to send dd. Not out of some kind of noble notion of fairness, but rather because I didn't feel that it was worth it.

I agree with those posters who say that family background/wealth are the factors that really determine outcomes for children, not private schools per se. Educated, aspirational parents, a strong work ethic and enough money to facilitate extracurricular/supercurricular activities.

There will be some kids who no doubt benefit from extra attention/extra pushing etc that they get at a private school, but lots of private school pupils would probably do just as well wherever they went.

To be clear, I'm not trying to suggest that there isn't huge inequality in the system, and we absolutely need to try to tackle that. However, I think it's about wealth and aspiration rather than private schooling per se.

@MrsBennetsPoorNerves but the OP @coffeerevelsrule does think it is worth it. Hence my question.

I agree other factors are relevant but if you see 70% of barristers for instance having been privately educated, and you want your son to have an equal chance, isn’t it also morally questionable to sacrifice your child’s chances on the basis of a wider moral principle?