Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you ever feel some big charities don't actually do anything?

168 replies

Cinderellaspumpkin · 10/04/2023 08:20

Do you ever feel some big name charities don't actually do much more , when scratching under the surface, than signposting, ( often to other organisations that signpost), and "raise awareness," of the cause.

OP posts:
Darker · 10/04/2023 09:40

snitzelvoncrumb · 10/04/2023 09:14

A lot of charities don’t do a lot. You need to look into admin fees. Many of them are mostly just an income for the ceo. There is a very popular men’s charity that is busy in November. Most of the money raised went to the man running it. It has improved, but never assume that a charity does much. You have to do your research.

Did the man at the top do a lot of the work, lead the team effectively etc? Then pay him. Certainly lots of people know this charity and it encourages them to raise money.

BadSkiingMum · 10/04/2023 09:38

A lot of good points already made, however on the point of ‘providing information’, that is a valuable and often costly service in itself:

Reading, interpreting and understanding the research;
Being aware of government policies and services;
Avoiding bias and commercial influence*;
Incorporating the views of practitioners and those with lived experience;
Presenting the information in a way that can be easily understood and is accessible to different groups of people;
Keeping said information up-to-date.

This is why charities employ researchers, participation specialists, librarians etc whose roles might appear to be ‘admin’ but who actually do a really important job.

*Yes, commercial organisations do try to influence charities to promote their products and they can be very devious about it!

EmmaEmerald · 10/04/2023 09:37

Jewel1968 · 10/04/2023 09:35

For those that are critical of charities and how they are run, would you prefer your money went to the state and for services to be provided by the state? And to those supportive of charities, same question.

Cross post
I'm not critical of charities full stop, I think there's some operating in ways I dislike

I'd definitely like to see more hospice places funded by healthcare money, though the local hospice is the main place I support. Less money for NHS who have questionable procurement processes and processes per se.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 10/04/2023 09:35

Age Concern ( if that is what it is called this year) are exactly what the OP has described in my experience. They offer no practical help, and their advice is generally to contact another organisation for advice or information.Citizens Advice Bureau does a lot of the heavy lifting for many charities, though I think they are finding it much more difficult to recruit volunteers since Covid.

EmmaEmerald · 10/04/2023 09:35

Yes
I worked for one - as a contractor, good money - and they were actually reducing their involvement in the practical things, doing a lot of signposting. They seem to exist for the benefit of directors on six figures with big expense accounts. I was offered a second contract there but said no.

I am very careful about where my donations go. There's some good books on this.

Jewel1968 · 10/04/2023 09:35

For those that are critical of charities and how they are run, would you prefer your money went to the state and for services to be provided by the state? And to those supportive of charities, same question.

MissTrip82 · 10/04/2023 09:34

I don’t donate to charities that just do ‘awareness raising’.

But I mix my donations and give to both small and large charities. I think people can be very naive and rather stupid about how much it costs to deliver a specialized service in difficult circumstances and how much it costs to ensure a continued source of revenue for long term projects. The ‘best’ charity is not necessarily the one with the lowest overheads.

Easterfunbun · 10/04/2023 09:33

It’s because charities have to compete with each other for funding off the commissioners so it’s all about the data in the end. The true mission can get lost due to how it’s structured in terms of funding. On the whole I don’t think they’re helpful for mental health issues but neither do I think statutory services are any good too

Easterfunbun · 10/04/2023 09:32

They have different agendas. Large MH ones lobby to the government for policy change, whilst delivering smaller projects that are different depending on locality and who wins the contracts.

SoShallINever · 10/04/2023 09:31

tomfromloveislandsbeard · 10/04/2023 09:21

Our local Mind throw money around on vanity projects that undermine better work being done by others, and constantly ask the community to 'chip in' rather than doing proper fundraising activity. And the local Mind boss is on 95k and is seen as some sort of martyr by some, it makes me Hmm

Agree with this too. There have been some fantastic social services and health care funded projects shelved or outsourced to charitable agencies who have then provided a shoddy service or stopped providing them altogether.
"Singing for the brain" I'm looking at you.

LakeTiticaca · 10/04/2023 09:30

Yanbu. Ever tried contacting the RSPCA to help an animal in distress? Don't bother

CrossEyedCrossFit · 10/04/2023 09:28

It's normal, in fact vital, to signpost if there is a whole other charity best suited for your issue or that can see you sooner where time is of the essence.

Sausagenbacon · 10/04/2023 09:28

I think another issue is duplication. In bristol we have 72 charities aimed at helping the elderly in the city. There are a large number of charities working with the homeless too.
Just think how effective they could be if they joined forces!

SoShallINever · 10/04/2023 09:27

I have worked alongside McMillan, Admiral nurses and the MND society and can't fault them for the practical support they give to patients and the free training for health care workers.
By contrast The Alzheimers Society seem to promise a lot but deliver very little.

tomfromloveislandsbeard · 10/04/2023 09:21

Our local Mind throw money around on vanity projects that undermine better work being done by others, and constantly ask the community to 'chip in' rather than doing proper fundraising activity. And the local Mind boss is on 95k and is seen as some sort of martyr by some, it makes me Hmm

Cluelessasacucumber · 10/04/2023 09:20

What @thecatsthecats said.
Size isn't a measure of success or efficiency.

Charities are organisations run by people, and like any organisation that involves people some will be better than others, some individuals will take the piss but most will be decent hard workers, and the organisation will go through good patches and bad patches.

I've worked and volunteered for national, regional and local charities. They have different roles, and achieve different things. I now work for a medium sized local charity affiliated with a household name - the work I do is hugely different from that my national colleagues do but it's all very needed, and we're all underpaid and busting a gut for a cause we believe in. There was a very good review a while ago (maybe by Giving what we can.. ?) about how we need to start measuring charities by impact not crude %spent measures which tell us nothing useful and confuse the general public.

If you don't want to give to charity then don't, that's your choice. But don't try to pretend you're actually taking the moral high ground because you've decided to proclaim some ill-informed opinion to make yourself feel good!

Strictly1 · 10/04/2023 09:15

WestOfWestminster · 10/04/2023 08:23

I see your point, although I find it hard to know which fit this catagory. It's hard to tell which make a meaningful difference & which don't.

I've heard mixed reviews about Macmillan for example, but would be interested to find out more.

MacMillan have been a fantastic support for my family as we continue to navigate a terminal illness. They are fabulous and we’d be lost without them.

snitzelvoncrumb · 10/04/2023 09:14

A lot of charities don’t do a lot. You need to look into admin fees. Many of them are mostly just an income for the ceo. There is a very popular men’s charity that is busy in November. Most of the money raised went to the man running it. It has improved, but never assume that a charity does much. You have to do your research.

Oblomov23 · 10/04/2023 09:14

@MeinKraft
I'm not disputing that some admin is needed. But lots of donation money is wasted. I believe there is a lot of waste. Most donators would be unhappy if they realised how little of their donation was actually going to 'help someone'. You know what I'm trying to say here.

89redballoons · 10/04/2023 09:08

https://www.mind.org.uk/about-us/what-we-do/

MIND are a national campaigning, advocacy and research organisation that run national advice lines and provide resources and training to smaller scale, local franchised organisations.

OP, it's hard to answer your question without knowing which charities you mean and in what sector, and what you expect them to "actually do".

Big organisations can be corrupt and slow to react, yes. But they can also have the advantage of being full of experienced people who are good at knowing where resources are best directed in order to forward that charity's aims.

For example look at the people who as soon as the war in Ukraine broke out started filling up vans with baby blankets and phone chargers and tins of beans and driving them over to the Polish border "because we just need to do something". It actually ended up being a hindrance as many of those items weren't needed and had to be sorted through and stored somewhere, and those that were needed could have been bought much more cheaply locally.

On the other hand organisations like UNICEF and the Red Cross have the expertise to acquire and direct aid efficiently and get the resources into the hands of people who actually need them, minimising corruption along the way. Or at least that's the theory.

Boshmama · 10/04/2023 09:08

Having worked in the sector for 15 years I now only give to large charities and organisations. They are so, so much more effective and efficient. They properly train people and the much maligned ‘admin and middle management’ make sure that everyone is working hard, efficiently and using donations in the best way.

I Would never give to a charity with a turnover of less than £5m a year as they will be often be trying their best but not able to have the impact big ones do.

one of the best things to happen was the merger of three small breast cancer charities into breast cancer now which makes so much more sense than three small inefficient ‘competing’ charities.

MeinKraft · 10/04/2023 09:05

Oblomov23 · 10/04/2023 09:00

If you do have a quick look at their accounts, it's shocking how much money is wasted on admin and middle management and not much is actually 'done', with the money given.

Money on admin isn't wasted. The charity can't run without the admins and managers. You need someone to take the referrals, assess them, supervise the staff, be a designated safeguarding officer, track (and spend) the money, and the funders want to see outcomes in return for their money. The admins and managers gather all that information and present it to the funders. If you had a load of project workers with no admin and no manager the place would be chaos.

Mightyouandiconfabulate · 10/04/2023 09:04

I have recently had my eyes opened to absolutely mind blowing AWSOME, over and above work by a couple of charities with dedication and commitment only seen previously in specialists in the NHS.

I felt very tiny in their presence.

These influence national policy, future research and evidence base, their mission is to find cures and do everything that they can to ensure a good life for sufferers.
Focussing on education and raising awareness.

Patient charities run by patients themselves are an inspiration.

You can’t lump them all together. There are some brilliant organisations out there.

DisquietintheRanks · 10/04/2023 09:01

No actually. There may be exceptions but by and large I think they are far more effective than the little ones that either have no reach or no internal auditing or evaluation processes so you never really know what impact they have.

Hearditonapodcast · 10/04/2023 09:00

I work for a small local office of a large, well known advice charity. They've recently had a massive fundraising drive in a well known newspaper, and local offices will see none of that money. It's all going to their national phoneline, who are the public face of the organisation but who, 9 times out of 10, signpost people to their local office. So we get 9 times the work but none of the funding. We're staffed mostly by volunteers, managed by paid staff (me included). We raise all our own funding from local sources, so it's galling seeing the newspaper articles about the charity and hearing how many millions have been raised for 'us' to help people through the cost of living crisis, knowing that we will never see a penny of it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread