Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Vanish Supporting Autism Advert

213 replies

Tealsofa · 09/04/2023 15:15

I don't normally watch terrestrial TV, but watching the voyage of the dawn treader on C4, and the advert for vanish keeps coming up.

It looks like a deep meaningful maybe a charity or awareness advert, and then it's "vanish" a cleaning product

My ds (autistic) was also wtf about it

OP posts:
fUNNYfACE36 · 10/04/2023 10:34

Poor lily.why do the parents indulge Ashley's every whim and let her rude roughshod over Lily.This is setting Lily up to accept abusive behaviour.

spring78 · 10/04/2023 10:34

user1471530109 · 10/04/2023 08:00

OP, have you watched the whole 3.5 minute advert? I'm a bit shocked by your take on it as a parent to an autistic ds?

Yes, pp, you feel sorry for the sister. My other DD has the same and it is definitely walking on egg shells. But she loves her dsis and would defend her to the hilt. I don't for a second think you're not supposed to feel sorry for her.

This advert made me cry. That girl reminded me so much of my DD. The morning scene is my morning before school....on a good day. My DD is nowhere near as good as communicating as the young lady in the advert though. The advert is a short glimpse into how overwhelming general life can be for someone with autism and the impact on their family. I thought it was very well done.

I'm quite sad about the comments on this thread. Quite surprised. Maybe I need to lower my expectations.

This - makes me sad that people don't see it

WinnipegDink · 10/04/2023 10:30

@FrancescaContini I'm not at all sorry I upset you though Grin

WinnipegDink · 10/04/2023 10:28

@Mycathatesmecuddling thank you for explaining. I am not dismissing your disability. I was explaining that I found PP's tone dismissive and that's what I responded to, not the fact that they didn't have their glasses on.

In much the same I suppose as you found my tone dismissive and responded. Rightly so. I'm sorry to have upset you.

RedToothBrush · 10/04/2023 10:27

I am sick of products being sold off the back of virtue signaling and awareness training.

I think it's exploitative tbh and I don't think it really helps awareness. It plays to already sympathetic audiences but alienates others - and the danger in that is active backlash.

So it gets cash out of people going 'ooo look at the poor people how wonderful are vanish' when vanish could actually have a really piss poor track record of employment for autism. We don't actually know.

The likes of energy companies have been criticised for adverts that promote green ideas but many have been shown to merely be running 'greenwashing' campaigns to improve their public imagine rather than their being substance to them.

I'm deeply skeptical of advertisers who jump on bandwagons rather than focusing on their product tbh. Is there product really that good, if they have to draw focus away from it? Is the branding worth the extra over the own brand alternative?

FrancescaContini · 10/04/2023 10:27

WinnipegDink · 10/04/2023 10:11

No I don't. I'm just tired of ignorance.

There are people responding to this thread who have plenty of close experience of DC with autism, and people who have zero.

Those with zero experience aren’t necessarily ignorant or uncaring about children with autism and its effects on other family members but perhaps they have other things going on in their lives, perhaps they genuinely dislike commercial companies jumping onto an issue (Vanish don’t actually care about people with autism, you know: they are looking for the best way to maximise their profits by shoehorning “social issues” into their advertising), perhaps they don’t like being lectured at, perhaps they watch TV in the evening to as escapism and to switch off after a difficult day, perhaps they simply don’t give a shit - and why should they?

Please don’t tell posters about how they would benefit from watching the ad - it’s patronising.

Mycathatesmecuddling · 10/04/2023 10:24

WinnipegDink · 10/04/2023 10:19

Don't be so disingenuous. The tone of the poster was incredibly dismissive - even after coming onto a thread that explained in great detail what it was about.

Dismissing about it being an advert by vanish, not about autism

I'm not being disingenuous I'm being absolutely sincere especially when talking about a disability I have. The fact that you think I'm pretending to be insincere about it is actually quite distressing

Tessisme · 10/04/2023 10:23

Namechangeforthis189 · 10/04/2023 09:41

I really really really dislike it. I have two children with autism and learning disabilities, one of whom I can only dream of being as functioning as the girl in the advert.

It’s always the same ‘type’ of autism shown in these adverts. Functioning, quirky, with some difficulties meant to tug at the heartstrings but nothing too extreme. Show me an advert with a non verbal, incontinent fifteen year old who frequently eats mud, sand and frankly her own faeces then maybe I’ll change my mind.

They’re trying to be inclusive but only as far as what’s palatable for the general public. Autism goes much further than sensory issues regarding clothes. I’m fed up of only one specific subset of autism being shown.

But Vanish is a clothes cleaning product, so the emphasis here is on sensory issues around clothing. I don't think anyone is suggesting for one minute that it's all there is to autism. It wouldn't be particularly relevant to this discussion if everyone was to give a long list of all the difficulties their autistic child faces day to day. It's a snapshot which captures a certain aspect of autism and, judging by the number of posters who have admitted to crying after watching it, it resonates on a very raw level. Just because life is even harder for some, doesn't mean that the difficulties faced by others shouldn't be highlighted and/or discussed. I also think dismissing the autistic girl as 'functioning, quirky with some difficulties' is astoundingly presumptuous.

WinnipegDink · 10/04/2023 10:19

Mycathatesmecuddling · 10/04/2023 10:17

Not understanding the advert was by vanish doesn't mean that poster is ignorant about autism

She said that she thought it was from a mental health charity, because the bit about it being vanish was written on the screen and not spoken, and she couldn't read the screen at the time

As someone visually impaired I also wouldn't be able to read the writing on the screen in all situations.

Me not realising its for vanish does not make me less aware of autism

Given the poster seemed to have understood the advert apart from the vanish part you only seem annoyed that she is ignorant that vanish created the advert, a very odd thing to be annoyed about

But just to be clear, being unable to read the writing on a TV screen doesn't make someone ignorant, unless you think all visually impaired people are ignorant?

Don't be so disingenuous. The tone of the poster was incredibly dismissive - even after coming onto a thread that explained in great detail what it was about.

user1471530109 · 10/04/2023 10:18

I agree that there are others on the spectrum that need their voices heard. The Chris Packham film a few weeks ago made some headway with this, especially with the non verbal young man. I have a close friend whose DS is non-verbal, incontinent and other medical needs. I can't imagine how difficult life is for her family. But equally, she struggles to see mine despite us being close.

This advert was highlighting the struggles of autism in girls. I think the labelling of 'autism spectrum' is the problem here. But that's a thread/topic done to death.

@Turquoisesilver I'm glad you acknowledge I have no real choice in this. But I wanted to say that my NT DD has a wonderful life filled with so many extra curricular activities and friends. Our household does revolve mainly around her sister, but my youngest doesn't go without in any way. Lots of alone time with both her parents. I'm very close to both girls and I think the ASD is the reason for that in way. Solidarity with the NT DD and the safe space for the ND DD.

Well done to that family. You have highlighted it so well. By 'it', I mean living as and with an autistic teenage girl.

BoojaBooj2 · 10/04/2023 10:18

kittensinthekitchen · 10/04/2023 10:12

Can we please stop making every thread about autistic awareness and acceptance about the affect on others?

These days ‘others’ is highly likely to include other ND people though. That’s the real life challenge.

Especially as ironically given my dislike for the video - the girl in it would have been the sort expected to give way if she doesn’t ‘seem autistic’ to others.

15-20% of the world population is estimated to be neurodivergent. What’s more, they all may have conflicting needs. You get on a plane, one person stims loudly, the other is distressed by noise and can’t wear earplugs cuz sensory issues - what do you do? Hmm? Who takes precedence?

That’s why ‘accommodation’ is a delicate dance. It sounds bitter but it’s actually easier to be one of a few ND people and have everyone else be understanding. Than have lots, with different needs, who can’t exactly ‘absorb’ each other. It’s politically incorrect to say this.

Mycathatesmecuddling · 10/04/2023 10:17

WinnipegDink · 10/04/2023 10:11

No I don't. I'm just tired of ignorance.

Not understanding the advert was by vanish doesn't mean that poster is ignorant about autism

She said that she thought it was from a mental health charity, because the bit about it being vanish was written on the screen and not spoken, and she couldn't read the screen at the time

As someone visually impaired I also wouldn't be able to read the writing on the screen in all situations.

Me not realising its for vanish does not make me less aware of autism

Given the poster seemed to have understood the advert apart from the vanish part you only seem annoyed that she is ignorant that vanish created the advert, a very odd thing to be annoyed about

But just to be clear, being unable to read the writing on a TV screen doesn't make someone ignorant, unless you think all visually impaired people are ignorant?

kittensinthekitchen · 10/04/2023 10:12

Can we please stop making every thread about autistic awareness and acceptance about the affect on others?

BoojaBooj2 · 10/04/2023 10:12

bellac11 · 10/04/2023 10:03

I dont know why on most threads which touch on ASD/ADHD there is always a cry that 'this or that group were consulted' or involved in the making of this policy or that presentation or whatever

What does that mean given there are tons of different experiences and this or that group are usually the most socially appropriate/articulate/noisy

Theres also an assumption (although its a real family so it may well be factual) that the sister is NT, she might not be, she might have her own learning or special needs and the advert makes me feel very uncomfortable in terms of how difficult life is for her

In addition as other posters have pointed out, the stereotype is overwhelmingly of people that years ago would have had the diagnosis of Aspergers (my sister has this) rather than those who are physically and mentally disabled, those people are hidden away, ignored, sidelined.

Yes exactly.
You know they could have just made a series - so this girl. And then someone else.
There are a lot of families like mine with multiple disabilities. Surely not that hard to find?

I know the point of ‘this’ was to raise awareness of women and girls being under-diagnosed but the majority of online support groups etc have been completely taken over by HFA. And parents of kids with difficulties are shouted down. I guess this is a good ad because while she’s a talented artist it’s more abo her difficulties.

anyway I’ve said enough and in true autistic mode have become obsessed with this so should probably stop posting now.

WinnipegDink · 10/04/2023 10:11

FrancescaContini · 10/04/2023 10:10

@WinnipegDink Do you work for Vanish? Your angry-sounding comment to a PP about how she would have benefited from paying closer attention to the ad makes you seem very invested in ensuring its success.

No I don't. I'm just tired of ignorance.

FrancescaContini · 10/04/2023 10:10

@WinnipegDink Do you work for Vanish? Your angry-sounding comment to a PP about how she would have benefited from paying closer attention to the ad makes you seem very invested in ensuring its success.

kittensinthekitchen · 10/04/2023 10:06

WinnipegDink · 10/04/2023 10:02

I don't think it was an 'easy' choice as such. As we all know, autism is on a spectrum. There are many many girls out there who have been overlooked for support - basic support - simply because of their ability to mask. Parents aren't believed because the girls are "fine at school". It's a problem that is very specific to autistic girls. This shows what those parents are often unable to articulate - the very real toll on the family behind the scenes. This advert chose to focus on this part of the spectrum and I'm glad for that.

Yes, there's nothing easy about navigating as either a family of, or as, a teenage girl with autism.

BoojaBooj2 · 10/04/2023 10:05

slowquickstep · 10/04/2023 09:58

This. My Grandson has Autism and my heart breaks for him but it also breaks for my Granddaughter as her life is severely impacted too. For days or weeks at a time he doesn't want to set eyes on her so she is banished from whatever room he is in or he gets in her face and scream at her, he throws things at her, hits her and ruins her things. The following week he is all over her and wants to play with her all of the time and can't understand that she won't go near him. As a family they can't go out in the car because he can't be trusted to sit close to her, so he gets days out and she stays at home, always. She is only 3. So yes, i too feel for the sister in the advert. The other siblings suffer too.

That’s the crux though. Autism is a massive, massive spectrum. This is similar to my family. But my younger daughter turned out to be autistic too.
I think for me, while I appreciate struggles of people like the girl who may be deemed ‘not autistic’ but has a decent amount of struggles. Like DC2.
Ultimately what is it we’re looking for?
More help? More funding? Being believed? What does belief translate to?

Wouldn’t it have been better, instead of this silly showboating to have made a donation to help people with things.

Bunnyhair · 10/04/2023 10:04

To the posters outraged by sympathy for the sister in this advert - feeling sorry for one person doesn’t mean you blame the others, or feel any less sorry for them. It’s not a race to the bottom.

My DH (who is also autistic, btw, though nobody spotted that when he was growing up) has a sister whose issues are consistent with a diagnosis of PDA. He has complex PTSD after a childhood living in the shadow of tremendous violence and aggression, and her anxiety-based need to control everything that went on in the home.

I think if we start saying that only the person with the greatest support needs is deserving of empathy and accommodation, we’re throwing a lot of people (including other autistic people) to the wolves. Surely there is some room for nuance here without anyone who acknowledges the difficulty of autistic family life being an ableist monster?

What seemed unrealistic about this advert to me is that there is NO WAY we’d be able to tell our PDA son to wake up and go to school, or the shit would hit the fan big time. The absence of declarative language here was jarring!

Also, my DS hates having his clothes washed. 😂 The idea of using autism to sell any kind of cleaning or hygiene product seems utterly misguided, in the context of my own particular family.

bellac11 · 10/04/2023 10:03

I dont know why on most threads which touch on ASD/ADHD there is always a cry that 'this or that group were consulted' or involved in the making of this policy or that presentation or whatever

What does that mean given there are tons of different experiences and this or that group are usually the most socially appropriate/articulate/noisy

Theres also an assumption (although its a real family so it may well be factual) that the sister is NT, she might not be, she might have her own learning or special needs and the advert makes me feel very uncomfortable in terms of how difficult life is for her

In addition as other posters have pointed out, the stereotype is overwhelmingly of people that years ago would have had the diagnosis of Aspergers (my sister has this) rather than those who are physically and mentally disabled, those people are hidden away, ignored, sidelined.

kittensinthekitchen · 10/04/2023 10:03

Those who talk about failures to platform a more severe presentation of autism... that's difficult because of consent issues surely?

PippaF2 · 10/04/2023 10:03

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 10/04/2023 09:51

Why is that ‘powerful’ and not just ‘easy’ @PippaF2 ?

Because most people's understanding of Autism is limited to films such as Rainmain.

Most people would see that sort of behaviour from a teenager and label them - spoilt, entitled, being difficult, high maintenance etc

Isn't it a good thing that people in the general population who don't have a close relationship to Autism can start to see the behaviour that was once blamed on bad parenting is actually a milder form of autism?

Timeturnerplease · 10/04/2023 10:02

Regardless of the intentions of this advert, what it has done for me personally is make me think more carefully about the children I teach who have autistic siblings. At school we, rightly, try our absolute hardest to accommodate the needs of ND children with the limited resources we have, but don’t give their siblings a second thought.

So, hopefully it hasn’t offended too many people and equally hopefully it’s opened others’ eyes to the trials of autism on a family.

WinnipegDink · 10/04/2023 10:02

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 10/04/2023 09:51

Why is that ‘powerful’ and not just ‘easy’ @PippaF2 ?

I don't think it was an 'easy' choice as such. As we all know, autism is on a spectrum. There are many many girls out there who have been overlooked for support - basic support - simply because of their ability to mask. Parents aren't believed because the girls are "fine at school". It's a problem that is very specific to autistic girls. This shows what those parents are often unable to articulate - the very real toll on the family behind the scenes. This advert chose to focus on this part of the spectrum and I'm glad for that.

slowquickstep · 10/04/2023 09:58

Turquoisesilver · 10/04/2023 08:23

I felt sorry for the sister too. No idea what the solution is but having to STFU all the time and be unable to watch a TV programme isn’t the solution, surely?

This. My Grandson has Autism and my heart breaks for him but it also breaks for my Granddaughter as her life is severely impacted too. For days or weeks at a time he doesn't want to set eyes on her so she is banished from whatever room he is in or he gets in her face and scream at her, he throws things at her, hits her and ruins her things. The following week he is all over her and wants to play with her all of the time and can't understand that she won't go near him. As a family they can't go out in the car because he can't be trusted to sit close to her, so he gets days out and she stays at home, always. She is only 3. So yes, i too feel for the sister in the advert. The other siblings suffer too.

Swipe left for the next trending thread