Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can’t decide on how to get married

37 replies

howcanIdothiss · 09/04/2023 16:03

I’m getting nowhere quickly with planning and keep reaching a brick wall with each idea.

Unfortunately my sis and MIL are quite manipulative in their own ways and I’m not confident that either or both of them would be nice on the day. We have little to do with them but there’s no way we could cherry pick our other lovely relatives and leave them out of it despite how they’ve both been. We are fairly introverted people anyway so a big day with all eyes on has never been the appeal. We also don’t like the idea of spending so much on one day and would rather put it to a holiday. No real rush to marry, but we lost an unplanned pregnancy some months back and do want to try again soon and my fiancé has said he would rather we are married first before we do

We are stuck between 2 ideas really

  1. Elope, with a good photographer, hire a hall/venue to throw an ‘engagement’ party when we get back which upon arrival people would discover is actually the wedding reception. We have my parents’ blessing to do this.

  2. Registry office locally with the people we want there, meal after then straight off to honeymoon.

We can see pros and cons to both, don’t want loved ones to miss out altogether but I do think its one of those all or nothing situations!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
greensac · 09/04/2023 20:44

We eloped! And then had a party for family when we got home.
Wedding and honeymoon absolutely wonderful, no terrible MIL who to this day 13 years later is just as terrible and we didn't really care how the party went because in our eyes we'd 'done' the wedding.

Btw side note that I always say now. I wish very much I'd married someone with a nice mother. I do love my dh but when I had dc she was so awful and still is and I truly envy those with nice MIL. I know it may not change anything but I was always taught you're not marrying his mother but I really feel like I did. She still gets to me and I'd had LTR without any sorts of drama with ex mothers in fact quite the opposite I really got on with all but MIL. My SIL also loathes her.

CelebrateAndDream · 09/04/2023 19:59

Youthinkyoureuniqueyourejustastatistic · 09/04/2023 18:35

What about doing the official stuff just you 2 + witnesses/eloping and then organising
something like a picnic on the beach/nice park so it’s a celebration but you don’t have to organise much - just invites and potentially a celebrant to do a mock ceremony.
People can bring their own picnic - you could have an ice cream van visit or something if you wanted to treat (obviously would need a wet weather contingency). (Or could be at a venue like a village hall with a nice garden.)

A lady in our village had a christening for her daughter and they got surprised married after the christening (obviously the vicar was in on it). I love that.

I officiated yesterday at a ceremony just like this 🥰 My couple wanted to avoid all the fuss and falling out often caused at a traditional 'big wedding' so did their legal paperwork with just two witnesses a couple of weeks ago. Nobody knew!

They arranged an Easter Picnic for friends and family at a local beach, and then surprised everyone with their Wedding Celebration, which I led (I'm a celebrant).

It's not a 'fake wedding' though...this is perfectly normal in most other countries (including Scotland). Just think of it as separation of the legal paperwork and the celebration of marriage...like buying a house, legally completing on the sale, then having a housewarming party to celebrate. In America and other countries, the marriage is registered before the ceremony, which is why on TV they say 'I Do' and walk straight out...the paperwork has already been signed days before.

OP...I'd go for either option...it's your day, so do it your way ♥️ Congratulations to you both xx

mamabear715 · 09/04/2023 19:36

Elope / party but for Heaven's sake invite sis / MIL - too cruel not to. If things get out of hand, you & new DH can just leave them all to it.. ;-)

Hankunamatata · 09/04/2023 19:31

I wouldn't even have a wedding reception. Just tell everyone you got married

Hankunamatata · 09/04/2023 19:30

Go on lovely holiday and get married while your there.

Swalewhale · 09/04/2023 19:27

We did option 2 but I wish we'd just eloped to be honest. Don't try and do a half arsed event to make other people happy, you can't please everyone, just elope.

And sorry for your loss Flowers

trevthecat · 09/04/2023 19:06

We eloped. Was the best decision for us. We had a party after. Was about 8 weeks after due to covid restrictions. We had the best day, no drama, was just about us.

Kranke · 09/04/2023 18:44

Viviennemary · 09/04/2023 16:24

Eloping is ridiculous unless you are both 16. Just have a wedding and put up with annoying folk. Everyone else has to.

No they don’t, are you 16?! I think what’s more ridiculous is to start off your married life with a day you don’t want, just to please other people. We eloped, everyone was happy for us. We’re lucky our family members are lovely, reasonable and respectful people. We chose our friends so no luck required there.

We had the best week of our life, great wedding (we hired a photographer who doubled as a witness). Had a fancy meal, and as we were abroad it was our honeymoon too. I have great memories from that day, would do the same again in a heartbeat.

strawberry2017 · 09/04/2023 18:39

Elope. It's the easiest one.

shelbaba · 09/04/2023 18:36

I'd do option one of ur 2 options def. It's your wedding don't worry about anyone else. Sounds fun!

Youthinkyoureuniqueyourejustastatistic · 09/04/2023 18:35

What about doing the official stuff just you 2 + witnesses/eloping and then organising
something like a picnic on the beach/nice park so it’s a celebration but you don’t have to organise much - just invites and potentially a celebrant to do a mock ceremony.
People can bring their own picnic - you could have an ice cream van visit or something if you wanted to treat (obviously would need a wet weather contingency). (Or could be at a venue like a village hall with a nice garden.)

A lady in our village had a christening for her daughter and they got surprised married after the christening (obviously the vicar was in on it). I love that.

Absy88 · 09/04/2023 18:28

We're doing option 2. Registry office and meal after (just parents and sibling and 1 friend each).
Then booking a party for in a couple month but it won't be a formal do with seating plans and that

Paperbagsaremine · 09/04/2023 18:25

howcanIdothiss · 09/04/2023 16:29

Do they?

No.
I know one couple who (increasingly annoyed by their wretched relatives) canned the Normal Sized Wedding and went down the registry office with the two relatives who weren't interfering misery guts.

Another two or three couples I know got hitched paperwork only, and had no celebration, one lot never even told anyone (we knew as we were helping with legal stuff, but were asked to keep schtum).

Various other lots "semi-eloped" to somewhere far away with eg parents only.

JacobsCrackersCheeseFogg · 09/04/2023 18:24

Option 2, which is the wedding I wanted. Instead I got everyone, and I could tell who was there simply for a free lunch! Do what's right for you.

UsingChangeofName · 09/04/2023 18:19

Does Option 2 include your sister , and your MiL ?
As that affects my opinion on which option.

Wherethewind · 09/04/2023 18:14

CheersForThatEh · 09/04/2023 18:09

Bullshit. We have lovely family and eloped as marriage was a financial decision and not a cause for a celebration. We still haven't told family even though they would be overjoyed and we have been married for years now.

Explain to me why my carefully weighed up financial decision is ridiculous?

🤣🤣🤣

CheersForThatEh · 09/04/2023 18:12

Do option 2 and keep it short and small so noone gets bent out of shape over wedding food and outfits and noone has time to get pissed and start a fight.

CheersForThatEh · 09/04/2023 18:09

Viviennemary · 09/04/2023 16:24

Eloping is ridiculous unless you are both 16. Just have a wedding and put up with annoying folk. Everyone else has to.

Bullshit. We have lovely family and eloped as marriage was a financial decision and not a cause for a celebration. We still haven't told family even though they would be overjoyed and we have been married for years now.

Explain to me why my carefully weighed up financial decision is ridiculous?

CheersForThatEh · 09/04/2023 18:06

For you....Option 2.

We married with 2 witnesses and went for food after. No outfits, photographers, chain restaurant after. We even caught the bus because our car was broken. It was gloriously naff! And no fuss. A photographer, fancy outfits...it would have felt awkward and embarrassing for a no-fuss marriage.

I think deep down you would resent the photos and decision on some level knowing that you felt you had to do it that way because of your MIL &SIL and you missed out on having your nice family there.

Aprilx · 09/04/2023 17:59

howcanIdothiss · 09/04/2023 16:55

Would you include MIL and sister in option 2, do you think?

You cannot are surely not going to miss your grooms mother off the invitation list are you? And yes not inviting your sister is pretty awful too. If you really cannot stand the idea of either of them being there, then you need to just go off and get married the two of you with two witnesses. But I wouldn’t bother with the party afterwards, just leave it at that.

FinallyHere · 09/04/2023 17:52

Registry office locally with just the people we want there

This seems a tad harsh on MiL, who I'm guessing would not be invited.

I'd go for a totally private just the two of you registry office. Tell no one, use witnesses off the street or even Mumsnet. Go out to lunch afterwards just the two of you or straight on honeymoon holiday.

Let everyone know as soon as you land. Let them get their drama out of the way while you are away.

Why throw a party at all?

Buy yourselves something that you both really love to remind you of a happy day. Simples.

BonnieBairn · 09/04/2023 17:11

Our wedding was 2020 so there were still restrictions in place. My second marriage, husbands first. We chose a registry office and luckily it was priced for a party under 10 or over 10. We chose the under 10 so my folks, his folks and my kids. No ambiguity. Then we just had a party. Put on food and some drinks and said to folk if they wanted to get pissed then it was byob. There are people I'd have loved to see me get married like my uncle and my brothers but the numbers helped us be very restrictive, esp as my OH has brothers too so then it just spirals. Our wedding was the best Ive ever been to

Vallmo47 · 09/04/2023 17:09

Married recently with just our two kids and our parents (one from each side, the others deceased) as witnesses. It was truly magical - the registrars were amazing, they knew exactly how to make a rather large room feel small and intimate. The guests who weren’t present were allowed to see videos after and as everyone was treated the same no one minded (too much). We threw a lovely little get together the same evening and had some beautiful photos done in the hotel we were staying in the night.
I do love your other option but I must admit you run the risk of a few people not being able to hide their disappointment at you already being married and that will take away from your celebrations on the evening. I’d come back and tell everyone you have married and when you invite them to an evening do, that’s the olive branch. :) But at the end of the day, most people do understand it’s your day to do with as you wish. Good luck

Gingergirl70 · 09/04/2023 17:08

Viviennemary · 09/04/2023 16:24

Eloping is ridiculous unless you are both 16. Just have a wedding and put up with annoying folk. Everyone else has to.

Why is eloping ridiculous? And why do they HAVE to have a wedding with annoying people because every other married couple in the world had to? What an absolute bizarre comment/opinion. Talk about ridiculous 🙄

Blanketpolicy · 09/04/2023 17:04

If someone falls out with you over that, then imo they're not worth having around!

Agree but you won't know who those people might be, and noone wants that and the under current it might cause, at their celebration, especially where drink is likely to be involved.