Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think it will always be hard to take disabled daughter anywhere ( bus spaces )

161 replies

Itsamission25 · 09/04/2023 20:36

I think I just need to vent tbh ! Today we took a 9 year old and a toddler on a day out to a well known theme park. 9 year old is sick/ disabled and had her wheelchair. The way from our house is a bus / coach service. We paid for our tickets etc
they are “ disabled friendly and adapted ) with the logo proudly on the front of the bus.
we went to the bus and there was a load of us including pushchairs waiting. I folded toddlers stroller down ready whilst I was doing this the 2 other pushchairs got on but didn’t fold down. They went to the wheelchair space, this was very clearly marked and had s sign saying wheelchairs take priority if needed please fold pushchair.
we then got in and asked for them to fold the pushchair and asked the bus driver for the space, one was a sleeping toddler so parent refused because he was sleeping, the second refused because she has no one to help fold her stroller and bus driver said he agreed with them. We ended up being left on the side watching the bus go with the next one not for another 2 hours.
we ended up paying over 100.00 for a taxi so a day trip cost us way more than it should. Should I just accept that this will always be the case and realise that the system doesn’t work for her :(

OP posts:
Nutsabouttopic · 10/04/2023 15:04

There was a thread on this topic on here recently. A wheelchair user was being refused entry to bus because buggies had taken up wheelchair space. He quoted a law that gives wheelchair users priority. The buggies had to be folded and moved. If you can find this quote it in your email to bus company. Ask them to make all drivers aware and to put signs on bus doors stating the law. I'm so sorry that you had to deal with this

Hesma · 10/04/2023 15:00
  1. That’s awful but…
  2. why didn’t you help them fold their stroller?
I would definitely report this!
SauvignonBlanche · 10/04/2023 14:42

Sorry to hear that OP, it’s so wrong! 😡

Samcro · 10/04/2023 14:23

I think its so sad that the only answer seems to be for the op to get a car. why can't people like the non moving mother do that. the onus always seems to be that the wheelchair user needs to do something.
I don't take my dd on buses. she would be so upset if someone refused to move, the tears would be awful. (adult with cp and lds) so we have a motorbility vehicle. all adapted and costly.
the wheelchair space should only be for wheelchairs imo, the threads i have been on over the years have been countless, unlike this one, full of posters making excuses as to why they wouldn't move.

SerendipityJane · 10/04/2023 14:22

Sugarplumfairy65 · 10/04/2023 13:24

I think its time for us wheelchair users to take back our spaces! Maybe a coordinated campaign to make sure that all wheelchair spaces on public transport have a wheelchair user in them and block these selfish pram pushers from using our spaces.
And, any public transport company not complying with the law should be prosecuted.
It will probably never happen, but it's a nice thought.

In a country where accessible toilets are quietly being turning into "gender neutral" I think you need to know your place. Which is to find a queue, and get to the back of it.

ValleyClouds · 10/04/2023 14:14

Sorry I think I got confused between who said what about the cost of vehicles I think I meant to reply to @Sugarplumfairy65

Oneiros · 10/04/2023 14:13

ValleyClouds · 10/04/2023 14:11

No @Oneiros it wasn't you!

Oh ok good! Thank you!! I didn't want to upset anyone. Flowers

Oneiros · 10/04/2023 14:12

I also didn't realise it was even harder for children to qualify for it with DLA. That's so wrong. 😡

ValleyClouds · 10/04/2023 14:11

No @Oneiros it wasn't you!

ValleyClouds · 10/04/2023 14:10

Totally in the same boat @Oneiros

I qualify for the scheme and having a car would change my quality of life

I cannot afford the scheme

As to the OP please do complain to the bus provider I've had to a number of times and had positive dialogue

Oneiros · 10/04/2023 14:10

ValleyClouds · 10/04/2023 13:58

I absolutely detest the misconception that if you are disabled or have a disabled child a "free car" is just handed out like sweets.

It's ignorant to the point of offensive.

Even if you do qualify for the Motability car scheme you lose a portion of your disability payments as a contribution

Many people need this money in the pot for their monthly bills.

Disabled adults who can't drive (and are supported by multiple people that come and go due to low rates of retention in care agencies) face issues with designated drivers and insurance also and find public transport less hassle (when it works)

Then there's the adaptations

Then there's the cost of petrol

Free "paid for" car my arse.

(Sorry if I'm repeating comments by others one post made me see red, this is a bugbear for me)

I think that was aimed at my comment. Sorry if I offended you. I have a motability car myself and I do view it as "free" because other than the downpayment at the start the only cost to me is petrol. I don't have to pay insurance, maintenance, servicing, road tax, breakdown cover, it's all covered by the mobility part of my PIP. I wasn't intending to upset anybody so sorry if I phrased it wrong. And no, I agree that they most certainly are not handed out like sweets, not many people meet the criteria.

Sirzy · 10/04/2023 14:08

BunnyRabbitSandwich · 10/04/2023 13:58

You don’t have to use the wheelchair every time you go out in order to get PIP/DLA. I have epilepsy and don’t have seizures everyday yet I get higher rate mobility which I use for a motability car. You have to use very specific wording on the form but lots of people who think they can’t get it actually can.

As others have said for dla unless you qualify under the SMI rules (which are very hard to prove) then unless your a full time wheelchair user it’s very unlikely that you will get higher rate mobility. There only being the two levels for mobility doesn’t help either.

ds is a part time wheelchair user and we generally have feeding pumps etc (as well as needing to be close to the car for medical emergencies ideally) - he qualifies for a blue badge but not for HRM

WhatNoRaisins · 10/04/2023 14:07

Are the drivers worried that a person using a wheelchair is going to take longer to board and disembark, especially if they need a ramp.

I don't use a wheelchair but I remember the bus service I would take to work really, really seemed to resent having to stop to pick people up. It would often whizz straight past stops full of people clearly wanting to get on. I'm guessing drivers like that just don't give a shit.

headbangs · 10/04/2023 14:05

I'm so sorry to read what happened to you. You definitely need to complain - your local councillor, MP etc. Local media.

Reading your post made me wish I could have been driving past when it happened and been able to give you a lift.

I'm so sorry, but really, you have to complain - loudly and repeatedly.

Oneiros · 10/04/2023 14:05

I have a WAV. When I got it 4 years ago, the down payment was £500 plus I had to pay for adaptations. When my lease runs out in a years time, the down payment for the same model is £4500 plus adaptations. The minimum for any type of WAV is £3500. Because of household income (not mine) I am not entitled to any grants to help with these costs. I also have to pay Motability the full amount of my mobility element of pip.
I cannot afford to get another Motability car when this lease runs out.

It's crazy how much the downpayments have increased. So sorry to hear of your situation. It's dreadful when most people with a motability car are so reliant on them, that these costs are making the scheme inaccessible. 😔

PIP and DLA need to be at least doubled to actually meet something like the real costs of disability like they are meant to. But as a PP said, people in the UK won't push for that because our society doesn't seem to care about disabled people.

Lovemusic33 · 10/04/2023 14:04

BunnyRabbitSandwich · 10/04/2023 13:58

You don’t have to use the wheelchair every time you go out in order to get PIP/DLA. I have epilepsy and don’t have seizures everyday yet I get higher rate mobility which I use for a motability car. You have to use very specific wording on the form but lots of people who think they can’t get it actually can.

PIP works differently to DLA sadly. My dd was unable to get high rate mobility on DLA but when she turned 16 and moved over to PIP it was much easier (as it’s done by a points system not just for physical disability). It’s hard to get DLA mobility at high rate unless you’re in a wheelchair full time. Hopefully OP will manage to appeal and get higher rate for her DD.

Itsamission25 · 10/04/2023 14:02

We had a car but it was written off and I haven’t able to replace ( not a mobility rewarded one )
if tribunal which I am sure they will over turn the low rate mobility to high rate and I decided to get a mobility car I would lose over a 100 pound of our currently money plus pat a deposit.

OP posts:
SouthCountryGirl · 10/04/2023 14:01

BunnyRabbitSandwich · 10/04/2023 13:58

You don’t have to use the wheelchair every time you go out in order to get PIP/DLA. I have epilepsy and don’t have seizures everyday yet I get higher rate mobility which I use for a motability car. You have to use very specific wording on the form but lots of people who think they can’t get it actually can.

The criteria for higher DLA and PIP are different. I get higher mobility but under DLA couldn't.

BunnyRabbitSandwich · 10/04/2023 13:58

Needmorelego · 09/04/2023 20:45

@Itsamission25 please complain to the bus company. That is completely not on.
@AlltheFs my daughter uses a wheelchair sometimes but not always so we wouldn't qualify for help with a car. Not every wheelchair user does qualify.
Sorry but wheelchair trumps pushchair Every Single Time - sleeping child or not.
You can hold a sleeping toddler - you can't hold a non mobile 9 year old.

You don’t have to use the wheelchair every time you go out in order to get PIP/DLA. I have epilepsy and don’t have seizures everyday yet I get higher rate mobility which I use for a motability car. You have to use very specific wording on the form but lots of people who think they can’t get it actually can.

ValleyClouds · 10/04/2023 13:58

I absolutely detest the misconception that if you are disabled or have a disabled child a "free car" is just handed out like sweets.

It's ignorant to the point of offensive.

Even if you do qualify for the Motability car scheme you lose a portion of your disability payments as a contribution

Many people need this money in the pot for their monthly bills.

Disabled adults who can't drive (and are supported by multiple people that come and go due to low rates of retention in care agencies) face issues with designated drivers and insurance also and find public transport less hassle (when it works)

Then there's the adaptations

Then there's the cost of petrol

Free "paid for" car my arse.

(Sorry if I'm repeating comments by others one post made me see red, this is a bugbear for me)

Sugarplumfairy65 · 10/04/2023 13:39

Oneiros · 10/04/2023 12:15

Do you think anything paid for with DLA/PIPis free, or just motability cars, £369.60 isn’t my definition of free. Also, good luck finding a motability car that can take a ramp and chair that doesn’t have a substantial deposit.

Well yes, I would view that as free because the mobility part of the benefit is extra money given to cover such mobility costs either through motability or privately. But take your point re. deposits at the moment: the shortage in supply of new cars and lower value of GBP ever since the Brexit vote does mean they ask for a deposit for most now, and probably all of the bigger models. Not good when many people need one that size for a wheelchair and other equipment. 😔

But regardless it's horrendous that OP was treated like this. How can there still be bus drivers who are oblivious to the law?

I have a WAV. When I got it 4 years ago, the down payment was £500 plus I had to pay for adaptations. When my lease runs out in a years time, the down payment for the same model is £4500 plus adaptations. The minimum for any type of WAV is £3500. Because of household income (not mine) I am not entitled to any grants to help with these costs. I also have to pay Motability the full amount of my mobility element of pip.
I cannot afford to get another Motability car when this lease runs out.

Itsamission25 · 10/04/2023 13:36

@Sugarplumfairy65 I think you are right maybe we don’t cause enough drama but I think I’m going to this time. It was so unfair I was literally in tears begging saying we had no way else to get home. They did not care
today after some reflection I think it’s my duty to now fight what’s right my daughter and for others !

OP posts:
Sugarplumfairy65 · 10/04/2023 13:24

Sirzy · 10/04/2023 06:57

I agree. That space should be reserved solely for those using wheelchairs (or special needs buggies)

if parents want a dedicated space for their prams they can campaign for spaces.

I think its time for us wheelchair users to take back our spaces! Maybe a coordinated campaign to make sure that all wheelchair spaces on public transport have a wheelchair user in them and block these selfish pram pushers from using our spaces.
And, any public transport company not complying with the law should be prosecuted.
It will probably never happen, but it's a nice thought.

ThinWomansBrain · 10/04/2023 13:18

report to the transport provider - with as much detail as possible so they can identify the offending driver and address the issue.
If TFL, report to TFL as well as the individual bus company.

GizzardChops · 10/04/2023 13:17

I hope you took a video of the driver refusing to do anything and send it to his employer along with your complaint.
The mum sounds like a selfish dick but the driver should have done his job and made her move.
I'm really sorry that your day was impacted by the selfish actions of others.

Swipe left for the next trending thread