Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Vanish Supporting Autism Advert

213 replies

Tealsofa · 09/04/2023 15:15

I don't normally watch terrestrial TV, but watching the voyage of the dawn treader on C4, and the advert for vanish keeps coming up.

It looks like a deep meaningful maybe a charity or awareness advert, and then it's "vanish" a cleaning product

My ds (autistic) was also wtf about it

OP posts:
NewNovember · 10/04/2023 17:14

CollieFIower · 10/04/2023 15:49

I'm lost as to why you think I implied it was a competition?

I'm just sick of seeing this advert trumpeted as some sort of amazing insight or representation. I don't like the way Vanish are using ND people to sell their product (which I also don't like). And I wonder how many ND people Vanish actually employ 🤔

No I am telling you it was a competion for advertisers to make an advert that had a neurodiverse theme in order to raise awareness. They are not using autistic people quite the opposite.

NurseCranesRolodex · 10/04/2023 17:09

Rosula · 10/04/2023 16:16

It could only compromise her GDPR if she and her family did not consent.

No danger of this being exploitative of this yp? Wow.

lemonsaretheonlyfruit · 10/04/2023 16:34

@MoreChilli

Yes I thought that about the drums too. It happens to be drums in their family but in ours it's teen DD walking in circles in front of the TV and shouting her name very loudly over and over when we are trying to watch TV in peace. Then half an hour later putting her hands over her ears as everyone is being too loud (including the car radio being on at normal volume) - those 2 shots really resonated with me.

bunhead1979 · 10/04/2023 16:16

I am autistic and have autistic teens. For years we have had the struggles with clothing, anxiety, school, siblings, etc.

When i saw the ad i found it jarring to have such a realistic portrayal of my family, and many families we knows life, in an ad break. Then when i saw it was actually an advert for a completely unrelated product, it made me feel even more weird.

I’m not saying its bad or good, i just don’t really get the placement, or the link to Vanish

Rosula · 10/04/2023 16:16

NurseCranesRolodex · 10/04/2023 09:12

If its a real family the meltdown scenes massively compromise the yp's GDPR so doubt that aspect. It definitely seems to portray PDA though, which may be helpful as its so misunderstood.

It could only compromise her GDPR if she and her family did not consent.

TorchwoodWho · 10/04/2023 15:59

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 10/04/2023 15:36

@RedToothBrush

’ND people are not sufficiently represented in the media, no wonder they are not understood by NT people’

‘ Let’s do an ad with ND people in as part of our not for profit advertising budget’

’you’ve Included your brand in your ad ! Disgusting, you’ve done it wrong’

’ let’s do rescue puppies this year, everyone likes them’

‘ no one ever shows ND people in their advertising. Ableists!’

🤷🏼

How about including us and not just because we're ND?
Instead of being hired for an ad as a one-off because of my autism, I would rather the company gave me a job without the dilemma of either having to tick the "no disability" box and struggle on if I do get hired, or tick it and run the risk of not getting hired because of it (and I know it's illegal to discriminate, but I'm not naive enough to think other applicants really are more qualified/closely match the job description all the time).

That sort of inclusion and awareness would benefit me more than 4 minutes of a badly executed and in my opinion, fairly damaging, advert.

RedToothBrush · 10/04/2023 15:53

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 10/04/2023 15:36

@RedToothBrush

’ND people are not sufficiently represented in the media, no wonder they are not understood by NT people’

‘ Let’s do an ad with ND people in as part of our not for profit advertising budget’

’you’ve Included your brand in your ad ! Disgusting, you’ve done it wrong’

’ let’s do rescue puppies this year, everyone likes them’

‘ no one ever shows ND people in their advertising. Ableists!’

🤷🏼

They are advertising a product. Not people.

Does the stain come out of the clothes? Yes.

Are the people in the advert relevant to stains in clothes? No.

I don't wish for a morality lecture from someone flogging stain removal products.

A drama / documentary which turns people into 3 dimensional characters is completely different thing rather than a couple of minutes of something that lots of people on her have wildly different impressions of - some of which are really not positive at all - whilst flogging soap powder.

How can you tell that all the people on the vanish adverts have been NT previously anyway? It's your bias to suggest they were.

I'm so over the virtue signaling which doesn't actually educate anyone on anything and is framed as educational when it's just marketing to make £££

CollieFIower · 10/04/2023 15:49

NewNovember · 10/04/2023 14:35

But it's not it's a competition

I'm lost as to why you think I implied it was a competition?

I'm just sick of seeing this advert trumpeted as some sort of amazing insight or representation. I don't like the way Vanish are using ND people to sell their product (which I also don't like). And I wonder how many ND people Vanish actually employ 🤔

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 10/04/2023 15:36

@RedToothBrush

’ND people are not sufficiently represented in the media, no wonder they are not understood by NT people’

‘ Let’s do an ad with ND people in as part of our not for profit advertising budget’

’you’ve Included your brand in your ad ! Disgusting, you’ve done it wrong’

’ let’s do rescue puppies this year, everyone likes them’

‘ no one ever shows ND people in their advertising. Ableists!’

🤷🏼

Floralsquirrel · 10/04/2023 15:23

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 10/04/2023 15:00

This Really wouldn’t be hard because you know, autistic people are still people can and live fun, fulfilling, and exciting lives too. is what I was talking about when I said the ad campaign has made an ‘easy’ choice rather than a ‘powerful’ choice.

Not all autistic people have the opportunity and/or the capacity to live ‘fun, fulfilling and exciting lives’- certainly not that would be recognised as such by the viewing public.

My comment is not about the ease or hardship of the family life depicted but about the easy choice for Vanish to depict an attractive person who fits the acceptable ‘able but different’ narrative that represented a step forward 20-30 years ago.

Indeed they don't, similarly though many such as the girl in the advert are dismissed and some say she can't be autistic because she can do x, she looks like y or she doesn't find it as challenging as z. That's also harmful for people. I guess going back to the point a PP made earlier for children who are very much at the other end of the spectrum it probably wouldn't be ethical to include them in an advert if they couldn't make an informed decision for themselves as others who are autistic can. I think a lot of people are expecting perfection or an all encompassing advert which would be impossible in 3.5 minutes.

I guess the point is do companies or whoever else attempt to be inclusive or do they just say fuck it easier to have the same old able bodied, NT model promoting their products? I wouldn't be a fan of this if the actress was NT, but realistically this echoes her experience and why shouldn't it be as valid as someone else's? I don't think she or the advert claims to represent everyone with autism.

RedToothBrush · 10/04/2023 15:13

NewNovember · 10/04/2023 14:42

No it was competion for an advertiser to make an advert based on neurodiversity to raise awareness.

To plug their brand...

...sorry I stick by my original point thanks.

Turquoisesilver · 10/04/2023 15:03

But then unlike @Turquoisesilver I've seen a lot of sibling impacts - out of my acquaintances a fair few of the siblings have been diagnosed with their own MH issues. Depression, anxiety, self-harm

?

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 10/04/2023 15:00

LibrariansGiveUsPower · 10/04/2023 10:45

Trying not to laugh at the implication that general soap storylines aren’t crap.

have a family with an autistic kid, older child/teen. Watch their struggles and triumphs over a few years. Really wouldn’t be hard because you know, autistic people are still people can and live fun, fulfilling, and exciting lives too.

This Really wouldn’t be hard because you know, autistic people are still people can and live fun, fulfilling, and exciting lives too. is what I was talking about when I said the ad campaign has made an ‘easy’ choice rather than a ‘powerful’ choice.

Not all autistic people have the opportunity and/or the capacity to live ‘fun, fulfilling and exciting lives’- certainly not that would be recognised as such by the viewing public.

My comment is not about the ease or hardship of the family life depicted but about the easy choice for Vanish to depict an attractive person who fits the acceptable ‘able but different’ narrative that represented a step forward 20-30 years ago.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 10/04/2023 14:59

BoojaBooj2 · 10/04/2023 10:18

These days ‘others’ is highly likely to include other ND people though. That’s the real life challenge.

Especially as ironically given my dislike for the video - the girl in it would have been the sort expected to give way if she doesn’t ‘seem autistic’ to others.

15-20% of the world population is estimated to be neurodivergent. What’s more, they all may have conflicting needs. You get on a plane, one person stims loudly, the other is distressed by noise and can’t wear earplugs cuz sensory issues - what do you do? Hmm? Who takes precedence?

That’s why ‘accommodation’ is a delicate dance. It sounds bitter but it’s actually easier to be one of a few ND people and have everyone else be understanding. Than have lots, with different needs, who can’t exactly ‘absorb’ each other. It’s politically incorrect to say this.

That is such a perceptive and thought provoking post.

NewNovember · 10/04/2023 14:42

RedToothBrush · 10/04/2023 10:27

I am sick of products being sold off the back of virtue signaling and awareness training.

I think it's exploitative tbh and I don't think it really helps awareness. It plays to already sympathetic audiences but alienates others - and the danger in that is active backlash.

So it gets cash out of people going 'ooo look at the poor people how wonderful are vanish' when vanish could actually have a really piss poor track record of employment for autism. We don't actually know.

The likes of energy companies have been criticised for adverts that promote green ideas but many have been shown to merely be running 'greenwashing' campaigns to improve their public imagine rather than their being substance to them.

I'm deeply skeptical of advertisers who jump on bandwagons rather than focusing on their product tbh. Is there product really that good, if they have to draw focus away from it? Is the branding worth the extra over the own brand alternative?

No it was competion for an advertiser to make an advert based on neurodiversity to raise awareness.

bossonext · 10/04/2023 14:39

fUNNYfACE36 · 10/04/2023 10:59

The trouble is I don't think is going to promote acceptance snd tolerance of people with autism.people who don't have understanding of autism.
They are going to feel sorry for Lily who presumably has her own non autistic anxieties, and frustrations and feel sorry for her and think Ash is a brat that needs taking in hand.

Well it clearly didn't work on you.

NewNovember · 10/04/2023 14:36

The girl herself is autistic and helped write the script it's excellent.

BoojaBooj2 · 10/04/2023 14:36

ArcticSkewer · 10/04/2023 14:14

Very true for me. Tbh I didn't even know any better/different when young. I now see it as a type of grooming and it's fucked up my adult relationships as I spent my 20s 30s 40s acting as support human to everyone around me.
When other siblings post on here about how lovely it is blah blah I do wonder what their own relationships are like. We normalise abuse.

That said, I still play that role of supportive sibling and it's a lifelong caring role. Obviously unthanked as the people being cared for don't even think they are being protected/looked after. I wouldn't abandon them to the system.

That's really sad, and it shouldn't be that way.

Depends on personal circumstances. It takes a lot of effort, and it's difficult. But yes, it's possible to pay attention to both siblings and not turn them into 'emotional support humans'. In my personal case although I have always tried to balance both needs the younger got diagnosed later than would have been ideal, which I still feel guilty about.

In my logical brain I don't think either of them are capable of, or should a 'caring role' for the other. So I don't see why another sibling, just because they are NT should have it. But then unlike @Turquoisesilver I've seen a lot of sibling impacts - out of my acquaintances a fair few of the siblings have been diagnosed with their own MH issues. Depression, anxiety, self-harm.

NewNovember · 10/04/2023 14:35

CollieFIower · 10/04/2023 08:04

I hate it and am utterly fed up of people sending me links to it (I have an autistic DC). Just feels like Vanish appropriating the struggles faced by autistic people to tug on heartstrings and flog their shitty stinky toxic-to-aquatic-life stain remover.

But it's not it's a competition

CaramelicedLatte · 10/04/2023 14:32

I can’t bear it. I agree that it depicts the life of siblings (accurately a lot of the time tbf) as total suit and if I could solve everything with a hoody life would be a fucking breeze.

I wish my DS had it that ‘hard.’

bellac11 · 10/04/2023 14:14

You can care deeply and love someone though and still be resentful and have unmet needs because of them

And its so insidious that like others say, the full fall out only because obvious in much later life.

It shouldnt be dismissed

ArcticSkewer · 10/04/2023 14:14

Turquoisesilver · 10/04/2023 14:03

In my personal experience, most siblings are incredibly loving and tolerant and understanding towards their brother or sister as children/teens. Being totally candid here it tends to be adult life when resentment starts to emerge. I’m not saying that to make anyone feel bad, it’s just a point to consider when discussing it.

Very true for me. Tbh I didn't even know any better/different when young. I now see it as a type of grooming and it's fucked up my adult relationships as I spent my 20s 30s 40s acting as support human to everyone around me.
When other siblings post on here about how lovely it is blah blah I do wonder what their own relationships are like. We normalise abuse.

That said, I still play that role of supportive sibling and it's a lifelong caring role. Obviously unthanked as the people being cared for don't even think they are being protected/looked after. I wouldn't abandon them to the system.

Fundays12 · 10/04/2023 14:13

As a mum of an autistic child with 2 other nuerotypical kids I really like the advert. For a start it's really good that Vanish are highlighting that girls are autistic too as some people in my experience still believe only boys are autistic. My son is diagnosed but I know mums of girls who are desperate for diagnosis for there daughters. Some present the same way as ds but they are still struggling to get diagnosis

I also like that it highlights the family dynamic and how living with someone can affect siblings but equally it's nice that it highlights that the sister realised how much she affected her sibling my taking her jumper. It highlights sensory overload too.

MoreChilli · 10/04/2023 14:05

user1471530109 · 10/04/2023 13:59

I don't know anything about 'Ash' as a real person. But if she is amazing at maths, why should this not be portrayed? I got the impression she was 'playing herself '. I also think the real sister would be mortified that some of you have interpreted the film the way you have. But maybe not. Maybe she happy that her side has 'come through'. We don't know these people.

As for the drums. I think that's a red herring. That scene was about her regulating her emotions and the impact on the family who understandably got frustrated. It wasn't supposed to come across as Ash being selfish or a brat! I didn't take that from it. But like I said, that's my life being shown! I also didn't interpret the sister giving her the hoodie back as her being controlled. The sister was also fed up after having her life impacted. She lashed out and regretted it. She saw the impact on her sister and instantly knew she had gone too far. Just like many sibling relationships. It was very clear in the film that she cared deeply about her sister. It wasn't a reaction of being scared or controlled like some seem to think.

I agree with you.

MoreChilli · 10/04/2023 14:04

I thought it was great. One of my DDs is autistic and masks so well in school that her difficulties aren’t seen, she isn’t properly supported in school, and then we deal with the fall out at home.

I cried when I watched it, it felt like a real snapshot of our family life. I hope all my DD’s teachers see it. Awareness is a good thing.

I have a few friends with autistic daughters and they had the same reaction as me.

We do walk on eggshells, including her sister. But they are also close. Luckily we don’t have a drum kit 😂 I think part is quite symbolic though.