Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Furious (again) at sister... how to raise this with DD

684 replies

Yellobird · 09/04/2023 19:39

Met up with my sister today, along with my DC. We don't see eye to eye and have taken very different paths, but my children like her so I go along with it.

DSis has no children. She was having a completely inappropriate conversation with DD about the gender pay gap and its because women can't go part time (in her job)- DD is 9!!! DD asked if that's why she doesn't have children. Sis went on to say that it's part of the reason, but mainly she likes her free time. Now bearing in mind DD thinks she's brilliant and hangs off her every word. Sis went on to say 'imagine if mum and dad wanted to go out tonight, on the spur of the moment. And then check out a new bar or comedy club. We'll they can't because they need to be at home with you and your brothers'

As if DH and I would even want to do that!!! Anyway, DH is doing bath time and I've said I'll go sit with her in bed and talk it through. DH says it's best to leave her so she doesn't dwell and get upset.

WWYD? Utterly furious that Sis has put us in this position after what should have been a nice family day.

OP posts:
mel71 · 10/04/2023 17:51

I have two sisters without children - I am the only one with children. When youngest was a baby and screeching my sister asked me if I should have got a puppy instead - it would be house trained by 8 months. I still chuckle now

LuckySantangelo35 · 10/04/2023 17:20

MyStarBoy · 10/04/2023 17:20

YADBU
What a stupid and insensitive thing to say to a 9 year old.

@MyStarBoy

how so?

MyStarBoy · 10/04/2023 17:20

YADBU
What a stupid and insensitive thing to say to a 9 year old.

bringincrazyback · 10/04/2023 17:10

ReadersD1gest · 09/04/2023 21:39

Your children are 9 and 15 and your husband was"doing bathtime"? You really do infantilise those kids, op...
Haven't you ever gone out without them?

OMG this! Even if 'bathtime' is only for the 9 y/o, she's way too old for that.

GoodChat · 10/04/2023 16:50

CovertImage · 10/04/2023 08:13

I don't know why you're all bothering, OP flounced about 6 pages ago, last night.

She flounced then carried on arguing. My favourite kind of flouncer Grin

MavisMcMinty · 10/04/2023 16:46

I suspect OP thinks her sister pities her trad-wife lifestyle and sees every remark as part of that belittlement. OP may also feel politics is of no concern to her, that “they’re all the same anyway”, and that it’s unfeminine to be opinionated and political. Just guessing, obviously, but that’s the most interesting aspect of this thread, what’s BEHIND the conflict?

BMW6 · 10/04/2023 16:37

I have several siblings and nieces and nephews since I was 18.

I didn't marry until late 40's and never wanted to have children. I had a career, my own home, holidays with friends, family, and several on my own.

If I was asked why I didn't have children I always replied that I liked to be only responsible for myself, and I liked the freedom being childless brought.

None of my siblings ever got the hump with my choice or views - quite the opposite, they were glad their children were seeing an example of a different lifestyle and the pros and cons of choices made.

I think OP has a backstory with her sister that she hasn't divulged. Resentment? Jealousy?

Arewehumanorarewecupboards · 10/04/2023 15:24

I like the sound of your sister. She’s not afraid to discuss real life with children.

ReadersD1gest · 10/04/2023 14:49

As if DH and I would even want to do that!!!”
It's quite an extraordinary thing to say, isn't it? Sounds so suffocating.

LuckySantangelo35 · 10/04/2023 14:47

@Yellobird

i actually think you could do with a night out OP - might help you be less uptight

LuckySantangelo35 · 10/04/2023 14:40

Yellobird · 09/04/2023 19:39

Met up with my sister today, along with my DC. We don't see eye to eye and have taken very different paths, but my children like her so I go along with it.

DSis has no children. She was having a completely inappropriate conversation with DD about the gender pay gap and its because women can't go part time (in her job)- DD is 9!!! DD asked if that's why she doesn't have children. Sis went on to say that it's part of the reason, but mainly she likes her free time. Now bearing in mind DD thinks she's brilliant and hangs off her every word. Sis went on to say 'imagine if mum and dad wanted to go out tonight, on the spur of the moment. And then check out a new bar or comedy club. We'll they can't because they need to be at home with you and your brothers'

As if DH and I would even want to do that!!! Anyway, DH is doing bath time and I've said I'll go sit with her in bed and talk it through. DH says it's best to leave her so she doesn't dwell and get upset.

WWYD? Utterly furious that Sis has put us in this position after what should have been a nice family day.

“As if DH and I would even want to do that!!!”

as if you never fancy going out on an evening to a bar or whatever just you and your DH? Why not? Get a grip, it’s a completely normal thing to want to do every so often!

momtoboys · 10/04/2023 13:52

sst1234 · 10/04/2023 00:08

I think that ship has sailed. What she’s probably being taught at school in the name of sex ‘education’ is far worse. No less than grooming. You may want to re direct your rage to where it’s really warranted.

Oh, come onnnnnn.......🙄

Hairybaker · 10/04/2023 12:20

You sound like hard work. Your sister did nothing wrong.

Cherrysoup · 10/04/2023 12:13

Telling your dd you can’t go out is wrong, however the Trump conversation is something my year 8 form group raise a lot. Kids are very aware of him and have very strong opinions on him.

whumpthereitis · 10/04/2023 12:13

WomanStanleyWoman2 · 10/04/2023 11:58

I’d wager the OP, and her sister, came in for similar pressure - and part of the reason the OP disapproves of her sister so much is that she didn’t toe the line. Worst of all, she didn’t even want to. A lonely old maid of a sister is someone you can pity; maybe reassure with an “Awwh, you never know; it could still happen” if you’re feeling generous.

Except the OP’s sister doesn’t actually need to be pitied. She’s happy. Central Casting offered her the role of Bitter Old
Spinster, but she said “No thanks - I’d much rather play the Fun Auntie”. And the OP is panicking that her daughter might see that and think “Ooh, that does look fun”. Because while you can pity a spinster sister, a spinster daughter is just an embarrassment.

And/or OP thinks life should have rewarded her for making the right choices, and she’s resentful that her sister’s not miserable, is loved and appreciated (even admired) by OP’s children, and is in better position finance and lifestyle wise (I suspect, reading between the lines).

QueenBee1234 · 10/04/2023 12:09

I genuinely can't believe people live in such a bubble.
Children are aware their parents can't go out because of them, most are aware it is a sacrifice their parents are happy to make and life goes on.

BigFatLiar · 10/04/2023 12:05

WomanStanleyWoman2 · 10/04/2023 11:58

I’d wager the OP, and her sister, came in for similar pressure - and part of the reason the OP disapproves of her sister so much is that she didn’t toe the line. Worst of all, she didn’t even want to. A lonely old maid of a sister is someone you can pity; maybe reassure with an “Awwh, you never know; it could still happen” if you’re feeling generous.

Except the OP’s sister doesn’t actually need to be pitied. She’s happy. Central Casting offered her the role of Bitter Old
Spinster, but she said “No thanks - I’d much rather play the Fun Auntie”. And the OP is panicking that her daughter might see that and think “Ooh, that does look fun”. Because while you can pity a spinster sister, a spinster daughter is just an embarrassment.

Wasn't wrong to tell the child that it's OK to be single and happy. Wrong for her to phrase it in a way that implied that if it wasn't for her and her brothers her mum could be having fun. Makes it sound like it's her fault and not a conscious decision on the part of her parents. I'm single I get to have fun, your parents have you they don't. People get their pleasure differently, she missed that bit out.

WomanStanleyWoman2 · 10/04/2023 11:58

Emotionalsupportviper · 10/04/2023 07:04

Agree.

I wish I'd been brought up more politically aware, and also not being under (not terribly subtle) pressure to find myself a husband. My DM was ashamed of me because all of her friends' daughters were married with babies and I wasn't.

I’d wager the OP, and her sister, came in for similar pressure - and part of the reason the OP disapproves of her sister so much is that she didn’t toe the line. Worst of all, she didn’t even want to. A lonely old maid of a sister is someone you can pity; maybe reassure with an “Awwh, you never know; it could still happen” if you’re feeling generous.

Except the OP’s sister doesn’t actually need to be pitied. She’s happy. Central Casting offered her the role of Bitter Old
Spinster, but she said “No thanks - I’d much rather play the Fun Auntie”. And the OP is panicking that her daughter might see that and think “Ooh, that does look fun”. Because while you can pity a spinster sister, a spinster daughter is just an embarrassment.

Mendholeai · 10/04/2023 11:35

I don’t see why you are so angry? She gave an example if one thing you can’t do with kids to illustrate her point? What do you think this will cause? Your Dd to never have kids?

Obviously parents can’t go out as much. It wouldn’t hurt your DD to know that you choose being with her over shows or clubs.

Talking about things is great for child development. Your DD will make her own mind up. I think you’ve overreacted.

bozzabollix · 10/04/2023 11:28

I’ve got an eight year old and a fourteen year old. My eldest is very politically engaged, and with what’s happening in this country it’s good that the young aren’t just ignoring politics.

Those who are unengaged politically are causing massive problems, my kids won’t be among them.

ReadersD1gest · 10/04/2023 11:27

DarkNecessities · 10/04/2023 07:47

Even some of the replies here are mad.

“btw - DD already know you love her so much, & has noticed you are not pining for comedy clubs, or constantly booking babysitters to you can abandon her & go to bars”

her DD would not be abandoned!

It’s important that children understand that it’s nice for their parents to do things without them sometimes as a couple or individuals.

Yes, the hysterical hype is quite something.
Reassure your daughter that you wouldn't abandon her for a night out... Wtf!
Some people must live such suffocating lives. Maybe their kids will bolt as far as they can as soon as the leash is loosened.

whumpthereitis · 10/04/2023 11:20

Georgeandzippyzoo · 10/04/2023 02:06

She told OP DD that because of her And Siblings her mum and dad don't get to go out for fun. She used the DD in the example yherefore possibly causing her to think it was her fault.
OP , you might be over reacting BUT some of the previous posters claimjnhbthey can't see the problem arectitally lacking in consideration for others. It's bleeding obvious WHY your DD may be upset and you are angry.

No, she said OP and her husband couldn’t spontaneously go and do something because they’re responsible for their children. Which is true, and hardly a devastating piece of knowledge for children to acquire.

She didn’t say that this was a bad thing, or cause for resentment. She also didn’t say the OP wanted to be able to spontaneously go to comedy clubs or whatever, just that she valued the that particular freedom she has through not having children.

Not having children if you don’t want them isn’t a sad thing at all, quite the opposite in fact, and there’s no reason why the DD shouldn’t know that it’s absolutely a choice she is free to make if she wants to.

WheelsUp · 10/04/2023 10:41

Rosula · 10/04/2023 05:23

What's inappropriate about a 15 year old talking about Trump? I'm just baffled.

I have a 16yo and he wanted a refresher on Trump because he could only remember him saying the stuff about building a wall. Luckily the keywords "January 6" had him remember stuff like the Q Shaman guy.

zingally · 10/04/2023 10:35

I don't think she's done anything wrong tbh.

An average 9yo is capable of hearing different opinions.

Dyslexicwonder · 10/04/2023 09:46

Macaroni46 · 10/04/2023 09:04

I teach 9 year olds and they very much do understand these topics and want to discuss them.

Thinking about this my DC were 12 & 9 in 2016, they absolutely knew all about Brexit. DS stayed up to watch the results with me and again in 2017 and 2019. During the whole prorouging parliament chaos we had the TV on and talked about it. How strange to think a 15yo wouldn't be interested.