Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Vanish Supporting Autism Advert

213 replies

Tealsofa · 09/04/2023 15:15

I don't normally watch terrestrial TV, but watching the voyage of the dawn treader on C4, and the advert for vanish keeps coming up.

It looks like a deep meaningful maybe a charity or awareness advert, and then it's "vanish" a cleaning product

My ds (autistic) was also wtf about it

OP posts:
WinnipegDink · 10/04/2023 09:29

AgrathaChristie · 10/04/2023 09:23

That’s an ad for a cleaning product? It was on this morning, didn’t have my glasses on so couldn’t read the script at the end on small bedroom tv. I assumed it was for a mental health support charity.
Sorry, it went completely over my head.

Well that's a shame because reading your contribution I suspect you would have benefitted greatly from paying closer attention.

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 10/04/2023 09:28

Tarantullah · 10/04/2023 09:16

I'm not sure why this advert has to be the best that can be done, why when a company sensitively and accurately depicts and gives a platform to an underrepresented and often misunderstood segment of society does it have to be a higher bar than other adverts? I don't see the issue with them 'blowing their own trumpet' either, some people like to choose which companies they spend their money on wisely, why shouldn't they promote that they have taken action to be more inclusive?

I think it shouldn’t really be an advert at all, to be honest. They could sponsor an awareness-raising campaign and just have a little logo at the end saying ‘sponsored by vanish in collaboration with ambitious about autism etc’ Then they get some credit but it’s not all about their (frankly rubbish) product. But the idea of leaving it to commercial forces to determine who is represented is pretty upsetting as a concept altogether.

Those awards make me suspicious because, without knowledge of those particular awards, I know that many such schemes depend on companies nominating themselves -ie thinking they’re great- rather than an objective body noticing them doing it well.

Turquoisesilver · 10/04/2023 09:28

That wasn’t just winding up and bickering. That was one sibling completely controlled and dominated by the other.

BoojaBooj2 · 10/04/2023 09:27

Turquoisesilver · 10/04/2023 09:20

I’m not intending to be unnecessarily argumentative here, but you did reply saying you were ‘disappointed’ with the comments on the thread, @user1471530109 and at that point there were only five posts (including the OP.)

I don’t think anyone doubts siblings have a really strong bond, but like any relationship, it doesn’t mean this bond is rooted in respect or is always positive. I suppose that’s my worry, from that advert: you take away someone spends their life being quiet, walking on eggshells, having to apologise for existing - that’s not setting someone up for a healthy adult life, at all.

Working on the assumption that it’s fine because of the positives actually make it even more uncomfortable for me, because those positives are borne in views that are quite toxic to women.

It is probably less problematic in families where there is a boy and a girl and the girl is the one with autism, or two boys.

I know I’m saying things that are uncomfortable in themselves but I don’t think this means they shouldn’t be said.

Lol I agree with you. In families with multiple autistic kids like mine (with conflicting needs) there is no NT sibling to pushover and shut up at the expense of the other :) so you do have to work hard to accommodate both.

As an autistic person it’s lucky I was an only child. I try hard as a mother because I have to. But the unwritten rule about autistic people it’s all about others ‘accepting and adapting’… nope the biggest problem is when there are lots of us in a room together.

kittensinthekitchen · 10/04/2023 09:27

I don’t think anyone doubts siblings have a really strong bond, but like any relationship, it doesn’t mean this bond is rooted in respect or is always positive. I suppose that’s my worry, from that advert: you take away someone spends their life being quiet, walking on eggshells, having to apologise for existing - that’s not setting someone up for a healthy adult life, at all.

@Turquoisesilver

I disagree. I think it highlighted that siblings have complicated relationships, and that's no different with a sibling with autism. There is always going to be situations where they wind each other up, bicker and get upset but that, ultimately, whilst siblings can and do do things to 'get at' each other, but sometimes do the wrong thing, but they do have each others back.
It shows that mistakes can be made, and apologies can be made.

gogohmm · 10/04/2023 09:27

@user1471530109

It's is so accurate it's uncanny. My dd2 had sent me the link yesterday. Dd1 (autistic) doesn't like they are selling things by tugging at heart strings. We think it's a useful portrayal of female autism

BoojaBooj2 · 10/04/2023 09:25

Autistic woman here, adult diagnosed.
Representation is great and all, but they just HAD to go with the trope of autistic people having special talents, eh? The girl’s clever and great at drawing. Yes I know she’s a real autistic girl but still.
Nobody cares about the rest of us who are shit at everything we touch.

Whatafustercluck · 10/04/2023 09:24

I think it's brilliant, and I totally understood the premise. I am currently washing the same items of clothing day in, day out, for my own 6yo dd. When she is anxious she has extreme tactile defensiveness (clothing) and also needs things to be the same. Having her favourite jumper dirty and in the wash completely ruins her day (and ours). So many similarities with my family's daily life - including the sibling walking on egg shells and having some natural resentment.

AgrathaChristie · 10/04/2023 09:23

That’s an ad for a cleaning product? It was on this morning, didn’t have my glasses on so couldn’t read the script at the end on small bedroom tv. I assumed it was for a mental health support charity.
Sorry, it went completely over my head.

kittensinthekitchen · 10/04/2023 09:21

NurseCranesRolodex · 10/04/2023 09:12

If its a real family the meltdown scenes massively compromise the yp's GDPR so doubt that aspect. It definitely seems to portray PDA though, which may be helpful as its so misunderstood.

What personal data did they give out against the yps consent? Confused

And which parts of the PDA criteria do you think were there? Has this young woman been diagnosed with PDA?

Turquoisesilver · 10/04/2023 09:20

I’m not intending to be unnecessarily argumentative here, but you did reply saying you were ‘disappointed’ with the comments on the thread, @user1471530109 and at that point there were only five posts (including the OP.)

I don’t think anyone doubts siblings have a really strong bond, but like any relationship, it doesn’t mean this bond is rooted in respect or is always positive. I suppose that’s my worry, from that advert: you take away someone spends their life being quiet, walking on eggshells, having to apologise for existing - that’s not setting someone up for a healthy adult life, at all.

Working on the assumption that it’s fine because of the positives actually make it even more uncomfortable for me, because those positives are borne in views that are quite toxic to women.

It is probably less problematic in families where there is a boy and a girl and the girl is the one with autism, or two boys.

I know I’m saying things that are uncomfortable in themselves but I don’t think this means they shouldn’t be said.

Xrays · 10/04/2023 09:16

VegetableGyoza · 10/04/2023 08:52

Fabulous. ❤️

Tarantullah · 10/04/2023 09:16

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 10/04/2023 09:08

Interesting… I might cut vanish a little more slack if their product had ever worked on the clothes my DC have ‘ruined’.

I can imagine that the campaign is coming from a well-intentioned place, and the awareness-raising is valuable, but the ‘vanish fixed it’ happy ending is so trite. Vanish barely touched the sides of all the stuff going on for that family. They also preface it with a note about the awards they’ve won for diversity in advertising which is more blowing their own trumpet, it’s not necessary for the campaign.

Ultimately I think, however accurate the representation might be in the space of three minutes, we’re setting a pretty low bar if this advert is the best that can be done.

I'm not sure why this advert has to be the best that can be done, why when a company sensitively and accurately depicts and gives a platform to an underrepresented and often misunderstood segment of society does it have to be a higher bar than other adverts? I don't see the issue with them 'blowing their own trumpet' either, some people like to choose which companies they spend their money on wisely, why shouldn't they promote that they have taken action to be more inclusive?

Xrays · 10/04/2023 09:15

Ds is 11 and has fairly severe autism in that he attends an autism specific specialist school. I have autism. His dad has autism. The only one in our family who doesn’t have autism is dd aged 20 (different Dad). We all love the advert. Ds actually sat and watched it from beginning to end when it came on which is very unlike him and it’s very close to how he behaves. I think it’s great to raise awareness like this.

fairgame84 · 10/04/2023 09:15

I thought it was pretty accurate.
I don't see how it's any different from the McCain Family Fund adverts.

NurseCranesRolodex · 10/04/2023 09:12

VegetableGyoza · 10/04/2023 08:15

I think I read somewhere that the Autistic Girls Network were consulted about it too. Also I think it’s a real family.

it made me cry, it’s so accurate. That was also the consensus amongst my support group for parents with PDAers. It really struck a chord with many of us.

If its a real family the meltdown scenes massively compromise the yp's GDPR so doubt that aspect. It definitely seems to portray PDA though, which may be helpful as its so misunderstood.

user1471530109 · 10/04/2023 09:12

@Turquoisesilver I don't think anyone on here has said that at all. You are imagining that people are thinking that. Every parent of a DC with an autistic sibling knows how awful it is for them. It can be pretty horrific for everyone involved.

But it's not all bad. I think the advert does well to show the bond the sisters have. My two will always stick up for each other against 'outsiders'. My non autistic DD goes to great lengths to defend her sister to others. She also shows enormous empathy to others. I am very proud of the way she tries to include any child left out.
I think we have interpreted the advert very differently. This advert to me is about the whole family. I think it does that very well.

Tarantullah · 10/04/2023 09:11

It's tricky isn't it, my brother is autistic and growing up mine and my other siblings life largely revolved around him, but similarly I love him dearly and can't imagine life without him. Its complex imo, very challenging at the time and having had therapy as an adult can see the impact on my behaviours, outlook on life and other things; but it's also not their fault and whilst you can do things to mitigate the negative effects on siblings you cannot completely eradicate them. I do think it's important to be able to talk about, but appreciate sensitivity is important as it can be hurtful and harmful for those who cannot help how they are.

I like the advert.

IScreamAtMichaelangelos · 10/04/2023 09:10

Just watched it. The tie in with Vanish at the end was a bit clunky I thought, but I liked the rest of it (autistic adult with autistic child here).

WinnipegDink · 10/04/2023 09:10

Good God. Some of the responses on this thread. I think quite frankly if the ignorance displayed by some of the posters here demonstrates anything it's that this advert should be compulsory viewing, whether it's a sales advert or not.

And to the poster whose contribution is - if I want to know about autism in girls then I'll ask someone who knows - if you had already done that (asked someone who knows) then you'd likely understand the ad. You clearly haven't. Which is why IMO the advert is welcome.

These are our girls. It's important. And it's accurate. Watch it properly.

FrancescaContini · 10/04/2023 09:09

@kittensinthekitchen I saw it a few evenings ago as an short ad between programmes, not as a three and a half minute standalone piece. I didn’t realise when I saw it that the girl was autistic. My WTF? reaction to it was as I saw it at the time, with no prior knowledge of it.

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 10/04/2023 09:08

Interesting… I might cut vanish a little more slack if their product had ever worked on the clothes my DC have ‘ruined’.

I can imagine that the campaign is coming from a well-intentioned place, and the awareness-raising is valuable, but the ‘vanish fixed it’ happy ending is so trite. Vanish barely touched the sides of all the stuff going on for that family. They also preface it with a note about the awards they’ve won for diversity in advertising which is more blowing their own trumpet, it’s not necessary for the campaign.

Ultimately I think, however accurate the representation might be in the space of three minutes, we’re setting a pretty low bar if this advert is the best that can be done.

Turquoisesilver · 10/04/2023 09:02

I don’t think we are disagreeing so much as our sympathies perhaps lying in different places, @user1471530109 . One of the big problems with growing up alongside a disability is that the disability takes absolute priority, 24/7, and in cases like this, and especially where the sibling is a girl, it can set up a sort of pattern for life that can be very difficult to get out of.

As I say, I don’t have any easy answers here, but I do think it’s telling that as soon as someone says something along the lines of ‘wow that poor girl’ (meaning the sister) they are told not to.

Moredarkchocolateplease · 10/04/2023 09:01

I've just watched it, floods of tears. DS13 is autistic and whilst his behaviours are not the same as the girl in the ad, the motivations behind those behaviours are similar. Especially the dragging of feet in the morning and then being ready to go out the door at the exact minute we need to 😁

Ironically our current battle with DS is washing his clothes, he wants to wear them as long as possible so they are comfy and worn in. I already use the tumble dryer to make them soft, I am considering using fabric softener which I hate and washing his clothes separately.

So the ad works for me. If it shows just a little bit of how difficult family life can be to people who wouldn't normally know as they don't have that experience.

I also have an autistic neice who is very far from the girl on the ad, and I know that my nieces family life is horrific by comparison.

This stuff all helps I think.

VegetableGyoza · 10/04/2023 08:52

I meant to say an autistic girl not an autistic