Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask dd to contribute more to the bills?

182 replies

namenamename12 · 09/04/2023 17:30

dd is 18 she finished college last year and is taking some time to decide what she wants to do, etc. since august she’s worked at a well known supermarket, earning just a bit above minimum wage and about 30 hours a week. her employer gave her a staff discount card for a family member as well as herself which was saving me quite a bit on the shopping. I still charged her £50 a month which I think is reasonable, considering she has been earning around 800 a month. She has more disposable cash than me.

well last week she’s decided to quit her job, she had a falling out with her manager and quit on the spot, she says she hated it there etc etc. tbf it was a stressful environment but she seemed to be doing okay there until recently.

so she’s quit her job, she has got a new job lined up, she’s going to work with her boyfriend at a fast food restaurant, her boyfriend has gotten her the job and she starts next week. she’s actually going to be earning less there than she was before, and tbh I think the main reason she quit was because she wanted to work with her bf. I think it’s a bad idea but she’s an adult she can do what she wants.

I’ve said to her since bills are going up and I won’t have access to the discount anymore I want her to contribute more- I’m asking for £75 a month instead of 50. Which is actually less than I would have saved with the discount etc etc. but even still, she’ll be earning upwards of 500 a month, I get she needs to save but I feel like what I’m asking isn’t unreasonable.

she’s lashed out at me and said that it’s not fair because she’s earning less why should she have to pay more, and that I’m being mean and horrible basically. when she got the job at the supermarket I said that her staff discount would count towards her contribution, but she’s saying that I’m penalising her for switching jobs🤷‍♀️

OP posts:
x2boys · 10/04/2023 10:50

Rhondaa · 10/04/2023 10:20

'So, they magically stop eating food when they leave college?'

'If you're not charging them anything and they still need a meal in the middle of the day... Why would that extra food being bought cost nothing?'

Well, they buy their own when at work you see and as we aren't forking out for dinner money and all the costs that come with school and college we have a bit extra to feed our kids in the evening. Swings and roundabouts. I loathe this 'oh they're on minimum wage I'm going to charge them a third of it to live in their own family home because they need to learn!'.

Then folk wonder why they're still there 10years later.

Well first of all the Op is asking for £75/ month not a third of their wages but anyway a third seems quite reasonable they would be paying a damn, site more if they had their own place
Has it occurred to.you that not everyone is as privileged as you ,some people rely on tax credits ,ect ,I have a severely disabled child so.I can't work even though my dh, works full.time it's a low paid job ,so we get tax credits ,when my older non disabled son finish,s full time education ,tax credits for him willl.stop.but we still.have the same bills ,so yes it he's working full.time and living at home ,I will.expect him to make a contribution.

Devoutspoken · 10/04/2023 10:42

Determined, - its not a scenario I am familiar as my kids like saving money

SorePaw · 10/04/2023 10:40

FavouriteDogMug · 09/04/2023 17:47

It depends if you need the money. I don't charge my dd any rent as we don't really need the contribution and I would rather she saved it for her future. If I did need the money I would charge but I think you are being a bit petty about the discount card thing.

Why?

The discount was saving the OP a considerable amount of money on food. She said this saving was part if DD's contribution. DD Chucked in her job at the supermarket so needs to make up for the discount the Op is no longer getting 🤷🏻‍♀️

life lesson, yes you can Chuck in your job, but you still need to pay your bills.

OP has been asking for a contribution of £50 & now is asking for £75. A MONTH. That won't even cover DD's food, let alone gas/electric/water/council tax etc and NO component for rent.

@namenamename12 ask moody mare what she thinks that will cover? Then tell her what half the bills actually are, and ask her where the hell she thinks she can live cheaper and why she thinks she should have much more disposable income while you struggle to pay the bills.

I think if parents don't need the money charging board for the sake of charging board is mean, but when an earning DC has plenty of surplus income, why shouldn't they contribute if money is tight for the parent/s??

zingally · 10/04/2023 10:27

I paid £100 a month and that was the better part of 20 years ago.

Rhondaa · 10/04/2023 10:20

'So, they magically stop eating food when they leave college?'

'If you're not charging them anything and they still need a meal in the middle of the day... Why would that extra food being bought cost nothing?'

Well, they buy their own when at work you see and as we aren't forking out for dinner money and all the costs that come with school and college we have a bit extra to feed our kids in the evening. Swings and roundabouts. I loathe this 'oh they're on minimum wage I'm going to charge them a third of it to live in their own family home because they need to learn!'.

Then folk wonder why they're still there 10years later.

00100001 · 10/04/2023 10:02

Rhondaa · 10/04/2023 09:09

You save money once they leave school and college, it's easily £15 a week dinner money they £50 a month bus fare or parking once driving. So that's £120 at least that would compensate for the loss of child benefit.

The point is it wouldn't 'be for decades' they would have savings to then move out.

We should be supporting our dc to save for deposits not grabbing money off them. They pay for their own clothes obviously when working I can't remember the last time I was forking out a fortune for uniforms, shoes trainers, pe kit and going out clothes so it does all balance out. I'm not 'parent of the year' but their futures are more important than paying towards bills that are already being paid. 'Board and lodge' for kids is just crazy do some of you charge relatives when they come and stay or maybe ask for a tenner each for Sunday lunch? You know, teach folk the importance of budgeting Confused.

So, they magically stop eating food when they leave college?

If you're not charging them anything and they still need a meal in the middle of the day... Why would that extra food being bought cost nothing?

PinkyFlamingo · 10/04/2023 09:58

Reason!

PinkyFlamingo · 10/04/2023 09:58

hcarter8 · 09/04/2023 17:41

I'll never understand parents who make their children pay rent, whatever age they are it just seems odd to me. You should never charge your child for something a parent should do for free

And theye lies the twadon so many people grow up entitled!

nurseynursery · 10/04/2023 09:57

hcarter8 · 09/04/2023 17:41

I'll never understand parents who make their children pay rent, whatever age they are it just seems odd to me. You should never charge your child for something a parent should do for free

What??

determinedtomakethiswork · 10/04/2023 09:55

Devoutspoken · 09/04/2023 17:45

Hcarter8, I agree, I'd rather my kids save their money

But what if they wouldn't be saving the money? And what if the poster cannot afford to keep the now-adult child without them paying something? After all child-support and child benefits end at that age.

determinedtomakethiswork · 10/04/2023 09:53

hcarter8 · 09/04/2023 17:41

I'll never understand parents who make their children pay rent, whatever age they are it just seems odd to me. You should never charge your child for something a parent should do for free

Oh behave.

Elmo230885 · 10/04/2023 09:51

Newyearnewmeow · 10/04/2023 09:36

All these wonderful parents who say they would never charge their adult children to pay towards the household bills so they can save up to move out.
What would you do if your child doesn’t save up but instead uses their wages to go out drinking and buy whatever they fancy whenever they want so end up with zero savings and nothing left at the end of the month?
Would you still support them not paying anything?
Would you be happy to be working and paying all the utilities and for all the food that your precious child eats every day?
There they are pissing their wages up against the wall every month while you are working to pay the bills for the family.

Exactly. My parents did this with my sister. Me and my other sister both went to uni and moved out, bought our own homes etc. My middle sister stayed at home, earned money, spent years & years of money on crap with my parents never asking anything from her. DM kept saying she would then save it to return when she moved out but never did. DSis now is mid 30s and has nothing. When she eventually moved out in her late 20s she had no idea about budgeting and continue to piss her money away ending up in debt. She never pushed herself to work harder for promotion or moved to a new job as she never needed to and could blow all her money on whatever she wanted.

Personally I think taking some money is about respect from the child to the parent. I hope when my children are older that I won't need money from them so will save it up and return it but either way they will be paying something to teach them responsibility and budgeting.

countrygirl99 · 10/04/2023 09:45

DisquietintheRanks · 10/04/2023 09:15

I've never really understood why adult children can't pay a reasonable contribution towards living costs and save. I mean, there'd be less going out and fewer new clothes or expensive IT but that's life isn't it?

Quite. If they can't save with a £50 a week contri to their own food etc they aren't going to save without one.

x2boys · 10/04/2023 09:44

Newyearnewmeow · 10/04/2023 09:36

All these wonderful parents who say they would never charge their adult children to pay towards the household bills so they can save up to move out.
What would you do if your child doesn’t save up but instead uses their wages to go out drinking and buy whatever they fancy whenever they want so end up with zero savings and nothing left at the end of the month?
Would you still support them not paying anything?
Would you be happy to be working and paying all the utilities and for all the food that your precious child eats every day?
There they are pissing their wages up against the wall every month while you are working to pay the bills for the family.

This is mumsnet land so all the adult children will be working hard in their chosen careers to earn six figures before they are thirty ,they won't be doing anything so common as going out on the piss!😂

countrygirl99 · 10/04/2023 09:43

Rhondaa · 10/04/2023 08:45

'Paying for working adults to live and eat for free isn't a bill...'

They're your kids. Let them save for their future and pay your own bills.

Presumably they eat food, use electricity/gas/water? Are they not the adult DCs bills, nit the parents?

Skybluepinky · 10/04/2023 09:41

When I started work I paid 1/3 of wages, so sounds like u r under charging her.

PurpleBananaSmoothie · 10/04/2023 09:40

@CrapBucket I’m a bastard because I wanted to go back to work after 6 months of maternity leave, formula fed DD and if the opportunity arose I would definitely leave her with family for a few nights before she turns 21. As I’ve said upthread I didn’t end up paying my mum rent because I moved out. However, we moved to DH’s parents flat. They definitely didn’t need the money but we still paid rent. We were both working and didn’t need subsiding by his parents. We also contributed towards the maintenance of the flat. We were still able to save and buy a house at 27 (now 33), it taught us responsibility and we were financially independent.

DH’s brother on the other hand moved in with his gf and her parents and paid no rent. He’s 31 and pisses money away, hasn’t bought a house and is unlikely to buy a house. He also makes a series of their bad decisions. There is probably more to it than just paying rent to parents (or in-laws) but I don’t think he was ever forced to face adult responsibilities and I don’t think it’s helped him. So even if you didn’t need it, I don’t think there’s anything wrong with charging rent.

Newyearnewmeow · 10/04/2023 09:36

All these wonderful parents who say they would never charge their adult children to pay towards the household bills so they can save up to move out.
What would you do if your child doesn’t save up but instead uses their wages to go out drinking and buy whatever they fancy whenever they want so end up with zero savings and nothing left at the end of the month?
Would you still support them not paying anything?
Would you be happy to be working and paying all the utilities and for all the food that your precious child eats every day?
There they are pissing their wages up against the wall every month while you are working to pay the bills for the family.

Tourmalines · 10/04/2023 09:36

hcarter8 · 09/04/2023 17:41

I'll never understand parents who make their children pay rent, whatever age they are it just seems odd to me. You should never charge your child for something a parent should do for free

When does it stop ? My son lived at home till he was 30 . He earned more than us . He started work at 18. I never charged rent as such but just a small contribution to living expenses each week . For him to have remained living at home without any sort of contribution would have been absolutely ludicrous.

RocketIceLollie · 10/04/2023 09:25

£75 is really not unreasonable. It's just over two quid a day really for electric to power all her gadgets, water, food, heat, etc. I'd put it across to her like that.

whowhatwerewhy · 10/04/2023 09:23

"You save money once they leave school and college, it's easily £15 a week dinner money they £50 a month bus fare or parking once driving. So that's £120 at least that would compensate for the loss of child benefit "

No sorry I never saved money once mine left education. Both had there child benefit as lunch money and both walked or went the free college bus .

DD went straight to an apprenticeship from school, she walked or paid for the bus and I collected her at night as no busses were running, extra petrol for me .
DS left college and works in retail, but he does late shifts so is now in all day so the heating is sometimes on just for him .
So no money saved in this house.

User639762456 · 10/04/2023 09:20

MN is obsessed with saving for deposits from about 16/18, never see it much in RL though

x2boys · 10/04/2023 09:17

Rhondaa · 10/04/2023 09:09

You save money once they leave school and college, it's easily £15 a week dinner money they £50 a month bus fare or parking once driving. So that's £120 at least that would compensate for the loss of child benefit.

The point is it wouldn't 'be for decades' they would have savings to then move out.

We should be supporting our dc to save for deposits not grabbing money off them. They pay for their own clothes obviously when working I can't remember the last time I was forking out a fortune for uniforms, shoes trainers, pe kit and going out clothes so it does all balance out. I'm not 'parent of the year' but their futures are more important than paying towards bills that are already being paid. 'Board and lodge' for kids is just crazy do some of you charge relatives when they come and stay or maybe ask for a tenner each for Sunday lunch? You know, teach folk the importance of budgeting Confused.

Don't be ridiculous,£75 is hardly going to.prevent an adult child from saving up leaving home ,it barely scratched the surface of everyday bills ,not having to.pay any bills however might make adult children want to.stay home for much longer ,I'm not sure why you would equate this to.charging relative ,s money when they come for lunch it's not at all.comparable .

DisquietintheRanks · 10/04/2023 09:15

I've never really understood why adult children can't pay a reasonable contribution towards living costs and save. I mean, there'd be less going out and fewer new clothes or expensive IT but that's life isn't it?

Rhondaa · 10/04/2023 09:09

00100001 · 10/04/2023 08:53

Again, if you're happy to pay for 3 adults to live for free in your house for possibly decades..
then great, have a medal, you're the best parent ever.

You save money once they leave school and college, it's easily £15 a week dinner money they £50 a month bus fare or parking once driving. So that's £120 at least that would compensate for the loss of child benefit.

The point is it wouldn't 'be for decades' they would have savings to then move out.

We should be supporting our dc to save for deposits not grabbing money off them. They pay for their own clothes obviously when working I can't remember the last time I was forking out a fortune for uniforms, shoes trainers, pe kit and going out clothes so it does all balance out. I'm not 'parent of the year' but their futures are more important than paying towards bills that are already being paid. 'Board and lodge' for kids is just crazy do some of you charge relatives when they come and stay or maybe ask for a tenner each for Sunday lunch? You know, teach folk the importance of budgeting Confused.