Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you ever feel some big charities don't actually do anything?

168 replies

Cinderellaspumpkin · 10/04/2023 08:20

Do you ever feel some big name charities don't actually do much more , when scratching under the surface, than signposting, ( often to other organisations that signpost), and "raise awareness," of the cause.

OP posts:
Timesawastin · 10/04/2023 12:56

AnneLovesGilbert · 10/04/2023 08:36

You sound fun at parties…

And you sound shallow and ignorant. Research is key in effective giving.

ToWhitToWhoo · 10/04/2023 12:51

A family friend, who unfortunately had terminal cancer, had wonderful help from Macmillan at the end of his life. That was about 15 years ago, so of course things could have changed.

ToWhitToWhoo · 10/04/2023 12:48

AnneLovesGilbert · 10/04/2023 08:36

You sound fun at parties…

More fun than the bores you sometimes meet at parties who like to spout loads of opinions with no backing. I'd much rather talk to someone who knows what they're talking about!

Mammillaria · 10/04/2023 12:38

I also spent a lot of time working in the third sector and agree with what @demhalluk says.

I own an engineering/construction business now and genuinely feel like we make more of a positive impact on the world than some of the charities I have worked for or alongside.

To balance this I would say that there are an awful lot of charities doing great work. As a very general rule, I find that community-based organisations with local staff tend to have the best £/impact ratios.

IncompleteSenten · 10/04/2023 12:35

That's true. They are an excellent example of the problem.

Babyroobs · 10/04/2023 12:34

AnnaMagnani · 10/04/2023 09:49

When my dad was terminally ill in hopsital (not with cancer) we were visited and supported by a McMillan funded palliative care nurse

Unless it was an entirely new post in it's first 2 years, that nurse was fully paid for by the hospital.

Nice business model Macmillan have come up with that most people think they are paying for all the staff when they absolutely are not.

It's just a massive con that they use to keep the money rolling in !

Babyroobs · 10/04/2023 12:32

stbrandonsboat · 10/04/2023 09:49

What I don't think people realise about Macmillan is that they don't employ the nurses they train. They only provide training. The amount of money they raise appears to be disproportionate to the actual service they provide. They don't run hospices or provide actual nursing services. Donate to Marie Curie or a local hospice instead.

I have had direct experience with Macmillan both professionally and personally and found them to be useless.

They want you to believe they provide Nursing care to people at the end of their lives but they don't. They sponser people in a new role in the NHS ofr maybe 12-18 months then the NHS takes over funding of that post, but they want you to think they pay those Nurses salaries to keep the money rolling in. They are NHS funded staff but just with macmillan on their badge. It's a hugely deceitful way of working. They also fund partnerships with organizations like CAB yet pay their staff through CAB hugely less than their own staff for doing the same advice roles. Awful charity, although I've no doubt the actual staff on the frontline are doing a great job.

Theeyeballsinthesky · 10/04/2023 12:32

So true @southlondoner02 i sit in meetings talking about 5 year plans with the NHS & I have keep reminding them that their 12 month funding cycles for the voluntary sector means it’s impossible for us to plan for 5 years. I don’t know if I’ll have a job next year let alone in 5 years. Interestingly they never apply this to private providers who get NHS contracts - they get multi year contracts.

Whiskyinajar · 10/04/2023 12:30

I am Chair for a small local charity which offers parent support.
We run after school clubs for children and teenagers plus an art group and have coffee mornings plus an ESOL group.

All our funding comes from organisations and we are totally non-profit making.

We have been able to off supermarket vouchers over the winter from county council funding. It doesn't change the world but it makes life a tiny bit better for each person we have contact with.

I do support some big charities but sometimes feel they no longer have their feet on the ground.

Babyroobs · 10/04/2023 12:27

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 10/04/2023 09:35

Age Concern ( if that is what it is called this year) are exactly what the OP has described in my experience. They offer no practical help, and their advice is generally to contact another organisation for advice or information.Citizens Advice Bureau does a lot of the heavy lifting for many charities, though I think they are finding it much more difficult to recruit volunteers since Covid.

I work for Age UK and offer practical help day in day out. Helping older people fill out form for Attendance allowance, PIP, doing benefit checks, helping them access thousands of pounds of money each year in benefits, grants, supplying food parcels. I recently helped someone get 5k of backpay from Universal credit by identifying where their claim had been wrongly paid for 18 months . Our staffing has been cut and we get very little funding so yes when we get overwhelmed we do have to signpost to CAB. But to say we offer no practical help is totally inaccurate. We are absolutely overwhelmed but trying our best !

Darker · 10/04/2023 12:26

Thing is, if you want to give to charity, think about why you are donating and what you want the outcome to be. Then choose the best charity to achieve that.

Its incredibly frustrating for those of us who work in the sector to have to justify crap like what car the CEO is driving. Unless the car is provided by the charity as a perk it really is none of our business… they could be independently wealthy. I just want them to provide good leadership.

southlondoner02 · 10/04/2023 12:22

I've worked for a range of small to medium charities over the years and all of them have basically carried out work that's contracted out from the state eg run homeless hostels or refuges, supported domestic abuse survivors etc. The main issue which wastes money is the commissioning cycles that essentially mean every 2 years another charity could be running that project which means they can't plan long term, and are always starting up or winding down a project. Plus an obsession with pilot projects which never allow enough time for a project to get off the ground.

Most of the places Ive worked don't fundraise much or effectively as they don't have the money to pay a fundraiser. Fundraising that does happen tends to go to make people's lives a bit better eg presents for children living in refuges, or food for people who need it.

There are loads of charities like this in the uk, although they're never going to get the recognition of the big charities

Babyroobs · 10/04/2023 12:17

I've worked for a few charities, currently working for one for older people. I will admit we do a lot of signposting. People expect us to have in depth knowledge about everything but it's just not possible. The local arm of our charity have no funds coming in, we are running at a deficit and staffing has been cut, morale is low and we have like 2 advisors to cover the whole county. Many queries on our helpline are complex, we never know what we are picking the phone up to, we get suicidal people, older people being financially abused by their kids, safeguarding issues as well as all the usual benefits queries and people facing being chucked out of their home. A lot of people are totally incapable of sorting anything out themselves, even filling in a simple form or making a phone call to DWP. A huge number of people have severe anxiety and depression, won't leave their homes, can't deal with the simplest thing. We are overwhelmed with no funding coming in, so we do have to signpost to other places like CAB or a law centre or shelter. I used to work for a certain large cancer charity and was appalled by the way they treated staff and the absolute wastage of charitable money. When I went for the interview for the job, they brought down around 10 senior managers to interview 6 potential candidates, only 3 of us were hired. It was held in a top hotel, massive buffet for these managers. They paid big car allowances for people wfh home and sometimes we would only need to travel once a week.

Darker · 10/04/2023 12:13

thecatsthecats · 10/04/2023 10:09

At the small charity I worked for, there was huge resistance to admin expenditure - either in dedicating the time or the money. This led to issues such as:

  • Unfair dismissal case because a manager didn't cross check the process with HR, and didn't have any management training. The appeal consumes hours and hours of multiple staff's time because they didn't do a half day course and a ten minute phonecall when the original situation arose.
  • Using the database incorrectly to record case notes and report successes. Our service users are highly vulnerable, and tell us very sensitive things about past abuse. These records need to be held securely. Some frontline staff are uncertain and won't engage with training. Half of them record too much, half of them nothing at all. Both are bad. If management would invest the time in sorting out what's needed, they could spend less time more effectively.
  • There is NO central network of folders/files. Every staff laptop is completely separate to the others. Staff lack basic knowledge such as searching emails, or filing important documents. Staff are continually emails each other copies of files, including going back to old versions of forms and spreadsheets.
  • Staff have no knowledge of basic cyber security. Day one, I'm handed a word document of logins for ALL secure systems, including highly sensitive data.

These are just a few examples.

I have actually sorted out a few things for them, but the list is endless. In my previous company, I invested time, effort and MONEY over a sustained period to improve issues like this. And productivity AND staff satisfaction went through the roof, for a fraction of the cost of the time lost to these issues daily.

So familiar…

Theeyeballsinthesky · 10/04/2023 12:13

Charity checker has around 1000 charities on it. There are aprox 168,000 charities in the UK. Charity commission is where to go to look things up

KnittingNeedles · 10/04/2023 12:12

Darker · 10/04/2023 12:08

I just looked at that. First charity - very established, well known - not listed. Second charity - CEO salary data was 8 years old.

And they grade charities on their own definition. Cancer Research is rated "poor" because they don't spend every penny on researching cancer - they don't have a salary for the CEO. Smaller charities with a handful of employees and lots of unpaid volunteers are "good".

Load of old nonsense. But will be leapt on as justification for not donating/supporting charity by people who had no intention of donating or supporting charity in the first place.

Darker · 10/04/2023 12:08

I just looked at that. First charity - very established, well known - not listed. Second charity - CEO salary data was 8 years old.

KnittingNeedles · 10/04/2023 12:02

focuslocus · 10/04/2023 11:49

This might be helpful:

http://www.charitychecker.net/

Not helpful.

It's a site which doesn't believe that money should be spent on anything other than "the cause". Their home page - complete with apostrophe errors - goes on about "unjustifiable salaries" .

Clearly have an axe to grind.

MajorCarolDanvers · 10/04/2023 12:00

Another slagging off charities thread 😳

Always filled by wild inaccuracies and Daily Mail prejudice.

IncompleteSenten · 10/04/2023 12:00

DisquietintheRanks · 10/04/2023 10:49

Are you seriously that stupid? You think the solution to providing clean water everyone, everywhere is a borehole? I'm embarrassed for you.

🙄

No. And I think the fact I've done 2 should suggest that perhaps I have a bit of an understanding of what is needed to give people access to clean water.

I do need to point out that when aiming to give people access to clean water, accessing a source of clean water is rather a large part of it.

I've also sent computers into a rural school in Kenya and I'm currently part of a group setting up a programme to identify and help children who are struggling to achieve in primary school in my in-laws village and support them to continue in their education.

I'm sure you personally do many similar things but don't assume I know nothing about it.

SoShallINever · 10/04/2023 11:57

LakeTiticaca · 10/04/2023 09:30

Yanbu. Ever tried contacting the RSPCA to help an animal in distress? Don't bother

Yes, I did, a fox was stuck in our fence. They asked if I knew a farmer that could shoot it to put it out of its misery.
In the end we donned the motorbike gauntlets, cut it free and got it to a local wildlife centre, where it received treatment and recovered.

DisquietintheRanks · 10/04/2023 11:23

Oh God, people's expectations.
I work for a wildlife charity that delivers nature conservation projects and does some advocacy and offers advise on managing green spaces foe wildlife.

We don't deal with animal cruelty (except wildlife crime).
We don't collect roadkill.
We don't do pest control.
We are not an animal sanctuary .

Yet we are routinely approached for all these things, then criticised because "we won't help". Were criticised on Facebook this week because a heron in the local park has eaten a duckling.

We signpost where possible but it's really not our fault your neighbour doesn't look after her cat properly.

SillyLavish · 10/04/2023 11:05

I loathe Shelter for this reason. Always getting adverts for them on FB too - they always portray situations as if their help was invaluable to the homeless person but in reality they don't offer anything. They merely signpost or advise people on getting what they're entitled to. If you're entitled to nothing, they wash their hands of you. It particularly rankles when they use people in their ads who they probably wouldn't help in real life.

When I was homeless, a local charity was far more helpful - they actually convinced the council I should be allowed a hostel place temporarily, and offered things like somewhere to wash clothes for people sleeping rough.