Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To suggest Harry potter is a rip off of star wars?

65 replies

Summerishere123 · 09/04/2023 21:26

NOT MY SUGGESTION!

DH has suggested it based on some random youtube video.
He hasn't watched either series. I have watched all harry potter and 10 minutes of star wars.

Any thoughts?

OP posts:
Deadringer · 09/04/2023 23:40

I lot of Disney movies, Roald Dahl stories and even books by Charles Dickens have a similar set up; 'good' orphan overcomes adversity and triumphs over evil. A person growing up in a nuclear family is likely to grow up happy and well and without any sort of hazardous life journey. Who wants to read/write about that?

merryhouse · 09/04/2023 23:32

"Prior art, DH, prior art"

Crinkle77 · 09/04/2023 23:19

Have to admit I've not read Harry Potter but the premise of the first book sounded very similar to The Worst Witch. What with both books being set in witch/wizard school and learning to ride broomsticks and cast spells.

ManchesterGirl2 · 09/04/2023 23:05

MinnieEgg · 09/04/2023 22:56

Why would you want to debate something that you know absolutely nothing about whatsoever? Grin How can that be interesting?

Does anyone have any restaurant recommendations for Krakow? I've never been and I'm never going.

You should go MinnieEgg, it's a cool city. The perogi is amazing.

Notellinganyone · 09/04/2023 22:56

Both of them, in common with many other films and novels, rely on some pretty basic tropes. Good v Evil, finding one’s true identity etc. That’s pretty broad though and the specifics are very different.

MinnieEgg · 09/04/2023 22:56

Why would you want to debate something that you know absolutely nothing about whatsoever? Grin How can that be interesting?

Does anyone have any restaurant recommendations for Krakow? I've never been and I'm never going.

GettingThereCharleyBear · 09/04/2023 22:56

@DannyZukosSmile really?? Did you read the thread?

DannyZukosSmile · 09/04/2023 22:53

Daftest thing I have ever heard. Confused

JFDIYOLO · 09/04/2023 22:50

George Lucas was a great admirer of Joseph Campbell's Hero with a Thousand Faces which analyses the hero's journey concept. You'll find the same story in the Lord of the Rings, Aquaman, His Dark Materials, you name it. The scene in HDM where Lyra first meets Lee and Iorek is basically Luke meeting Han and Chewie in Mos Isley. Luke and Ben is basically Wart and Merlin in The Sword in the Stone. This stuff repeats and repeats.
<a class="break-all" href="https://www.starwars.com/news/mythic-discovery-within-the-inner-reaches-of-outer-space-joseph-campbell-meets-george-lucas-part-iwww.starwars.com/news/mythic-discovery-within-the-inner-reaches-of-outer-space-joseph-campbell-meets-george-lucas-part-iwww.starwars.com/news/mythic-discovery-within-the-inner-reaches-of-outer-space-joseph-campbell-meets-george-lucas-part-i" rel="nofollow" target="_blank">https://www.starwars.com/news/mythic-discovery-within-the-inner-reaches-of-outer-space-joseph-campbell-meets-george-lucas-part-iwww.starwars.com/news/mythic-discovery-within-the-inner-reaches-of-outer-space-joseph-campbell-meets-george-lucas-part-iwww.starwars.com/news/mythic-discovery-within-the-inner-reaches-of-outer-space-joseph-campbell-meets-george-lucas-part-i

PuppyMonkey · 09/04/2023 22:47

YABU to have watched 10 whole minutes of Star Wars. More than I could manage.Grin

Cinpple · 09/04/2023 22:43

They both share some common tropes but I don't think HP is derivative of SW in particular.

OMG12 · 09/04/2023 22:38

Both are just an iteration of one of the oldest story arch’s -the hero’s journey

Itstarts · 09/04/2023 22:24

T4W - there are only 6(?) story structures.

NumberTheory · 09/04/2023 22:21

Most books (and pretty much all films) are derivative, Star Wars certainly was. Harry Potter too. Even the mainstays of some religions are pulled from others.

There’s frequently a push to discredit popular works just because they’re popular and, of course, there’s the whole attempt by a few very loud trans activists to pull her down for her sex matters views. But Rowling’s books were good storytelling. And they still are.

kittenkipping · 09/04/2023 22:11

Well there's nothing new under the Sun there? As other have said if hp rips off Star Wars, that rips of the chronicles of narnia and lord of the rings. Avatar rips off fern gully. The lion king rips off hamlet. Shakespeare rips off cinthio with Othello. On and on it goes.

ElleMD80 · 09/04/2023 21:57

A chosen one, a villain, a ‘princess’, a rogue, a wise man. It’s hardly unique to either HP or SW. That is not a rip-off, it’s a trope. And if he has not seen any of it, or read any of it, he gets no opinion.

Heroicallyfound · 09/04/2023 21:51

Look up The Seven Basic Plots by Christopher Booker.

Also look up Carl Jung’s archetypes - the orphan one particularly. That’s the crux of it all really! It’s not that the stories are a rip off of each other but that we all have these archetypes jostling in us, some more integrated than others, and stories are culture’s way of making sense of them.

James Bond is arguably the same story too.

https://www.twinkl.co.uk/teaching-wiki/hero-story

https://www.tedxmilehigh.com/five-examples-heros-journey/

https://www.twinkl.co.uk/teaching-wiki/hero-story

GettingThereCharleyBear · 09/04/2023 21:51

@donquixotedelamancha there are lots of crossovers between LOTR, SW & HP. Not bollocks at all. Not a surprise either. Widely commented on.

donquixotedelamancha · 09/04/2023 21:49

ForestofD · 09/04/2023 21:40

In that case, you could put forward a argument that SW was ripped off from Lord of the Rings or the Narnia Chronicles.

This is true. Rescued by beavers/ewoks/elves; given gifts by Father Christmas/Leia/Galadriel; Yoda, Elrond and Aslan are basically the same character and, of course, Sauron is Peter's father.....ah wait, it's bollocks again isn't it?

SherbertDabs · 09/04/2023 21:44

*does he think wands ..

SherbertDabs · 09/04/2023 21:43

He’s not seen either? Does the think he ands are lightsabers? Tell him to watch both then start a conversation about it.

ForestofD · 09/04/2023 21:40

In that case, you could put forward a argument that SW was ripped off from Lord of the Rings or the Narnia Chronicles.

CampervanKween · 09/04/2023 21:40

Metaphor for the journey of life really

Broadbeachshallow · 09/04/2023 21:38

Both are classic quest structures. Three buddies on a journey/quest/adventure. Discovering a special power (magic, The Force, the power of self-belief, courage, whatever). A lot of stories follow this same broad plot.