Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To suggest Harry potter is a rip off of star wars?

65 replies

Summerishere123 · 09/04/2023 21:26

NOT MY SUGGESTION!

DH has suggested it based on some random youtube video.
He hasn't watched either series. I have watched all harry potter and 10 minutes of star wars.

Any thoughts?

OP posts:
CampervanKween · 09/04/2023 21:38

donquixotedelamancha · 09/04/2023 21:37

He's got a point, what with Harry being Voldemort's son, Hermione being his sister, Dumbledore dying in the first book then ghost-Dumbledore sending Harry off to train with his old master, Ron being a loveable rogue smuggler, R2D2 gets his freedom by being given a sock and....oh wait, no it's total bollocks

😆😅😁

donquixotedelamancha · 09/04/2023 21:37

He's got a point, what with Harry being Voldemort's son, Hermione being his sister, Dumbledore dying in the first book then ghost-Dumbledore sending Harry off to train with his old master, Ron being a loveable rogue smuggler, R2D2 gets his freedom by being given a sock and....oh wait, no it's total bollocks

CampervanKween · 09/04/2023 21:37

It's not a big part of the story though, they're not cruel to him, his dad is alive and in fact is the baddie, he has a twin sister who he is reunited with, she lives.

Wotwotwotwotwot · 09/04/2023 21:36

CampervanKween · 09/04/2023 21:30

No that's just silly talk. Can't see it has anything in common with Star Wars.

Orphan lives with his uncle and aunt but is destined to take on a great foe aided and abetted by some trusty sidekicks under the guidance of a wise mentor. No I can't see any similarities myself

Icedlatteplease · 09/04/2023 21:35

Tbh I love JK Rowling but bless her, Harry Potter ripped off so many different franchises (worst witch I think you can almost compare some classroom scenes like for like) I wouldn't be at all surprised if star wars was in there.

But yes it is also a fairly standard Fantasy trope

TheYearOfSmallThings · 09/04/2023 21:33

An 11 year old propounded this exact same theory to me yesterday!

I didn't even know Luke Skywalker was raised by his aunt and uncle.

StrictlyAFemaleFemale · 09/04/2023 21:33

I suppose they both have a dark lord and a dark side. Good overcoming evil. But I think it's a bit of a push to say it's a rip off.

Tell him the Lion King is Hamlet and watch his mind blow.

GettingThereCharleyBear · 09/04/2023 21:32

It definitely has things in common with Star Wars, but all stories borrow off each other. It also has things in common with LOTR. It doesn’t make any less of a fabulous piece of story writing which continues to captivate millions 😍❤️.

MammaWeasel · 09/04/2023 21:31

There are only so many storylines, there are bound to be parallels

Summerishere123 · 09/04/2023 21:31

MoggyP · 09/04/2023 21:29

Is your DH some sort of god, that means whatever shite comes from his lips is an opinion worthy of debate?

What is your opinion on this?

I think he is talking bollocks...

OP posts:
Suzi888 · 09/04/2023 21:31

You can’t compare Harry Rotter to Star Wars! YABU without the YouTube link.

Luckydog7 · 09/04/2023 21:31

They are both based on a very old classic story structure/trope ' the heros journey' so no.

7Worfs · 09/04/2023 21:31

Harry Potter is somewhat derivative like all fantasy really, but it had themes and characters that translated extremely well into films.

There are common themes with SW - an orphan raised by relatives, an inherited power etc but that’s most fantasy books/films.

CampervanKween · 09/04/2023 21:30

No that's just silly talk. Can't see it has anything in common with Star Wars.

MoggyP · 09/04/2023 21:29

Is your DH some sort of god, that means whatever shite comes from his lips is an opinion worthy of debate?

What is your opinion on this?