Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Vanish Supporting Autism Advert

213 replies

Tealsofa · 09/04/2023 15:15

I don't normally watch terrestrial TV, but watching the voyage of the dawn treader on C4, and the advert for vanish keeps coming up.

It looks like a deep meaningful maybe a charity or awareness advert, and then it's "vanish" a cleaning product

My ds (autistic) was also wtf about it

OP posts:
Floralsquirrel · 10/04/2023 11:59

NurseCranesRolodex · 10/04/2023 11:56

Video recordings & photographs are classed as personal data, do you believe consent can really be sought for this, if the footage is a real family, as claimed.

I see the fear and avoidance of familiar daily routines that appear to be perceived as (extremely) demanding and cause an emotional escalation to begin, triggering dysregulation, upset, repetitive behaviour, depiction of skin picking and self protective fear response reactions. Presumably full self harm & physical attacks on others couldn't be portrayed in a shit washing up product advert?!!!

GDPR doesn't apply to a recorded advert, yes there are plenty of safeguards and regulations around recording them. I highly suspect although its an actual family they didn't follow them around filming ffs.

NurseCranesRolodex · 10/04/2023 11:56

kittensinthekitchen · 10/04/2023 09:21

What personal data did they give out against the yps consent? Confused

And which parts of the PDA criteria do you think were there? Has this young woman been diagnosed with PDA?

Video recordings & photographs are classed as personal data, do you believe consent can really be sought for this, if the footage is a real family, as claimed.

I see the fear and avoidance of familiar daily routines that appear to be perceived as (extremely) demanding and cause an emotional escalation to begin, triggering dysregulation, upset, repetitive behaviour, depiction of skin picking and self protective fear response reactions. Presumably full self harm & physical attacks on others couldn't be portrayed in a shit washing up product advert?!!!

TorchwoodWho · 10/04/2023 11:43

debbiewest0 · 10/04/2023 11:25

Disappointing that in this entire thread, nobody has raised the issue that this advert is supported by/ supporting the charity ‘ambitious about autism’
A charity that supports and uses ABA therapy to treat autistic children in their schools badly. A charity that doesn’t want to change society’s views towards autism or build up schools that quietly nurture and support autistic needs, but spends its time making autistic children conform and be manipulated into behaving more NT. A charity that restrains children in its facilities. How disgusting.
I will never buy vanish products again now knowing that any penny might go to this charity.

Same. I also think @fUNNYfACE36 is allowed to have an opinion, and I feel similarly. I am autistic, and think the ad portrayed Ash as causing issues without explanation. It showed her family seemingly having to put themselves out for her (radio off in car, sister told to shut up, subtitles on TV), making it look like they have to tread on eggshells around her. They likely don't, and will be used to supporting her by doing these things, and understanding that she might be snappy when overwhelmed (e.g. the noise in the car).

bellac11 · 10/04/2023 11:32

ZombieKettle · 10/04/2023 11:16

Ash is a real autistic young woman. And that's her real family and friends in the advert. By calling her a "brat" you are simply highlighting the kind of nasty prejudices faced by autistic people that this advert aims to tackle.

www.diversityinadvertising.co.uk/winner/vanish-me-my-autism-and-i/

The poster didnt call her a brat at all.

debbiewest0 · 10/04/2023 11:25

Disappointing that in this entire thread, nobody has raised the issue that this advert is supported by/ supporting the charity ‘ambitious about autism’
A charity that supports and uses ABA therapy to treat autistic children in their schools badly. A charity that doesn’t want to change society’s views towards autism or build up schools that quietly nurture and support autistic needs, but spends its time making autistic children conform and be manipulated into behaving more NT. A charity that restrains children in its facilities. How disgusting.
I will never buy vanish products again now knowing that any penny might go to this charity.

ZombieKettle · 10/04/2023 11:16

fUNNYfACE36 · 10/04/2023 10:59

The trouble is I don't think is going to promote acceptance snd tolerance of people with autism.people who don't have understanding of autism.
They are going to feel sorry for Lily who presumably has her own non autistic anxieties, and frustrations and feel sorry for her and think Ash is a brat that needs taking in hand.

Ash is a real autistic young woman. And that's her real family and friends in the advert. By calling her a "brat" you are simply highlighting the kind of nasty prejudices faced by autistic people that this advert aims to tackle.

www.diversityinadvertising.co.uk/winner/vanish-me-my-autism-and-i/

Bunnyhair · 10/04/2023 11:15

BoojaBooj2 · 10/04/2023 10:18

These days ‘others’ is highly likely to include other ND people though. That’s the real life challenge.

Especially as ironically given my dislike for the video - the girl in it would have been the sort expected to give way if she doesn’t ‘seem autistic’ to others.

15-20% of the world population is estimated to be neurodivergent. What’s more, they all may have conflicting needs. You get on a plane, one person stims loudly, the other is distressed by noise and can’t wear earplugs cuz sensory issues - what do you do? Hmm? Who takes precedence?

That’s why ‘accommodation’ is a delicate dance. It sounds bitter but it’s actually easier to be one of a few ND people and have everyone else be understanding. Than have lots, with different needs, who can’t exactly ‘absorb’ each other. It’s politically incorrect to say this.

This articulates perfectly so much of my life in a multiplex family with a whole range of ND presentations (including my own). I feel like the internet of autism is good at recognising the paradox of high sensitivity and high need for stimulation when it presents with in one individual; it’s a lot harder to think about honouring multiple people’s fluctuating and often conflicting sensory needs within one setting, whether that’s a home or a workplace or a school.

Rainbowsandbutterflies1990 · 10/04/2023 11:14

The point I was trying to make and doing quite a bad job is there are behaviours that autistic children can do that can be really difficult or not spoken about due to nature and can be quite hidden to society in general . I'm not saying a advert would be appropriate at all I'm just mentioning the irony

Rainbowsandbutterflies1990 · 10/04/2023 11:10

I cried when I watched it. Not because of my severe autistic daughter who is non verbal as that isn't relatable to our life in the advert . It was more me being the sibling in my family life when I was a child when my brother who is undiagnosed autistic was at home. Its funny/ironic I actually use vanish quite a lot my daughter smears a lot and gets its everywhere and I use vanish to try and help with that. I'm guessing showing autism in that way wouldn't be so pleasantly pleasing . I find with this particular issue. Its quite a hidden thing. Its awful to talk about it to others and it's as it isn't a pleasant thing I guess others wouldn't want to know about it anyways. Thankfully I have friends who have children who do same so we can get emotional support from each other.

Mycathatesmecuddling · 10/04/2023 11:02

fUNNYfACE36 · 10/04/2023 10:59

The trouble is I don't think is going to promote acceptance snd tolerance of people with autism.people who don't have understanding of autism.
They are going to feel sorry for Lily who presumably has her own non autistic anxieties, and frustrations and feel sorry for her and think Ash is a brat that needs taking in hand.

So you think we shouldnt portray people with autism on the TV in case ableist people think they just need to change their behaviour, and its just bad parenting?

Abelist people think that anyway, that shouldnt stop ND people from being portrayed in media

WinnipegDink · 10/04/2023 11:00

@FrancescaContini on the basis of this alone they're an organisation I'd be quite happy to be allied to. And to be completely fair to them they produce effective stain removers. So maybe I will apply!

Spiderysenses · 10/04/2023 11:00

I haven't read the whole thread, as I couldn't cope with some of the comments.
But yes, this advert (the full version) made me cry, it's our DD to a tee. We've been fighting for a diagnosis for years. I won't be buying Vanish, but I am very grateful for them highlighting autism in girls. Perhaps some HCPs might see this and learn too. The ignorance in the medical community is worse than the general public sometimes.
There are also stories of girls and young women getting other harmful health diagnoses when they have undiagnosed autism.
The actress in the advert is autistic.

fUNNYfACE36 · 10/04/2023 10:59

The trouble is I don't think is going to promote acceptance snd tolerance of people with autism.people who don't have understanding of autism.
They are going to feel sorry for Lily who presumably has her own non autistic anxieties, and frustrations and feel sorry for her and think Ash is a brat that needs taking in hand.

itsgettingweird · 10/04/2023 10:58

Things that becomes a barrier to most disabled people is the term "appeasing to their whims".

A disability isn't ever a whim.

What worked for me and my disabled ds was a) ignoring those who decided this was what I was doing and b) focussing on supporting him with the things that count. What we called the necessaries.

For me is wasn't necessary for him to learn to cope with a music lesson at school. This was a societal norm that had no actual life skill attached to it.

What did matter though was supporting him to manage things such as accessing food (whatever he can eat made into a balanced diet). Accessing a healthy lifestyle including the ability to exercise. Manage an income so he could afford life. (And for some this will include supporting them to claim benefits because they can't work).

It's not a "whim" that a wheelchair user wants the wheelchair space on public transport. It's necessary for them to access a balanced lifestyle and get out and about like non disabled people do.

It's not a "whim" someone who's ND can't access a supermarket. It's necessary to purchase food for survival. So you find a way around that. Online ordering, going during the night when it's quiet with a support worker or whatever works.

For us it's worked really well.

No my 18yo teen can't do a supermarket shop, manage money well or budget, go out alone, cook. He needs full support for all these things because of his physical disability and autism.

But he's also just made the British team for his sport and has been told of his performances continue as they are he'll be going as part of that team to the Paralympic's next year.

I've never seen it as pandering to his whims but supporting him to access a full life where he can pursue his dreams like everyone else and finding out what support he needs to do this.

And the most amazing thing is all those things I didn't force him to do at 11/12 yo and was told I was mollycoddling him over are things he's found his own way to do as he wasn't in a pressurised environment to act "normal" and non disabled and so had the energy to find his own way in the world.

Mycathatesmecuddling · 10/04/2023 10:56

bellac11 · 10/04/2023 10:42

Everyone has needs and everyone has whims. People with autism arent any different, they will still have whims/likes/dislikes/desire, not everything in their life is about their condition.

Of course they do

But the poster was referring to the small snippets about Ashley displayed in the advert as whims where as it seems quite clear that some of them at least (the need for quiet, the need to play the drums, the need for the sensory room, the need for the hoody) where not whims

FrancescaContini · 10/04/2023 10:52

WinnipegDink · 10/04/2023 10:30

@FrancescaContini I'm not at all sorry I upset you though Grin

I’m not remotely upset, what makes you think that?

I still think you’re a Vanish employee though 🤪

Tealsofa · 10/04/2023 10:51

AgrathaChristie · 10/04/2023 09:23

That’s an ad for a cleaning product? It was on this morning, didn’t have my glasses on so couldn’t read the script at the end on small bedroom tv. I assumed it was for a mental health support charity.
Sorry, it went completely over my head.

That's what we thought

I am not saying it is not a good depiction of how tough it is for siblings (we have a younger ds) it was more "this is an advert for a CLEANING PRODUCT???"

OP posts:
LibrariansGiveUsPower · 10/04/2023 10:50

IScreamAtMichaelangelos · 10/04/2023 09:10

Just watched it. The tie in with Vanish at the end was a bit clunky I thought, but I liked the rest of it (autistic adult with autistic child here).

Clunky is the right word here. Good on vanish for getting people talking though. I know many parent friends with autistic kids feel seen.

user1471530109 · 10/04/2023 10:45

fUNNYfACE36 · 10/04/2023 10:34

Poor lily.why do the parents indulge Ashley's every whim and let her rude roughshod over Lily.This is setting Lily up to accept abusive behaviour.

Such ignorance.

To the last few PP who have highlighted the fact that yes, Lily has some tough moments. But it's a 3 minute clip. Just like trying to fit in all of Ash's difficulties and of course strengths in that time is near on impossible.

I have noticed a lot more is being done to highlight awareness of autism in girls. Recently there has been a number of things in TV. Let's hope the tide is turning. Clearly there is still work to be done ☹️.

LibrariansGiveUsPower · 10/04/2023 10:45

thegrain · 10/04/2023 08:38

Because they'd not know what to do with it. The character would be one of those that comes in for a few months and then goes. It would be crap.

Trying not to laugh at the implication that general soap storylines aren’t crap.

have a family with an autistic kid, older child/teen. Watch their struggles and triumphs over a few years. Really wouldn’t be hard because you know, autistic people are still people can and live fun, fulfilling, and exciting lives too.

bellac11 · 10/04/2023 10:42

Mycathatesmecuddling · 10/04/2023 10:38

Peoples needs due to autism are not whims

It is uncomfortable so see Lily's life and to see the impact living with a sibling with autism has on her

But dont dismiss the very real day to day issues that Ash deals with as whims. That's like calling someones wheelchair a whim if sometimes they can walk

Everyone has needs and everyone has whims. People with autism arent any different, they will still have whims/likes/dislikes/desire, not everything in their life is about their condition.

Iam4eels · 10/04/2023 10:39

fUNNYfACE36 · 10/04/2023 10:34

Poor lily.why do the parents indulge Ashley's every whim and let her rude roughshod over Lily.This is setting Lily up to accept abusive behaviour.

Because the advert is specifically about Ashley and the difficulties she has so it highlights a montage of moments in her day, why it would show the days/times where Lily is at forefront when they're not relevant to the story being told? If you followed this RL family around for a few days you'd probably see those moments.

As an FYI, meeting the support needs of a disabled person is not the same thing as "indulging their every whim". They're not whims, they're behaviours associated with their disability and helping that person to manage them isn't an indulgence.

Mycathatesmecuddling · 10/04/2023 10:38

fUNNYfACE36 · 10/04/2023 10:34

Poor lily.why do the parents indulge Ashley's every whim and let her rude roughshod over Lily.This is setting Lily up to accept abusive behaviour.

Peoples needs due to autism are not whims

It is uncomfortable so see Lily's life and to see the impact living with a sibling with autism has on her

But dont dismiss the very real day to day issues that Ash deals with as whims. That's like calling someones wheelchair a whim if sometimes they can walk

Mycathatesmecuddling · 10/04/2023 10:36

WinnipegDink · 10/04/2023 10:28

@Mycathatesmecuddling thank you for explaining. I am not dismissing your disability. I was explaining that I found PP's tone dismissive and that's what I responded to, not the fact that they didn't have their glasses on.

In much the same I suppose as you found my tone dismissive and responded. Rightly so. I'm sorry to have upset you.

I appreciate your apology, I suppose its irritating for me to see an advert win awards for being inclusive when they have writing on a screen not read out that visually impaired people then might not be able to read

Genuinely though I think you are misreading that posters post

There are several conversations going on on this thread

How good a representation it is of autism, especially in girls

How hard it is for the sister

Whether autism in all its forms could be better represented

Why vanish has chosen to do this and whether commercial interests best align with supporting disability and whether vanish is making money off appropriating someone's disability

To the last point the poster responding that they hadn't even realised it was vanish because they hadn't read the screen

They weren't being dismissive of autism, they were joining in the conversation around vanish making money off this and whether that's right or not. The only people they were being dismissive of was vanish, which is why another poster asked if you worked for vanish because given the context of the post that's the only way your response made sense

FlemCandango · 10/04/2023 10:36

On the point of the NT sibling, my other teenage daughter is in a similar position. Has to put up with a lot being the younger sibling of two teen autistic people a sister and brother. So there are compromises due to limitations on our lives that are necessary for her siblings to cope. I admire my DD2 greatly, she is emotionally mature, kind and fiercely protective of her siblings. She loves them, and at the same time they squabble and snipe like any siblings close in age do. However they are all kind and respectful and supportive of each other. But she is human and a teen so there are times when none of us cope well, we argue, and it gets very stressful. Then other times when DD2 is encouraged and entertained by her siblings in a way only they can, as they know her so well and have an honest and unique approach to life. So despite the compromises I don't think dd2 would have it any other way.

The glimpses you get in a 3 minute film are not enough to conclude that the nt sibling has a terrible time. Just that they are a family doing their best in a difficult situation with teen hormones thrown in to really ramp up the emotions. I respect the messy and imperfect nature of it. Life is imperfect, messy and often unfair.