Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Annual Family Arguments.

57 replies

EmpressOfTheSofa · 10/04/2023 07:33

I’m such a mug.

I hosted Easter Sunday yesterday, my parents, two sisters, one BIL and then me, adult DD and her boyfriend and my DH.

Over dinner S1 asked DD what her plans are. She just turned 19 and is finishing college, she’s had a bumpy ride after failing her first year and then only doing six weeks of an apprenticeship. She’s about to gain a BTEC in art and works in a pub. I couldn’t be prouder.

DD said for now she will pick up full-time hours in the pub. S1 went off on a massive rant about how hospitality isn’t a career, there’s only a small window to choose a career before your life is a waste. Hospitality is for losers and thick people who can’t do anything else.

I manage a cafe and was a pub manager before that. She left school with no qualifications and worked her way up through various office jobs and now earns £££ in HR. She’s single, for context.

I pushed back and said I didn’t have a ‘career’ until my late 30s and that’s ok. She cackled and said I still don’t; and my life wouldn’t be worth anything if I didn’t have DH (he has a proper job, you see).

I tried to keep it light, laughed it off and took the dog out. But I’m still furious. And everyone just sat there! Including DH.

There is a common theme with her of mocking my job, she told me a few months ago that my qualifications aren’t real (I did a L3 apprenticeship and got distinctions across the board,) as everyone passes it and it’s easy. I was made to feel small and stupid for celebrating it. But now she’s come right out and told DD that she’d be a loser if she worked in my field as well.

I’ve woken up today with it all going round in my head. I’m angry and embarrassed. I’m off to work in a bit in my shit job that isn’t worthy of respect. I’m trying to laugh it off but it has got to me. DH says everyone just thinks she’s a mouthy idiot but I’m the only one who ever challenges her nonsense and I come out of it feeling awful.

Anyone else have a ridiculous family dynamic like this where it’s acceptable to put someone down to this extent? I think I’m done.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Cherrysoup · 10/04/2023 19:30

Jesus, she wounds be allowed in my house with that shitty attitude. Please don’t tolerate her nonsense again.

DashboardConfessional · 10/04/2023 17:07

Baabaa75 · 10/04/2023 08:52

While your sister is clearly a twat don't say this. No-one would swap a career in HR to be a rec consultant, which is a very shitty job. People usually make the jump from recruiter into HR, not the other way round 🤷

That's the point. You say something as untrue as hospitality being shit with no prospects, to wind her up!

EmpressOfTheSofa · 10/04/2023 16:57

My friend met her for the first time a couple of years ago and she was vile to him; he said as soon as she left that she was obviously jealous of me.

I don’t know if it is that though. She is just a nasty cow to people. My mother said they went to a wine tasting a while back and she was berating a pair of newly weds on what a crock of shit marriage is. Really embarrassing. She’s divorced (several years now) and does have children and I know she was upset they weren’t with her yesterday. So whether it is jealousy, bitterness or she’s just a narc who thinks her life is the only proper life, who knows.

Im not going to put up with it any more though.

She also slagged off my dungarees and said I looked like a children’s tv presenter; although she does have a point there 🤣

OP posts:
Coyoacan · 10/04/2023 15:10

I never come with this response to things, but in this case I think it applies. Jealousy!

My cousin told me by accident about how favorably her family, ie. parents and siblings, compared to mine. But the thing is we were too busy getting on with our lives to bother comparing ourselves with other people.

EmpressOfTheSofa · 10/04/2023 15:01

If I’d asked her to leave it would have caused a big row and she’d have made out I was being unreasonable/over sensitive. She kept saying ‘I’m only giving advice to DD’ and couldn’t see anything wrong with it. She just kept doubling down on hospitality not being a career.

BIL (other sisters DH) came and gave me a hug while I was washing up and said ‘she’s a twat’. She is prone to dramatics so I did get why everyone just let her carry on.

OP posts:
AgentJohnson · 10/04/2023 13:30

I do think one jibe back from you about how much time she has to devote to work because she is single/childless/has no friends/whatever would shock her into behaving.

I doubt it, she’d sooner declare herself the victim.

Op, you are also part of your family’s dynamic. I can’t believe you didn’t ask her to leave. She was a guest in your home, that is a privilege not a right. Do not ask this self righteous, insecure woman back.

dottiedodah · 10/04/2023 12:45

I think she sounds a bit jealous of you TBH .Maybe she thinks by belittling you she can feel better! Sounds tiresome.You are working and supporting your DH, its not all one way traffic here.Maybe she is regretting her Career choice and taking it out on you. Your DH is in a tight spot really,if he defends you then your parents may take your sisters side and cause a big falling out.Maybe next time just ask your DP and other Sister along .If she does end up coming ,dont engage with her too much .

Natty13 · 10/04/2023 11:05

You have some choices:

  1. Stop inviting her. Tell her it's because she can't seem to stop herself being insulting whenever you host her.
  2. Keep inviting her, keep trying to reason with her.
  3. Fight fire with fire. Tell her something like "well yes, of course you are focusing on your career dear, since you have no partner or children to enrich the rest of your life 😉 ". I wouldn't usually say something like that unless really pushed. People who try to put others down is almost always because of insecurity in themselves. I do think one jibe back from you about how much time she has to devote to work because she is single/childless/has no friends/whatever would shock her into behaving.
Lolapusht · 10/04/2023 10:57

OP, I’m guessing that you take care of family/house things so your husband can do his job? His very important job which will save lives? You contribute to that too. If you didn’t do everything you do then your DH couldn’t FIND A CURE FOR CANCER!!!!!

Sod your sister. Don’t invite her again. When you were growing up, was she jealous of you? What was the dynamic? Sounds like she’s negging you. Does she, for example, want a husband and children so she’s putting your life down?

Scottishskifun · 10/04/2023 10:51

Agree she sounds jealous so decides that putting you down is easier.

I have the opposite snobbery from my DB - I can't possibly know what hard work is because I don't do a manual job and I just push paper all day!

I don't rise to it anymore and just say different horses for different courses all job roles in society are needed and all are careers!

Nanny0gg · 10/04/2023 10:48

That made me chuckle as DH literally cures cancer everyday; he writes the code that directs the beam in radiotherapy machines…he starts every day by saying ‘another day in the fight against cancer’

When you think of IT jobs that one doesn't come to mind! What a responsibility! Amazing

Topsy44 · 10/04/2023 10:44

I agree that this is jealousy from your sister. I have a SIL like this and I do now only see her about once a year which makes things easier.

InSpainTheRain · 10/04/2023 10:36

I'd never host her again but cut her off for what she said to DD.

Skybluepinky · 10/04/2023 10:35

She is laying the bait and u r biting, whilst u continue to do so the cycle will never end.

Minierme · 10/04/2023 10:30

I’m sorry. This is classic jealousy. Either call her on it or ignore it (if you don’t want WW3) but definitely don’t pay the slightest bit of attention to it.
If you want the best revenge, next time look lovingly into your DHs eyes and say “oh sis, it’s okay it must be hard. We are so lucky to have each other and both be fulfilled in our work. Having my girls is my proudest accomplishment”… then float away to refill the gravy boat.

dig135 · 10/04/2023 10:25

That made me chuckle as DH literally cures cancer everyday; he writes the code that directs the beam in radiotherapy machines…he starts every day by saying ‘another day in the fight against cancer’ 🤣🤣

Awesome!

Minimalme · 10/04/2023 10:21

The biggest bitch I ever encountered worked in HR. She was very skilled at self promotion and not much else.

Don't invite your sister to your house. Seriously, ditch her.

Irritateandunreasonable · 10/04/2023 10:13

Aprilx · 10/04/2023 07:52

Why is her being single required context?

I think because shes being able to focus solely on herself and her work so a very different lifestyle to OP.

Foreversearch · 10/04/2023 10:10

@EmpressOfTheSofa I’m curious, did your parents not say anything? My parents would have jumped in and said they were proud of all 3 DD and their achievements.

EmpressOfTheSofa · 10/04/2023 09:59

dig135 · 10/04/2023 09:16

And, while descending to her level isn't a good look, HR isn't exactly developing a cancer vaccine or making millions as an investment banker.

Before people jump on me, I know HR is a very valuable role but not so ground-breaking to be worthy of belittling someone who works in hospitality.

I know someone in one of the categories above and they wouldn't dream of speaking to people like your sister does. It smacks of insecurity on her part.

That made me chuckle as DH literally cures cancer everyday; he writes the code that directs the beam in radiotherapy machines…he starts every day by saying ‘another day in the fight against cancer’ 🤣🤣

And he thinks my job is hugely worthwhile 🤷🏻‍♀️

OP posts:
Newnamefor23 · 10/04/2023 09:57

Sorry about this. Some just ‘try to help’ with unhelpful and caustic comments.

Perhaps a bit of jealousy? She might have £££s and a BMW but you have a daughter + husband.

My late Dad felt the need to have an annual Christmas discussion/argument with my young adult son. Even on his deathbed, 2 weeks to go Christmas.

For him he wanted to be top dog, alpha male, not wrong or critisised. My son tried to avoid these but my Dad always managed.

We tried different seating plans, subject changing but he usually managed.

Looking back I should have challenged him on this - but never did hoping that next Christmas would see a change, a mellowing.

CleaningOutMyCloset · 10/04/2023 09:55

Next time she starts tell her she's being offensive, if she carries on tell her to leave.

DingDongDenny · 10/04/2023 09:53

Like others have said she is jealous of what you have and so is trying to undermine you and big up the one thing she thinks she is more successful than you at - her career, while dissing the other things you have - DH, DD and happy home life

The best response is just to say 'I am very happy with all my choices, my job and home life and really proud of DD' then ignore.

Forestdweller11 · 10/04/2023 09:50

Just reread and apologies it's your sister not SiL.

Bit more understandable that your DH didn't say anything.

Bet Dad's boyfriend was a bit 😱.

But my earlier comments stand, largely.

But maybe you need to look at the sibling dynamic - golden child, jealousy, favouritism etc potentially going back donkeys years etc .

But you certainly don't have to put up with her sniping/undermining.

Forestdweller11 · 10/04/2023 09:45

Personally, I'd have done the same. It wasn't just you she was attacking but your daughter as well. If it was just a personal attack I'd probably just have quietly seethed.
I think you need to be having another word with your not so DH about where his loyalties lie. Your SiL has effectively dissed both you and his daughter whilst he appears to have sat and said nothing.

And also a conversation with your daughter about how proud you are of her and understand if she doesn't want to socialise with SiL for a while/ever.

Don't invite your SiL again. You and your daughter don't need exposing to such a twat.

Swipe left for the next trending thread