Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think exH should've allowed DS and DD to share a room

57 replies

NamechangedAgainAndAgain123 · 10/04/2023 00:01

Me and ex adopted DD and DS at 8 and 4, DD turned 16 today and DS is 12. DS is also autistic.

He doesn't like sleeping alone and won't, he gets very upset but won't say why, I suspect it could be a fear of the dark but ive tried everything with different lights etc but nothing helps.

He sleeps in DD’s room on weekdays which DD is fine with as I've asked her and told her to tell me if she ever feels uncomfortable with this, he then sleeps in my bed on weekends as a treat and so DD can have friends round if she wanted to etc.

I have started getting him try to sleep in his own bed, I tried for the first time last Sunday and I had to sit with him until he fell asleep and he then got into my bed at around midnight.

He hadn't stayed overnight with ex for a while as he didn't want to be away from me, he stayed over last night which was his choice and when they got back today DD was telling me that my ex wouldn't let DS sleep in her room, he said it was inappropriate and wouldn't listen when DD said she didn't mind, he asks DD and DS to hand their phones in usually but when DS got upset and was asking for it back to message me he wouldn't give it to him. DD told him to sleep in her room when ex had gone to bed which he did.

He seems fine but AIBU to be annoyed at ex and for thinking he should've let them share?

OP posts:
UndercoverCop · 10/04/2023 10:42

*their

UndercoverCop · 10/04/2023 10:41

It places the role of carer on a 16 year old's shoulders. I wouldn't be happy with that consistently, if it was because of a change of environment eg a holiday and she was ok with it for a few days that's different, but she's been taught to place everyone else's needs above her own day in day out, her brother's, her mother's (let him sleep with me at weekends as a treat) , adopted children in particular can fall into people pleasing she to fear of rejection or abandonment.
I don't agree with the way they're father has dealt with it, but it should never have been allowed to become the situation it is

MoreSleepPleasee · 10/04/2023 10:35

I used to always sleep in my sisters bed though as I was scared sleeping alone. No adult ever had an issue.

MoreSleepPleasee · 10/04/2023 10:34

Special needs child needing to feel safe. Where is the problem with that. What did your ex think they would do.

Dilemma19 · 10/04/2023 10:12

Op why isn't your ds sleeping with you? I wouldn't be happy to let that fall on my dd, she's 16 and needs her own space. You might think she's happy to do it, but she feels she has to and not want to upset anyone by saying so.

LBFseBrom · 10/04/2023 09:34

I get what you are saying (I am an adopted child), but this is not going to last much longer. He will want privacy on reaching puberty and the op's daughter won't want her brother sleeping in her room forever. I think it is OK for now.

JudgeRudy · 10/04/2023 06:25

Have you recently split? How come your ex isn't aware of these things or is this a new rule he's introduced.
When you say your 12 year old son won't sleep alone, how far have you pushed it? I mean what efforts have you made to instil boundaries?
I know sometimes it's hard when someone has special needs to see them upset but l bet you would have upset your daughter if she had not followed the rules. He may be a bit frightened and he may scream the house down for 3 nights but surely it would work eventually. Yes he's autistic but he doesn't have a right to never be upset or challenged. Going forward, your daughter won't want to keep this up. Have you resigned yourself to never having a relationship? What's your plan?

Slight digression, but why is your ex confiscating phones from a 16 year old? My daughter would never have gone along with that. I wonder if it's actually your daughter you should be looking out for. She sounds very much like a people pleaser. Could she be avoiding conflict because she feels responsible for your son? That's a big burden.

MrsTerryPratchett · 10/04/2023 06:21

Are they biologically related or were they adopted at 8 and 4 separately?

The reason I ask is that there are hardwired processes in sibling relationships. Knowing each other in very early childhood, regardless of biology, hardwires a sibling relationship. Meeting later doesn't.

Also, a 16 yo girl should be allowed to develop her sense of self privately. Sharing with her 12 yo sibling every night as essentially a carer isn't entirely healthy. I don't think you ex is right to impose this suddenly, but you should gradually.

JudgeRudy · 10/04/2023 06:12

LBFseBrom · 10/04/2023 00:20

I don't think there is anything inappropriate about your son sleeping in your daughter's room, or with you, especially as he is nervous in a room on his own. He is still very young and will outgrow this. I was very nervous at night, even terrified, as a child and a teenager and would have been happier had I been able to sleep with somebody else in the room, even if I was on the floor! My only child used to get up and come in with us for years, for the same reason. Plenty of kids are like this and a big sister is a comfort. Presumably he has his own room to keep all his things in, etc, it's just the going to sleep which is a problem.

Your ex is over reacting to something which is actually quite common though not always admitted (for fear of reactions like your ex has displayed).

Hes not very young though is he? He's 12!

NumberTheory · 10/04/2023 04:48

I agree with the posters saying your DD shouldn’t have this role put on her. Though it’s lovely that she is kind to her brother, it’s something that you and ExH should have sorted out some time ago, though I appreciate it can be really hard to balance all your family’s needs. I’m glad you’re working on trying to get DS into his own room now.

Despite that, I don’t think your DH’s actions were reasonable unless he’s talked to you about it before and you’ve been ignoring him/dragging your heels. He could have talked to you about it first and discussed it more with DS, not unilaterally insisted on the first time DS stays over in some time.

Goodread1 · 10/04/2023 04:25

It's not fair on her to expect your daughter to fulfil that role of night time baby sister,

He is 12 yrs age,
Surely you can sort something out better long term, for them come on...

Goodread1 · 10/04/2023 04:22

I think your daughter at her age of 16 yrs should have her own space,
She is entitled to at that age to want have her own space , for whatever reasons ,

This situation of allmost having to constantly look out for younger brother age 12 isn't something that should be imposed on her,

She is not your 12 Yr old sons babysitter at night time,
Your ex husband and yourself need to come up with a better solution

It's not really on her, that's she responsible to make him feel safe and happy all the time @NamechangedAgainAndAgain123

WeWereInParis · 10/04/2023 04:21

I don't think your ex went about it in the right way but I don't think his opinion on the situation is wrong.

I think if your DS can't sleep alone he should be in with you, it's not fair on his sister even if she is happy with it.

TheOriginalEmu · 10/04/2023 04:00

EllandRd · 10/04/2023 02:47

He is not very young, he is 12 years old?

12 is still very young: particularly for an autistic child.
forcing him to sleep alone when dd is HAPPY to do it doesn’t help either of them, and may make it a hundred times worse. It needs to be worked on slowly, in a safe space.

TheOriginalEmu · 10/04/2023 03:57

CJsGoldfish · 10/04/2023 03:05

My first reaction was how lovely your DD sounds OP. Thoughtful and caring of her younger brother. It's lovely.

Then when I think about it, I do agree with the above. As much as she is happy helping her brother, it is not the role she should be burdened with. Not that it is a burden to her, I can see that it isn't. I just think that, at 16, this isn't the role she needs to be playing. It will inhibit what she wants to do and that's not fair.

If she’s happy to do it, it’s not a burden. My sister slept in my bed with me for years.she’s autistic and she didn’t like to sleep alone. So she didn’t. I didn’t mind, there was no ‘burden. We just had a double bed.

HoppingPavlova · 10/04/2023 03:49

Hard to know without knowing the dynamics of your relationship. I imagine he is actually safeguarding himself so he can’t be put in a position where you could make a complaint against him. While you may be fine with it, I can understand why he may be reluctant.

ArcticSkewer · 10/04/2023 03:38

It's plainly inappropriate to expect a 16 year old girl to regularly share with her 12 year old brother in order to act as an emotional support person, even if that does make your own life easier. This is not healthy or appropriate for her, not at all.

I can't say your ex approached it well, on your daughter's birthday it sounds like. The whole event must have been upsetting. But your lack of boundaries for your daughter is also not okay.

LettingMySouthSideShow · 10/04/2023 03:34

I’m sure OP is aware the situation isn’t ideal. The time to tackle it wasn’t this time when her son hadn’t stayed with his dad for a while. I’d be annoyed too.

Your kids sound like they have a lovely, close bond. Keep working on your son sleeping separately, but I’m sure you don’t need us lot to tell you that.

I have an autistic child that didn’t sleep well for years but now does. We tried everything to be honest, nothing worked. It just stopped being an issue. I hope it’s the same for you. 💐

Quitelikeacatslife · 10/04/2023 03:27

Up to exh to have these boundaries at his place but if ds was upset he should have made up a bed for him in his room. It's time at 16 for your dd to have her own space now, though she sounds kind

momonpurpose · 10/04/2023 03:12

While it's lovely that your DD is willing to do this it is not her job to make him feel safe. It's yours. I think you need to take a hard look at this situation to see it cannot continue. You need to do whatever it takes to make him comfortable on his own

stardust40 · 10/04/2023 03:08

In terms of it being appropriate.....no probs as they are brother/sister. However at 16 I agree with others that dd shouldn't have to do this every night of the week. She should have her own space and not be a cared for her brother.

CJsGoldfish · 10/04/2023 03:05

Namechanger2n2 · 10/04/2023 02:35

I actually agree with xdh that it isn't appropriate. dd may now be used to it, but she is not responsible for making her autistic brother feel safe at night. She is entitled to her own space. What happens when she grows up and leaves. If he sleeps with op then that's her choice as a dm but dd should be weaned off this habit imho.

My first reaction was how lovely your DD sounds OP. Thoughtful and caring of her younger brother. It's lovely.

Then when I think about it, I do agree with the above. As much as she is happy helping her brother, it is not the role she should be burdened with. Not that it is a burden to her, I can see that it isn't. I just think that, at 16, this isn't the role she needs to be playing. It will inhibit what she wants to do and that's not fair.

FangedFrisbee · 10/04/2023 02:57

Namechanger2n2 · 10/04/2023 02:35

I actually agree with xdh that it isn't appropriate. dd may now be used to it, but she is not responsible for making her autistic brother feel safe at night. She is entitled to her own space. What happens when she grows up and leaves. If he sleeps with op then that's her choice as a dm but dd should be weaned off this habit imho.

I agree, he's 12.

EllandRd · 10/04/2023 02:47

LBFseBrom · 10/04/2023 00:20

I don't think there is anything inappropriate about your son sleeping in your daughter's room, or with you, especially as he is nervous in a room on his own. He is still very young and will outgrow this. I was very nervous at night, even terrified, as a child and a teenager and would have been happier had I been able to sleep with somebody else in the room, even if I was on the floor! My only child used to get up and come in with us for years, for the same reason. Plenty of kids are like this and a big sister is a comfort. Presumably he has his own room to keep all his things in, etc, it's just the going to sleep which is a problem.

Your ex is over reacting to something which is actually quite common though not always admitted (for fear of reactions like your ex has displayed).

He is not very young, he is 12 years old?

Namechanger2n2 · 10/04/2023 02:35

I actually agree with xdh that it isn't appropriate. dd may now be used to it, but she is not responsible for making her autistic brother feel safe at night. She is entitled to her own space. What happens when she grows up and leaves. If he sleeps with op then that's her choice as a dm but dd should be weaned off this habit imho.

Swipe left for the next trending thread