Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you ever feel some big charities don't actually do anything?

168 replies

Cinderellaspumpkin · 10/04/2023 08:20

Do you ever feel some big name charities don't actually do much more , when scratching under the surface, than signposting, ( often to other organisations that signpost), and "raise awareness," of the cause.

OP posts:
lljkk · 10/04/2023 14:21

The ones I follow on social media, post stories from people doing work for them. It seems pretty full on to me, vocational. I don't know what "big" means: I volunteer regularly for one that may be "big". I know people appreciate what I do.

Noorandapples · 10/04/2023 14:09

A very elderly relative of mine worked for oxfam in the 50s and 60s all over the world, lived in absolute luxury. We found out after his death that he has a sealed public letter that is not allowed to be opened until about 50 years after his death. Bet it's about what went on.

WhoWants2Know · 10/04/2023 14:07

I work for a large charity that a previous poster said they weren't impressed with. That's hard for me to hear, but at the same time I have to recognise that people in a different local team might have a very different experience from the people I support.

Likewise, people who contact our national helpline will probably be given lots of information from the very knowledgeable phone advisors-- but it's not the same as what we do on a local level.

For me, the job is very much about giving ongoing support from the moment of the first concern/symptoms, right up until the end of a person's life. I will give information and signpost to other providers if that's what the family needs, but that's a small part of the job. I'm a familiar face and voice to go where I'm needed most. I answer questions, listen to fears, hold hands, offer tissues, empathise with confusion and resentment, and find laughter in dark moments. I help navigate a confusing path and bring in help when it's needed. And I am so lucky to be based in a team within a building where we can bring in as many other providers as possible who are also able to help in their various ways. I know the impact I have, because people tell me I've made a difference and taken weight off their shoulders.

My point, I suppose, is not to judge a large charity by its central media or even an experience in one local area. There will be hundreds of stories under each one.

Supersimkin2 · 10/04/2023 14:07

Measurability is notable by its absence.

If big charities are so effective and so thrifty, could we see them dish out just one sheet of A4 with

  • money into our charity £
  • people helped by our charity to value of £
  • people helped by giving CAB number
  • cost per person helped £

It’s not difficult. Every business on the planet manages a more complicated version every month, no matter how tiny.

TeenLifeMum · 10/04/2023 14:04

@WestOfWestminster macmillan do a huge amount. Working in a hospital I know they find specialist nurses we wouldn’t have under normal budgets, provide ongoing training for the macmillan funded nurses and wider team plus provide a huge amount of support for people with cancer - financial and practical advice and support. That’s as well as the cancer research projects. I’m genuinely surprised anyone would think they don’t do very much.

Babyroobs · 10/04/2023 14:04

Cheeseandlobster · 10/04/2023 13:56

Read my above post. You show massive ignorance here. They are not even called Age Concern anymore and haven't been for a long time . I worked for this charity and we were hugely proactive in what we did. Of course every branch is different but we were pivotal in the area I worked in. Most gp's referred to us for this reason and we made a huge difference to our local population and rarely did we signpost

Agree wholeheartedly with this. We have social prescribers, GP's , older people being recommended by work of mouth, social workers all referring to us. The only reason we signpost is if we are totally overwhelmed with referrals which happens a lot as we are such a small team and funding has dried up/ been cut, or if it's something that is out of our remit like complex housing or immigration advice ( we operate in a city with a huge number of immigrants, older family members being brought over from India , young wives being brought over from India etc ) and we want to make sure the advice people get is absolutely up to date.

Cheeseandlobster · 10/04/2023 14:03

Babyroobs · 10/04/2023 12:27

I work for Age UK and offer practical help day in day out. Helping older people fill out form for Attendance allowance, PIP, doing benefit checks, helping them access thousands of pounds of money each year in benefits, grants, supplying food parcels. I recently helped someone get 5k of backpay from Universal credit by identifying where their claim had been wrongly paid for 18 months . Our staffing has been cut and we get very little funding so yes when we get overwhelmed we do have to signpost to CAB. But to say we offer no practical help is totally inaccurate. We are absolutely overwhelmed but trying our best !

Hear hear @Babyroobs

Cheeseandlobster · 10/04/2023 14:00

EmmaEmerald · 10/04/2023 10:09

If it's about checking accounts, you end up just not giving, who is going to check accounts?

Oddly enough, mum has someone from Age UK or whatever visiting soon. I have a feeling they will just tell us to do the things we've already done.

I think you will be in for a surprise then

Cheeseandlobster · 10/04/2023 13:56

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 10/04/2023 09:35

Age Concern ( if that is what it is called this year) are exactly what the OP has described in my experience. They offer no practical help, and their advice is generally to contact another organisation for advice or information.Citizens Advice Bureau does a lot of the heavy lifting for many charities, though I think they are finding it much more difficult to recruit volunteers since Covid.

Read my above post. You show massive ignorance here. They are not even called Age Concern anymore and haven't been for a long time . I worked for this charity and we were hugely proactive in what we did. Of course every branch is different but we were pivotal in the area I worked in. Most gp's referred to us for this reason and we made a huge difference to our local population and rarely did we signpost

Cosyblankets · 10/04/2023 13:50

Do not underestimate raising awareness.
It can be life saving

Cheeseandlobster · 10/04/2023 13:48

Xiaoxiong · 10/04/2023 08:41

I recently looked through the websites of Mind, and the Energy Saving Trust. Both websites felt like signposting alone and for Mind it then said that the "local Mind" which seemed like it actually provided support groups and counsellors was financially independent of Mind. So as far as I can tell the national charity Mind is just a shop front, directing people to local groups (financially separate) and providing info on the website. Energy Saving Trust was even more explicit about being a signposting site.

This. I used to work for a national charity with this set up and trust me, we not only worked our arses off but we made such a difference to the lives of our target group including helping them to claim benefits thus taking them out of poverty, reducing social isolation and supporting them to navigate the social care system. We worked closely with gp practices and health professionals and were regular attendees at their meetings. I don't think that is doing nothing do you?

MotherOfRatios · 10/04/2023 13:45

I work in public affairs in the charity sector, we're not all service based.
A lot of my job is holding the government to account and helping to influence and shape strategy, so you can't lump the charity sector with all the same issues

KnittingNeedles · 10/04/2023 13:40

The solution is direct giving

Except often it's not. Direct Giving is what leads to people loading up transit vans with random items donated by well-meaning neighbours and friends, and driving across Europe to Ukraine/Turkey, with nothing but a vague idea about doing a "good thing" and socking it to those big money grabbing charities who dare to spend 1p on admin and salaries.

Supersimkin2 · 10/04/2023 13:38

Taking buckets of cash for doing fuck all? Yes.

I remain horrified.

I can read accounts. I did.

One charity, donated to lavishly by celebs, kept 92 percent and spent 8 percent on projects that were already fully funded by the council.

I’ve worked for two famous charities too. Most of the remarkably well-paid staff do nothing.

The solution is direct giving.

Elvis1956 · 10/04/2023 13:37

I have been keeping an eye on a small local charity. 2 years ago almost 35% of the income went on fundraising. There seems to be no sign in the accounts that they have done anything in connection with their objectives.
The web site talks about fund raising, which seems to be about giving the principles life experiences. There was no mention of how to access their services or how they can help

Nimbostratus100 · 10/04/2023 13:36

Nimbostratus100 · 10/04/2023 13:31

but surely they are digging and maintaining large numbers of boreholes? And all the surveying, and planning, and permissions, and admins etc that needs to be done first?

and, of course, provision of toilets and sewers, which is far more difficult and expensive

Nimbostratus100 · 10/04/2023 13:31

IncompleteSenten · 10/04/2023 10:17

I do, yes.
If they solved the cause they campaign for they'd all be out of work and those at the top would have to look elsewhere for their gigantic salaries.

Example, water aid. I just took a look at their figures and it seems in 2018-19 alone they raked in over 113 million. In one year. You should be tripping over boreholes all over the place by now. They cost around £10,000. I know because I've done 2. And a big organisation could definitely get a cheaper price based on volume.

I think big charities are actually big businesses in disguise.

but surely they are digging and maintaining large numbers of boreholes? And all the surveying, and planning, and permissions, and admins etc that needs to be done first?

Nimbostratus100 · 10/04/2023 13:29

Sausagenbacon · 10/04/2023 10:04

I think it boils down to, as someone said above, checking a charities accounts. A friend of mine has done this and I piggy back on what she found. She even visited their offices.
But that's because, once she supported it, she did it wholeheartedly. Like her, I've identified 2 charities that I support, and I give them a monthly donation by standing order. That means that the charity knows the money is coming in, and that I don't have to think about it, or worry about not giving to other charities.

which charities?

AnnaMagnani · 10/04/2023 13:23

Nimbostratus100 · 10/04/2023 13:10

Macmillan to loads!

My experiences of Macmillan include

-financial advice and help to apply for benefits

-grant to pay for travel to hospital and towards winter heating costs

-emergency medical advice

-general chat support line

-online information and advice

There is lots more available to me too, that I have not needed as yet, but might in the future

Yes but none of those are actually expensive given how many millions Macmillan raises:

-financial advice and help to apply for benefits.

Can be done by any benefits advisor or even the social prescriber at your GP

-grant to pay for travel to hospital and towards winter heating costs

They will do this once, means tested, up to £350. It's an incredibly cheap thing for the charity to do. Most people won't qualify.

-emergency medical advice

Should come from your hospital Acute Oncology Team, who Macmillan don't pay for

-general chat support line

Can be done by minimal staff WFH

-online information and advice

There used to be an amazing charity that did all the cancer info but they didn't have the name recognition of Macmillan. Macmillan basically took them over including all their information processes. For anything related to chemo, Cancer Research's info is usually better.

Nimbostratus100 · 10/04/2023 13:21

EmmaEmerald · 10/04/2023 09:35

Yes
I worked for one - as a contractor, good money - and they were actually reducing their involvement in the practical things, doing a lot of signposting. They seem to exist for the benefit of directors on six figures with big expense accounts. I was offered a second contract there but said no.

I am very careful about where my donations go. There's some good books on this.

why not name them? Its not much help to us if we dont know who this is?

Nimbostratus100 · 10/04/2023 13:19

Sausagenbacon · 10/04/2023 09:28

I think another issue is duplication. In bristol we have 72 charities aimed at helping the elderly in the city. There are a large number of charities working with the homeless too.
Just think how effective they could be if they joined forces!

In my experience, charities helping homeless people cooperative with each other and work together hugely -but they all have different specialisms, and areas of expertise. I dont really see the benefit of lumping them altogether and adding another layer of admin on top.

Nimbostratus100 · 10/04/2023 13:10

WestOfWestminster · 10/04/2023 08:23

I see your point, although I find it hard to know which fit this catagory. It's hard to tell which make a meaningful difference & which don't.

I've heard mixed reviews about Macmillan for example, but would be interested to find out more.

Macmillan to loads!

My experiences of Macmillan include

-financial advice and help to apply for benefits

-grant to pay for travel to hospital and towards winter heating costs

-emergency medical advice

-general chat support line

-online information and advice

There is lots more available to me too, that I have not needed as yet, but might in the future

TheWayTheLightFalls · 10/04/2023 13:05

Everything @89redballoons said, imo.

I run a small charity (a food bank). I think we do well by the metric the OP set out - we "do something" measurable, again and again (we distribute around a tonne of food a week to named recipients). And we have a lot of (happy, afaik! They keep coming back) volunteers and few staff, which keeps our costs low.

But our systems are pretty basic, and there's a lot of duplication across the sector/area. And frankly I'd rather adequate gov't provision of money/benefits/food, than chronic food bank use. Because that's another (avoidable) layer of cost and bureaucracy.

On balance we do more good than harm, but I dislike the overall fat in the system.

Knowing what I know now, my charity donations would always be to a charity I know/understand, where I have seen the impact and where the need is clear.

dragonbreaths · 10/04/2023 13:00

stbrandonsboat · 10/04/2023 09:57

Palliative care is not a particularly difficult area of nursing. Any half decent nurse who works in this area will already be doing what the Macmillan nurse advises. It changes little and doesn't require expert knowledge. We sometimes used to have to tolerate the Macmillan nurse visiting our care home to 'advise' on care and we'd already be doing what she advised because the nurses had years of experience between us. It's just not that difficult in practical terms. I also had the Gold Standard training in palliative care.

Macmillan will help people access benefits, but you don't need to be a qualified nurse to do that.

I suggest that your years of experience = expert knowledge