Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be offended by friends comment

118 replies

yellowbricklane · 09/04/2023 17:49

Hello,

For the past couple of years, I have been considering getting a family dog and have looked across many dog rescue shelters and gone through the appropriate verifications. I have fallen in love with a French bulldog and currently going through the process in getting the dog into our home. I told a very good friend of mine, who has always known that I've always wanted a dog (since growing up with them during childhood) and has been supportive. But she disapproves of our chosen dog. She said the following "I don't regard French bulldogs as proper dogs, they are more like designer handbags. I have never seen one run around or behave like normal dogs do. They are quite pretty to look at but that's all they are. A walking deformed handbag Confused. If that's what your after- go ahead and add it to your bag collection. But if you want a normal dog then I suggest you look elsewhere".

I find her comment very offensive. She has always been blunt, which I love her for and she is the only friend that tells me how it is. I honestly did not understand what she was trying to imply with her comment. At times, I feel like she drains on my happiness, any good things or opportunities that come my way she always puts a downer. How should
I respond? I didn't say anything when she said, but I want to tell how I truly feel. What do you all think

OP posts:
Iwasafool · 09/04/2023 21:45

Mincedpies · 09/04/2023 18:50

You can be as offended as you want but Frenchies are riddled with health problems. As a breed it’s cruel to continue breeding them. I know you’re rescuing rather than buying but your friend is right in her assessment.

PP have commented that their Frenchies have no health problems but trust me, they will. I wish I was wrong writing that but I’m not 😔

My friends is 9, just checked as I couldn't remember exactly how old, and she is very healthy and very well behaved. They had her as a rescue whens he was coming up to two and they've had no problems with her at all, she has a lovely nature and is very active.

ChamonixSky · 09/04/2023 21:41

I think she's right. They're overbred and have significant health issues. I judge people who have these breeds. It's great that you want to rehome a dog, but it's definitely not the type of dog I'd go for personally. It sounds to me like your friend may have hit a nerve, possibly about vanity and wanting a cute looking dog? Try to unpick what it is about her comment that you find offensive and then let her know.

whynotwhatknot · 09/04/2023 21:38

yeah they ar eknown for their health problems but you are rescuing not buyung so i dont understamnd her desinger handbag comment

shutthewindownow · 09/04/2023 21:28

VagueSpirit · 09/04/2023 21:22

more likely to suffer from medical conditions

This is key. More likely to, not guaranteed to as some of the posters who have no personal experience with the breed indicate. Many seem to believe the generalisations as gospel on the breed but that's their issue. Enjoy your dog op. Ignore the uneducated idiotic comments that know nothing about the individual dog you're adopting.

I don't think people are idiotic to make comments given these dogs have so many health problems and this is part of the reason so many end up in rescue Vets bills are so expensive and insuring a French bulldog is also very costly Of course not every dog will have health problems but most of them do !

IcedBananas · 09/04/2023 21:23

I wouldn’t be offended. Sounds like she’s questioning the ethics of how certain dogs are bred. It’s her opinion and she’s not going to be the only one to feel strongly about this kind of thing so it’s worth thinking about. You’re not breading, you’re giving a rescue dog a good home so I’d respond with that. I think she’s just trying to highlight something to you although maybe she’s been a bit blunt about it.

VagueSpirit · 09/04/2023 21:22

more likely to suffer from medical conditions

This is key. More likely to, not guaranteed to as some of the posters who have no personal experience with the breed indicate. Many seem to believe the generalisations as gospel on the breed but that's their issue. Enjoy your dog op. Ignore the uneducated idiotic comments that know nothing about the individual dog you're adopting.

shutthewindownow · 09/04/2023 21:21

I do think this breed of dog is cruel and breeding needs to be stopped However you are rescuing so that is different. You arnt encouraging the breeding so I see no issue. Well done for rescuing. Adopt don't shop

xsquared · 09/04/2023 21:18

A French Bulldog is a brachycephic breed, so they are more likely to suffer from medical conditions because of restricted ability to breathe.

I am with your friend, they are more like a fashion accessory, bred for their appearance. Up to you of course.

Have you posted about this before?

Buildingthefuture · 09/04/2023 21:11

She sounds horrid. And no, she is not correct in her assessment. You aren’t “buying a designer handbag” you are giving a home to a dog who needs one. Which frankly, is more than most people bother to do. Brachycephalic breeds are in the spotlight at the minute but the fact is, a lot of dogs have massive breeding issues (Daxies, GSD, Cavaliers to name just a few, the list is endless) and all the while people keep buying puppies, and the Kennel Club continue to be utterly useless, those issues will continue. What would she prefer you to do? Leave the dog in a shelter? I would never buy a Frenchie but I would adopt one and providing you’ve done your research and know what you are taking on, then go for it. And tell her to mind her manners!

VintageThoughts · 09/04/2023 20:57

Your friend is talking nonsense.

They're not remotely pretty.

Grumpusaurus · 09/04/2023 20:52

She is absolutely right so!

mbosnz · 09/04/2023 20:50

Frenchies are riddled with health problems. Please do not get one if you are on a budget.

Mincedpies · 09/04/2023 20:46

SardineStitches · 09/04/2023 20:21

You can be as offended as you want but Frenchies are riddled with health problems

And you can make up whatever shit you want doesn't mean it's accurate.. So clueless but you do you.

Absolutely zero reason to be so rude. I’m 100% certain you wouldn’t talk to me like that in person so stop with the bravery that comes from sitting behind a keyboard thinking you’re sounding clever.

Do your research. Frenchies are riddled with health problems. The only person being clueless is, sadly, you,

ActDottie · 09/04/2023 20:36

I wouldn’t want one personally, but if you’ve found one in need of a home and you’re happy with your choice then go for it. The little one is alive and needing a home regardless of what others think.

Atethehalloweenchocs · 09/04/2023 20:35

As well as their health problems they are notoriously hard to train. So she is not wrong, but perhaps not tactful.

choccytime · 09/04/2023 20:30

She s right dont get it, if people stopped buying these poor dogs maybe there might be an end to the awful suffering they have to endure . Theres plenty of other breeds you could consider

SardineStitches · 09/04/2023 20:23

Are they the breed that looks as though it's walked into a bollard?

No more than I'm sure you do.

Most of these comments highlight why dogs are better people.

SardineStitches · 09/04/2023 20:21

You can be as offended as you want but Frenchies are riddled with health problems

And you can make up whatever shit you want doesn't mean it's accurate.. So clueless but you do you.

SardineStitches · 09/04/2023 20:20

And I hope you can afford the vet's bills OP

I've got 4. Only vet bills have been desexing and vaccinations... Just because they are a certain breed doesn't mean the automatically have issues.
But this is always a call card for those with no experience with the breed.

They’ve been over breed and have numerous health problems

I guess finding a good breeder can avoid this.. Like with any breed. Any badly bred dog of any breed can have issues. My 4 don't. But the comments on this thread by those who have know idea apart from the bad stories they've read are humerous. I'd only be concerned by the one in the OP as it is a rescue and so the breeder and breeding is unknown. It may well have been surrendered due to the individual health of that dog not just because of its breed.

My 4 are like normal dogs, not sure why they wouldn't be. They play with each other and are lovely natured dogs. Eldest is almost 7 and none of them have any health issues. Many people including some vets believe any frenchie has issues just because they are frenchies. I have had the odd vet tell me they need airway surgery when they don't simply because of the breed they are, not because it's required.
There are a lot of dog breeds that can have well known issues for their specific breed but that doesn't mean they all do. I also have cavaliers who are known to have heart conditions, mine don't and they're 10. Never had a problem. Though I have seen those awful oodle mixes needing to be put down due to the issues common to the other breed it's bred with even though an oodle breeder promises that by crossing them and making a mutt they won't have these issues. A good friend had a cavoodle that died due to the heart condition common to cavaliers... But no one mentions those issues, oodle mutts are for some reason popular and people pay thousands to dodgy backyard breeders (as an oodle isn't a breed and are not bred by reputable registered breeders) for the privilege of owning the mess and that seems more acceptable than people buying whatever breed suits their lifestyle from a good breeder... Sure that makes sense.

chocolatemademefat · 09/04/2023 20:17

Well she was definitely lying about them being pretty. They’re not. Why do you put so much emphasis on her opinion anyway? Do you REALLY want this dog if her thoughts on it matter?

YouOKHun · 09/04/2023 20:14

Well done in going for a rescue dog and clearly doing your research - I wish others would be as thorough. I expect your potential rescue dog is the victim of someone who didn’t think it through and found out their new fashion accessory was quite hard work. There are lots of responsible French Bulldog owners of course but FBs have attracted the wrong people recently, with Lockdown increasing the amount of cruelty and subsequently rejected dogs. I read somewhere that fashionable small breeds have been particular victims.

I do agree with your friend to a point though it sounds more like she likes to bring you down than have an honest conversation. I have to say that I’ve seen some FBs really suffer with all sorts of problems from an early age and they can be very expensive to insure. You may spend a lot of money at the vets on a regular basis. But if you’ve done your research you’ll know that and be ready for it.

If I had my way no one would be allowed to breed dogs in a way that introduced such potential suffering and there are some breed that should be allowed to die out.

SkyeBlue28 · 09/04/2023 20:12

I think your friend was rude. If you have fallen in love with a dog then you should go for it. It sounds like you have put a lot of thought into it. I’m not a dog person so I know nothing about French bulldogs. If there are drawbacks to that breed of dog I think it’s ok for a friend to have a chat with you about them. However your friend was very blunt and rude.

FawnFrenchieMum · 09/04/2023 20:07

saraclara · 09/04/2023 19:20

I think this is due to how many die young that brings the average age right down. If they have got past the first year or two. Then they are likely to live to 7-9.

Oh, well that's okay then 🙄
I'm not sure what point you thought you were making there, but it's probably not the one you intended @FawnFrenchieMum .

I was meaning if it’s a rescue, it’s probably past the risk of a premature death. I was not saying this isn’t an awful thing in its own right. I was talking about this specific dog. You will see from my other comments. I am involved with fostering for a frenchy rescue so well aware of the issues with mis-breeding.

saraclara · 09/04/2023 19:41

I was appalled that my brother bought a French bulldog. But I've not said anything because it was done and dusted before I found out, and we don't see each other often, so that kind of conversation isn't something I'd want to have.
If I knew that a friend was intending getting one, I'd express my surprise, and my concerns for such a dog's quality of life. But if it was a rescue, I'd probably keep my trap shut, or at least only mention the problems from the perspective of how the friend would manage them.

But I'd love to see the breed become extinct. Those poor dogs...

ToWhitToWhoo · 09/04/2023 19:30

Is she aware that this is a rescue dog? If you were buying it from a breeder, I think she'd have a point, as they are often bred to be very unhealthy, with serious breathing problems, and this should not be encouraged. But this issue does not apply to a rescue dog!