Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Annual Family Arguments.

57 replies

EmpressOfTheSofa · 10/04/2023 07:33

I’m such a mug.

I hosted Easter Sunday yesterday, my parents, two sisters, one BIL and then me, adult DD and her boyfriend and my DH.

Over dinner S1 asked DD what her plans are. She just turned 19 and is finishing college, she’s had a bumpy ride after failing her first year and then only doing six weeks of an apprenticeship. She’s about to gain a BTEC in art and works in a pub. I couldn’t be prouder.

DD said for now she will pick up full-time hours in the pub. S1 went off on a massive rant about how hospitality isn’t a career, there’s only a small window to choose a career before your life is a waste. Hospitality is for losers and thick people who can’t do anything else.

I manage a cafe and was a pub manager before that. She left school with no qualifications and worked her way up through various office jobs and now earns £££ in HR. She’s single, for context.

I pushed back and said I didn’t have a ‘career’ until my late 30s and that’s ok. She cackled and said I still don’t; and my life wouldn’t be worth anything if I didn’t have DH (he has a proper job, you see).

I tried to keep it light, laughed it off and took the dog out. But I’m still furious. And everyone just sat there! Including DH.

There is a common theme with her of mocking my job, she told me a few months ago that my qualifications aren’t real (I did a L3 apprenticeship and got distinctions across the board,) as everyone passes it and it’s easy. I was made to feel small and stupid for celebrating it. But now she’s come right out and told DD that she’d be a loser if she worked in my field as well.

I’ve woken up today with it all going round in my head. I’m angry and embarrassed. I’m off to work in a bit in my shit job that isn’t worthy of respect. I’m trying to laugh it off but it has got to me. DH says everyone just thinks she’s a mouthy idiot but I’m the only one who ever challenges her nonsense and I come out of it feeling awful.

Anyone else have a ridiculous family dynamic like this where it’s acceptable to put someone down to this extent? I think I’m done.

OP posts:
mondaytosunday · 10/04/2023 09:27

I have a friend, who along with her husband, have two masters degrees and speak five languages. What do they do? They run a small hotel. This has allowed them to travel for three months of the year and put their child through private school. It's not even an expensive hotel - it's a two star (but lovely) in a seasonal area.
So tell your sister that hospitality is indeed an excellent CAREER. It is worth £59billion to the UK economy. (Human resources is worth about £2billion).
And pubs in particular are often the bedrock of communities.
Also have a word with your husband about sticking up for you and your daughter.

MzHz · 10/04/2023 09:26

EmpressOfTheSofa · 10/04/2023 07:59

Honestly this is why I feel like a
mug. Things will be good and I think I can host a nice time and then she’ll make me feel small AGAIN.

So please bookmark or download this thread so you never lose it and any notion that enters your head of trying to host and all have a nice bit of family time is nixxed and you remind yourself that your sister WILL ruin it because she enjoys making you feel bad.

you keep going back to this in the hope she’ll be nice.

she’s not a nice person. She’s just being herself and that’s someone who bullies and belittles you.

have a prepared response ready for if she suggests coming to yours or wonders where her invitation is

“Going by how rude and belittling you are to me every time I have you to ours, perhaps you don’t enjoy my hospitality. In any case I don’t appreciate being made to feel like crap in my own home, in front of my family and spending good money for the insults.”

it’s a bit vicious and you don’t have to actually say it, just knowing you could can give you a little power and you won’t feel so stressed

long story short, don’t invite her and make excuses to not have her.

MauveCow · 10/04/2023 09:21

And she works in HR?

Apologies to any HR workers on here, but...haha.

Brefugee · 10/04/2023 09:19

the actual meat of her jibes isn't the issue - the fact is that she was a guest in your home and insulted you and your DD.
The correct approach is to tell (not ask) her to apologise to both of you and then leave.
That is it. Don't invite her again.

dig135 · 10/04/2023 09:16

And, while descending to her level isn't a good look, HR isn't exactly developing a cancer vaccine or making millions as an investment banker.

Before people jump on me, I know HR is a very valuable role but not so ground-breaking to be worthy of belittling someone who works in hospitality.

I know someone in one of the categories above and they wouldn't dream of speaking to people like your sister does. It smacks of insecurity on her part.

Pixie18 · 10/04/2023 09:12

Id screenshot all these responses and send them to her to show just how vile her behaviour is. Sisters/ family are supposed to support and build each other up. But yes - would definitely have v little to do with her. She must be v unhappy about something to treat other family members this way x

cryinginhmart · 10/04/2023 09:10

I rely on hospitality workers for much of the fun in my life - going out with friends, my partner etc. Without them none of that would be possible. There is also absolutely no fucking way I could do that job - I did when I was younger and it was so hard physically. My partner used to work in a pub and I’d go sometimes when he was working and see him constantly ferrying drinks up massive flights of stairs and dealing with drunk customers and just think… how are you doing this?!

Your sister is an idiot.

SilverTotoro · 10/04/2023 09:07

Just look at all the supportive comments you’ve had on here most saying your sister is insecure and quite possibly also jealous. You have a lovely family and a career to be proud of. If you’re happy in your life then you’re winning her comments are irrelevant.

Keep contact to a minimum and just ignore her digs because as much as we’d all like to deliver perfect put downs in these situations, it rarely works that way. It is possible to grey rock, ignore comments and change the subject. Once I’d perfected this with a difficult family member I felt a sense of serene satisfaction after every event where they’d tried and failed to get a rise out of me.

TheFullPicnic · 10/04/2023 09:06

She’s very desperate to big herself up at the expense of everyone else, isn’t she?

I wonder why?

Don’t let her be the centre of attention. Ignore, change the subject, grey rock. And where possible, don’t invite her. You don’t have to have people who put you down at your table. If she asks why no invite just tell her calmly that she put you and your Dd down and you it spoiled the occasion. And don’t rise to the wailing and gnashing that ensues. Just shrug. “You said what you think, I said what I think”.

Chessetchelsea · 10/04/2023 08:55

Well done for sticking up for yourself and your DD. She sounds dreadful. I wouldn’t invite her again. I’d be disappointed at no one else pulling her up, particularly your DH. That’s very hurtful. And as for her snobbery, ignore! Interestingly, the more money I’ve had in life, the less I’ve been interested in new phones and flashy cars. It’s like a weird reverse psychology thing. I know I could buy them but I don’t need to prove I can to anyone!

Baabaa75 · 10/04/2023 08:52

Whichnumbers · 10/04/2023 07:39

I worked in hospitality on and off all my life

many people have this view, they’re the same people that “expect” good service and complain at the state if the industry. An industry that is extremely important to the economy and has suffered since brexit and covid saw an exit if many of the workers

dont let your sister live rent free in her head

next time tell her HR is where you go if you’d not survive in the recruitment industry in commission targets

While your sister is clearly a twat don't say this. No-one would swap a career in HR to be a rec consultant, which is a very shitty job. People usually make the jump from recruiter into HR, not the other way round 🤷

Lordofthebutterfloofs · 10/04/2023 08:49

She is massively jealous of what you have OP.

Don't invite her anymore. Or if you do and she does it again just smile and roll your eyes at everyone else and change the subject. OR give her a head tilt and say 'are you ok? Because you don't seem like your ok'

LlynTegid · 10/04/2023 08:40

So does S1 never go out to a restaurant, never stay in a hotel? I doubt that very much. Probably the first to complain if a place is short staffed and service is limited or slow.

Don't invite her again, please tell her why.

FinallyHere · 10/04/2023 08:38
  • She's that insecure relative who has to tell other people how shit their lives are. Just think how unhappy she must be deep down to do that.

she’ll make me feel small AGAIN.*

The trick with people like this is to get clear in your own mind that they do not really have any power over how you feel, unless you give them that power.

Don't give her that power

She is only jealous of what you do have, jealous and insecure.

Imagine how she would feel if you smiles indulgently at he, as the toddler she is behaving like. You are happy with your life, you have a job you enjoy and are good at, you ah E a lovely DH and family.

Why would you care how she tried to needle you. Smile indulgently at her and do not rise to it. Pinch you thumb between your fingers to remind yourself to just smile and give no other reaction

I promise you she will hate being ignored so much more

Good luck. You are doing so well, don't let be undermine you.

Eggseggseverywhere · 10/04/2023 08:37

Well that's your christmas card list shortened.. Honestly op just keep her away. Dna doesn't mean she gets to abuse you in your own home or at all.

Needapadlockonmyfridge · 10/04/2023 08:36

Easy to say, but I just wouldn't invite her.
She sounds nasty.

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 10/04/2023 08:32

Honestly this is why I feel like a mug. Things will be good and I think I can host a nice time and then she’ll make me feel small AGAIN.

So just stop. You can still see your parents and your other sister - but you're under no obligation to spend time with anyone you don't want to.

EmpressOfTheSofa · 10/04/2023 08:30

So I did call her out, and said you’re being really offensive about my career and DD’s choices. She said ‘I’m only trying to help DD, I don’t want her to waste her life’. I said so are you saying I’ve wasted mine? And she said yes; you’d be nothing without DH.

She says DD has to get a job in a big company with prospects to climb the ladder. I said yes, she can do that in hospitality, there’s more to the sector than just front of house work. She poo pooed that and said well they don’t employ bar staff to do head office jobs. Well, they literally do. Most of the HO team in my last company had done just that.

NO ONE at the table apart from my DH has a professional job by the way. So she was putting everybody down really but specifically targeting hospitality. Other sister works in commission based sales (but I think that’s ok because it’s an ‘office’ job).

I honestly don’t know why I give her the headspace. She has also said I look ridiculous taking a £500 handbag on the bus, that she wouldn’t be seen dead driving a Ford as they are cheap (parents have a aka, we have a Fiesta, sis has a Kuga…she has a BMW). She’s a fucking snobby idiot.

OP posts:
IAteAllTheTomatoes · 10/04/2023 08:18

On repeat "why do you continually need to put others down to make yourself feel better? Is everything really OK with you because your behaviour says otherwise?"

Call her out every single time untim she gets the mesage.

DoristheDuchess · 10/04/2023 08:14

Did you ever see that Hitchcock film Strangers on a Train, where two complete Strangers meet and decide to swap the murders of annoying relatives so they wouldn't get caught?

I often think that at holiday family events, mumsnet should run a 'swap me out' service where we exchange each others families and have a grand time telling other people's relatives they're acting like arseholes whilst sitting at thr dinner table and smiling sweetly.

Re-label your sister like Peter Kay's uncle knobhead. She's that insecure relative who has to tell other people how shit their lives are. Just think how unhappy she must be deep down to do that.

Limit contact to once a year and secretly run a bitch bingo card with your DH that you can chuckle about afterwards.

You're giving her too much power and letting her live in your head. Take it back and limit her impact on your life.

EmpressOfTheSofa · 10/04/2023 07:59

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 10/04/2023 07:57

Why do you keep inviting her when she behaves like this and makes you feel this way?

It's not obligatory - just don't have her over again.

Honestly this is why I feel like a
mug. Things will be good and I think I can host a nice time and then she’ll make me feel small AGAIN.

OP posts:
coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 10/04/2023 07:57

Why do you keep inviting her when she behaves like this and makes you feel this way?

It's not obligatory - just don't have her over again.

EmpressOfTheSofa · 10/04/2023 07:54

Aprilx · 10/04/2023 07:52

Why is her being single required context?

Because she said I’d be nothing without DH’s job.

OP posts:
junebirthdaygirl · 10/04/2023 07:52

Think your dh is right. Everyone else in the room knows she is completely out of order and making a fool of herself. Completely ignore her as she loves the fight so having it fall on deaf ears will not satisfy her.

But l would be slow to ask her back especially

picking on your dd at a vulnerable time in her life as she makes decisions for her future.

Had she drink taken as it sometimes brings out the obnoxious side in people?

Aprilx · 10/04/2023 07:52

Why is her being single required context?