Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why so anti drag?

319 replies

nicetoseetgesunsout · 10/04/2023 16:44

I've just watched the Paul oGrady tribute programme and it brought me to tears.
He did so much for children and their families and for so so many animals, plus against social injustice for gay people and anti section 28, not being scared to raise its injustice on mainstream tv.
My 75yr old mum is very upset about his passing.
Why the hate for drag performers?
My children grew up with Boy George,Marilyn and Leigh Bowrie RIP as they are friends. My children (boy and girl, now a woman and a man) always knew that they were, and are, men and saw them without costume wigs and makeup.
I'm also friends with a married couple who were drag queens a long time ago. My children have always known that these guys are men, dressing up as women, as they liked to and it was entertainment.
No offence meant to women. They saw them dressed as their drag persona but also without costume and mostly as men.
One couple of ex drag queens I know are now a Director for a hospice and his husband is a social work manager. Reputable jobs, no desire to be women and have two cats who are their babies. Lovely men.
Pantos have always had men playing women but we all know that they're men. Shakespeare plays had men playing women - that's more offensive to me.
Female authors like SE Sinton wrote and published amazing books without her obviously female first names - as she couldn't get published otherwise. These upset me much more

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
goodf · 10/04/2023 19:54

No I think i understood you perfectly. We just disagree.

xx

eurochick · 10/04/2023 19:53

@goodf you have completely misunderstood my post. I'm saying that men wearing stereotypically feminine clothes is absolutely fine. I gave the examples of past Eddie Izzard and the New Romantics. Men claiming to be women (transwomen) or parodying them (drag acts) is not.

CurlewKate · 10/04/2023 19:45

@mynameisnotkate Exactly. You are making my point! Sorry if it was me clear I was quoting someone.

Mxflamingnoravera · 10/04/2023 19:43

I always found drag terrifying as a child (Danny La Rue was one of the most well known, but pantomime dames were equally terrifying). I still feel deeply uncomfortable with men pretending to be women and using stereotypes to do so.

I liked POG after he dropped Lily Savage and became an out gay man instead.

Some people just don't like drag, I'm one of them.

mynameisnotkate · 10/04/2023 19:43

I don’t buy the argument that is ok because it’s mostly gay men and they’re oppressed. They are, but not, as a class, by women (although obv in a lot of individual cases). If they were mocking straight people, this is punching up. Drag is about mocking a group of people who are oppressed in the way they are not, so not ok.

chocolateisavegetable · 10/04/2023 19:42

There is misogyny in drag. There is misogyny outside of drag. Victoria Scone is a Drag Queen and is female. There are Drag Kings. There are male Drag Queens like Cheddar Gorgeous who look stunning in artistic outfits that are nothing like a traditional female look. I do get frustrated with those who have a blanket hatred of all drag, whilst agreeing that people in any sort of sexualised outfit should not be reading stories to children.

mynameisnotkate · 10/04/2023 19:40

CurlewKate · 10/04/2023 18:39

"
I do understand why some people do but personally I don’t see drag as ‘womanface’ because it suggests that there’s automatically something demeaning about being a woman" Sorry? Are you suggesting that blackface suggests that there's automatically something demeaning about being black? Surely not....

This is a strange, muddled argument. Of course there is nothing demeaning about being black, but there is something highly demeaning in black face. The argument is exactly the same for women.

Botw1 · 10/04/2023 19:37

@ThereIbledit

Yes, I think them being older might be the difference but I dint know why that should be the case!

Botw1 · 10/04/2023 19:35

@Burgoo

Gay men who aren't out have all the privilege of straight men

It's homophobia but women can't avoid sexism

ThereIbledit · 10/04/2023 19:29

@Burgoo
And yet there are female members of the LGBT community here telling you that we find it offensive.

midgemadgemodge · 10/04/2023 19:29

Just because gay men have suffered oppression does not justify them dishing it out

Just because it's "part of their history" doesn't make it right either

Morris men have a history of blacking up which they don't do now even though their blacking up is completely unrelated to things like black and white minstrels

ThereIbledit · 10/04/2023 19:27

@Botw1

My brain seems to accept a man playing a female character (like Mrs brown/doubtfire/savage/everage) as being ok but not the more modern ru Paul types and I'm not really sure why.

Society wouldn't accept a white person playing a black or Asian character. Christ, it wouldn't even accept a non trans person playing a trans character these days

So why is a man playing a woman acceptable?

I don't have a fully formed answer for this but here are my incomplete thoughts:

I think society had a backlash against white people playing BAME characters because BAME actors/tresses exist, and paying a white person to do the job rather than a person of the correct ethnic origin who was already at a disadvantage due to structural racism was acknowledged to be an obviously shit thing to do.

I do think it's a little different in the case of men playing women (sincerely) because women ARE usually employed to play female roles. I do think that both sexes can play the opposite in a way that is tasteful, sympathetic and not offensive, and that to see this DONE WELL adds variety and interest.

Whether a man playing a woman is offensive or not - well to set aside the bigger "is it always offensive" question for a moment, to me it's about whether the character is created for poking fun at women. Most drag acts are created like a trope of a woman, hyper-exaggerated features, to poke fun at women, at women's expense.

Mrs Brown was successful because she was a mildly exaggerated character, I think. I think if a woman had've played her, people may have found it too uncanny valley - whereas a man playing her promoted us to suspend disbelief and relax into enjoying the ridiculousness.

Everage - I found her too exaggerated for me to enjoy most of the time, but it's interesting that a lot of the less problematic characters are older women, isn't it.

Savage - Again, too exaggerated looks-wise for me, but at least the character was a comedian who was actually funny and not taking the piss out of women.

Doubtfire - again, an older female character, and the premise was clear - it was a male - the father - who was trying to get access to his own children. Of course it's the premise that hasn't aged well, 30 years later! But I think Doubtfire trod the line of exaggerated, but only slightly, and not at the expense of women, rule.

Curious to hear your thoughts if you have any?

Burgoo · 10/04/2023 19:26

@CurlewKate "I do think we often forget that gay men are still men. Often with the same mind set and privileges that all men have."

Ludicrous take. I don't think you realise the level of hostility and oppression gay people suffered even into the 2000s. I am not out at work because I don't want it impacting my prospects.

Burgoo · 10/04/2023 19:25

@JaninaDuszejko "Womanface. It's misogynistic and sexist."

You clearly don't understand the history of drag and the representation within the LGBT community.

CurlewKate · 10/04/2023 19:21

I do think we often forget that gay men are still men. Often with the same mind set and privileges that all men have.

CampervanKween · 10/04/2023 19:18

I've always hated men dressing up and mocking women. Even as a young child.

Plus it's talentless and shit in the main. Vile. Fat men dressed as a parody of a woman lip synching to music. Urgh. You couldn't pay me to watch it.

midgemadgemodge · 10/04/2023 19:14

http://eprints.lse.ac.uk/100829/3/AcceptedManuscripttGayMisogynyyHale_Ojeda.pdf

Gay people can be mysogenistic and the mysogeny is often overlooked just because they are gay

LittleEsme · 10/04/2023 19:12

Not RTFT.
Whether we appreciate Drag as humour or not, I'm sure we'd all agree that Drag doesn't belong in story time.

thebaneofmylifeisacat · 10/04/2023 19:08

I liked both Lilly savage and when Julian clearly was Joan Collins tribute both were funny and edgy.

However both Julian and Paul don't drag up now except for pantomime which is fine.

Drag acts per se are so old fashioned now I regard them as unacceptable to me as black face and find it distasteful and inappropriate now. Ugly too.

hockeysticks89 · 10/04/2023 19:07

mynameisnotkate · 10/04/2023 17:01

It’s members of an oppressor class dressing up as members of an oppressed class to caricature tropes about them for humour.

i don’t agree that P O’G was blameless here. Yes, he seemed to have been a lovely man and did a lot of good but I think Lily Savage was based on misogynistic stereotypes, as all drag is.

This. First paragraph. And if you can't see it, you're really not looking.

ThereIbledit · 10/04/2023 19:06

@Knullrufs

Drag has a long, rich and complex history within gay culture and a bunch of (largely) straight (largely) women are not the intended audience.

Drag acts used to perform to gay clubs, whereupon the (almost exclusively gay male) performers would be taking the piss out of women to the (gay male) audience. The "shared enemy" as it were."

There are many tropes within drag which are actually about challenging and subverting the kind of misogyny which drives homophobia. But the nitty gritty of the cultural context is so specific to gay men’s experiences that to an outside audience it appears impenetrable, open to misinterpretation, or even offensive.

If you have a reference for this I'd be open to reading more about it. As a gay woman in gay bars, it was pretty offensive, and we were often directly (as individuals and as a group) the target of their jokes.

Many gay men find the current feminist angle on drag-as-mockery perplexing because the idea that it is mocking couldn’t be further from their minds. Most drag personas are derived either from an aggregation of strong women in their own lives, or a kind of fantasy figure of a powerful, take-no-shit personality who nevertheless still holds appeal to men.

nah, I just don't buy this. I can believe that they have been thoughtless about whether it's offensive to women though.

The naming conventions (punny stuff like Anna Rexia or Dixie Normous) are intended to be subversive, not funny. If you think it’s a joke, you’ve missed the point. Taking the kicking-down shit that women and gay men get from straight, patriarchal society all the time and making it into a name, a badge of pride, a bold performance, a two-fingered salute. It’s meant to be a fuck-you to the world, not a joke at the expense of women.

I'm afraid I still don't get the point.

I do understand why some people do but personally I don’t see drag as ‘womanface’ because it suggests that there’s automatically something demeaning about being a woman; that there is something inherent in women that is there to be mocked. It feels a bit internalised misogyny to me. But as I say that’s just my view and I know many of you think differently.

The reason why we find it offensive is that drag intends to say there is something demeaning about being a woman.

Of course some drag acts are offensive but then there are offensive performers across all mediums. Finding an individual performer or performers offensive doesn’t automatically mean there’s a problem with the whole medium, or the entire culture.

I agree. I also think that when the majority of performers of any given medium are offensive to the group of people who they are impersonating, it's a problem with the medium, not just the individuals.

Botw1 · 10/04/2023 18:59

@ThereIbledit

My brain seems to accept a man playing a female character (like Mrs brown/doubtfire/savage/everage) as being ok but not the more modern ru Paul types and I'm not really sure why.

Society wouldn't accept a white person playing a black or Asian character. Christ, it wouldn't even accept a non trans person playing a trans character these days

So why is a man playing a woman acceptable?

Anonymouseposter · 10/04/2023 18:59

I don't like Drag. I think it's to women what the black and white minstrels was to race. Usually a unflattering , supposed to be funny, stereotyping of women is involved.
Paul O'Grady won me over with his attitude to dogs and Tory politicians and his quick wit. I still strongly dislike drag.

Thighlengthboots · 10/04/2023 18:54

I dont "hate" drag, but the more I see of it in live shows etc, the more offensive and gross and outdated I feel it is. Firstly, the defining of being a woman by ridiculous makeup, clothing, being bitchy, referring to women as "fish" (which I have heard many, many times in drag shows etc). I understand that the intention isnt to offend women but the more I see of it the more I just think its really outdated and frankly, really quite sad. It doesnt come across as laughing with womne, it comes across as laughing AT them. Why cant you be funny without having to impersonate women in a really groteqsue stereotypical way? if you cant, and have to put on a huge ridiculous wig and makeup to get laughs then maybe you just arent actually that funny at all..............