Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Vanish Supporting Autism Advert

213 replies

Tealsofa · 09/04/2023 15:15

I don't normally watch terrestrial TV, but watching the voyage of the dawn treader on C4, and the advert for vanish keeps coming up.

It looks like a deep meaningful maybe a charity or awareness advert, and then it's "vanish" a cleaning product

My ds (autistic) was also wtf about it

OP posts:
Turquoisesilver · 10/04/2023 14:03

In my personal experience, most siblings are incredibly loving and tolerant and understanding towards their brother or sister as children/teens. Being totally candid here it tends to be adult life when resentment starts to emerge. I’m not saying that to make anyone feel bad, it’s just a point to consider when discussing it.

Fundays12 · 10/04/2023 14:02

spindrycycle · 09/04/2023 15:19

I just felt sorry for the sister in the advert. Yelled at for talking with her friend in the car, then forced to listen to drumming in a shared room later. Like she was walking on eggshells the whole time.

Unfortunately this is the reality for my whole family. We all feel we are waking on egg shells as dc1 is autistic and very highly strung. one of his siblings in particular takes the brunt of his outbursts and now has anxiety himself and needs support

TheVolturi · 10/04/2023 14:00

It moved me. Just because my son age 10 who has Autism is very much like the Autistic girl in the video. And the chaotic, testing, difficult dynamic of the house is very much like ours too. Son age 9 has Adhd and also have dd age 5. I am now a single parent to them all after suffering a lifetime of domestic abuse from my husband, and it's really not easy. There isn't much if any support in our area for parents of Asd kids.
I wish that after diagnosis by nhs there was immediate support and education, to make all of our lives easier and better.

user1471530109 · 10/04/2023 13:59

I don't know anything about 'Ash' as a real person. But if she is amazing at maths, why should this not be portrayed? I got the impression she was 'playing herself '. I also think the real sister would be mortified that some of you have interpreted the film the way you have. But maybe not. Maybe she happy that her side has 'come through'. We don't know these people.

As for the drums. I think that's a red herring. That scene was about her regulating her emotions and the impact on the family who understandably got frustrated. It wasn't supposed to come across as Ash being selfish or a brat! I didn't take that from it. But like I said, that's my life being shown! I also didn't interpret the sister giving her the hoodie back as her being controlled. The sister was also fed up after having her life impacted. She lashed out and regretted it. She saw the impact on her sister and instantly knew she had gone too far. Just like many sibling relationships. It was very clear in the film that she cared deeply about her sister. It wasn't a reaction of being scared or controlled like some seem to think.

Bunnyhair · 10/04/2023 13:55

BoojaBooj2 · 10/04/2023 12:33

Hi fellow multiplex! I like that term.

Yes, it seems many people jump on the bandwagon of 'adapting' = 'making more NT acceptable' and that's not true at all.

Also while this ad is about autism, on a wider scale there are other conditions with overlap (e.g. ADHD). And there are specific diagnoses that can be similar - e.g. general sensory issues with food, sound of autism vs AFRID, misophonia. There's really no 'catch-all' term that expresses a person's needs.

At the end of the day , in a philosophical way I think it all comes down to the increasing attempt to fit people into boxes. Everything around us is increasingly automated. You can't speak to a human in any form of customer service without going through a million forms. We have algorithms supposedly providing 'personalisation' but it's just classification on a deeper scale. Job interviews all have online tests, rubrics (which yes while enforcing a standard also allow many to fall afoul of them).

A slower pace, more individually geared way of life with the time and space to think, and personal connection would go a long way towards making life easier. Everyone would benefit, yes but especially ND people. Autism is very individualised in its presentation and that's the main thing that has to be gotten across.

Hear hear! And I do often think that, as a society in general, the more granular we’re encouraged to get with our diagnoses and identities, the greater our expectation that others should be able to understand us perfectly, intuit our needs, and offer perfectly tailored adaptations and accommodation.

And that is just not possible, in the crowded and overwhelming world we live in. The underfunded and bureaucratic systems that serve us are scrambling to keep up with our expanding self-awareness.

The nervous-system-friendly environment you describe is basically how I grew up, in a rural university town outside the UK, in the halcyon days before the internet.

I went to a state school where there was no uniform, no rigid national curriculum, no pressure about exam results. We had a guidance counsellor who said ‘the best part of my job is hanging out with the Different kids’ - like we were Ally Sheedy and Judd Nelson in the Breakfast Club, rather than personified checklists of needs and sensitivities. We were just Different, in all our different ways, and he was there to help each of us work out ways to navigate the hellscape of adolescence as comfortably as possible.

Our high school also had a free crèche so that teenage mums could finish school. The system was set up to support kids to have as many options as possible, whatever their circumstances. And graduates did really well, by all the standard metrics.

There was no school ‘refusal’ that I was aware of. Not because people were made of sterner stuff back then, but because the system was flexible and properly resourced, and the teachers weren’t burnt the fuck out. Plus, of course, there was no such thing as social media, and there were half as many people in the world as there are now. Take me back!! 😭

BoojaBooj2 · 10/04/2023 13:48

EsmeSusanOgg · 10/04/2023 12:49

Not the person you replied to. We need more ND representation. But I think the bit with the drums in a shared space was a mistep. It was an unreasonable thing to do, regardless of being ND. And pushed audience sympathies entirely to the (presumably) NT sister and her issues.

So much of the ad was me growing up. And I really empathised. Especially with a beloved clothing item. But the drums? In the living room effectively? That seems like an utter recipe for disaster. And most people on the Asperger's end of the ASD spectrum (which is what is being portrayed here) know that. And I hope their parents would know that too.

The sister getting annoyed by all the cumulualtive little things, would make just as much sense. And not give the impression that all people with autism are utterly unreasonable - whilst still presenting that autistic teens can be very difficult to live with.

Yes, exactly!
I think the 'plot' here is a major issue. The sister got annoyed (understandably) at the drums, hid the blazer. Triggering a meltdown, she then had to find it and apologise.
There's nothing 'positive' about the main character from a human perspective. She's clever and artistic - so? The public already think autistic people all have some hidden genius. It doesn't really add anything. They could have portrayed her as doing OK with a mix of A/B grades.
Yes, this is a snapshot and not her whole life, but what they choose is consistent with the story they want to tell, that's why we have film analysis as an academic subject in the first place.
What is that story? That while the world can overwhelm autistic people, their loved ones have to just tiptoe around them?

The sister may not even have been ND. Could've been like mine. Champion masker, unlike her older sibling. Until she couldn't.

Would it have been so hard to have a scene where something nice is shown? Like maybe the sisters making up after fighting, like any other pair of sisters?

ArcticSkewer · 10/04/2023 13:40

Found it quite traumatising.

Poor bloody sister. Will probably grow up to be in some kind of abusive relationship where she acts as the 'rescuer' to some knob and can't even recognise her own feelings or emotions til she's about 50.

Or maybe that's just me projecting.

And who buys a full on drum set and puts it in their living room?

That aside, why isn't the money going 50:50 to a better autism support charity and a young carers charity? Whatever the equivalent of greenwashing is, this is it. As if Vanish care.

Autumnalblooms · 10/04/2023 13:19

@Floralsquirrel apologies the post is not meant to look as a reply to you as that i disagree with you , i actually do not .I missed to quote what you were replying too.

Autumnalblooms · 10/04/2023 13:16

Floralsquirrel · 10/04/2023 12:59

You have your opinion and I have mine, I think you're being ridiculous and it's still not bloody GDPR!

Ok i work in care , have done a long time and this is not a GDR concern because she and her family have given consent .You don't know they were talked into it that is one huge assumption .They have i feel brought a lot of awareness to autistic girls who mask .Out of my two high functioning teen DD one can attend mainstream one cannot .The one is a extremely good masker ,very intelligent and very quiet in class .So anything that highlights this is brilliant in my eyes .To be honest the way you say they were talked into it is a bit rude ,we don't know them personally yet you have assumed that they were naive enough to let themselves be used .Wonder what they would make of that ?

Floralsquirrel · 10/04/2023 12:59

NurseCranesRolodex · 10/04/2023 12:41

Fucking hell.
I'd prefer people with ASD & their families were not exploited for the benefit of Proctor & Gamble, or whoever owns Vanish. Does the understanding of autism depend on capitalism?

I did not suggest "no one with autism would be able to" (give consent). Nor did I say "her parents are exploiting her". Of course there are stringent controls around children 'performing' BUT this girl & family have been talked into exploiting her needs by depicting her real life for an advert which will profit a massive brand as they can be seen as Autism allies now. Not only have her personal rights (GDPR) been advertised but the whole thing shows who she is, how vulnerable she is. If you can't or refuse to see the problem with this then it says alot about why this allegiance behaviour is so successful in the advertising/media world.

Let's have respectful, real education about real lives of families with autism and other disabilities, especially the non media friendly world of PDA.

You have your opinion and I have mine, I think you're being ridiculous and it's still not bloody GDPR!

EsmeSusanOgg · 10/04/2023 12:53

Bunnyhair · 10/04/2023 11:15

This articulates perfectly so much of my life in a multiplex family with a whole range of ND presentations (including my own). I feel like the internet of autism is good at recognising the paradox of high sensitivity and high need for stimulation when it presents with in one individual; it’s a lot harder to think about honouring multiple people’s fluctuating and often conflicting sensory needs within one setting, whether that’s a home or a workplace or a school.

Gosh yes.

I present with quite stereotypical ASD (and probable ADHD). My sister, who has the same diagnosis is impacted by entirely different things to me.

EsmeSusanOgg · 10/04/2023 12:49

Mycathatesmecuddling · 10/04/2023 11:02

So you think we shouldnt portray people with autism on the TV in case ableist people think they just need to change their behaviour, and its just bad parenting?

Abelist people think that anyway, that shouldnt stop ND people from being portrayed in media

Not the person you replied to. We need more ND representation. But I think the bit with the drums in a shared space was a mistep. It was an unreasonable thing to do, regardless of being ND. And pushed audience sympathies entirely to the (presumably) NT sister and her issues.

So much of the ad was me growing up. And I really empathised. Especially with a beloved clothing item. But the drums? In the living room effectively? That seems like an utter recipe for disaster. And most people on the Asperger's end of the ASD spectrum (which is what is being portrayed here) know that. And I hope their parents would know that too.

The sister getting annoyed by all the cumulualtive little things, would make just as much sense. And not give the impression that all people with autism are utterly unreasonable - whilst still presenting that autistic teens can be very difficult to live with.

Spiderysenses · 10/04/2023 12:42

Going off on a tangent. I do wonder if it was helpful to get rid of the Aspergers (I realise the name is problematic) part of autism diagnosis. Putting everyone under the ASD umbrella, seems to have thrown people together who have such varying needs and must lead to difficulties?

NurseCranesRolodex · 10/04/2023 12:41

Floralsquirrel · 10/04/2023 12:17

So why mention GDPR at all? And yes some people with autism will be more than capable of giving consent, some won't sure but its quite offensive to suggest no one with autism would be able to. Cripes. Also that's quite an accusation to suggest that her parents are exploring her or unaware of the legal ramifications. Would you prefer the part was given to someone who wasn't autistic and therefore was simply acting out and profiting from autism? Or perhaps never have any representation at all in advertising or the media? There are stringent controls around children performing.

Fucking hell.
I'd prefer people with ASD & their families were not exploited for the benefit of Proctor & Gamble, or whoever owns Vanish. Does the understanding of autism depend on capitalism?

I did not suggest "no one with autism would be able to" (give consent). Nor did I say "her parents are exploiting her". Of course there are stringent controls around children 'performing' BUT this girl & family have been talked into exploiting her needs by depicting her real life for an advert which will profit a massive brand as they can be seen as Autism allies now. Not only have her personal rights (GDPR) been advertised but the whole thing shows who she is, how vulnerable she is. If you can't or refuse to see the problem with this then it says alot about why this allegiance behaviour is so successful in the advertising/media world.

Let's have respectful, real education about real lives of families with autism and other disabilities, especially the non media friendly world of PDA.

BoojaBooj2 · 10/04/2023 12:33

Bunnyhair · 10/04/2023 11:15

This articulates perfectly so much of my life in a multiplex family with a whole range of ND presentations (including my own). I feel like the internet of autism is good at recognising the paradox of high sensitivity and high need for stimulation when it presents with in one individual; it’s a lot harder to think about honouring multiple people’s fluctuating and often conflicting sensory needs within one setting, whether that’s a home or a workplace or a school.

Hi fellow multiplex! I like that term.

Yes, it seems many people jump on the bandwagon of 'adapting' = 'making more NT acceptable' and that's not true at all.

Also while this ad is about autism, on a wider scale there are other conditions with overlap (e.g. ADHD). And there are specific diagnoses that can be similar - e.g. general sensory issues with food, sound of autism vs AFRID, misophonia. There's really no 'catch-all' term that expresses a person's needs.

At the end of the day , in a philosophical way I think it all comes down to the increasing attempt to fit people into boxes. Everything around us is increasingly automated. You can't speak to a human in any form of customer service without going through a million forms. We have algorithms supposedly providing 'personalisation' but it's just classification on a deeper scale. Job interviews all have online tests, rubrics (which yes while enforcing a standard also allow many to fall afoul of them).

A slower pace, more individually geared way of life with the time and space to think, and personal connection would go a long way towards making life easier. Everyone would benefit, yes but especially ND people. Autism is very individualised in its presentation and that's the main thing that has to be gotten across.

MushroomQueen · 10/04/2023 12:30

Just watched it- my sister has severe autism- she insists on her clothing being washed everyday cannot be left at all. It's a good awareness promoting ad

Spiderysenses · 10/04/2023 12:29

@Floralsquirrel

Sorry, the quote system makes it look like I was replying to you, but the reply was to the post you were replying to...iyswim🤦‍♀️

Spiderysenses · 10/04/2023 12:27

Floralsquirrel · 10/04/2023 12:17

So why mention GDPR at all? And yes some people with autism will be more than capable of giving consent, some won't sure but its quite offensive to suggest no one with autism would be able to. Cripes. Also that's quite an accusation to suggest that her parents are exploring her or unaware of the legal ramifications. Would you prefer the part was given to someone who wasn't autistic and therefore was simply acting out and profiting from autism? Or perhaps never have any representation at all in advertising or the media? There are stringent controls around children performing.

People with disabilities have agency. They can marry, have sex, be employed, appear in TV commercials - Of course they can. Pretty shocked at some of the attitudes here. And yes, some of them can actually act and even become successful actors. Mind-blowing isn't it? 🙄

Autumnalblooms · 10/04/2023 12:21

I have two high functioning teen DD's and the advert was my eldest DD to even the hood pulled up to keep out the world .It made me cry .I worked as a team leader with challenging behaviour and autism .But when it is your own child it is a whole different ball game .Working fulltime and coping with meltdowns and trying to avoid triggers it is hard but i love them and i would not change them for the world .What does really upset me is when people have the oh they are just naughty attitude .The lack of knowledge of autism is still bad .

Floralsquirrel · 10/04/2023 12:17

NurseCranesRolodex · 10/04/2023 12:08

Not sure you understood my comment. Video/photos do constitute GDPR, as I said. Can a dysregulated young person really, truly give consent for this depiction....... for a fecking household cleaning product?!!! Can they really "act" out a meltdown. It's very exploitative and the family are lacking in legal advice in their media career based on their DC's disability and how it manifests.

So why mention GDPR at all? And yes some people with autism will be more than capable of giving consent, some won't sure but its quite offensive to suggest no one with autism would be able to. Cripes. Also that's quite an accusation to suggest that her parents are exploring her or unaware of the legal ramifications. Would you prefer the part was given to someone who wasn't autistic and therefore was simply acting out and profiting from autism? Or perhaps never have any representation at all in advertising or the media? There are stringent controls around children performing.

user1471530109 · 10/04/2023 12:16

The article linked earlier in the thread says the family acted it. It isn't a documentary! There was improvisation. I'm amazed at how well all the 'cast' acted. Including her real best friends at school. They've done a brilliant job.

I agree maybe there could have been a little more of a clear indication she was overwhelmed by the noise in the car etc. That an accumulation of all the triggers built up until she shutdown. Then when she's home she lets it all out. To me it was obvious, but then I live that everyday.

This thread has been a bit of an eye opener for me this morning. I am very much my dd's advocate and I'm a bit upset at some of the perceptions on here. One thing I still struggle with, is not getting overwhelmed and embarrassed during a meltdown or shutdown. My own issues that I'm working on. But listening to some of the perceptions of Ash's behaviour have been hard to hear. This is my biggest fear for my DD. That people think she is 'a brat ' at times or my own parenting is to blame. This has got more difficult the 'older she looks'. Lots of staring from strangers when she was running up and down the escalators bare foot the other day crying. My fault for not acting earlier to try and prevent the meltdown. What they hadn't seen is her competing in an international sporting event minutes before. They hadn't seen her coping with the noise and people, hanging on by a thread. Then something tipped her over the edge. She got to the semi finals 😊.

Those complaining about the link to the washing powder. I think it's a ligament link. Yes some ND DC don't like clothes washed. But equally, they'd want their clothes to be washed in the same detergent etc. My DD isn't too bothered by this unless she is struggling with something. Then she likes to wrap herself up with something familiar and very soft.

NurseCranesRolodex · 10/04/2023 12:08

Floralsquirrel · 10/04/2023 11:59

GDPR doesn't apply to a recorded advert, yes there are plenty of safeguards and regulations around recording them. I highly suspect although its an actual family they didn't follow them around filming ffs.

Not sure you understood my comment. Video/photos do constitute GDPR, as I said. Can a dysregulated young person really, truly give consent for this depiction....... for a fecking household cleaning product?!!! Can they really "act" out a meltdown. It's very exploitative and the family are lacking in legal advice in their media career based on their DC's disability and how it manifests.

ZombieKettle · 10/04/2023 12:04

bellac11 · 10/04/2023 11:32

The poster didnt call her a brat at all.

Thank you for alerting me. I'd misread her post. I've apologized to them.

ZombieKettle · 10/04/2023 12:01

fUNNYfACE36 · 10/04/2023 10:59

The trouble is I don't think is going to promote acceptance snd tolerance of people with autism.people who don't have understanding of autism.
They are going to feel sorry for Lily who presumably has her own non autistic anxieties, and frustrations and feel sorry for her and think Ash is a brat that needs taking in hand.

My sincere apologies. I misread your post. I realize now you didn't call her a brat. Sorry 💐

lemonsaretheonlyfruit · 10/04/2023 12:01

I have an autistic teen DD. She saw it first and said 'omg it's me' - and it is. I then showed it to my teen DS as he is definitely the sibling shown in the ad. Ds has problems understanding how but of DDs issues is autism and how much is just 'her' - I think it was useful for him. A friend saw it and said 'we'll most of that is just like my teen DD (who is NT) - I saw it through different eyes as it was very similar to what we (DS and I ) live with every day.

I don't mind which product it's associated with - but I think it's brilliant for raising awareness. Even better that it's a real family.

I wish my DD could go into school with just a bit of the reluctance shown in the ad though - mine hasn't been in for 3 months and that has so many other repercussions- confidence in herself, low self esteem and huge amounts of stress. But if that's representative of their day to day then good for them for bringing it to a wider audience