Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To suggest Harry potter is a rip off of star wars?

65 replies

Summerishere123 · 09/04/2023 21:26

NOT MY SUGGESTION!

DH has suggested it based on some random youtube video.
He hasn't watched either series. I have watched all harry potter and 10 minutes of star wars.

Any thoughts?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Maray1967 · 10/04/2023 11:45

TheYearOfSmallThings · 09/04/2023 21:33

An 11 year old propounded this exact same theory to me yesterday!

I didn't even know Luke Skywalker was raised by his aunt and uncle.

Yes but the skywalker aunt and uncle were generally pleasant? Hardly the same as the potter relatives.

GasPanic · 10/04/2023 11:21

Yeah but who is R2D2 then.

Twinsforthewin · 10/04/2023 11:10

Shit guys wait til you hear about the Bible.. or the Iliad. Or the Tale of Genji (sp?) Or the Labours of Hercules. Or anything by Diana Wynne Jones.

Check out the Three Musketeers as well 😉 (swords not magic but really good)

😂😂😂😂

AllOfThemWitches · 10/04/2023 10:42

Ifailed · 10/04/2023 10:35

They are both children's entertainment that gets taken way too seriously by some adults.

I'd rather be friends with someone who took Harry Potter too seriously than with someone who took football (for example) too seriously.

stargirl1701 · 10/04/2023 10:40

No. Harry Potter is a mash up of The Dark is Rising and The Worst Witch.

Ifailed · 10/04/2023 10:35

They are both children's entertainment that gets taken way too seriously by some adults.

MrsWembly · 10/04/2023 10:28

Another who has noted the similarities with The Worst Witch. I hadn’t heard of it until watching it on Netflix with the kids (and we subsequently read the books), and was surprised by how heavily HP borrowed from it.

Off topic, but I was similarly surprised (shocked) by how much of The Casual Vacancy had been borrowed from South Riding.

KettrickenSmiled · 10/04/2023 10:27

MinnieEgg · 09/04/2023 22:56

Why would you want to debate something that you know absolutely nothing about whatsoever? Grin How can that be interesting?

Does anyone have any restaurant recommendations for Krakow? I've never been and I'm never going.

😂😂😂
https://www.tripadvisor.co.uk/Restaurant_Review-g274772-d10371753-Reviews-Garden_Restaurant-Krakow_Lesser_Poland_Province_Southern_Poland.html

After you haven't been, be sure to have strong opinions about the food you didn't eat Minnie.

Usernameisunavailable · 10/04/2023 10:24

Yes, he’s talking bollocks. Make him watch both and then maybe his opinion will be worth hearing.

thecatsthecats · 10/04/2023 10:19

Apart from anything else, JKR just really isn't a sci-fi/fantasy person. She's openly said that she's not into fantasy.

She's a mystery and adventure writer who just happened to have an idea based in a wizarding school.

My brother has written a story about a boy wizard at a boarding school. He pre-empts the "HP rip off" jokes by getting in there first. My own fantasy novel was influenced and inspired by Brexit, but also my history degree. But it's not an allegory or a retelling. It looks at populism, nationalism, trade - but centres on the personal relationships. It even starts with a bloody pandemic, and the debt ramifications of that - written in 2016.

Shakespeare wrote this in 1605:

"Love cools, friendship falls off, brothers divide. In cities, mutinies; in countries, discord; in palaces, treason; and the bond cracked twixt father and son."

It's practically my synopsis!

It really is the shallow end of the pond to consider things as "rip offs". There's nothing new under the sun.

Legocurlers · 10/04/2023 10:17

Star Wars is a rip off of Dune

Harry Potter is a rip off of the worst witch.

Everything borrows heavily from what went before. Nothing is new.

110APiccadilly · 10/04/2023 10:17

TheMarzipanDildo · 10/04/2023 10:11

I think its quite biblical. Harry dies to save everyone and then comes back to life!

Also, the fantasy genre is invariably and purposefully derivative. Originally from a combination of the Bible and Ancient Greek myths I think, and I'm of the belief that Dante was the first fantasy author (whether he knew it or not).

Did you too suffer through, "Finding God in Harry Potter" at some point as a child?!

determinedtomakethiswork · 10/04/2023 10:12

It's nothing like Star Wars, but it's a lot like Enid Blyton.

TheMarzipanDildo · 10/04/2023 10:11

I think its quite biblical. Harry dies to save everyone and then comes back to life!

Also, the fantasy genre is invariably and purposefully derivative. Originally from a combination of the Bible and Ancient Greek myths I think, and I'm of the belief that Dante was the first fantasy author (whether he knew it or not).

110APiccadilly · 10/04/2023 10:10

They both use a lot of classic tropes (orphaned child hero, quest, hero learns to use a magical power, plucky band of rebels, evil vs good, dark overlord, older wiser mentor who dies, and I'm sure lots of others). But those are tropes for a reason. I mean, most if not all of them also apply to say, Spiderman, or Lord of the Rings, or even the story of Perseus.

StagsLeap · 10/04/2023 10:07

MinnieEgg · 09/04/2023 22:56

Why would you want to debate something that you know absolutely nothing about whatsoever? Grin How can that be interesting?

Does anyone have any restaurant recommendations for Krakow? I've never been and I'm never going.

Well, I’m more interested in why the OP feels that a throwaway theory on something her DH knows nothing about is worth being posted on the internet and other peoples’ thoughts invited on it. Did she think we were all going to cry ‘GENIUS!’ and suggest he starts a YouTube channel called ‘Stuff I’ve never seen but will propound about’?

Kanaloa · 10/04/2023 10:04

They have some similarities, but you could say that about literally any two stories really. AIBU to say Harry Potter is basically a rip off of Buffy because they’re both about a chosen one with two school friends who are a boy and a girl, guided by a mentor, who then follow a prophecy to fight a creepy looking white skinned dude in a black robe?

Almost anything will have similarities if you set it out like that. It doesn’t make the one that came out second a ‘rip off.’

AllOfThemWitches · 10/04/2023 10:04

Isn't most fantasy a rip off of mythology

MoggyMittens23 · 10/04/2023 10:02

MammaWeasel · 09/04/2023 21:31

There are only so many storylines, there are bound to be parallels

Exactly

QuillBill · 10/04/2023 10:01

Crinkle77 · 09/04/2023 23:19

Have to admit I've not read Harry Potter but the premise of the first book sounded very similar to The Worst Witch. What with both books being set in witch/wizard school and learning to ride broomsticks and cast spells.

I can't tell if you are taking the piss or not!

And why are people discussing and having opinions in things they haven't watched or read? Confused

YellowGreenBlue · 10/04/2023 09:57

donquixotedelamancha · 09/04/2023 21:37

He's got a point, what with Harry being Voldemort's son, Hermione being his sister, Dumbledore dying in the first book then ghost-Dumbledore sending Harry off to train with his old master, Ron being a loveable rogue smuggler, R2D2 gets his freedom by being given a sock and....oh wait, no it's total bollocks

Grin Grin Grin

ErrolTheDragon · 10/04/2023 09:54

Wtf would anyone bother watching, let alone discussing, a YouTube video of two series they'd never watched? Maybe the OP and her DH are both very bored and could do with some book or film recommendations?

DisquietintheRanks · 10/04/2023 09:44

MoggyP · 09/04/2023 21:29

Is your DH some sort of god, that means whatever shite comes from his lips is an opinion worthy of debate?

What is your opinion on this?

Amen

ErrolTheDragon · 10/04/2023 09:39

Someone upthread mentioned Narnia - thats entirely deliberately a rip off of the Christian story, with a side-helping of evacuated kids and talking animals.

theWarOnPeace · 09/04/2023 23:42

Dying at “R2D2 is given a sock”

The tropes definitely converge at points, but orphan and good vs evil, overcoming seemingly insurmountable odds with the help of a band of misfit friends, hero’s journey, touch of romance are always recycled across literature.

Even Jane Eyre is an orphan and has a fire and ice contrast running through it, nasty aunt and bastard cousins etc. Game of Thrones. On and on. We were listening to music today and were trying to guess the song from the first few chords - we kept getting them wrong because there’s apparently nothing new under the sun.

Swipe left for the next trending thread