Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you ever feel some big charities don't actually do anything?

168 replies

Cinderellaspumpkin · 10/04/2023 08:20

Do you ever feel some big name charities don't actually do much more , when scratching under the surface, than signposting, ( often to other organisations that signpost), and "raise awareness," of the cause.

OP posts:
EmmaEmerald · 10/04/2023 09:59

stbrandonsboat I think what you do is amazing. Flowers

ACynicalDad · 10/04/2023 09:58

There are doers and takers in the sector, I used to be very anti talkers, but they can work for years to influence government policy and then when they break through the money they leverage is way beyond the doers. I see a lot of bad small charities, doing their best but not very good, I also see some that are great innovators. There is waste, but frankly not a great a deal, certainly compared to the public sector and no hospitality budgets like the top of the private sector. They are a vital part of the fabric of our society.

DisquietintheRanks · 10/04/2023 09:58

AnnaMagnani · 10/04/2023 09:49

When my dad was terminally ill in hopsital (not with cancer) we were visited and supported by a McMillan funded palliative care nurse

Unless it was an entirely new post in it's first 2 years, that nurse was fully paid for by the hospital.

Nice business model Macmillan have come up with that most people think they are paying for all the staff when they absolutely are not.

It takes about 1 minute to find out what MacMillan do. It's on their website under "About Us" They support people w cancer in all sorts of ways and also push for policy changes.

I'm not sure why anybody would think they should employ nurses - wouldn't that be a waste of money and stupid duplication when the nhs had so many?

EmmaEmerald · 10/04/2023 09:58

No issue with admin, it's a vital function
The large charity I worked for - with shops - had a bi monthly SMT off site meeting. Catering per person was £80. The venue hire was expensive. They all took cabs. Friends of SMT came in as coaches. It was all listed as staff training. £12k a year and that's just a drop in the bucket with the money spent, that's just one thing I can say without being outing.

And Claire's office in Fleabag was nothing compared to the SMT offices!

stbrandonsboat · 10/04/2023 09:57

Palliative care is not a particularly difficult area of nursing. Any half decent nurse who works in this area will already be doing what the Macmillan nurse advises. It changes little and doesn't require expert knowledge. We sometimes used to have to tolerate the Macmillan nurse visiting our care home to 'advise' on care and we'd already be doing what she advised because the nurses had years of experience between us. It's just not that difficult in practical terms. I also had the Gold Standard training in palliative care.

Macmillan will help people access benefits, but you don't need to be a qualified nurse to do that.

KnittingNeedles · 10/04/2023 09:57

Agree, @Darker . I volunteer in a large charity which has a chain of shops. Our till is ancient, the touchscreen doesn't work properly any more, we get the blue screen of death on it at least once a shift, the credit card machine regularly stops "talking" to the till and has broken beyond all repair twice since Christmas meaning we can't take card payments. We are getting a new system - was supposed to be April, now pushed back until "at least October". Because the charity knows that if it was in the press that they were spending £500 or £1000 per store for new IT/till systems they would have all the usual comments about wasting money and how many starving people could have been fed with the money.

Can't win.

Sparklesocks · 10/04/2023 09:57

I think it’s not always possible to say unless you know the inner workings of each one. I used to work at CRUK and they funded labs across the country and even some in Europe/US, funded some phd students, development trials for new drugs. Also things like roadshows to raise awareness of certain cancers and highlight symptoms to the public. It’s obviously not a lightning quick process but fascinating to see all of the great work being done. There was also a team of nurses who managed a hotline/inbox for patients or anyone who had questions. It’s hard to envisage a single ‘cure’ as there are 200+ types of cancer with their own nuances and everyone responds to treatment differently. It’s more likely that personalised approaches with a range of treatment options will be the answer, rather than a single pill or magic cure.

But we’d still get angry letters from people saying we weren’t doing enough, sitting on the cash and refusing to find a cure because the money would stop. Which was ridiculous for many reasons, the main being that any cure discovered would be sought across the world. You’d make billions. Any fundraising totals would pale in comparison. But people love to confidently be wrong.

AnnaMagnani · 10/04/2023 09:57

If you donate money to your hospice, a lot will be spent on 'admin' - because they need HR, Occ Health, secretaries, a Quality Improvement department, grounds and maintenance...

Everyone always wants to donate to a nurse, or for a piece of equipment (we had so many In Memoriam benches we banned them) but the reality is that to run an organization effectively you need everything a business needs.

Xiaoxiong · 10/04/2023 09:56

Well now I understand the Mind franchise model, and I agree that local groups will be better placed to deliver practical services but I was a bit taken aback that the local Minds are financially independent - I guess I assumed that all the national level fundraising would actually support the practical level who wouldn't have to waste their time fundraising (because they're actually doing the real work!)

89redballoons · 10/04/2023 09:55

Jewel1968 · 10/04/2023 09:35

For those that are critical of charities and how they are run, would you prefer your money went to the state and for services to be provided by the state? And to those supportive of charities, same question.

Again, this wholly depends on the charity.

i think there are some organisations, like in the health sector, whose work should be done by the state, yes. I think things like hospice care and cancer therapies and resources for children with disabilities are sufficiently beneficial for everyone in a society that they should be funded by taxes collected from everyone, and not individual donations or discretionary grants.

Then there are some charities that I don't think should be taxpayer funded at all, as in shouldn't get the favourable tax treatments that charities get. Private schools are the obvious ones.

There's another category of charity which I can see why they are tax-advantaged, but I wouldn't particularly want my money going there as I have different priorities. Animal shelters for example. I like animals but I'd rather my tax money and my charitable donations went to people as I think they're more important. But some people legitimately love animals more than people and I don't begrudge them donating to animal charities. So it's appropriate for some charitable spending to be discretionary like this.

Another point is that many charities exist partly to scrutinise and at times criticise government policy, and campaign for change. If they were taxpayer funded that role would be compromised.

As to whether services that charities provide would be more efficient if they were directly publicly funded - no idea. People criticise the NHS and local government for spending money inefficiently just as much as they criticise big charities for doing it.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 10/04/2023 09:54

I can’t speak for all of them, since I don’t know, but a dd worked for many years for a major charity and it’d be nonsense to say they didn’t do anything. Dd and others were there on the ground, after sundry natural disasters in several different parts of the world - doing their best to help by providing food /water/shelter etc., in often very trying and difficult conditions.

As for donors’ money being wasted (it’s not ‘donators’) I know that the one dd worked for stated on its website how much of the money was spent on necessary admin - around 10% IIRC.

People often like to think or assume - with no evidence - that hardly any of the money goes to the actual cause. IMO this may often be because it absolves them from feeling they ought to donate.

Darker · 10/04/2023 09:53

Oblomov23 · 10/04/2023 09:00

If you do have a quick look at their accounts, it's shocking how much money is wasted on admin and middle management and not much is actually 'done', with the money given.

I’ve worked for lots of charities and the ones which ‘save’ money on admin are both inefficient and miserable places to work. Charities need good HR, IT, finance, comms etc. Not to mention fundraising.

It’s horrible working in a place where you have to pick up extra roles because there is no budget for a dedicated staff member, or to get no investment in staff training, or decent systems.

Evaka · 10/04/2023 09:52

Testina · 10/04/2023 08:39

She does actually. I’d rather be stuck in the corner with the intelligent speaker backing up her views for an interesting discussion, than the person just saying, “yeah but no but what do they dooooooo” who just likes the sound of their own voice and doesn’t actually want to know 🤷🏻‍♀️

Likewise!

KnittingNeedles · 10/04/2023 09:50

AnnaMagnani · 10/04/2023 09:49

When my dad was terminally ill in hopsital (not with cancer) we were visited and supported by a McMillan funded palliative care nurse

Unless it was an entirely new post in it's first 2 years, that nurse was fully paid for by the hospital.

Nice business model Macmillan have come up with that most people think they are paying for all the staff when they absolutely are not.

I have no idea who was paying him. I was very grateful that he was there.

Sausagenbacon · 10/04/2023 09:50

Thanks theeyeballinthesky. That's useful to know

BadgerFacedCoo · 10/04/2023 09:50

Trussel trust don't feed people. They're a franchise operation. They teach people how to manage difficult to access food banks. Local churches and charities do 10 times what they do without their millions.

Macmillan train nurses then the NHS pays them but they still wear the Macmillan uniform. Good for helping fill in benefit forms, not much else.

AnnaMagnani · 10/04/2023 09:49

When my dad was terminally ill in hopsital (not with cancer) we were visited and supported by a McMillan funded palliative care nurse

Unless it was an entirely new post in it's first 2 years, that nurse was fully paid for by the hospital.

Nice business model Macmillan have come up with that most people think they are paying for all the staff when they absolutely are not.

stbrandonsboat · 10/04/2023 09:49

What I don't think people realise about Macmillan is that they don't employ the nurses they train. They only provide training. The amount of money they raise appears to be disproportionate to the actual service they provide. They don't run hospices or provide actual nursing services. Donate to Marie Curie or a local hospice instead.

I have had direct experience with Macmillan both professionally and personally and found them to be useless.

Ingrowncrotchhair · 10/04/2023 09:48

tomfromloveislandsbeard · 10/04/2023 09:21

Our local Mind throw money around on vanity projects that undermine better work being done by others, and constantly ask the community to 'chip in' rather than doing proper fundraising activity. And the local Mind boss is on 95k and is seen as some sort of martyr by some, it makes me Hmm

Can you give some examples, please? Genuinely curious @tomfromloveislandsbeard

Theeyeballsinthesky · 10/04/2023 09:47

Age UK (formerly Age concern - they changed the name in 2009) operate the same model as MIND ie a national charity that does campaigning, policy, research, information & provides advice & guidance to the local Age UKs who are all independent affiliated charities who deliver the direct services to older people.

snitzelvoncrumb · 10/04/2023 09:46

He started the company, it’s successful and I imagine he works hard. But I prefer to bypass his pocket and have donated directly to other charities his charity supports rather than letting him take a cut. My money can do more that way.

KnittingNeedles · 10/04/2023 09:46

DisquietintheRanks · 10/04/2023 09:01

No actually. There may be exceptions but by and large I think they are far more effective than the little ones that either have no reach or no internal auditing or evaluation processes so you never really know what impact they have.

Exactly. The big household name charities in the UK like the RNLI, Oxfam, Red Cross, British Heart Foundation, RSPCA are subject to so much criticism and scrutiny in the press and by the charities commission. Annual reports and published accounts for all the big charities are all online and you can easily see how much money they're taking in and what they are spending it on. And then use that information to make an informed decision about whether you wish to support them or not.

Small independent charities run by a husband and wife, or two siblings, often have no requirement to be as transparent. No independent oversight, no need to publish an annual report or accounts. Everything done on trust. Some might be doing an amazing jobs, others not so much. And you have no way of sorting the wheat from the chaff.

We have a large laboratory a mile down the road staffed by Cancer Research funded scientists. A friend's daughter is doing a PhD researching cell changes in heart disease funded by the British Heart Foundation. When my dad was terminally ill in hopsital (not with cancer) we were visited and supported by a McMillan funded palliative care nurse. The RNLI saved 408 lives in 2021. Oxfam sent 19 tonnes of aid to help people in Turkey get clean water after the February earthquake.

But yeah, they don't "do" anything. 🙄

AnnaMagnani · 10/04/2023 09:44

Macmillan is absolutely a charity I wouldn't donate to.

They don't have to run or maintain any buildings - like for example your hospice does.

They pay for new posts, but only for 2 years after which the NHS picks up the bill. However all of those posts remain Macmillan branded for eternity - great for their brand awareness! Compared to your local hospice which has to fundraise for everything - usually only 1/3 max is paid for by the NHS.

So, what do they actually need so much money for?

You may have thought your Macmillan nurse was awesome but she doesn't work for Macmillan. She's awesome thanks to the NHS unit who train her.

Theeyeballsinthesky · 10/04/2023 09:43

Sausagenbacon · 10/04/2023 09:28

I think another issue is duplication. In bristol we have 72 charities aimed at helping the elderly in the city. There are a large number of charities working with the homeless too.
Just think how effective they could be if they joined forces!

I do get that but working in the field of ageing & knowing Bristol a bit I’d say

  • most of them won’t be Bristol wide but work in a particular bit of Bristol e.g lockleaze, Southmead, knowle West
  • some will be Bristol wide but have a narrow focus eg providing housing for older ppl or working on something specific eg dementia
  • I do know that Age UK Bristol coordinates an ageing hub that tries to pull them all together so they work together but I suspect it’s a lot like herding cats! I do a similar job and it’s really hard to get them to work together mostly because working together requires time to build trust & relationships. Most small local charities are very focused - rightly - on the doing and so don’t have time to come to meetings to get to know & understand colleagues & so build trust. They just don’t see that as a priority compared to eg ensuring the lunch club at Easton community centre runs. It’s a difficult one to crack
DisquietintheRanks · 10/04/2023 09:42

Oblomov23 · 10/04/2023 09:14

@MeinKraft
I'm not disputing that some admin is needed. But lots of donation money is wasted. I believe there is a lot of waste. Most donators would be unhappy if they realised how little of their donation was actually going to 'help someone'. You know what I'm trying to say here.

Yeah that's a fallacy I've seen played out time and time again in the development sector - charities squandering money on projects that don't work or stuff that isn't needed because they don't want to pay for the admin or staff that would allow them to put their money where its needed.

I only give to charities that pay their staff properly, and who put a good chunk into the administration of their affairs. All that safeguarding, auditing, training, accounting, monitoring, a robust complaints procedure- that's all overheads. If you don't want any of your money to go on overheads then that's what's cut and the result is that donors get a nice warm glow and recipient's get sweet fa.