Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want to use this name for DC2

143 replies

Ohmy88 · 09/04/2023 21:55

5 months pregnant with DC2. We know we’re having a girl & have a few names we really love. I am really set on a name I’d like to us as a middle name. DH loves it too and it goes really well with the various first names we like. It is also the name of my DH DSM who sadly passed away a few years back & who we absolutely adored.

We know FIL would be thrilled if we used the name, but my DH is (I think understandably) worried that it would upset his DM.

I’ve suggested we speak to MIL, even ask her permission, so we can rule it out/in once & for all. I can’t stop thinking about the name now we’ve discussed it! DH thinks even the conversation might upset her and that she might not even be honest about how she feels about us using it. They (MIL & FIL) did have a fairly acrimonious split - but over 30 years ago & absolutely nothing to do with DH’s wonderful DSM.

So question is, WIBU to ask MIL her thoughts on us using the name? Should I just put it to bed to keep the peace but knowing I’ll never get give our DD the middle name we really want & love?

OP posts:
Ohmy88 · 09/04/2023 23:11

MysteryBelle · 09/04/2023 23:05

No, this way you can enjoy putting it out there on an anonymous forum beforehand because you can’t in real life, you’d be known to all as insensitive and cruel. Especially as it seems dm is a lovely person. It would hurt her and you know it.

@MysteryBelle people’s minds actually work this way! 🤣

OP posts:
MysteryBelle · 09/04/2023 23:05

Ohmy88 · 09/04/2023 22:59

Wow @MysteryBelle you’re a delight. If that were true I wouldn’t be here on this thread would I. I would use the name & take pleasure in announcing it when DC2 arrived. That is absolutely not me.

We love a name, it so happens to be that of my DH dead DSM. I’m very aware & sensitive, hence being here with the dilemma.

MIL thought a lot of DH DSM & was very sad when she passed. DH & I are genuinely unsure how she’d feel about the fact that a name we love also belonged to his DSM.

No, this way you can enjoy putting it out there on an anonymous forum beforehand because you can’t in real life, you’d be known to all as insensitive and cruel. Especially as it seems dm is a lovely person. It would hurt her and you know it.

Minime88888888 · 09/04/2023 23:04

Because her daughter in law would be naming her granddaughter after her son's step mother/her husband's second wife.......not nice. In fact bloody terrible. An embarrassment that would live on and on. Cringe.

whynotwhatknot · 09/04/2023 23:02

maybe read the other thread about someone naming a baby after a dead relative-not exactly the same situ but still can be very hurtful

FirstnameSuesecondnamePerb · 09/04/2023 23:00

I think that it would be hurtful just asking tbh. Pick another name.

Mummynew08 · 09/04/2023 23:00

Ps my nanny had a great name. Would have been a delightful baby name.

Just. No.

Mummynew08 · 09/04/2023 22:59

Yabu - the fact that smil wasn't the ow, and mil happily remarried, is irrelevant and missing the point.

The point is that when they broke up, her son spent some (half?) his time being brought up by another, genetically unrelated woman. I don't think I would ever really get over that myself. The only way I could get over that is if I could convince myself that I was still always no1 mother figure.

Analogy: when I was little my single mum had to work long hours and I had a nanny. I remember my mum telling me much later, as a grown up, that she was terrified at the time that I'd love the nanny more as I spent so long with her. (I didn't love the nanny more, although i did bond with her and she was great). Imagine if I later named my daughter after the nanny.

Gosh, have some empathy, honestly

Ohmy88 · 09/04/2023 22:59

Wow @MysteryBelle you’re a delight. If that were true I wouldn’t be here on this thread would I. I would use the name & take pleasure in announcing it when DC2 arrived. That is absolutely not me.

We love a name, it so happens to be that of my DH dead DSM. I’m very aware & sensitive, hence being here with the dilemma.

MIL thought a lot of DH DSM & was very sad when she passed. DH & I are genuinely unsure how she’d feel about the fact that a name we love also belonged to his DSM.

OP posts:
Sugarfree23 · 09/04/2023 22:59

Op would your own mum not be hurt that the child is called after step-mum rather than her or the other grandma?

I really think it's like throwing a match to see what happens.
DH needs to grow a pair and stop you hurting his poor mum.

Lottieoxo · 09/04/2023 22:58

I dont see anything wrong with it. Just like if it was your MILs new husbands name being used. It's your choice what you name your baby no one else's. MIL should be able to respect and understand that DH was close to his Step Mum, and it's honouring someone who is no longer here. I dont see any issue at all with it.

UsingChangeofName · 09/04/2023 22:57

I wouldn't ask her.

I think, if you love the name itself, then use it.
As @Luredbyapomegranate said, if you feel she is a bit unhappy about it, then you can explain you just really like the name and it is nothing to do with your dh' dsm.
However if you are making a thing about it being a tribute to her, then I don't think you should use it. It is insensitive.

But, decide between you and dh, don't start asking people for opinions before the baby is here. Particularly if there is the possibility his dm might say one thing to keep the peace, but really be thinking another. At least if it is 'fait accompli' she won't be thinking "should I have said?" all the time.

MysteryBelle · 09/04/2023 22:49

‘Hey dear mother, we want to name your grandchild not after you, dh’s mother, but after stepmother, how do you feel about that? Don’t you think that’s lovely of us?’ (😎😏😂😁)

You must despise her. I bet you’re looking forward to seeing her face when you tell her. Unless she did something horrible to you, of course she’d be upset if conversation is even broached and of course you shouldn’t do it. No self awareness whatsoever. Bizarre.

quaverface · 09/04/2023 22:48

Limetart · 09/04/2023 22:24

My dd and dsil gave dgc middle name after dsil’s father. Dh and I not the slightest bit bothered.
Parents name their dc and it’s absolutely nothing to do with anyone else!

That's not the same.

dutysuite · 09/04/2023 22:46

I couldn’t do that to my mum, I know she’d be hurt but would hide it.

ParistoMilan · 09/04/2023 22:44

Use it. Speak to his mum to prepare her and just check there is nothing unknown you don't know. It sounds like this woman would have been a grandparent to your child and sadly won't be. I understand the hurt to your mum but not when it isn't someone who is no longer here. Step mum gets the name because that's all she can possibly have. Mum gets everything else.

I'm a mum and step child. I'd name after my step parents in this situation and would think my parents selfish and awful if that was an issue.

You could always go with more than 1 middle name?

Dragonsandcats · 09/04/2023 22:42

I think it would be hurtful to do this, even if you ask her what she thinks it’s putting her in a difficult position.

Luredbyapomegranate · 09/04/2023 22:40

I think as a middle name it’s fine, but I think you need to say ‘just so you know, although we were really fond of X it’s not after her, we just love the name’ to both your mum and dad.

pizzaHeart · 09/04/2023 22:40

Do you like the name or do you want to honour SMIL?
if you like the name just use it because you like it but don’t say then that it’s special for you because of SMIL.
If you want to honour SMIL it’s another story. Was she playing a particular part in your life for some reason?

MysteryBelle · 09/04/2023 22:40

How cruel to do this. Wow.

Sugarfree23 · 09/04/2023 22:39

Op don't even go there.
MIL is likely to be polite and say the right thing - that's lovely - but inwardly be cut to ribbons.

Pick a different name, why risk a shed load of bad feeling and hurt on a middle name that's likely only to be heard about 3 times ever, baby's name, christening & wedding!

MysteryBelle · 09/04/2023 22:38

You want to name your child after your husband’s stepmother and he is trying to tell you that even broaching the possibility to his mother would of course upset her.

But, by all means do it if you despise your husband’s mother and want to hurt her by naming your child, her grandchild, after a woman who later married her ex husband and is not your husband’s mother, she is. And have relationship with her grandchild calling her the stepmother’s name forevermore.

Out of all the names in the world, you say you have to use that one. I think there is a backstory. Personally I think it’s vicious to do this.

ChocChipHandbag · 09/04/2023 22:37

Thinking it through OP, I guess it is fairly common for a child to be named to honour one grandparent, excluding the others. Often subsequent children get the other names.

My son is middle named after my father, who died before he was born. FIL is still alive, so he had no issue with the other dead granddad being honoured in that way. Had both granddads been dead, or both alive, I guess we'd maybe not have used either name.

If you think of DSMIL as an additional grandparent who has sadly passed away, versus the other who gets to meet her grandchild, it makes more sense. But your DH has a gut feeling that his Mum would be upset. How did MIL get on with SMIL? Did MIL go to the funeral? Was she sad about her death?

Mamamia7962 · 09/04/2023 22:35

I can't see the problem if you're using it as a middle name. I have nieces and nephews as well as great nieces and nephews and can't remember their middle names.

thegrain · 09/04/2023 22:34

Unicorn2022 · 09/04/2023 22:30

Would you really be happy with your son naming your precious granddaughter after his dad's second wife rather than after you, his actual mother? All of your friends and family thinking that the step mum was more loved by your son than you are? Being too embarrassed and upset to tell people the name? Feeling second best?

OP I can't believe you are even considering putting her in the awful position of asking her permission about this! You'll be on here next year moaning that she's not taking much interest in the new baby.

Why would anyone think that? Instead they'd be like aw that's nice she must have been a really nice stepmum. I think it's a bit off if this lady has treated him like her own to then go oh but it can't work both ways you can't admit you loved her back.

worryingalot · 09/04/2023 22:33

If you have to use it I’d use it as a middle name (I’m known by my middle name so there is that option)
but it doesn’t sound ideal if it will upset his mum