Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I wrong to cut contact with parents?

84 replies

Usernamenoavailable · 09/04/2023 17:25

As the title says I have cut contact with my parents.

I don’t want to drip feed but this is a long story so I will try to keep it short.

As a child I was neglected, left to fend for myself, my parents were emotionally and mentally abusive towards me, my father went from job to job so we barely had any money, no food, no gas or electricity in the house. We often ate in the dark or by candlelight. As a child I often felt unloved and would act out to get some sort of attention.

I admit I was an unruly teenager, there was no consequences for my behaviour, I was told I would learn from my own mistakes. There was no push for me to go to school, to get a good job or try and better myself. As a result of no consequences I fell in with a bad crowd, got pregnant as a young teen and couldn’t afford to leave my parents home. So I felt stuck for years.

In recent years I pushed myself to get a better education and I’m now in my final year of my degree, I went to night classes and got a well paying job. I saved every penny I had and moved out. My working hours were odd, I relied on them for childcare so I could start work at 7.30am. I would often have discussions with them about not letting my child do what she wanted, the exact same behaviour as I was child. She would be placed in front of the tv for hours on end and fed McDonald’s, chocolate and just general rubbish. This often fell on deaf ears and they would tell me they could do what they liked.

I found a new job, one that allows me to work from home and around my daughters school hours so no longer rely on them for childcare. This is when I decided to go low contact, see them once or twice a month for around 30/45 minutes. During this time I done some soul searching, I slowly realised that my upbringing and family life wasn’t “normal” and that I needed time to heal. So yes I wouldn’t see them for weeks on end and neither would my child.

Since moving out my child is much better behaved, our relationship has improved greatly and I feel like I can finally be the mother I have always wanted to be. I want her to have a better life, better food and travel the world.

There have been small incidents that I have not paid much attention to, just added to my long list of problems. However, in the last couple of days they have accused my partner of being abusive and controlling. They think he is the one taking me away which is so far from the truth, he has been the one to listen to me, to support me and love me the way I deserve to be loved. He adores my dd and she adores him.

I had a final conversation and told them straight that he is not the source of my problems but they were, it was me that made this decision and that I just wanted peace and happiness. I want a loving family and that was it. Since then I have blocked them on everything and cut all contact. Other family members have since reached out and think I’m wrong as my parents have claimed that time doing this has made them depressed and they feel sad all the time.

Was I wrong? Or did I do the right thing?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
NaturalBae · 10/04/2023 13:01

When you say neglected what do you mean?

Read ‘all’ of OP’s posts again. OP’s second post answers your question:

Usernamenoavailable · Yesterday 17:58
When I say neglected I mean that they would not take care of my basic needs. My father would not wash me, feed me or change me as a baby. My sister would be the one to wake up during the night to feed me and the one night she slept through instead of waking up to feed me, my dad got angry and upset at her. Often it would fall on my sister to make sure I was ok. She is a lot older than me.

Cherrysoup · 10/04/2023 12:41

NaturalBae · 10/04/2023 00:26

I’m sure our kids won’t have any need to cut us off, if we’re good parents to them.

But it’s highly subjective. From my perspective, my parents were emotionally absent (frequently actually absent), more concerned about going to the pub/socialising than looking after me and my brother. Dad would frequently come home with his mates at stupid o’clock, all shitfaced. Mum was the only wife that would allow this so we were often woken up. She then turned to booze and I was too embarrassed to bring round friends because she would be shitfaced.

She never had time to take me to the dentist (teacher) or even for days out in the summer. Another family member took me somewhere local last year and was genuinely gobsmacked that I’d never been-mum was there and said I could have gone myself but I’d never heard of it (pre-internet) and it’s 40 minutes in the car.

Speaking to my brother recently, however, he listed all the ‘good’ things our parents did eg fed/clothed us/moved so we could go to good schools.

Were my parents ‘good’ parents? Imo (and that of most of the extended family) absolutely not but my brother (mum’s golden child) thinks it wasn’t a terrible childhood. Probably not, compared to some of the horror stories I read on here, but I think it was very poor.

I think the OP is right to cut off her parents, she is clearly resentful of her childhood. People go nc for much less, ime.

billy1966 · 10/04/2023 12:22

Well done OP for turning your life around.

You should be so proud of yourself.

Yes your parents absolutely neglected you and yet you have lifted yourself out of a tough situation.

I think you are absolutely doing the right thing for you.

Your parents chose their actions and have to accept the consequences.

I don't blame you for not wanting their influence around your child.

Moving away is a good idea.

Your sister sounds like a wonderful woman and influence.

I think her stance with your parents tells a lot.

You do not owe your parents a relationship after such neglect.

Continue to make choices that will give your child a far better start than you had.

AlexiaR · 10/04/2023 12:09

OP you have created so many opportunities for yourself and your daughter. Given your awful childhood, I would do everything to protect your new life. I would away and go either go low or no contact. You owe your parents absolutely nothing in this situation. The worry is that you stay and end up having to care for them in the future, which would not be fair on you. Please put yourself and your daughter first.

AlexiaR · 10/04/2023 11:48

girlfriend44 · 09/04/2023 21:26

Nobody has a perfect upbringing. Everyone just does their best there is no manual.
No such thing as a perfect upbringing.

How would you like your daughter to cut you off when she's older because that is what your teaching her.
Unnecessary and selfish imo. Just go low contact if you want but don't cut them off.

But the OPs parents did nothing for her growing up. They completely neglected her and her sister, neglected their basic human needs, neglected them emotionally, neglected them physically - as parents they completely failed their children in every way. She owes them absolutely nothing! Any idiot can have children, and parents are not sacred. Hope the OP goes on to have the best life for herself and daughter, as she deserves happiness, away from her shitty parents!

NaturalBae · 10/04/2023 11:28

girlfriend44 · 10/04/2023 11:16

You are still sending out the message that it's OK to cut family off though.
Estrangement is getting more and more common with younger people now so I'd be wary. It might come back and bite you on the bum etc.

Of course it’s OK to have nothing to do with family members or anyone who treats you badly! Absolutely no one needs to put up with it. It’s absolutely normal to put boundaries in place. Boundaries serve to indicate to other people what you would put up with and how they should treat you. If everyone was nice to each other, boundaries would not need to be enforced.

Really? I wonder why estrangement is becoming more and more common with younger people these days?? Be wary of what exactly? Having a happier and more peaceful existence?

I can’t believe the amount of apologists and excusers on this thread.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 10/04/2023 11:27

It's far healthier for children to know that blood / love aren't reasons to accept abusive behaviour.

Yep.

Especially as we live in a world where the number of domestic violence cases and abusive relationships has gone up and up.

herlightmaterials · 10/04/2023 11:27

Given that they're never going to understand where you're coming from, I think you did the right thing if you feel you need to. It would be different if they'd accepted low contact but going after your partner as a villain suggests they never would.

monsteramunch · 10/04/2023 11:25

@girlfriend44

You are still sending out the message that it's OK to cut family off though.

So you don't think it's ever ok to cut family off?

Even if they're abusive?

It's far healthier for children to know that blood / love aren't reasons to accept abusive behaviour.

Nanny0gg · 10/04/2023 11:24

QueenoftheNimbleFlyingCat · 09/04/2023 17:44

Have you spoken to them about your childhood and feeling unloved? Perhaps going from job to job wasn't a choice - you were poor and they may be able to shed some light on that? When you say neglected what do you mean?

From what you've said, I think talking to them about how you felt in childhood may be the first step and if you still feel the same way then NC. It is a drastic (and sometimes absolutely justified) step and if no communication has happened of course your parents will feel depressed and probably confused by it

First step to what?

She doesn't owe them a thing and the way they also treated their grandchild shows that.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 10/04/2023 11:19

girlfriend44 · 10/04/2023 11:16

You are still sending out the message that it's OK to cut family off though.
Estrangement is getting more and more common with younger people now so I'd be wary. It might come back and bite you on the bum etc.

Why is sending that message a bad thing?

I would openly tell my children that if someone is physically violent, burns them with an iron or tries to kick their front door down at 4am to cut them off.

Why would you not want your children to feel strong enough to cut off abusive people?

girlfriend44 · 10/04/2023 11:16

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 09/04/2023 23:16

I’m not the op..,

my parents were neglectful and abusive. It sounds like the OPs were too. It’s not an easy realisation so doesn’t always happen right away - in fact it’s very common for people to realise after they gave children themselves that “hang on, that’s not right…”

And in my case I’m happy if my children realise that if people abuse you you don’t have to stay in touch with them because they’re related.

Neglecting and abusing children is not “cocking” up and people who downplay and minimise it really need to wind their necks in and accept that you just don’t get it.

Walking away is teaching your children the valuable lesson of breaking the cycle of abuse.

You are still sending out the message that it's OK to cut family off though.
Estrangement is getting more and more common with younger people now so I'd be wary. It might come back and bite you on the bum etc.

winningeasy · 10/04/2023 11:10

@anyolddinosaur wow you came on here to suggest the OP is lying about her childhood? Crawl back under your rock please

Rule number one of speaking to someone who has suffered from childhood abuse or neglect; believe them, don't minimise it, don't justify it.

Intergenerational trauma can explain it but it doesn't excuse it.

Going NC is not easy, it goes against the grain, it might take years for the adult child to feel comfortable with their choice, for me, I feel like there's something wrong with me, I feel embarrassed I don't have parents, it's very awkward when anyone asks me about them, but I am getting more comfortable explaining that I am NC and for good reason. I always expect it to reflect badly on me, but I am ok with that because peace is more important to me than anything.

It took me until I was late 30s to unpick the level of childhood abuse I suffered. My dad was overtly abusive and so it easier to separate myself from him, after he ruined my wedding it was very easy to block him on every channel. For my mum it's been harder as since early twenties and separating from him, she has been softer but unfortunately since I have had kids the old toxic traits have come back and it's become obvious to me she enabled my father to abuse us all. Her whole life she has been surrounding by narcissistic/ self centred people so if she isn't herself, she certainly has very clear narc traits. I am ultra low contact with her but prob won't completely go NC, she gets bday card and Mother's Day card/flowers, some pics of her grand children she never sees every few months, but I'd never let her stay over my house again, or go to visit her. Neutral places only and very short meet ups if at all. Never speak on the phone or go out my way to contact her. She's so emotionally immature, never ever done any form of self enquiry, and I've done so much work on myself, it's been a real journey and I'm just glad I'm still alive to enjoy it.

My point is the OP was not deceitful in getting childcare or a place to stay, she just didn't have any other option (narc parents don't usually set you up to succeed trust me) and she prob wasn't self aware enough to realise that she was trapped in a dysfunctional family dynamic. It's called being enmeshed.

I think it speaks volume the other sibling is also NC / VLC and fully supportive, this often isn't the case and this shows how overt the neglect / abuse was.

NaturalBae · 10/04/2023 11:07

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 10/04/2023 10:37

We have only the OPs word for it that her parents were abusive and neglectful

Its always funny how that comes out on every thread about going NC with parents.

Parents who are wronged and being cut off unfairly are believed, but if you cut your parents off it’s one sided/only get one mum/parenting is difficult.

And people totally fail to see that it’s one of the reasons abusive people get away with things, because getting support to walk away is often nigh on impossible.

Or the “Blood is thicker than water” line is trotted out.

I had an extended family member say this about my Father until he turned on them. They are also NC with him now.

There is a massive issue with child abuse being swept under the carpet. In many cases, other adults are aware of the abuse but are actively choosing not to report it. I also work in this area.

NaturalBae · 10/04/2023 10:58

anyolddinosaur · 10/04/2023 10:34

We have only the OPs word for it that her parents were abusive and neglectful. I've known people turn on their parents for no good reason and also kids who really were abused still craving their parents love.

They may have been bad parents when she was a small child but there are always 2 sides to a story. They were there for her throughout difficult teenage years and looked after her child for her. And children who have had a bad infancy are not invariably difficult teenagers - I did and I was not. Children blame other people for their own faults, adults dont.

This is an anonymous forum, so you have to take an OP’s post on face value, unless it seems obvious that they may not be telling the truth.

Why would you automatically assume that people would lie about being abused?

Children blame other people for their own faults, adults dont.

That’s nonsense and complete denial of the truth. Of course some adults blame other people for their faults!

NaturalBae · 10/04/2023 10:50

Throwncrumbs · 10/04/2023 10:09

You will never know, some small upset turns into something big when there is injured parties. I never thought it would happen to me!

I’m sorry you’re going through that with your children, but I would not compare your situation to the OP’s.

Try talk to your children to find out exactly why they are treating you this way. It sounds like there’s much more to it.

IsolatedWilderness · 10/04/2023 10:47

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 10/04/2023 10:41

I’ve rarely seen that. Yet the level of abuse that gets “but she’s your mum/you only get one dad” is unreal.

I’ve even had someone explain to me (I have 6 kids) how difficult parenting can be and defending my father who punished my brother by burning his hand with the iron.

Apparently everyone can snap once…

That's not something I would find forgivable. I do get it though. My husband has cut off family. I often find the outsider gets blamed. Wander over to sites with estranged parents if you want to see how often the SIL or DIL gets the blame.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 10/04/2023 10:41

IsolatedWilderness · 10/04/2023 10:39

@YetMoreNewBeginnings It's interesting you say that. What I've seen is that more children who walk away get sympathy than the parents. People wonder what they did wrong to drive their child to that.

I’ve rarely seen that. Yet the level of abuse that gets “but she’s your mum/you only get one dad” is unreal.

I’ve even had someone explain to me (I have 6 kids) how difficult parenting can be and defending my father who punished my brother by burning his hand with the iron.

Apparently everyone can snap once…

IsolatedWilderness · 10/04/2023 10:39

@YetMoreNewBeginnings It's interesting you say that. What I've seen is that more children who walk away get sympathy than the parents. People wonder what they did wrong to drive their child to that.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 10/04/2023 10:37

We have only the OPs word for it that her parents were abusive and neglectful

Its always funny how that comes out on every thread about going NC with parents.

Parents who are wronged and being cut off unfairly are believed, but if you cut your parents off it’s one sided/only get one mum/parenting is difficult.

And people totally fail to see that it’s one of the reasons abusive people get away with things, because getting support to walk away is often nigh on impossible.

anyolddinosaur · 10/04/2023 10:34

We have only the OPs word for it that her parents were abusive and neglectful. I've known people turn on their parents for no good reason and also kids who really were abused still craving their parents love.

They may have been bad parents when she was a small child but there are always 2 sides to a story. They were there for her throughout difficult teenage years and looked after her child for her. And children who have had a bad infancy are not invariably difficult teenagers - I did and I was not. Children blame other people for their own faults, adults dont.

monsteramunch · 10/04/2023 10:15

@Throwncrumbs

I wasn’t abusive and neglectful. My other children cannot understand why their sibling has done this and it has caused a rift between them as well.

I'm sorry you're going through that.

But the situation you describe bears zero resemblance to that of OP, who was brought up in a neglectful environment.

If your child has cut you off unreasonably it doesn't mean that by default, children cutting off their parents is automatically unreasonable.

Your situation doesn't compare to OPs, surely you can see that?

Throwncrumbs · 10/04/2023 10:11

winningeasy · 10/04/2023 06:53

@Throwncrumbs hopefully everyone on this thread remembers not to be abusive and neglectful to their children

I wasn’t abusive and neglectful. My other children cannot understand why their sibling has done this and it has caused a rift between them as well.

Throwncrumbs · 10/04/2023 10:09

NaturalBae · 10/04/2023 00:26

I’m sure our kids won’t have any need to cut us off, if we’re good parents to them.

You will never know, some small upset turns into something big when there is injured parties. I never thought it would happen to me!

Usernamenoavailable · 10/04/2023 09:52

My sister is fully supportive of my decision and she hasn’t spoken to our father in a very long time. She is low contact with our mum. But live nearly 100 miles away. I can rely on her for everything and I would see her as more of a mother to me.

OP posts: