Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask dd to contribute more to the bills?

182 replies

namenamename12 · 09/04/2023 17:30

dd is 18 she finished college last year and is taking some time to decide what she wants to do, etc. since august she’s worked at a well known supermarket, earning just a bit above minimum wage and about 30 hours a week. her employer gave her a staff discount card for a family member as well as herself which was saving me quite a bit on the shopping. I still charged her £50 a month which I think is reasonable, considering she has been earning around 800 a month. She has more disposable cash than me.

well last week she’s decided to quit her job, she had a falling out with her manager and quit on the spot, she says she hated it there etc etc. tbf it was a stressful environment but she seemed to be doing okay there until recently.

so she’s quit her job, she has got a new job lined up, she’s going to work with her boyfriend at a fast food restaurant, her boyfriend has gotten her the job and she starts next week. she’s actually going to be earning less there than she was before, and tbh I think the main reason she quit was because she wanted to work with her bf. I think it’s a bad idea but she’s an adult she can do what she wants.

I’ve said to her since bills are going up and I won’t have access to the discount anymore I want her to contribute more- I’m asking for £75 a month instead of 50. Which is actually less than I would have saved with the discount etc etc. but even still, she’ll be earning upwards of 500 a month, I get she needs to save but I feel like what I’m asking isn’t unreasonable.

she’s lashed out at me and said that it’s not fair because she’s earning less why should she have to pay more, and that I’m being mean and horrible basically. when she got the job at the supermarket I said that her staff discount would count towards her contribution, but she’s saying that I’m penalising her for switching jobs🤷‍♀️

OP posts:
thegrain · 09/04/2023 18:04

I'd charge her £50 and make her buy her own food..she'll soon agree to £25

quaverface · 09/04/2023 18:04

Are you sure she's earning as little as she says she is?

According to your figures, she's been earning less than £7 in the supermarket, and now even less in the fast food place?

I'm pretty sure the big supermarket in my area pays around £10 an hour at 18, and the well known fast food plays definitely pays that as my DC works there. He does 30 hours per week and pays me £40 a week.

pussycatinfluffyslippers · 09/04/2023 18:03

When I started work (in the late 80s) my wage was £40 for 20hrs. I paid my mum and dad £25 of that - and had to pay my own Community Charge/Poll Tax Thanks Maggie

I would point out how much it will cost to rent somewhere and cover all her bills...

Strictly1 · 09/04/2023 18:02

hcarter8 · 09/04/2023 17:41

I'll never understand parents who make their children pay rent, whatever age they are it just seems odd to me. You should never charge your child for something a parent should do for free

I think it’s a parent’s job to prepare them for real life. I will charge my child (I don’t need it) and I’ll put it away for them for a house deposit but I won’t tell them. They need to learn to budget and live within their means.

Ilikewinter · 09/04/2023 18:01

100% you are being reasonable in charging her £75 a month. If she doesnt like it then tell her to buy her own food and charge her a proportion of all the other bills.

Sugarplumfairy65 · 09/04/2023 18:01

hcarter8 · 09/04/2023 17:41

I'll never understand parents who make their children pay rent, whatever age they are it just seems odd to me. You should never charge your child for something a parent should do for free

But she isn't a child

Quveas · 09/04/2023 18:00

Can I move in please? I am willing to go up to £100 a month 😀

This happened to a friend of mine a few weeks ago. He's disabled and only has ESA - his adult step-daughter (her mother is dead) works full time and has a decent if not splendid wage and has been paying £200 a month for all bills and food. He couldn't afford this so he asked her for £250 a month. She had a tantrum (really!) stormed off screaming that she couldn't afford that, and said she was moving out. I told him to tell here that would be fine, and to let him know how long that would take so he could look at claiming the single person's discount on council tax. It took her a week of house hunting to quietly start forking out £250 a month.

I should add that she has a huge studio bedroom, wi-fi, multi-room, and had spent £1300 on an iPad the week before. For those who think that a parents role is to subsidise their child living at home forever, you are doing them no favours by letting them think that adult life is about free-loading, and wants come before needs.

User639762456 · 09/04/2023 17:58

I would charge more, she has probably got a lot more disposable income than you by the sounds of it

BungleandGeorge · 09/04/2023 17:56

How many hours is she working? If she’s only earning 500 a month, it’s not very many. Her previous job was part time too. Less than £20 a week for rent and expenses is practically nothing. She needs to get back to studying or get an apprenticeship or a full time job, and pay you more rent. I don’t think you’re really doing her a favour, is she saving any of the money earned?

literalviolence · 09/04/2023 17:55

It's not rent, it's board. She is costing you a great deal more than that in food and bills so personally I'd charge more. You are definitely not being unreasonable but she is showing a significant lack of maturity. She's still young though. I'm sure she'll look back on this with horror at some point.

letsgotothebeachyay · 09/04/2023 17:55

Ps to all those commenting here - this young lady is a grown adult and she needs to start acting like one and understand that everything now costs a lot of money and she needs to contribute

Createausername1970 · 09/04/2023 17:54

But to follow on from above post, if we go out for a meal, we pay. We are going to America later this year and are paying for his travel and accommodation, but he can fund his spending money. Having him contribute to the household budget means we can afford to pay for him in other ways. He kind of gets it back, but feels good in himself for contributing in the first place.

JuicyBanana · 09/04/2023 17:54

I believe that lots of financial advisors tell you that even if you don't need the money you should charge them as it starts them with good habits of budgeting and not having their entire wage to piss up a wall.

Ask her where she thinks she can rent a room with utilities included where you also get food for £75 a month. Make her look online at Spareroom etc to see what people are charging locally to you.

Does she know how much bills are at home? Gas and electric? Water? Food for the week? The things she is consuming? Maybe she should find out.

letsgotothebeachyay · 09/04/2023 17:54

i would say “that absolutely fine, you don’t have to contribute, u don’t have to do any housework. Please allow me to assist u to find an apartment somewhere so that you may do exactly as you please.”

CheersForThatEh · 09/04/2023 17:52

Yabu and yanbu.

I think its fair to want more rent in principle....

but that you have been very unfair mentioning the discount card because it was never yours and it bringing it up now saying that she got a rent reduction for it is massively changing the goalposts. It's not up to her to make up a family shortfall, however unfair it feels that she has more take home pay.

She didnt know you were charging less because of the card (nor did you) so yabu to tell her it was effectively payout of part of her rent now.

PurpleBananaSmoothie · 09/04/2023 17:50

hcarter8 · 09/04/2023 17:41

I'll never understand parents who make their children pay rent, whatever age they are it just seems odd to me. You should never charge your child for something a parent should do for free

My mum made me pay rent because she was a single parent. Living with her as an adult that wasn’t in full time education so she lost her single person discount on council tax. Her utility bills and food bills increased with me being home. My dad stopped paying maintenance and she couldn’t afford those increases. It’s nice that you have never been in that position but not everyone is.

SeemsSoUnfair · 09/04/2023 17:50

My first wage in 1980s was around £500/month - my parents took £150 of that, but I had a lot of travel expenses to get to work (2 buses and train each way).

If she was earning £800/month then £200-£250 would not have been unreasonable.

Once out of education it is important they feel they are paying their own way and are not too comfortable that they don't aspire to more.

If she has been out of college since August and has no plans for the next academic year she is no longer considering her future, she has decided working with her bf is it for now, so now she needs to start adulting and that means paying.

Createausername1970 · 09/04/2023 17:49

When I was at home, I had to pay a third of my take home pay. My dad said a third to the household bills and food, a third to save and a third for me.

This is what I now do with DS when he is working and he is very happy with this. He knows what things cost and he knows what he likes to find in the fridge. So if he was bringing home £800 I would be looking for £250.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 09/04/2023 17:49

hcarter8 · 09/04/2023 17:41

I'll never understand parents who make their children pay rent, whatever age they are it just seems odd to me. You should never charge your child for something a parent should do for free

Eh? They are out of education and working. Why shouldn't they contribute??

Beamur · 09/04/2023 17:48

Her choices have consequences! Fair enough to change jobs but she knew her staff discount was off setting her contribution. So only fair that you charge her more..£75 is still an absolute steal for board and lodgings. I'd ask for more.
I don't see why working adult children should be given a free ride. It really doesn't teach them about the next stage of their lives - financial responsibility and self sufficiency.

FavouriteDogMug · 09/04/2023 17:47

It depends if you need the money. I don't charge my dd any rent as we don't really need the contribution and I would rather she saved it for her future. If I did need the money I would charge but I think you are being a bit petty about the discount card thing.

FavouriteDogMug · 09/04/2023 17:47

It depends if you need the money. I don't charge my dd any rent as we don't really need the contribution and I would rather she saved it for her future. If I did need the money I would charge but I think you are being a bit petty about the discount card thing.

Innocentinfamy · 09/04/2023 17:47

hcarter8 · 09/04/2023 17:41

I'll never understand parents who make their children pay rent, whatever age they are it just seems odd to me. You should never charge your child for something a parent should do for free

Not every parent is in the position to support adult children no matter how much they wish they could.

BaronessEllarawrosaurus · 09/04/2023 17:46

hcarter8 · 09/04/2023 17:41

I'll never understand parents who make their children pay rent, whatever age they are it just seems odd to me. You should never charge your child for something a parent should do for free

We're talking adults who should be covering their own costs. If they expect food on the table and laundry etc then it needs to be paid for

Devoutspoken · 09/04/2023 17:45

Hcarter8, I agree, I'd rather my kids save their money

Swipe left for the next trending thread