Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think it will always be hard to take disabled daughter anywhere ( bus spaces )

161 replies

Itsamission25 · 09/04/2023 20:36

I think I just need to vent tbh ! Today we took a 9 year old and a toddler on a day out to a well known theme park. 9 year old is sick/ disabled and had her wheelchair. The way from our house is a bus / coach service. We paid for our tickets etc
they are “ disabled friendly and adapted ) with the logo proudly on the front of the bus.
we went to the bus and there was a load of us including pushchairs waiting. I folded toddlers stroller down ready whilst I was doing this the 2 other pushchairs got on but didn’t fold down. They went to the wheelchair space, this was very clearly marked and had s sign saying wheelchairs take priority if needed please fold pushchair.
we then got in and asked for them to fold the pushchair and asked the bus driver for the space, one was a sleeping toddler so parent refused because he was sleeping, the second refused because she has no one to help fold her stroller and bus driver said he agreed with them. We ended up being left on the side watching the bus go with the next one not for another 2 hours.
we ended up paying over 100.00 for a taxi so a day trip cost us way more than it should. Should I just accept that this will always be the case and realise that the system doesn’t work for her :(

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TomeTome · 10/04/2023 18:22

purpledalmation · 10/04/2023 16:19

I would have stood there, not moved and asked the bus driver for his supervisors number. All the while recording for SM. Shame them all.

Very brave and courageous but not necessarily if you are actually WITH a disabled child

RettyPriddle · 10/04/2023 16:20

LookUponMyWorks · 09/04/2023 21:30

Living with/alongside disability means you constantly have to advocate for the most basic access and continually assert yourself against ignorance and/or outrage that 'they can't do that!/that's illegal' when we know they can and they do -- constantly. It is hard and exhausting and unfair, you are right.

But I strongly believe that your experiences will make you and your daughter more empathetic, more compassionate and more resilient. There is disabled joy to be found and celebrated. It shouldn't be like this but when I made a conscious effort try to focus on the positive experiences and positive moments and let the ignorance roll off my back it was easier. Good luck to you both and solidarity!

Well said. So true!

purpledalmation · 10/04/2023 16:19

I would have stood there, not moved and asked the bus driver for his supervisors number. All the while recording for SM. Shame them all.

PussBilledDuckyPlait · 10/04/2023 16:12

Nutsabouttopic · 10/04/2023 15:04

There was a thread on this topic on here recently. A wheelchair user was being refused entry to bus because buggies had taken up wheelchair space. He quoted a law that gives wheelchair users priority. The buggies had to be folded and moved. If you can find this quote it in your email to bus company. Ask them to make all drivers aware and to put signs on bus doors stating the law. I'm so sorry that you had to deal with this

Here is the thread - the law is quoted in the opening post:

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/uk/4775052-bus-driver-refused-me-boarding-in-wheelchair

Bus driver refused me boarding in wheelchair | Mumsnet

Mumsnet makes parents' lives easier by pooling knowledge, advice and support on everything from conception to childbirth, from babies to teenagers.

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/uk/4775052-bus-driver-refused-me-boarding-in-wheelchair

Hesma · 10/04/2023 16:11

@Itsamission25 that's awful! What a bitch!

SouthCountryGirl · 10/04/2023 16:10

"Wheelchair users do not choose to be differently abled."

It's disabled. Not bloody differently abled.

Oneiros · 10/04/2023 16:10

LadyGrinningSoul85 · 10/04/2023 15:24

So are pram users just meant to stay inside for the rest of our lives?
I'm not saying I agree with what happened to the op here, but these comments about barring pram users from using the spaces are almost as bad.

I suffer from social anxiety which is gradually morphing into agoraphobia and getting on a bus with my pram is one of the most terrifying aspects of me deciding to leave the house.
I spend days working myself up about it (days out are planned due to how bad my social anxiety is. I can't just go out on a whim), I spend the entire time I'm on the bus terrified that a wheelchair will get on or another pram and I'll have to awkwardly manoeuvre to give them space, I always try to sit on the opposite space where some buses in my area actually have a pram symbol painted on the floor as they aren't suitable for wheelchairs as that side has no backrest, my kids hardly go anywhere because of MY mental problems, and the comments on this post beautifully illustrate why.

I'm sick of being made to feel like a nuisance for daring to try to have a life and go out in public with my kids.

I have a double buggy, so 'just fold it' isn't always practical and I have nerve damage too so can no longer fold or unfold without a lot of help, then my pram takes up more space folded with the seats off anyway!

Maybe some of you could stop being so pigheaded and see it's not always black and white and 'selfishness'

Living inside my head with all my anxieties makes me want to die sometimes, but yes, we pram pushers should just stay in and not be such an inconvenience to others.

Anxiety is horrible. BUT you can buy a pram suitable to fold (even a double one! I used to have one). I mean this kindly but you are projecting: your worries about going out are not because disabled people may need to use the disabled space, as is their legal right.

I hope you can get the support you need to improve things and I know having two young kids plus severe anxiety is hard, I've been there. However, it does not excuse you taking up a space that disabled people need to access public transport at all and refusing to move. Can you imagine the anxiety they feel waiting for a bus and dreading seeing an obstinate person with a pram in the space they need who refuses to move, when they have literally no other option?

You do have an option: buy a sling to use when needed and a pram that folds.

Hesma · 10/04/2023 16:09

@bossonext I never said it was OPs responsibility but if their excuse was that they couldn’t fold the buggy single handedly then I would have offered to get it out of the wasy and make space for the wheelchair… kind of makes sense!

Shopper727 · 10/04/2023 16:09

Having a double buggy is a choice, as is having one that doesn’t fold easily and having to use a bus. When purchasing a double buggy perhaps think about how it’s going to fold or if there is not space what you will do. A wheelchair user does not have that CHOICE!! No one is going to stop pram users going out bUt your baby is portable and small, I used to bring the sling - baby went in sling toddler sat beside me buggy folded up simple, or you could learn to drive?
Wheelchair spaces are for wheelchairs not buggies, they are protected by law.

i think some people have no idea op, I’m sorry this happened to you, I hope you get answers from the bus company but it’s shocking that people can be so entitled and cruel sours your day out too!! Am so angry for you!!!

Simonjt · 10/04/2023 16:08

So are pram users just meant to stay inside for the rest of our lives?

We use public transport a lot, thats why we chose a pram that very easily folds, its also why we chose one thats easy to push etc, so if we’re feeling too lazy to fold it, we can just walk instead. If someone chooses a pram that doesn’t easily fold, they need to accept that when a wheelchair user is at a bus stop, they need to leave the bus and walk, wait for the next one etc. Parents actively choose to have children, they also actively choose to use a pram, they know they will face the consequences of those actions, both positive and negative. Wheelchair users do not choose to be differently abled.

ilovesooty · 10/04/2023 16:04

Rosula · 10/04/2023 16:00

So are pram users just meant to stay inside for the rest of our lives?

Self-evidently, no. Unless you intend to transport your children around by pram for the rest of your life.

Exactly. And no social anxiety, however severe it is (and of course it's distressing to experience) trumps the needs of someone in a wheelchair who needs the space.

Oneiros · 10/04/2023 16:03

For example just before I went onto the scheme, I received the renewal quotation for my privately owned car. Over 50% increase in premiums, with nothing changed from last year. Now I do not have to worry about this.

Anyway OP sorry for the derail. How you were treated is completely unacceptable. Your disabled daughter has a legal right to use that space and it's disgusting people wouldn't move. I think you're right to male a formal complaint and in future be much more forceful about it and refuse to move until they vacate the space. Every disabled person should do this. We shouldn't have to, it's appalling, but if everybody does it then the message may get through, finally. It's your DD's legal right so if necessary, enforce it for her.

Rosula · 10/04/2023 16:00

So are pram users just meant to stay inside for the rest of our lives?

Self-evidently, no. Unless you intend to transport your children around by pram for the rest of your life.

Oneiros · 10/04/2023 15:56

For a person who is over 25, already has full no claims bonus and a lump sum in the bank, it is significantly cheaper to buy a secondhand vehicle and run that instead

This isn't necessarily true though. Me being me, I did a spreadsheet before deciding to get one. Grin

I have an excellent credit rating, and my motorbility car did require a significant downpayment (as most do now). I have a full no claims bonus from private ownership before moving onto the scheme, and have always bought second-hand cars previously. With the depreciation, servicing, MOTs, repairs, paying insurance, breakdown cover etc, it works out significantly cheaper for me to have a motorbility car (including using the mobility part of my PIP to "pay" for it) than it did to buy 3-5 year old cars myself and maintain, repair, MOT, insure, service them etc, per year of ownership/ use. But with the bonus that the motorbility car is new so less stress because it's less likely to break down and there's no risk to me of a sudden expense if something goes wrong with it, or the hassle of having to sell the old one when it needs replacing, or worry about buying a new one with something seriously wrong with it, or the insurance premiums rocketing upwards every year as they were doing even though I'd got an even longer driving history with full no claims, etc.

The scheme is decent value. But not such good value as it used to be when most cars didn't also require larger downpayments. That's partly due to supply chain issues post-Covid so may improve in future years. But it's also largely down to GBP having been massively devalued ever since the Brexit referendum and never recovering to its previous levels because of the obvious effect that decision would have on the British economy.

Of course if we got a Government that would remove the unnecessary trade barriers and rejoin the single market and customs union then this might also improve, along with many of the other cost of living pressures and lack of funds for public services and low productivity making all British people poorer year on year, but no politicians if any party seem to be proposing to take this obvious step to stop impoverishing British people so...

Yolo12345 · 10/04/2023 15:47

So sorry this happened to you OP, can't believe you were treated like this. Had I been on that bus, I would have moved heaven and earth to help you.

Needmorelego · 10/04/2023 15:43

@LadyGrinningSoul85 do you have a double 'buggy' or a 'pram'? If you have to remove the seats to fold it then it isn't the style suitable for public transport.
While I sympathize with your situation the problem is people using 'prams' on buses - large frames, large wheels and seat or carrycot has to be removed to fold. A lighter weight, easy to fold one piece 'buggy' is what is needed for public transport. You can get those in double and suitable from newborn.
You don't say how old your children are so this might not work but I hope this helps to make travelling on a bus with them easier for you and give you more confidence.
Get a lightweight easy to fold buggy. Keep the rain cover in a small PE style bag under the buggy so you can whip it out and put it on your back if you need to fold (because often you can't fold if there is stuff in the underneath basket). If one of your children still a baby small enough to be in a sling you can put them in the sling while on the bus (keep the sling in the bag with the rain cover if not using).
If you don't have to fold then it's great but if you need to you can do it all quickly - sit the kids on a seat (even hand them to another passenger to hold for a minute), whip out the bag from underneath, fold buggy down 🙂

Sirzy · 10/04/2023 15:42

It may be tough for parents when babies are little but they do have choices in what they buy and it’s only for a few years.

disabled people face these challenges day in day out for their whole lives.

i think many people forget that disability campaigners fought long and very hard for these very basic adjustments. Now they are being taken over by other groups who don’t want to bother fighting themselves.

if you aren’t a wheelchair user (including SN buggies) then if you decide to use the space allocated for wheelchair users to be able to travel safely then you need to be prepared to leave the space if someone needs it.

Oneiros · 10/04/2023 15:39

Why would a pram user have to stay inside? Confused You can just fold your pram and hold your child. As the law requires when a disabled person needs to use the disabled space? Clue is in the name.

SerendipityJane · 10/04/2023 15:31

So are pram users just meant to stay inside for the rest of our lives?
I'm not saying I agree with what happened to the op here, but these comments about barring pram users from using the spaces are almost as bad.

(Now there's a username that goes back to the days of LOOT.)

Invariably these threads always attract people who cant' quite seem to make out the distinction between a disability and being a parent. Granted there are several nuances (there aren't) and it can be an incredibly subtle distinction (it isn't). But hey. lets make it all about them, shall we ?

NeverDropYourMooncup · 10/04/2023 15:30

AlltheFs · 09/04/2023 20:40

I think this is why most people get a car surely? I know several parents with a child
with disabilities and they all have motorbility cars (paid for).
Shouldn’t be like that no, but public transport and disabilities doesn’t mix well.

IF somebody has been awarded Higher Rate Mobility, then it is possible to personally enter into a leasing contract with Motorbility and some of the vehicles available (not necessarily wheelchair accessible ones, mind) can be leased for the entire amount of the mobility component with breakdown recovery, repairs, insurance and servicing included in that amount. However, the fuel costs and parking outside the terms of the blue badge scheme and any other additional costs have to come out of the rest of the income, such as any amount paid in respect of care (not guaranteed), wages, child benefit, UC or anything else that is not actually intended for, nor it is increased to take account of, additional costs of meeting the person's mobility needs. The main advantage is that there isn't a credit check to be passed, as the existence of an award for x years is deemed sufficient - although if the award is stopped due to an error/end of claim, the car is collected very quickly. For a person who is over 25, already has full no claims bonus and a lump sum in the bank, it is significantly cheaper to buy a secondhand vehicle and run that instead - if they have that financial advantage in the first place, of course, what with being a disabled person or parent/carer of of one not guaranteeing this.

In short, it's never a free car. It's an extremely expensive for what it is leasing/hire contract that has to be paid for by the person and represents significant further costs over and above the amount paid for mobility. I looked into it when eligible and decided it was the equivalent of Brighthouse for the Disabled.

Samcro · 10/04/2023 15:26

sorry not sorry its a wheelchair space, for wheelchairs.

LadyGrinningSoul85 · 10/04/2023 15:24

So are pram users just meant to stay inside for the rest of our lives?
I'm not saying I agree with what happened to the op here, but these comments about barring pram users from using the spaces are almost as bad.

I suffer from social anxiety which is gradually morphing into agoraphobia and getting on a bus with my pram is one of the most terrifying aspects of me deciding to leave the house.
I spend days working myself up about it (days out are planned due to how bad my social anxiety is. I can't just go out on a whim), I spend the entire time I'm on the bus terrified that a wheelchair will get on or another pram and I'll have to awkwardly manoeuvre to give them space, I always try to sit on the opposite space where some buses in my area actually have a pram symbol painted on the floor as they aren't suitable for wheelchairs as that side has no backrest, my kids hardly go anywhere because of MY mental problems, and the comments on this post beautifully illustrate why.

I'm sick of being made to feel like a nuisance for daring to try to have a life and go out in public with my kids.

I have a double buggy, so 'just fold it' isn't always practical and I have nerve damage too so can no longer fold or unfold without a lot of help, then my pram takes up more space folded with the seats off anyway!

Maybe some of you could stop being so pigheaded and see it's not always black and white and 'selfishness'

Living inside my head with all my anxieties makes me want to die sometimes, but yes, we pram pushers should just stay in and not be such an inconvenience to others.

bossonext · 10/04/2023 15:13

Hesma · 10/04/2023 15:00

  1. That’s awful but…
  2. why didn’t you help them fold their stroller?
I would definitely report this!

How is that OPs responsibility?

Itsamission25 · 10/04/2023 15:08

@Hesma she was refusing, at this point I was back outside with my daughter. I would have happily folded her stroller for her. It was just an excuse she never wanted anyone to help.
I also had a stroller on me with toddler along side my daughter in he wheelchair and it was folded with no issues it’s can easily be done.

OP posts:
Rosula · 10/04/2023 15:04

I hope you took down exact details of the bus, or at least the time and location? That bus driver clearly didn't do his job and you need to make a formal complaint about him. If the bus company don't take it seriously, escalate it to the authorities that licence the bus company to operate.

Swipe left for the next trending thread