Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I wrong to cut contact with parents?

84 replies

Usernamenoavailable · 09/04/2023 17:25

As the title says I have cut contact with my parents.

I don’t want to drip feed but this is a long story so I will try to keep it short.

As a child I was neglected, left to fend for myself, my parents were emotionally and mentally abusive towards me, my father went from job to job so we barely had any money, no food, no gas or electricity in the house. We often ate in the dark or by candlelight. As a child I often felt unloved and would act out to get some sort of attention.

I admit I was an unruly teenager, there was no consequences for my behaviour, I was told I would learn from my own mistakes. There was no push for me to go to school, to get a good job or try and better myself. As a result of no consequences I fell in with a bad crowd, got pregnant as a young teen and couldn’t afford to leave my parents home. So I felt stuck for years.

In recent years I pushed myself to get a better education and I’m now in my final year of my degree, I went to night classes and got a well paying job. I saved every penny I had and moved out. My working hours were odd, I relied on them for childcare so I could start work at 7.30am. I would often have discussions with them about not letting my child do what she wanted, the exact same behaviour as I was child. She would be placed in front of the tv for hours on end and fed McDonald’s, chocolate and just general rubbish. This often fell on deaf ears and they would tell me they could do what they liked.

I found a new job, one that allows me to work from home and around my daughters school hours so no longer rely on them for childcare. This is when I decided to go low contact, see them once or twice a month for around 30/45 minutes. During this time I done some soul searching, I slowly realised that my upbringing and family life wasn’t “normal” and that I needed time to heal. So yes I wouldn’t see them for weeks on end and neither would my child.

Since moving out my child is much better behaved, our relationship has improved greatly and I feel like I can finally be the mother I have always wanted to be. I want her to have a better life, better food and travel the world.

There have been small incidents that I have not paid much attention to, just added to my long list of problems. However, in the last couple of days they have accused my partner of being abusive and controlling. They think he is the one taking me away which is so far from the truth, he has been the one to listen to me, to support me and love me the way I deserve to be loved. He adores my dd and she adores him.

I had a final conversation and told them straight that he is not the source of my problems but they were, it was me that made this decision and that I just wanted peace and happiness. I want a loving family and that was it. Since then I have blocked them on everything and cut all contact. Other family members have since reached out and think I’m wrong as my parents have claimed that time doing this has made them depressed and they feel sad all the time.

Was I wrong? Or did I do the right thing?

OP posts:
IsolatedWilderness · 10/04/2023 00:10

A lot of teens seem to be given a lot of leeway to do whatever they want. At least, that was how it seemed to me being ruled with an iron fist as a teen! Everyone else could go out and do things. I was the only one that had to be home by 9, no matter how inconvenient that was for the rest of the group. I think perhaps parents can be held responsible for lack of guidance but choices are the teens own.

I can't say if you are right or wrong to cut off your parents, though I support that sometimes it is the right thing to do. Your parents must have lived very difficult years as well. No-one really wants to live by candlelight, and in such poor circumstances, do they? Changing jobs might not have been a choice. There may be issues going on with your parents you aren't or weren't aware of. They have helped you to get ahead by allowing you at home with your child and helping you position yourself better.

I can't say if you're right or wrong. I don't know the nuances of the situation, but you do have the right to make that choice. They will have their feelings about it. Wouldn't you if your child did the same? I'm no contact with some people, so appreciate why it can be necessary. I've become more forgiving of my parents over the years and I hope my children forgive me my failings. We all have them. Maybe some counselling will help you work through some of your feelings around this issue?

WallaceinAnderland · 10/04/2023 00:05

I think it's ok to cut contact if that's what you want but I don't think it was ok to use them for childcare knowing that they will neglect the child.

goodnessgraciousmeagain · 10/04/2023 00:03

It's a very difficult situation but I would be willing to bet that if your parents neglected you, chances are that's the environment they grew up in too. That's not an excuse but maybe an explanation. It seems though that you're the one to break the cycle and that's a good thing!

However personally I'd not go NC as you may well be punishing them for something which although wrong, is a cycle they got caught up in too. However I would limit my contact and have some very firm boundaries in place. NC (for me) is really something that's for the absolute worst of the worst. But that's just me! Everyone is different.

Catsmere · 10/04/2023 00:00

Totally reasonable. I cut my father off completely for much less than this.

Moomoola · 09/04/2023 23:59

As a mum whose daughter is being persuaded to cut contact, id suggest talking to your parents. It might be difficult but there might be misunderstandings and stuff that can be resolved. It’s not fair to just suddenly cut them off without the respect of an explanation. I can tell you it’s the most devastating thing to think your child dislikes you so much but doesn’t have the basic humanity to explain so you are left hanging and not understanding what she is thinking, not getting chance to explain/ resolve and going over everything in your head day after day. It’s really really devastating.

NaturalBae · 09/04/2023 23:48

You did the best thing for your child, including breaking the cycle of abuse.

I’m NC with my Father, so I understand.

I don’t believe you used your parents for childcare, as I’m sure your indifference to your parents was gradual and has culminated in you deciding to go NC now. Ignore the posters who are berating you for going NC. They’ll never understand, especially if they’ve never had abusive parents.

Well done for going to Uni as an adult and with a young child. I did the same. None of my last two DC have met my Father.

outofthefog.website/

Somanycats · 09/04/2023 23:45

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 09/04/2023 23:29

@Usernamenoavailable Thats incredibly common. Especially after you have children of your own.

The stately homes thread is really good on here. People understand on there.

Good therapy is also worth considering, it took me a long time to unpick my childhood but I’m glad I did.

Doing right by your DD is spot on

Usernamenoavailable · 09/04/2023 23:27

It has taken me a really long time to realise that what my parents did to me wasn’t right. I swayed for a really long time and I was convinced that my upbringing was a “normal” thing, that everyone experienced what I experienced.

I know I wasn’t a perfect child, I explained that in my original post. But I realise now that I was yearning for their love, guidance and support. Something that I never received.

I don’t want my child to think that just because they are family, you have to stick by them. If this was an abusive partner or friend then yes I would do the same thing. Just because they are family does not mean that I should have to put with it.

I am trying to give my dd a better life.

OP posts:
YetMoreNewBeginnings · 09/04/2023 23:16

dottypotter · 09/04/2023 23:11

It's teaching your children that it's OK to cut family off.
They might do it you, sometimes people don't even need much of a reason.
You waited until they had looked after your children to so you could work.
If they were a bad parent just pity them. They did the best with what they had at the time.
Just love them warts and all as the saying goes.

My parents had their faults. I pitied them they didn't know any different. I loved them though and now they are passed away I missed them. To cut them off would have caused so much upset it wouldnt have been worth it.
You can still want people in your life even if they cooked up.

I doubt we were perfect children either.

I’m not the op..,

my parents were neglectful and abusive. It sounds like the OPs were too. It’s not an easy realisation so doesn’t always happen right away - in fact it’s very common for people to realise after they gave children themselves that “hang on, that’s not right…”

And in my case I’m happy if my children realise that if people abuse you you don’t have to stay in touch with them because they’re related.

Neglecting and abusing children is not “cocking” up and people who downplay and minimise it really need to wind their necks in and accept that you just don’t get it.

Walking away is teaching your children the valuable lesson of breaking the cycle of abuse.

dottypotter · 09/04/2023 23:11

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 09/04/2023 22:53

That’s such a load of nonsense.

I’d be absolutely devastated if my DC went NC with me. Then again since I’ve never neglected or abused them it wouldn’t be remotely comparable to me doing it to my parents.

Unless the OP treats her children in the way her parents treated her and her siblings theres no simple comparison

It's teaching your children that it's OK to cut family off.
They might do it you, sometimes people don't even need much of a reason.
You waited until they had looked after your children to so you could work.
If they were a bad parent just pity them. They did the best with what they had at the time.
Just love them warts and all as the saying goes.

My parents had their faults. I pitied them they didn't know any different. I loved them though and now they are passed away I missed them. To cut them off would have caused so much upset it wouldnt have been worth it.
You can still want people in your life even if they cooked up.

I doubt we were perfect children either.

HappyMe6 · 09/04/2023 23:09

Well done you! You have turned your life around which must have been really difficult at times, you have done the right thing, wishing you every happiness

ThinWomansBrain · 09/04/2023 23:02

so you sponged off your parents by living there as an adult with your child, and relied on them for free childcare - and now you've decided to go NC?
One of my neighbours took early retirement and looked after grandson 12-14 hours a day from a baby until he started school, and the all contact cut immediately by the parents who live about ten minutes walk away (in a home largely funded by the parents). The child must be about twelve now, and the GM still breaks down in tears about it whenever I speak to her.
So you didn't have the perfect parents - who did? I can see that you don't want as much contact, and there is no reason to rely on them for childcare - but to cut off all contact is harch - and what about the relationship with GPs who to date have been a large part of her life?

winningeasy · 09/04/2023 23:01

@dottypotter if they didn't abuse her she wouldn't be cutting her off, consequences have actions.

OP has made the necessary self enquiry and is creating a different life for her child, therefore very unlikely her child will cut her off.

It's very simple; don't abuse and neglect your child. If you do, expect to be cut off at some point. Sometimes it takes decades to conclude you were abused.

winningeasy · 09/04/2023 22:57

Op, the posters on this thread are not being helpful, look up FOG and post on Stately Homes.

Accepting abuse just because someone biologically parented you only perpetuates a cycle of abuse and neglect, it's ok because 'well you know you only get one Mum/Dad.'

You didn't ask to be born, you can't chose your parents and unfortunately like some of us got dealt a shit hand. Maybe they also had a shit childhood themselves, it explains why they treated you as they did but it doesn't excuse it. Everyone has a choice.

WhiteBobbin · 09/04/2023 22:56

Huge well done on turning your life around. You’ve done the right thing and owe them nothing. You need to protect your child.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 09/04/2023 22:53

dottypotter · 09/04/2023 21:51

What if your children do it too you?
If you wouldn't like it then there's your answer?

That’s such a load of nonsense.

I’d be absolutely devastated if my DC went NC with me. Then again since I’ve never neglected or abused them it wouldn’t be remotely comparable to me doing it to my parents.

Unless the OP treats her children in the way her parents treated her and her siblings theres no simple comparison

winningeasy · 09/04/2023 22:50

@girlfriend44 how dare you minimise what OP has been through!

dottypotter · 09/04/2023 21:51

What if your children do it too you?
If you wouldn't like it then there's your answer?

sweeneytoddsrazor · 09/04/2023 21:49

Where was your mother in all of this?

Starlightstarbright1 · 09/04/2023 21:47

No one here can tell if its right or wrong .

As someone who has no contact with my parents i will say its never simple or the easy option.

I still for many years craved my parents love. I still sometimes find fb with love you mum posts evoke that wanting from my own parents.

I can't tell if you have ever challenged , ever tried to find acway to be because if you can do low contact it is sometimes easier.

But you know what is right x

Iwasafool · 09/04/2023 21:40

I don't think it is wrong to go NC with people if that is what you need. I do think it seems quite calculating to use them for childcare and then when child is at school and you don't need them to start cutting yourself off. That seems like something a user would do. It also seems off to leave a vulnerable child with people you deem so unsuitable. I suppose I'm a bit on the fence.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 09/04/2023 21:37

People won’t understand you doing it. They never do. I still get grief for cutting line off even though the level of neglect and abuse was so bad we were removed to live with our grandparents.

Theres a general feeling that “you only get one mum/dad” or that you should be grateful for any of the good bits and ignore the neglect.

Do what is right for you.

And do consider proper therapy - when you start unravelling childhood neglect it can be really really difficult.

anyolddinosaur · 09/04/2023 21:33

Well done for studying and getting a better job. Not good to blame all the mistakes of your teenage years on your parents, make use of them for childcare for years and cut them off as soon as you dont need them. You may not have liked their childminding but they helped you out.

It's very ungrateful of you. You can give your child a better life without cutting all contact.

girlfriend44 · 09/04/2023 21:26

Usernamenoavailable · 09/04/2023 17:25

As the title says I have cut contact with my parents.

I don’t want to drip feed but this is a long story so I will try to keep it short.

As a child I was neglected, left to fend for myself, my parents were emotionally and mentally abusive towards me, my father went from job to job so we barely had any money, no food, no gas or electricity in the house. We often ate in the dark or by candlelight. As a child I often felt unloved and would act out to get some sort of attention.

I admit I was an unruly teenager, there was no consequences for my behaviour, I was told I would learn from my own mistakes. There was no push for me to go to school, to get a good job or try and better myself. As a result of no consequences I fell in with a bad crowd, got pregnant as a young teen and couldn’t afford to leave my parents home. So I felt stuck for years.

In recent years I pushed myself to get a better education and I’m now in my final year of my degree, I went to night classes and got a well paying job. I saved every penny I had and moved out. My working hours were odd, I relied on them for childcare so I could start work at 7.30am. I would often have discussions with them about not letting my child do what she wanted, the exact same behaviour as I was child. She would be placed in front of the tv for hours on end and fed McDonald’s, chocolate and just general rubbish. This often fell on deaf ears and they would tell me they could do what they liked.

I found a new job, one that allows me to work from home and around my daughters school hours so no longer rely on them for childcare. This is when I decided to go low contact, see them once or twice a month for around 30/45 minutes. During this time I done some soul searching, I slowly realised that my upbringing and family life wasn’t “normal” and that I needed time to heal. So yes I wouldn’t see them for weeks on end and neither would my child.

Since moving out my child is much better behaved, our relationship has improved greatly and I feel like I can finally be the mother I have always wanted to be. I want her to have a better life, better food and travel the world.

There have been small incidents that I have not paid much attention to, just added to my long list of problems. However, in the last couple of days they have accused my partner of being abusive and controlling. They think he is the one taking me away which is so far from the truth, he has been the one to listen to me, to support me and love me the way I deserve to be loved. He adores my dd and she adores him.

I had a final conversation and told them straight that he is not the source of my problems but they were, it was me that made this decision and that I just wanted peace and happiness. I want a loving family and that was it. Since then I have blocked them on everything and cut all contact. Other family members have since reached out and think I’m wrong as my parents have claimed that time doing this has made them depressed and they feel sad all the time.

Was I wrong? Or did I do the right thing?

Nobody has a perfect upbringing. Everyone just does their best there is no manual.
No such thing as a perfect upbringing.

How would you like your daughter to cut you off when she's older because that is what your teaching her.
Unnecessary and selfish imo. Just go low contact if you want but don't cut them off.

Swipe left for the next trending thread