Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think it will always be hard to take disabled daughter anywhere ( bus spaces )

161 replies

Itsamission25 · 09/04/2023 20:36

I think I just need to vent tbh ! Today we took a 9 year old and a toddler on a day out to a well known theme park. 9 year old is sick/ disabled and had her wheelchair. The way from our house is a bus / coach service. We paid for our tickets etc
they are “ disabled friendly and adapted ) with the logo proudly on the front of the bus.
we went to the bus and there was a load of us including pushchairs waiting. I folded toddlers stroller down ready whilst I was doing this the 2 other pushchairs got on but didn’t fold down. They went to the wheelchair space, this was very clearly marked and had s sign saying wheelchairs take priority if needed please fold pushchair.
we then got in and asked for them to fold the pushchair and asked the bus driver for the space, one was a sleeping toddler so parent refused because he was sleeping, the second refused because she has no one to help fold her stroller and bus driver said he agreed with them. We ended up being left on the side watching the bus go with the next one not for another 2 hours.
we ended up paying over 100.00 for a taxi so a day trip cost us way more than it should. Should I just accept that this will always be the case and realise that the system doesn’t work for her :(

OP posts:
itsgettingweird · 10/04/2023 06:21

Itsamission25 · 09/04/2023 21:15

@itsgettingweird its really not that simple.

It shouldn't be that hard.

I know it can be but the system is shocking.

My sons been on disability benefits for 10 years now.

Simonjt · 10/04/2023 06:10

Oneiros · 10/04/2023 05:46

Obviously legally the people should have moved and OP's child bad the right to that space on the bus. It's shocking people behaved like that and that the bus driver didn't sort it out.

But of course motability cars are free. You can choose a more expensive one and pay a top up but some cars on the scheme are completely free, paid for entirely from the mobility part of the benefit (and that covers the lease of the car itself, no road tax, insurance and maintenance and repairs covered, no need for MOTs) so that there is no cost to the user at all other than putting the petrol for their journeys in it. That's the whole point of them. Hope OP wins her tribunal and can get one because she absolutely should have one in this situation,

Do you think anything paid for with DLA/PIPis free, or just motability cars, £369.60 isn’t my definition of free. Also, good luck finding a motability car that can take a ramp and chair that doesn’t have a substantial deposit.

Oneiros · 10/04/2023 05:46

BakedTattie · 09/04/2023 21:02

It doesn’t matter if the op’s daughter is or isn’t entitled to high rate DLA (pip etc) motability cars aren’t free! The op may not have the means to afford a motability car.

what the ops daughter IS entitled to, is the space on the bus. That she should have been given.

Obviously legally the people should have moved and OP's child bad the right to that space on the bus. It's shocking people behaved like that and that the bus driver didn't sort it out.

But of course motability cars are free. You can choose a more expensive one and pay a top up but some cars on the scheme are completely free, paid for entirely from the mobility part of the benefit (and that covers the lease of the car itself, no road tax, insurance and maintenance and repairs covered, no need for MOTs) so that there is no cost to the user at all other than putting the petrol for their journeys in it. That's the whole point of them. Hope OP wins her tribunal and can get one because she absolutely should have one in this situation,

Danikm151 · 10/04/2023 05:30

You need to complain to the provider of the bus service.
show them a receipt for your taxi and ask for reimbursement as their driver went against their own policies.

Sirzy · 10/04/2023 05:05

thankfully I rarely need to use a bus with ds but when I do there often seems to be a selfish parent using the space And not wanting to move.

the best driver was the one who turned off his engine and said “well we won’t be going anywhere until the wheelchair is safely in the wheelchair space” strangely the parent was soon able to collapse their buggy then!

nettie434 · 10/04/2023 04:53

BakedTattie · 09/04/2023 21:02

It doesn’t matter if the op’s daughter is or isn’t entitled to high rate DLA (pip etc) motability cars aren’t free! The op may not have the means to afford a motability car.

what the ops daughter IS entitled to, is the space on the bus. That she should have been given.

I completely agree with BakedTattie that it should be standard for someone in a wheelchair to travel on the bus.

The supreme court judgement in favour of Doug Paulley ruled that bus companies have to do more to encourage non disabled passengers to move from the wheelchair area - eg to refuse to move until a pushchair or buggy is folded.

https://www.equalityhumanrights.com/en/legal-casework/paulley-v-firstgroup-plc

I have noticed that drivers on Transport for London services are good about ensuring wheelchair users take priority. I hope you will write to the bus company complaining about your experience, itsamission25 and asking for a refund. It really reflects badly on the parent involved that they were so unreasonable when there was such a gap between services.

Paulley v FirstGroup PLC | Equality and Human Rights Commission

https://www.equalityhumanrights.com/en/legal-casework/paulley-v-firstgroup-plc

PuttingDownRoots · 10/04/2023 02:44

What sort of parent looks at a disabled child, waiting for a 2hrly bus service, and thinks .. can't be bothered?

Forgooodnesssakenow · 10/04/2023 02:27

I disagree with those saying buggies should all be folded etc, it would make it very difficult for parents of multiple children to transport them and for those with older kids in mobility buggies or with kids with hidden disabilities alongside a sibling etc.

I take my youngest on buses in a buggy, she's almost 2, her brother is a bit of a flight risk and has a seizure disorder but walks and 90% of the time is fine but getting caught out that other 10% is a genuine unsafe disaster.

However, because I'm aware the space is really for wheelchairs I leave early enough that I could let a couple of buses go without being late for where we're going or that if we're on a bus and a wheelchair user needs our space I could get off and wait for the next bus. If everyone who wanted/needed to keep a child in a stroller did that we wouldn't have an issue.

In ops case, I wonder if they felt (wrongly, definitely wrongly and I'd be livid if I were you to be clear) that because the wheelchair user is a child then you could lift your child out and fold the chair just like a buggy user could? I wonder if they'd have been more helpful or respectful with an adult wheelchair user 🤔 shit regardless to be honest and I'm surry you'd this experience.

abmac95 · 10/04/2023 02:14

Next time get your phone out and film the whole thing. People refusing to move, driver refusing to help. Its a public space you are entitled to record it. People will change their tune when they wonder what you intend to do with the recording.

AnorLondo · 10/04/2023 02:13

rwalker · 10/04/2023 00:29

No they cannot physically remove them if they refuse
tbh working with the general public knowing how unpredictable and aggressive they can be I personally would not put myself in that position open to all sorts of abuse and allegations
granted they could refuse to move the bus and ring police but who helps them in the time it takes the police to turn up
every year hundreds if not thousands of public service workers are attacked by the general public
I worked in retail I’ve been threatened ,and spat at

It sounds like he didn't even ask them though.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 10/04/2023 02:05

onepieceoflollipop · 09/04/2023 20:42

I almost think now that all parents should be made to fold the buggies and the wheelchair space should be ring fenced just for wheelchair users. It would mean that at times it is empty but at least it would be slightly fairer.
that way, the only reason a wheelchair user couldn’t access it would be if there was already a wheelchair on board…

I agree.

rwalker · 10/04/2023 00:29

GrumpyPanda · 09/04/2023 21:01

Of course the bus drivers have the power to enforce, they just cba. They can order the space freed and not move on until that happens/worst case, call police.

OP i just saw a Twitter thread by a wheelchair user on that very topic. She refused to move out of the door and didn't let them depart until she was accommodated. Sadly you'll have to be a great deal.more assertive in dealing with entitled assholes. in the meantime, definitely go after the bus company for a reimbursement- escalate to local paper/MP/whatever if necessary.

No they cannot physically remove them if they refuse
tbh working with the general public knowing how unpredictable and aggressive they can be I personally would not put myself in that position open to all sorts of abuse and allegations
granted they could refuse to move the bus and ring police but who helps them in the time it takes the police to turn up
every year hundreds if not thousands of public service workers are attacked by the general public
I worked in retail I’ve been threatened ,and spat at

DdraigGoch · 10/04/2023 00:02

Did you get a receipt from the taxi firm? Go all-in on this OP - complaints direct to the company, followed up by councillors, you MP and the press. Might be worth threatening them with a lawyer too if you can.

What a couple of selfish parents and a lazy/cowardly driver.

Spikeyball · 09/04/2023 23:29

'get a letter from your doctor confirming that your daughter has a prescribed wheelchair from the enablement center
That is literally all your doctor needs to write
xxx was prescribed a wheelchair from the mobility center on xxx date due to her lack of mobility .'

That isn't enough. If someone can walk short distances they may have been given a wheelchair but may not meet the criteria for high rate mobility.

Sailingaround · 09/04/2023 23:18

Disgusting behaviour from those two parents. A clear example of ableism. They basically thought their child was more important and the driver agreed.

Please report the bus driver to the company quoting the relevant legislation and demand reimbursement. Take it to the local Mp if you need to.

EmmatheStageRat · 09/04/2023 23:12

Eleganz · 09/04/2023 22:53

Definitely a formal complaint needed. It is a depressingly frequent occurrence that I hear or read of wheelchair uses being discriminated against by passengers and drivers on buses. Really not on at all and obviously illegal.

I also understand that it is very hard to stand your ground in such circumstances when faced with utterly shitty behaviour and the one person in authority (the bus driver) being a coward. Just makes it all the worse really.

It’s non-stop full-on being the parent of disabled children, I know as I have two. I am a massive introvert so it literally pains me to have to advocate so publicly for my children. My elder DD is blind and has a long white cane and the number of times ignorant people jump over her cane or cut her up short, you wouldn’t believe. I’m tired of battling for every little bit of help for my children. I would simply like to get on a bus or a train and be confident that the spaces designated for disabled people are actually available for disabled people. I don’t want to have a confrontation every time we go out in public, this is not what the Equality Act is about.

Itsamission25 · 09/04/2023 23:11

About the having a drs letter saying she has a prescribed wheelchair, it does not go by that at all that would auto get you low rate not high rate.
because she “ can walk “ but is unwell so it flactuates and can’t walk far but she can at times walk the required 50 meters they like to be annoying about it. We will win at tribunal which we are waiting for but it takes over a year to get to tribunal.

OP posts:
Monstermoomoo · 09/04/2023 23:11

Complain and send the bus company your taxi receipt together with your bank details for reimbursement for their blatant discrimination. Worth a try anyway.

I had to once hand over my baby to a stranger on the bus so I could fold his pram up to make space for a wheelchair. It was incredibly annoying. I've also been made to get off a bus (after paying, had already been on a few stops) to make space for a wheelchair as there wasn't enough space for both of us. Also incredibly annoying. Still the right thing to do! As a parent I have a choice in taking either a pram/buggy or a baby carrier. Wheelchair users don't have the same choice.

Danielle9891 · 09/04/2023 23:10

That's horrible. I'd name and shame the bus company on their Facebook and Twitter as well as any local Facebook groups you are on. It's probably the only way they will take your complaint seriously. I've got a toddler but will always fold the pram if a wheelchair needs the space, I thought this was company policy.
The bus company should pay the taxi fare as well.

Nsky62 · 09/04/2023 23:07

Go to the press, name and shame county and bus company

violetrain1 · 09/04/2023 22:59

Itsamission25 · 09/04/2023 20:42

@AlltheFs Unfortunately DLA high rate mobility is not that easy :(

Please try appeal.

My cousins boyfriend has a disability car and I'm not actually sure why. Something to do with his leg.
He's perfectly fucking fine. He goes jogging for Christ sake.

So this angers me that you've been refused!

ParistoMilan · 09/04/2023 22:57

That's awful. It doesn't help right now but for next time I would make sure you know the exact law that you are quoting at the bus driver, even maybe have a print out. Also, make sure, for other passengers you are very vocal that she won't fold her buggy with a 2 year old in, so your disabled 9 year old has to wait in the rain for 2 hours. Many people won't have any awareness off the full consequences of this and could assume it's a 10 min wait, if you can be as vocal and clear as possible it could help get you support.

You shouldn't have to do any of this. It's awful. People should be able to be decent human beings and help each other. In the few situations where a mum genuinely can't fold a buggy (disabled mum, disabled child, oxygen tanks, etc(there are others) that can be communicated and some solution should be found.

Eleganz · 09/04/2023 22:53

Definitely a formal complaint needed. It is a depressingly frequent occurrence that I hear or read of wheelchair uses being discriminated against by passengers and drivers on buses. Really not on at all and obviously illegal.

I also understand that it is very hard to stand your ground in such circumstances when faced with utterly shitty behaviour and the one person in authority (the bus driver) being a coward. Just makes it all the worse really.

inloveandmarried · 09/04/2023 22:44

The bus drivers actions were illegal. He doesn't get to choose which parts of the law he abides by.

This was covered well on a previous thread that might help give you the confidence to challenge him. Definitely contact the bus company and complain as his actions are not acceptable. The more people who complain the more education bus companies will provide.

Was I Unreasonable - wheelchair Space http://www.mumsnet.com/Talk/amiibeingunreasonable/4729298-was-i-unreasonable-wheelchair-space

TomeTome · 09/04/2023 22:41

AlltheFs · 09/04/2023 20:40

I think this is why most people get a car surely? I know several parents with a child
with disabilities and they all have motorbility cars (paid for).
Shouldn’t be like that no, but public transport and disabilities doesn’t mix well.

Motorbility cars aren’t “paid for” in the way this appears. Motability is a rental agreement and for a larger car that takes a wheelchair you will likely need to sign over all you mobility allowance plus put down thousands of pounds deposit. You need to provide/pay for a parking place and fuel.