Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask dd to contribute more to the bills?

182 replies

namenamename12 · 09/04/2023 17:30

dd is 18 she finished college last year and is taking some time to decide what she wants to do, etc. since august she’s worked at a well known supermarket, earning just a bit above minimum wage and about 30 hours a week. her employer gave her a staff discount card for a family member as well as herself which was saving me quite a bit on the shopping. I still charged her £50 a month which I think is reasonable, considering she has been earning around 800 a month. She has more disposable cash than me.

well last week she’s decided to quit her job, she had a falling out with her manager and quit on the spot, she says she hated it there etc etc. tbf it was a stressful environment but she seemed to be doing okay there until recently.

so she’s quit her job, she has got a new job lined up, she’s going to work with her boyfriend at a fast food restaurant, her boyfriend has gotten her the job and she starts next week. she’s actually going to be earning less there than she was before, and tbh I think the main reason she quit was because she wanted to work with her bf. I think it’s a bad idea but she’s an adult she can do what she wants.

I’ve said to her since bills are going up and I won’t have access to the discount anymore I want her to contribute more- I’m asking for £75 a month instead of 50. Which is actually less than I would have saved with the discount etc etc. but even still, she’ll be earning upwards of 500 a month, I get she needs to save but I feel like what I’m asking isn’t unreasonable.

she’s lashed out at me and said that it’s not fair because she’s earning less why should she have to pay more, and that I’m being mean and horrible basically. when she got the job at the supermarket I said that her staff discount would count towards her contribution, but she’s saying that I’m penalising her for switching jobs🤷‍♀️

OP posts:
Rhondaa · 09/04/2023 19:13

shellyleppard · 09/04/2023 19:03

If you pay for your children how are they ever going to gain financial independence??? I think £75 is low!!! Children need to learn to be independent and able to work out a budget. Simples

If you demand money from them how tf will they ever save for deposits and move out?! Pay your own bills, get your kids to save and pay for their own social lives and phone etc. It's no wonder kids can't move out when their parents don't give them chance to save a few thousand first. I must remember to tell ours that the virgin bill is due next week, oh actually no I won't because that's our responsibility.

Itsallaloadofbollocks · 09/04/2023 19:10

hcarter8 · 09/04/2023 17:41

I'll never understand parents who make their children pay rent, whatever age they are it just seems odd to me. You should never charge your child for something a parent should do for free

She may be their child but she is not a child. That's why she should pay.

ClaudiaCustard · 09/04/2023 19:10

I wouldn't take money off my 18 year old I don't think.

What I would do is ensure she was now paying for her own bits and pieces, so stuff I'd previously paid for (for example, I currently pay for contact lenses, gym subscription, monthly pocket money,etc for my youngest who is 16 and that alone totals £130 a month)

I'll reduce what I pay there in my circumstances and probably have him pick up his £50 gym membership .

My approach is different with an older child - my eldest is now 24 and has her own house now but she was here until she was 23 and she earned over 30k a year in her career at that point

I charged her nothing whilst at university and I said I'd like a £50 a week food contribution once she settled into her job as she was bringing home £1800 an month

Ffsmakeitstop · 09/04/2023 19:06

My adult son pays £260 a month plus buys some of his own food,. He earns about £2000.
He has grumbled occasionally if I've mentioned putting it up so I explained it that there is 3 adults living here and how much 1/3 of every bill would be and that amount is more than I ask for.
He did give extra over winter towards the gas and electric without me asking. So explaining to reasonable adults does work. He is saving for a deposit so we compromise.
I don't look on it as making money off him just him contributing to the 20 minute showers he has daily.

Cardamoney · 09/04/2023 19:04

hcarter8 · 09/04/2023 17:41

I'll never understand parents who make their children pay rent, whatever age they are it just seems odd to me. You should never charge your child for something a parent should do for free

Seriously ? Will you still think that when they’re 40, living the life of Riley for free and you’re still working to support them?! They’ll still be your child then.

WhereYouLeftIt · 09/04/2023 19:04

You're still undercharging her at £75/month. I paid 25% of my take-home pay to my mum in dig money. If she's on £500, £125/month would be what I'd be taking from her.

shellyleppard · 09/04/2023 19:03

If you pay for your children how are they ever going to gain financial independence??? I think £75 is low!!! Children need to learn to be independent and able to work out a budget. Simples

WateryDoom · 09/04/2023 19:00

Tell her to move out. Life's not fair and she's paying a pathetic amount. Does she genuinely think that (less than) £20 a week is a fair amount to pay for board and lodge?

Adults pay their way.

Youthinkyoureuniqueyourejustastatistic · 09/04/2023 19:00

Get the bills out, sit her down and show her how much they’ve increased in the last year.
Show her how much elec/water/council tax/Netflix whatever cost each month and then look at rightmove and see what a 1 bed in a flat share is locally.

like you say, she is an adult now. She’s allowed to feel annoyed over it but she’s not allowed to take it out on you. It’s reasonable.

quaverface · 09/04/2023 18:57

Tell him to budget and save it while he is living with you?

Genius.

How on earth are these kids going to save for house deposits or rent when their parents are demanding chunks of it 🙄.

Maybe by saving some of the remaining £1400?

anerki10 · 09/04/2023 18:56

PurpleBananaSmoothie · 09/04/2023 17:50

My mum made me pay rent because she was a single parent. Living with her as an adult that wasn’t in full time education so she lost her single person discount on council tax. Her utility bills and food bills increased with me being home. My dad stopped paying maintenance and she couldn’t afford those increases. It’s nice that you have never been in that position but not everyone is.

My situation was the same. My Mum charged me half of my wage when I started earning at 18. It was about £500 a month I paid her until I moved out.

KingandIfan · 09/04/2023 18:55

hcarter8 · 09/04/2023 17:41

I'll never understand parents who make their children pay rent, whatever age they are it just seems odd to me. You should never charge your child for something a parent should do for free

There are quite a lot of adult children who do not leave home in their 30s or more and other boomerang adults who return when a relationship ends or other problems. Would you expect a single pensioner mother to still keep these middle-aged adults?

RosemaryAndTime · 09/04/2023 18:52

@Janiie Not everyone has the means to give their kids £50 every weekend for a night out and a takeaway!!! We must live in different worlds.

ilovesooty · 09/04/2023 18:50

It sounds as though she needs to understand exactly what the financial demands on the household are, and be paying quite a lot more if she intends to stay at home.

ILoveMyCaravan · 09/04/2023 18:44

My mother charged her sons the bare minimum "rent" when they were living at home. They all turned into financially abusive twats when they left home and shacked up with their poor unsuspecting gf\wife.

OhcantthInkofaname · 09/04/2023 18:44

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 09/04/2023 17:39

20% of take home pay is my sort of thinking with adult dc who are no longer in education. Especially if you are providing all food, mobile contract etc.

I would think it would be more like 40%.

Lovelynames123 · 09/04/2023 18:43

My dps didn't need the money but 20 odd years ago me and my sibling paid £50 a month each, we did both get it back to help furnish houses when we moved out. £50 20 years is very different to £50 these days, my earnings were under £5p/h!

KittyAlfred · 09/04/2023 18:43

hcarter8 · 09/04/2023 17:41

I'll never understand parents who make their children pay rent, whatever age they are it just seems odd to me. You should never charge your child for something a parent should do for free

But where do you draw the line? A friend of mine is a single Mum and her DD lives at home. She went to local uni and didn’t pay any rent. She got a degree and got a job and still didn’t pay any rent. She’s now 25, earns about £10k/year more than my friend , but still doesn’t pay a single penny toward bills, food etc. All her income is for herself, while my friend pays the rent, bills, food and so on. It’s none of my business and my friend isn’t bothered, but I feel it’s a dangerous precedent to set, unless you have some kind of ground rules in place.

strawberry2017 · 09/04/2023 18:42

Tell her good luck finding somewhere to live for £50 a month elsewhere!

SpilltheTea · 09/04/2023 18:40

£75 a month is absolutely nothing. Does she have any idea how much things cost? That's less than you probably spend just to feed her.

RaininSummer · 09/04/2023 18:40

She is well out of line. I was paying 50 a month 40 years ago.

Hidingawaytoday · 09/04/2023 18:35

softsweets · 09/04/2023 18:26

My 18yo DS has £1400 a month after he has paid us his £200 a month board - he spends it all on designer clothes, vape juice, his car and getting pissed! 🤬 I'll let him have another year of 'fun' and then I'm going to double it.

I could only dream of £1400 a month disposable income!

Madness! My parents charged me token board when I moved back home after uni - but made it very clear that if they thought I was spending it all on crap rather than saving a decent amount, they'd put it up.

Rhondaa · 09/04/2023 18:35

softsweets · 09/04/2023 18:26

My 18yo DS has £1400 a month after he has paid us his £200 a month board - he spends it all on designer clothes, vape juice, his car and getting pissed! 🤬 I'll let him have another year of 'fun' and then I'm going to double it.

I could only dream of £1400 a month disposable income!

Tell him to budget and save it while he is living with you? How on earth are these kids going to save for house deposits or rent when their parents are demanding chunks of it 🙄.

clocktock · 09/04/2023 18:34

hcarter8 · 09/04/2023 17:41

I'll never understand parents who make their children pay rent, whatever age they are it just seems odd to me. You should never charge your child for something a parent should do for free

I'll never understand parents who don't give their adult children the tools they need to live independently in the future. Understanding household costs etc is very important and most kids do not have a clue how much it costs to run a household.

My dd pays 100 a month. Buys all her own toiletries etc. 25 quid a week barely covers her food but she likes to feel that she's contributing. This family works as a team. We all chip in.

My ds left college and worked in a fast food place on minimum wage. I still took rent. He soon realised he wanted to better his employment and started an apprenticeship in a trade. If I'd just let him carry on earning just enough for his nights out and trainers, well he'd have wasted his potential imo.

Girliefriendlikespuppies · 09/04/2023 18:33

hcarter8 · 09/04/2023 17:41

I'll never understand parents who make their children pay rent, whatever age they are it just seems odd to me. You should never charge your child for something a parent should do for free

You're lucky 🤷‍♀️

I'm a single parent, once dd leaves full time education I will lose my child benefit and my discount of my council tax. I'm barely scraping by now with the cost of everything, my dd will have to contribute otherwise I will sink financially.

If I were wealthy then yes I wouldn't have to worry about it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread