Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be a bit sad about how eldest DS’s life has turned out?

155 replies

SimoneSayz · 09/04/2023 20:18

I’ve got three sons aged 19, 21 and 23. The eldest, P, has always been a sweet, loving and kind boy who lacked confidence. When he finished university he’d never had a girlfriend, just a few dates here and there. The younger two had plenty of girlfriends and I know that made P sad. We have a close family and spend a lot of time with cousins.

P started work at 21 and quickly made friends with an older married woman with three young kids, B, who was 30 at the time. I don’t know the exact ins and outs but within six months of meeting P, she’d split from her husband and P moved from our house into her rented one. A few months after that, they moved 300 miles away to be closer to her family.

It’s now two years on and they’ve established a business and a life up there. We rarely see him, never alone, but sometimes he calls on his way to work and he sounds very stressed and isolated. He doesn’t have any friends of his own up there, never sees his old friends, and he works long and antisocial hours on their business whilst she looks after the kids. B is now pregnant.

I know he’s an adult, and has made his own choices, but AIBU to feel a little sad that he’s so far away and now probably always will be?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Wingingit11 · 13/04/2023 14:13

SimoneSayz · 12/04/2023 12:54

Some people have asked about the ex-husband… He does see the children and he has moved closer to them but not close enough to do the school run, so they’re mostly with P and B. The children are often with him on weekends and holidays (during which P and B work or go on holidays with her family).

Both B and P hate her ex-husband and their move was without telling him, so although I don’t say it to them, I can understand why he’s angry. According to P (who knew him before) he’s often angry and not a great man and doesn’t act in the best interests of the children.

Yes, they are renting. Offering to pay for his visits is a good idea. He should be able to visit when the children are with their dad but I expect B would want to come too and I can’t really say she’s not welcome. They did visit together last summer but it was whilst they were bickering and it was tense. Oh dear, it’s all a bit of a mess.

I’m not surprised the ex husband was angry about his children being moved secretly after their affair came to light - in fact is that even allowed on the assumption he has PR?! The more you post the more it sounds like your Ds has a fine life - holidaying, exH trying to play an active part in his children’s lives etc. the reality is more that your ds has his own child on the way. There have been many, many fathers before him of a younger age who have dealt with that just fine. It sounds like his partner is close to her family and presumably they will support them. I wonder OP if that rankles you a bit?

WhatNoRaisins · 13/04/2023 06:54

I wonder if you need to talk about how a potential co-parenting relationship can work. At 23 most of us would be clueless about the logistics of this.

He needs to be able consider all his options. Loads of people stay in relationships they don't want to because they believe rightly or wrongly that there is no other option. Knowledge is power.

Sugarfree23 · 12/04/2023 13:18

Suggest to him the next time she's holidaying with her family he comes to you.

If they are holidaying that much they cannot be as skint as you think.

He's under the thumb, he needs to know you have his back and will support him.

SimoneSayz · 12/04/2023 12:54

Some people have asked about the ex-husband… He does see the children and he has moved closer to them but not close enough to do the school run, so they’re mostly with P and B. The children are often with him on weekends and holidays (during which P and B work or go on holidays with her family).

Both B and P hate her ex-husband and their move was without telling him, so although I don’t say it to them, I can understand why he’s angry. According to P (who knew him before) he’s often angry and not a great man and doesn’t act in the best interests of the children.

Yes, they are renting. Offering to pay for his visits is a good idea. He should be able to visit when the children are with their dad but I expect B would want to come too and I can’t really say she’s not welcome. They did visit together last summer but it was whilst they were bickering and it was tense. Oh dear, it’s all a bit of a mess.

OP posts:
sst1234 · 12/04/2023 08:05

OP you are not wrong. Being lumbered with someone else’s 3 kids at 21 does not sound like a great outcome from him.

Summerof85 · 12/04/2023 08:01

SimoneSayz · 09/04/2023 20:32

He’s cried a few times whilst saying how much he misses us all, and said that he and B were bickering a lot last summer but he didn’t feel they could separate as they couldn’t afford to run two households. He was throwing himself into work and doing little else. He feels responsible and is a stoic person. They live rurally and he’s always working so there’s not much opportunity to meet new friends.

DH and I are thrilled to be grandparents but I am sad that this means even if P and B did separate, he’ll always live there to be close to his child. He’ll never be near his support network again. His brothers are starting their lives locally and his school and uni friends (he went to uni an hour away) are all still close too. I don’t think he has much to say to his friends now as they’re in very different life stages to him and he can hardly go for a lads’ week in Spain, so I think he’s lonely.

Why did he feel 'they couldn't separate ' ? They weren't married and her 3 children were not his. He could have left at any time then. Maybe she had "brainwashed" him into thinking that. He can still leave at anytime while taking responsibility for his own soon to be born baby. Are they renting? If he's not happy he needs to do something about it before the situation gets worse.

Sugarfree23 · 12/04/2023 07:11

Op I think I'd be making it very clear to him he is not responsible for her or her 3 children. If he wants to come home he is more than welcome. He only needs to co parent and support his own baby.

I don't believe that the baby was an accident. She's tried to trap him. If the baby is due soon then it's better for him to wait until the baby is born and his name is on the birth cert.

If the business isnt making money their comes a point when they have to close it. He talks to you when he's travelling to and from work. Listen to what he's tell you. And support him.

Lcb123 · 12/04/2023 07:10

You just need to be there for him, not judge or project your obvious disappointment onto him. Go and visit him/them rather as much as you can. It’s pretty normal for at least 1 of your kids to live that far away, you can’t assume they’ll stay near you

LaurieFairyCake · 12/04/2023 07:07

I'm not sure anyone would be happy about a 23 year old having 3 children and one on the way Flowers

His life sounds pretty hard

Summerof85 · 12/04/2023 06:53

90sbab8 · 10/04/2023 14:34

I'm sorry but isnt anyone else here going to point out that this woman is a predator?! She was unhappy in her marriage. She saw a vulnerable, naive and inexperienced 21 year old lad who she could easily influence and control and snared him, and has now isolated him from his family by moving him miles away from them and never let's them see him alone, and now has him completely trapped with a baby on the way! Im sorry but no other normal 21 year old bloke would even consider a 30 year old woman with 3 small kids!

Agree. This is not something I would want for my son or daughter. The OP's son sounds miserable and I wonder if the girlfriend is stopping him from visiting his friends and family., using the excuse that he has no money.
He has no real legal obligation to her other 3 children really, sounds like he is a bit trapped in the situation. Where is the children's father? Now tbere is another baby on the way although that is his doing too.
Could you offer to send money for him to visit you then see what he says. If there are still excuses that says it all, he is entitled to see his own family and friends.

SallyWD · 11/04/2023 15:56

The thing is he's still very young and there's plenty of time to turn his life around. At 23 my life was a car crash living with an alcoholic (now ex) boyfriend, living off baked beans because we had no money at all. By 30 I was free of him and living a great life. By 35, I was a mum, a home owner, had a good career and a happy narriage. I also lacked confidence and was very shy. Don't wrote off your sons life at 23!

grivelling · 11/04/2023 15:53

Why doesn't the Children’s father pay for them? Is he alive?

Verbena17 · 10/04/2023 19:45

@90sbab8 Sadly, I thought the exact same thing.

SimoneSayz · 10/04/2023 19:05

90sbab8 · 10/04/2023 14:37

And oh, OP, this woman might be nice to your face when you visit them, but you never know what's going on when you're not there and miles away. Most of the most controlling and abusive people I've known have been charming and friendly to outsiders.

B is always friendly and welcoming but we really don’t know her well. My middle son isn’t keen at all, nor is his girlfriend. I don’t think B would be physically abusive but in other ways, perhaps… I know she controls the household finances and they’re in some joint debt. P doesn’t have enough for to take time off work to visit or to pay for the petrol but he’s always working. But then things are expensive with lots of children and only one worker.

OP posts:
LlynTegid · 10/04/2023 14:42

Almost every parent has expectations or hopes for their children, and if it does not turn out as expected, reasonable to be sad. Probably the only thing you can do is reassure your DS you will be there for him if needed.

90sbab8 · 10/04/2023 14:37

And oh, OP, this woman might be nice to your face when you visit them, but you never know what's going on when you're not there and miles away. Most of the most controlling and abusive people I've known have been charming and friendly to outsiders.

90sbab8 · 10/04/2023 14:34

I'm sorry but isnt anyone else here going to point out that this woman is a predator?! She was unhappy in her marriage. She saw a vulnerable, naive and inexperienced 21 year old lad who she could easily influence and control and snared him, and has now isolated him from his family by moving him miles away from them and never let's them see him alone, and now has him completely trapped with a baby on the way! Im sorry but no other normal 21 year old bloke would even consider a 30 year old woman with 3 small kids!

AprilFool23 · 10/04/2023 13:53

*breaking up

AprilFool23 · 10/04/2023 13:52

She should be helping to guide her DS to do the right thing which is to lay in the bed he has made

No, that isn't the right thing.

He had one child with a nearly decade older woman who starred a relationship with him while married with 3 kids; he can end the relationship and try to responsibly coparent if he wants. He doesn't have to stay, Noone does. Just like his partner didn't when she was married with 3 kids!!

AprilFool23 · 10/04/2023 13:50

I don’t really see why OP is feeling sorry for herself when another family has been hugely and directly impacted by that family being broken up. She should be helping to guide her DS to do the right thing which is to lay in the bed he has made

If this woman left her husband with whom she had 3 kids for a 21 yr old - quite quickly by the sounds of it (he moved in with her, they've relocated and she's pregnant by him within two years) ....it doesn't sound like that particular family was going to last in its original form anyway. She's now apparently moved herself and her kids 300 miles away from the ex. Doesn't exactly sound like the dream, stable setup..She clearly wanted out asap and used ops son to give her the impetus and probably to have another salary/worker in her new household. Now she's bringing another child into their lives with the contraceptive "accident".

I don't think.ops son contributed to destroying something that wasn't already wrecked; to the contrary she seems to have been looking for an out, without having to be single; and she found it on an inexperienced malleable 21 yr old man.

Oh and op I'd not responsible for her son's actions, and sges perfectly entitled and natural to feel sad at how it's worked out. She probably hoped it would fizzle out. Instead he's as deep in as possible (without more kids with her) and does not sound happy. He's talking about braking up FFS, and the reasons he feels he cant.

If he was the shit person you appear to be portraying him as, he'd be out of there, and wouldn't be considering any of them.

AprilFool23 · 10/04/2023 13:26

He sounds trapped.

I'd be worried about his mh going forward.

AprilFool23 · 10/04/2023 13:25

He's called crying that he's feeling homesick and said he couldn't afford to separate and now with baby on the way he can't really leave the area of he wants to be an involved parent. So doesn't sound like he's in a good relationship and happy

Exactly a few factors entirely and conveniently ignored by some posters on here, determined to undermine the op. These ppl specialise in doing that on threads like this.

AprilFool23 · 10/04/2023 13:22

At best he has exercised extremely poor judgement with massive implications for those children

Yeah because he was 20 fucking 1. A few dates but no previous relationship. Straight out of uni by the sounds of it. I used to listen (I had no choice) to early and even.mid twenty somethings on the train and they sound exactly like what they are - so where between older kids and ful adults. Their thoughts, their expression, their reasoning; it's not full adult. No doubt a few more posters will be on to assert how incredibly grown up they were at 21; maybe you were, for a 21 yr old. Many ppl are not like you.

This young man would only just have been allowed to buy alcohol in most US states.

The person with responsibility for their kids and their stability is their then 30 yr old mother.

I doubt the father's doing much from 300 miles away, unless he moved too (diesbt sound like it).

I find her behaviour irresponsible and predatory ... As I would a man doing the same thing.

AprilFool23 · 10/04/2023 13:17

*are paired

AprilFool23 · 10/04/2023 13:16

the fact is “the other woman”
is 99% of the time chastised as a marriage wrecker.

Not by anyone with a tap of sense.
Ain't nobody walking in a closed door. Not only do the mm open that door, they invite the ow to walk through it.

And the younger and less experienced the ow/on, the even less they are culpable. Theres a reason the word "young and stupid" and paired.

Most of us have made mistakes and done shit wgen younger wed not do when older.