Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Furious (again) at sister... how to raise this with DD

684 replies

Yellobird · 09/04/2023 19:39

Met up with my sister today, along with my DC. We don't see eye to eye and have taken very different paths, but my children like her so I go along with it.

DSis has no children. She was having a completely inappropriate conversation with DD about the gender pay gap and its because women can't go part time (in her job)- DD is 9!!! DD asked if that's why she doesn't have children. Sis went on to say that it's part of the reason, but mainly she likes her free time. Now bearing in mind DD thinks she's brilliant and hangs off her every word. Sis went on to say 'imagine if mum and dad wanted to go out tonight, on the spur of the moment. And then check out a new bar or comedy club. We'll they can't because they need to be at home with you and your brothers'

As if DH and I would even want to do that!!! Anyway, DH is doing bath time and I've said I'll go sit with her in bed and talk it through. DH says it's best to leave her so she doesn't dwell and get upset.

WWYD? Utterly furious that Sis has put us in this position after what should have been a nice family day.

OP posts:
KettrickenSmiled · 09/04/2023 23:02

Mosaic123 · 09/04/2023 22:48

I think the gender pay gap issue is ok to talk about with a young child but as for the not being able to go out on impulse that's wrong.
Your sister is implying that your 9 year old is a burden and more fun could be had without her.

This would be a horrible message to hear as a child.

I would interpret it as not far off from "I wish you hadn't been born".

You know DD's aunt didn't give birth to her - right?
And was honestly answering a question posed to her by DD?

Sailingaround · 09/04/2023 23:02

I’m glad sanity has prevailed on Mumsnet here. I was about 5 pages in when I realised this was genuine and most likely not a wind-up.

OP, equality including pay gap etc is taught in the primary school curriculum! It’s also something a 9 year old will be coming across if she reads a wide range of books. I used to be a children’s book blogger and there are MANY 8+ books that allude to the gender pay gap, and other forms of discrimination including racism. Let me guess you don’t talk to her about that either? I am almost sure if you or your kid was for eg. a POC or ND you wouldn’t be so casual about relegating unfairness and discrimination to something that shouldn’t be discussed until they’re adults, because you wouldn’t have that luxury!

I can’t see why your kids like your sis, she sounds very well-balanced and Broad minded and I’m afraid you sound very limited in your thinking and narrow-minded.

I’m very uneasy about people who dismiss equality as “politics” and act as if it’s something they can just opt out of being mindful.

I will say though that comment about spontaneity might fly over most kids head but it could rub some kids up the wrong way if they’re overly sensitive or insecure in some way. However as pp have said you can rectify that easily by casually mentioning that Aunty has her own opinions and lifestyle which is valid and cool way but for you missing out on last minute stuff is worth it to spend time with them…and you wouldn’t swap them for the world etc .

KettrickenSmiled · 09/04/2023 22:59

Yellobird · 09/04/2023 19:53

DD is 9! She doesn't need to get into conversations about politics, or worry about mum and dad staying at home. Dsis has form for talking to my kids about entirely age inappropriate stuff. Eldest is 15, and walked in on them in the kitchen talking about Trump and the trial and his treatment of women. Just rolled my eyes and walked out.

You think 15 year olds should be kept in the dark about politics, & predatory men?

When my DD was 8, she would start conversations about social-political stuff. Obviously basic, but she was insightful about the ridiculousness of convention, the inequity of wealth & privilege ... why are you so intent on sheltering your kids? Nobody pushed it on her, she was just a bright, enquiring child, like many are.Why would you want to quash any of that in your own child? Especially as she is, as you say, "a thinker".

I suspect this has far more to do with your dislike of your sister than genuine worry for your DD's. Stop shielding them from the world, & let them understand that other people have various opinions. How else are they going to inform themselves, & genuinely make up their own minds about what they think & how they live?

RosieLeaLovesTea · 09/04/2023 22:59

I think at age 9 your DD will naturally have questions about why your life may be different to you sister and why she does not have children. Your DD asked a question and your sister answered it honestly. I think that your DD will appreciate that and that there are different views about what people want from their lives.

Flowerly · 09/04/2023 22:58

Janedoe82 · 09/04/2023 22:57

And this is why we have a generation of children that can’t cope with anything…..

Isn't it just?

InWalksBarberalla · 09/04/2023 22:58

Yellobird · 09/04/2023 19:53

DD is 9! She doesn't need to get into conversations about politics, or worry about mum and dad staying at home. Dsis has form for talking to my kids about entirely age inappropriate stuff. Eldest is 15, and walked in on them in the kitchen talking about Trump and the trial and his treatment of women. Just rolled my eyes and walked out.

Neither of these are age inappropriate or outside the kinds of discussions they'd have at school at those ages (or younger for the Trump conversation).
Sounds like you baby your kids.

Janedoe82 · 09/04/2023 22:57

And this is why we have a generation of children that can’t cope with anything…..

Prometheus · 09/04/2023 22:54

I have similar conversations with my 8 year old niece. Told her all about the gender pay gap, feminism, how having kids holds you back in the workplace. And I have two kids myself - both boys who I also tell this stuff too. Things will never change if we pretend we have equality. I also joking tell my boys that we’d be out having fun on a Saturday night rather than at home watching Ant and Bloody Dec if we didn’t have kids….

Mosaic123 · 09/04/2023 22:48

I think the gender pay gap issue is ok to talk about with a young child but as for the not being able to go out on impulse that's wrong.
Your sister is implying that your 9 year old is a burden and more fun could be had without her.

This would be a horrible message to hear as a child.

I would interpret it as not far off from "I wish you hadn't been born".

EnidSpyton · 09/04/2023 22:47

You sound incredibly defensive OP.

Reading between the lines it seems you see your sister’s decision to have an independent life without children as a rejection/critique of your life choice to do the opposite, and as such you resent her.

The fact that you don’t want your sister to talk to your daughter about life choices outside of being a parent is also suggestive of you feeling threatened by any suggestion that marriage/motherhood isn’t the only life open to a woman.

I would suggest you spend some time looking inwards at why you feel so threatened by your sister and her lifestyle choices. Your sister sounds like a wonderful aunt and a great role model to your daughter to show how many possibilities there are for her when she’s older if motherhood doesn’t appeal to her or isn’t a possibility for any reason. It’s great that your kids have an adult in their life who respects their intelligence and is willing to have meaningful discussions with them. It’s a shame you can’t see that.

Womencanlift · 09/04/2023 22:47

Yellobird · 09/04/2023 20:00

OK, so I'm wrong I'm wanting my kids to enjoy their childhood and not be worrying about politics 🙄
As I said, dd is a thinker and she'll be mulling this over, I know her. To say that 'mum and dad have no life because of you' is an incredible rejection

Oh my. This is one of the most ridiculous posts I have read in a long time. That is not an “incredible rejection”.

If you think it is then you need to open your eyes to what a lot of children are going through every day - there are a lot of rejected children out there.

Your DD is not one of them by the sound of things

Holly60 · 09/04/2023 22:43

ReadersD1gest · 09/04/2023 22:29

All you need to do is reiterate that you made the choice to have children because you WANTED to be in looking after little ones in the evening
Speak for yourself. That's not why I had children.

That's fab to know, but your reasons for having children are totally irrelevant to this thread.

OP was looking for advice on what to say to her DD. I was merely making a suggestion.

muppetmayhem · 09/04/2023 22:40

I think your sister sounds brilliant.

Minime88888888 · 09/04/2023 22:37

You don't see eye to eye with your sister. Here lies your problem.

Mummyoflittledragon · 09/04/2023 22:36

*the world

Mummyoflittledragon · 09/04/2023 22:36

She sounds like a fun aunt. I was a fun aunt to my cousin’s dd. Her dd is a fun big cousin to my dd. It’s important to have these people in kid’s lives. Your dc will not love you less, they will just have a more comprehensive view of the world.

Don’t underestimate how much of an impact your sister can have on your children and do try to be happy for it. She really hasn’t said anything wrong.

If you’re concerned about your dd, I agree asking her about how she felt and answer any questions then a big hug and reassurance that you wouldn’t have it any other way because she’s great company. However, it is good for our children to know that we have a life outside of them. It gives them balance and can take the pressure off them as they grow older. No teen wants to be their parents’ world. They want to start to cut the apron strings and explore the work.

chaosmaker · 09/04/2023 22:35

ohfook · 09/04/2023 20:39

I think it's good that she has an understanding of the fact that having children is a choice and not a path set in stone for her.

I'm on the fence with the rest though. I don't think your sister said anything wrong but I have a very sensitive kid who would walk away from that conversation thinking he was preventing me from having fun. I think I'd just use it to remind him that different people like doing different things and I'd obviously much rather be spending my Saturday nights listening to him talk incessantly about minecraft than be four drinks deep at the comedy club with daddy.

He doesn't know sarcasm then? 😀

Grimbelina · 09/04/2023 22:35

You are infantilising your children which is setting them up to have some big shocks later in their lives. It is perfectly possible for children to have an understanding of the world, politics etc. and enjoy their childhood. Your sister sounds great.

23usrnm · 09/04/2023 22:34

I think you are being unreasonable. Your sister sounds like she is engaging your kids on real world issues (politics is not just for grown ups - it affects children too). It is true that you can’t be spontaneous once you have kids and it’s a useful life lesson for all kids but especially girls as they are statistically more likely to be picking up more of the caring duties. You sound like you have an idealised version of what childhood should be, insulated from any challenging topics. That’s not equipping your children to thrive in the real world.

ibblebibbledibble · 09/04/2023 22:33

This is so sad that you think 9 year olds can’t discuss politics. We talk about news and politics all the time in our house. They’re naturally interested in what’s going on in the world and find it fascinating.

Holly60 · 09/04/2023 22:32

Yellobird · 09/04/2023 20:00

OK, so I'm wrong I'm wanting my kids to enjoy their childhood and not be worrying about politics 🙄
As I said, dd is a thinker and she'll be mulling this over, I know her. To say that 'mum and dad have no life because of you' is an incredible rejection

At 15 your DC should be talking to you about politics and current affairs. In 3 years they will be voting!

Do you think that 15 and 16 year olds aren't encouraged to engage in these things at school??

Matchymatchylemonscratchy · 09/04/2023 22:30

Yellobird · 09/04/2023 19:44

That she's told DD that mum and dad are not having fun because of her!! Thought that was obvious.

Nope not obvious. You are massively overreacting. Most children would know parents occasionally hire babysitters so they can go out. Or are you a complete martyr?

And the gender pay gap is real. There is no harm in talking about it.

ReadersD1gest · 09/04/2023 22:29

All you need to do is reiterate that you made the choice to have children because you WANTED to be in looking after little ones in the evening
Speak for yourself. That's not why I had children.

momtoboys · 09/04/2023 22:28

Yellobird · 09/04/2023 19:44

That she's told DD that mum and dad are not having fun because of her!! Thought that was obvious.

It wasn’t obvious and I think you are making too much out of this. Your daughter knows you and her dad love being her parents and that lifestyle isn’t what you chose.

Holly60 · 09/04/2023 22:26

She was trying to explain to your daughter why she has chosen not to have children. She didn't patronise her and gave her an age appropriate version of the truth.

She didn't say you aren't having fun, she said you can't spontaneously go out, which is true. All you need to do is reiterate that you made the choice to have children because you WANTED to be in looking after little ones in the evening. Then your DD can see that you and your sister have made equally valid life choices that make you both happy.

I think your sister was modelling healthy open discussion.