Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Furious (again) at sister... how to raise this with DD

684 replies

Yellobird · 09/04/2023 19:39

Met up with my sister today, along with my DC. We don't see eye to eye and have taken very different paths, but my children like her so I go along with it.

DSis has no children. She was having a completely inappropriate conversation with DD about the gender pay gap and its because women can't go part time (in her job)- DD is 9!!! DD asked if that's why she doesn't have children. Sis went on to say that it's part of the reason, but mainly she likes her free time. Now bearing in mind DD thinks she's brilliant and hangs off her every word. Sis went on to say 'imagine if mum and dad wanted to go out tonight, on the spur of the moment. And then check out a new bar or comedy club. We'll they can't because they need to be at home with you and your brothers'

As if DH and I would even want to do that!!! Anyway, DH is doing bath time and I've said I'll go sit with her in bed and talk it through. DH says it's best to leave her so she doesn't dwell and get upset.

WWYD? Utterly furious that Sis has put us in this position after what should have been a nice family day.

OP posts:
MumOfOneAwesomeHuman · 11/04/2023 17:59

OK, so hear me out. I think you are over reacting but I understand how comments from siblings to our children can seem so much bigger than they are.

Personally, I like my DD knowing there are different options as a woman, it's fine to have children and it's also fine not to want them and to go out to comedy clubs and have a different kind of fun life too. I also think our DDs should know about the gender pay gap early so they don't accept the absolute shit we've all had to put up with as women.

BUT mostly what I want to say to you is my sister and I fought like cat and dog as teenagers and some of that spilled into adulthood. We were best friends mostly but the times we argued or fell out as adults were always about how the other parented and our differences of opinion. If I could go back in time I would never have fallen out with her over things that really REALLY don't matter.

My sister died 11 years ago, age 41, leaving her children behind. I got to parent them the way I thought they should be parented but what I didn't get and will never have is the chance to grow old with my sister. The chance to share in the burden of dealing with our parents ill health, their deaths and all the difficult times I've struggled through alone when I know she would have been my rock.

I would give anything to see her again and so I just want to urge you to try and see that differences of opinion are ok and even her saying something you don't like to your child is not the biggest deal and is something you can put right with a bedtime chat or two. Value what you have because you are so lucky to have a sister who wants to spend time with your DD and chat to her and share her opinions, right or wrong. And you are so lucky that you can choose to forgive her this, give her a big hug, be her best friend, share in the ups and downs of life. Please be grateful for her and cherish her and give her the hug I can't give my sister. I promise you nothing is worth falling out when you see the bigger picture.

Harleyband · 11/04/2023 17:47

I know OP has disengaged, but, wow, I feel so sorry for her DCs. She's going to destroy her daughter's lovely relationship with what sounds like the only sane member of the family

ReadersD1gest · 11/04/2023 17:00

AnnieSnap · 11/04/2023 16:49

@ReadersD1gest hmmm, but it’s a weird response for so many to have isn’t it?

Absolutely!

AnnieSnap · 11/04/2023 16:49

@ReadersD1gest hmmm, but it’s a weird response for so many to have isn’t it?

ReadersD1gest · 11/04/2023 16:39

AnnieSnap · 11/04/2023 16:35

I’m amazed that 9% of those who voted believe the OP response is reasonable 😮😳

I'm not sure I am surprised. There's a hefty dose of "She's jealous she hasn't got a beautiful little girl like yours, hun" responses.

AnnieSnap · 11/04/2023 16:35

I’m amazed that 9% of those who voted believe the OP response is reasonable 😮😳

Mumwomansisterdaughter · 11/04/2023 15:41

The only thing I can get from this post is that my 7 year old is extremely intelligent, I cannot phantom why anyone else pups think a 9 year old would not benefit of knowing about women’s rights and the gender pay gap , can even understand less why a 15 year should not know about trump since in parts of the U.K. they can actually vote a year after .
At 7 my child is perfectly capable of having a small discussion about politics ( who are the prime and first ministers and why she likes or doesn’t like them as a example ) , environment and women’s rights and has enough knowledge to actually do it . It seems your kids might love their aunt so much because she actually treats them as intelligent people as ho can have age appropriate conversations in all subjects.

Dweetfidilove · 11/04/2023 13:22

Having read this twice, I think it's a good thing your daughter has her aunt.

The gender pay gap should be discussed and 9 is as good an age as any.

We also see so many people on here regretting having children, so it's not a bad thing for her to know it's a sacrificial role.

I'm sure she's knows you enjoy spending time with her too, so will see both sides.

Huge overreaction on your part.

Hmm1234 · 11/04/2023 13:19

IamKlaus · 11/04/2023 11:57

Nothing age inappropriate there. Teach your children if you don't want other people to do it for you!

And maybe you should go to a comedy club, you might unclench a bit,

This! Hahaha

Hmm1234 · 11/04/2023 13:18

Wow she sounds like a realist. There is nothing wrong with the conversation she was having sounds like she was keeping it real and you keep the children living in a fantasy world

CurlewKate · 11/04/2023 13:16

What a fantastic aunt!

Macaroni46 · 11/04/2023 13:08

IamKlaus · 11/04/2023 12:17

Mummy Martyrs are the worst. Joyless bores.

Agreed 😂

ilovechocolate07 · 11/04/2023 12:26

I can't see anything wrong with the comments. I talk with my children about this all of the time. I like them to know that I am in my job because of choices we made and how me and dad have only been able to each get where we are because of these decisions.

LuckySantangelo35 · 11/04/2023 12:25

MargotBamborough · 11/04/2023 12:19

I'm wondering how the OP's sister was actually supposed to answer the question, "Is that why you don't have children?"

What were the other options?

"Oh I do have children but I keep them locked in the cupboard under the stairs." (stupid)

"I don't have children because I haven't found a man to have them with." (not true)

"I don't have children because I can't have them." (probably not true)

"I don't have children because I don't like children." (untrue and hurtful)

It seems to me that, "I like children but I have chosen to spend my time doing other things instead" is the best answer.

The OP clearly feels threatened by her sister having made different life choices, and is possibly worried that if her 9 year old DD realises there are other paths in life than becoming a wife and mother, she might not get grandchildren.

The OP clearly feels threatened by her sister having made different life choices, and is possibly worried that if her 9 year old DD realises there are other paths in life than becoming a wife and mother, she might not get grandchildren.

that could be it. I can’t see any other reason why op wouldn’t want her daughter to know that other paths in life exist for her when she’s older

FatGirlSwim · 11/04/2023 12:22

People are different. I don’t want to go out and I’d rather be at home with my children. There may come a time in my life when I want to go out at night again but I really don’t atm.

Other people have kids and still feel like going out.

Others don’t have kids and go out a lot.

Others don’t have kids but prefer staying in.

All these options are fine.

MargotBamborough · 11/04/2023 12:19

I'm wondering how the OP's sister was actually supposed to answer the question, "Is that why you don't have children?"

What were the other options?

"Oh I do have children but I keep them locked in the cupboard under the stairs." (stupid)

"I don't have children because I haven't found a man to have them with." (not true)

"I don't have children because I can't have them." (probably not true)

"I don't have children because I don't like children." (untrue and hurtful)

It seems to me that, "I like children but I have chosen to spend my time doing other things instead" is the best answer.

The OP clearly feels threatened by her sister having made different life choices, and is possibly worried that if her 9 year old DD realises there are other paths in life than becoming a wife and mother, she might not get grandchildren.

IamKlaus · 11/04/2023 12:17

Mummy Martyrs are the worst. Joyless bores.

latetothefisting · 11/04/2023 12:13

LuckySantangelo35 · 11/04/2023 11:53

EXACTLY

all this “oh I don’t ever wanna go out again now im a mum! I love staying home every single night” is bullshit

It's so unhealthy to promote to kids that once you procreate your life is essentially over and you can never do anything you enjoyed doing before because the kids must come first at all times.

Op's ridiculous amazement at the mere thought that her and her DH, two adults in their - what, 40s? might want to occasionally go to something as inoffensive as a comedy club is bizarre and a bit sad.

From what she's said the sister didn't suggest that nobody could ever have any fun once they've spawned - ironically its the op who seems to be passing that lesson down to her kids! The sister only seems to have suggested that you can't be as spontaneous once you have kids (although the same applies to any other dependents!) - which is usually true so can't see how that's offensive?

arethereanyleftatall · 11/04/2023 12:00

Kate0902900908 · 11/04/2023 09:41

‘DD there’s a big part that auntie has missed out today. We don’t have to be here with you and your brothers … we WANT to be, that’s why we had children we wanted a family and have a family life. Someone people prefer clubs and shows and and don’t have children. Having children is a privilege not an option and we have been lucky enough to have you and your brothers’

No. No. No. no. No. No. No

PLEASE don't tell young girls this!! Having children is absolutely and utterly a choice, and we should absolutely not be giving girls (or boys) any inkling that it is the only 'successful' route.
Just spend one day on mumsnet reading about miserable women in miserable relationships who have been socially conditioned that regardless of what goes on, having a partner is an aspiration above all else.
No. No. No. no. Fuck NO.

seratoninmoonbeams · 11/04/2023 11:59

You went and sat with her in bed to talk it through. Wow. Like PPs I couldn't quite grasp what the point of your OP was so it seems like a huge over reaction to me. Children do limit what you can do on the spur of the moment. End of.

Tessabelle74 · 11/04/2023 11:58

Pluvia · 11/04/2023 09:53

Someone people prefer clubs and shows and and don’t have children.

Ah, the old 'you childfree people just want to go clubbing and see shows and be selfish, whereas we made the ultimate sacrifice and had children' trope. The moment you say that your secret — that you regard having children as a hardship that everyone should have to go through — is out.

Brilliant! I have 4 kids, I still love clubs and shows etc. I'm conflicted now 😂

IamKlaus · 11/04/2023 11:57

Yellobird · 09/04/2023 19:53

DD is 9! She doesn't need to get into conversations about politics, or worry about mum and dad staying at home. Dsis has form for talking to my kids about entirely age inappropriate stuff. Eldest is 15, and walked in on them in the kitchen talking about Trump and the trial and his treatment of women. Just rolled my eyes and walked out.

Nothing age inappropriate there. Teach your children if you don't want other people to do it for you!

And maybe you should go to a comedy club, you might unclench a bit,

ReadersD1gest · 11/04/2023 11:57

My DD11 is a thinker, she'd dwell on a comment like that and days later ask if we regret having children because we can't go out whenever we like - it would literally keep her up at night worrying that we didn't want kids anymore
She doesn't sound much of a deep thinker to me, tbh.

Eleven, and she'd worry that you didn't want kids anymore?

LuckySantangelo35 · 11/04/2023 11:57

FooFighter99 · 11/04/2023 11:54

I get it @Yellobird

My DD11 is a thinker, she'd dwell on a comment like that and days later ask if we regret having children because we can't go out whenever we like - it would literally keep her up at night worrying that we didn't want kids anymore Sad

She would also stew on issues like women's right and the pay gap - though she wouldn't fully understand them, which in turn would worry and confuse her more... There is a time and place for talking about these things, but your sis was wrong IMO to put that weighty issue on a 9 year old

So no, YANBU

@FooFighter99

is your daughter not at secondary school? Or soon to go? It’s just that lots and lots of weighty and thought provoking topics and issues are discussed there

FooFighter99 · 11/04/2023 11:54

I get it @Yellobird

My DD11 is a thinker, she'd dwell on a comment like that and days later ask if we regret having children because we can't go out whenever we like - it would literally keep her up at night worrying that we didn't want kids anymore Sad

She would also stew on issues like women's right and the pay gap - though she wouldn't fully understand them, which in turn would worry and confuse her more... There is a time and place for talking about these things, but your sis was wrong IMO to put that weighty issue on a 9 year old

So no, YANBU