Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my parents are controlling?

135 replies

schoolissues1234 · 09/04/2023 15:10

Growing up in the 80s/90s my parents were quite controlling. It wasn't a very collaborative family dynamic, very much an old fashioned, parents decide, kids do as they are told at all times situation. My dad would get quite angry and shout at us and rules ranged from what we wore / what we did on holiday, down to what we discussed at dinner etc.

My sister and brother are fairly robust, or seem to be, but I suppose I have always been a bit different, more free spirited, but also more anxious... A lot of my issues with anxiety in my 20s/30s can probably stem back to a cold household, angry parents, never being comforted or my feelings listened to etc. It wasn't until I had therapy and built healthy friendships and relationships that I thought the way I felt was valid.

As I grew up, married and had kids I became very independent, but since my divorce six years ago and an illness (cancer) in my late 20s, my parents have played more and more of a role in my life again. I am the oldest child, nearly 40, own my own home, have a teenage and 10 year old child, work full time etc, yet they act like I can't be trusted and need their input on every last thing, from household purchases to bigger life and career decisions.

To begin with, over the years, I appreciated it, they helped with childcare or DIY etc but now it's got so extreme that I don't know what to do.

In this week alone I've had my holiday plans torn apart by them, had my dad turn up at my house while I worked to do the garden, and start nagging me about my finances, how clean my house was / how much washing I had put in the washing machine etc.

I feel like I am a child again, disappointing them and they are involved in every bit of decision making.

This is not how I want to live my life and I feel quite trapped. They are not the sort of people I can say this to, without getting very defensive. They are not acting like this with my (younger) brother and sister, who are both married with kids. It's like I am an idiot to them, incapable of taking care of anything.

I just want them to back off but I don't know how to handle it.

AIBU to ask, is this too much or quite normal?

OP posts:
Anonymouseposter · 09/04/2023 23:33

I wouldn’t dig too deep into the can of worms on the internet initially . They aren’t necessarily narcissistic, their original intent may have been to support you. They are now undermining you and it sounds like your father thinks it’s okay to talk to you as if you’re a teenager. I would try talking to them first before going down the no contact routes you will read about on the internet. Tell them less, don’t ask for their approval or very much help, unless you reciprocate by helping them so it’s equal. If you change how you respond they may change. Don’t argue like an adolescent just do as you please and if they criticise pull them up on it. If things don’t start to change in a few months and they up the ante you will know there’s more to it. There’s an awful lot of encouragement on the internet to cut parents off and an awful lot about narcissistic parents. It’s not always very nuanced.

SpringingSpring · 09/04/2023 22:39

My parents are like this, I tell them nothing, I don’t request help, I try to accept as little help as possible. I see them as little as possible & prepare “safe / easy” topics to discuss to keep the conversation as light as possible & let everything they say to me wash over me.

It’s sad that I have to do this but they won’t change so I’ve had to manage their behaviour & choose not to be impacted by them.

Hungrycaterpillarsmummy · 09/04/2023 22:27

Your parents sound exactly like mine! I was born 86.

I think sometimes the key is to not tell them so much. Do some thing spontaneous but don't tell them about it before you do it.
Don't tell them your holiday plans. Etc
I tell my parents things and then think "why did I tell them that?"
It's like we seek approval

schoolissues1234 · 09/04/2023 22:24

I just read about co-dependency, parents infantilising adult children and narcissistic parents, wow, I have opened a can of worms..

OP posts:
schoolissues1234 · 09/04/2023 21:53

@Anonymouseposter This has given me food for thought.

OP posts:
Rightsaidmargot · 09/04/2023 21:00

Have a look at dr ramani on YouTube. She has loads of content on narciccist parents. Not sure if yours are narciccistic but I've found it really helpful in terms of setting boundaries and breaking free from old patterns.

Anonymouseposter · 09/04/2023 20:19

I expect they were very worried about you when you had cancer and were going through the divorce and, at first you were grateful for their help. It seems to have interrupted the normal path towards full adulthood and independence.
I think you need to talk to them properly and tell them that you understand how this has come about but that you are now feeling undermined and criticised. I also agree that it would be an idea to tell them less about your plans. Reassure them that you are okay now and can cope fine.
It's possible that their original intentions weren't bad but a sort of co-dependance has evolved.

billy1966 · 09/04/2023 20:05

Good for you.

Put a note up to remind you to be vague and look up grey rock and medium chill methods of conversing.

Learn to be vague.

Tell them things only when they are decided.

You do not need their permission for anything.

Counselling would be very helpful as you have been through so much.

Be kind to yourself, you have had a very tough time.

I think putting boundaries will be well within your reach considering all you have gone through.

Mary46 · 09/04/2023 20:04

Dont tell as much. My mother is unreal I say little now. Holidays) no not sure plans again vague. I learnt hard way. She tries take over its draining..

thisisallquitecomplicated · 09/04/2023 19:56

My parents are like this, too. And it is really hard and frustrating. I haven't cracked yet how to navigate the situation, but just wanted to send you my sympathies, OP. I am reading the advise here with interest.

schoolissues1234 · 09/04/2023 18:26

@billy1966
Thank you.

I think I actually needed other adults to say this to me - that I need to stop it myself and be firm.

OP posts:
schoolissues1234 · 09/04/2023 18:25

@Createausername1970 That is actually a really good shout. It just crossed my mind that I never book away with my kids without telling them first.

How has this become my life.

Thanks also for the other suggestions, it's good to hear from people with similar parents who have managed to set boundries.

My ex husband was also very controlling and it was the main reason I left the ended, I felt so free... and now I feel I have been trapped and controlled again.

Sigh.

OP posts:
billy1966 · 09/04/2023 16:49

Yes awfully controlling.

You badly need to step back.

Stop calling or answering the phone so much.

If you stop telling them all your business they will have less to interfere about.

Arrange someone else to do your garden if necessary.

Get used to say, thanks I'm good, I have it sorted, no need to concern yourself etc.

You obviously have been very involved but you need to pull back sharply.

Createausername1970 · 09/04/2023 16:38

It might be difficult to row back from where you are now immediately, but you can definitely stop it getting any worse.

For a start, do not tell them your plans in future unless it directly affects them. And can you do a couple of unexpected things in the near future? Day out with the kids, overnight stay somewhere? Paint a wall in your living room? Colour your hair green? Things they will definitely find out about afterwards. Start to put a buffer between them and you.

They do it with best of intentions, and you don't want to piss them off completely, you can never know when you might need some extra support, but you should have your own life.

GarethSouthgatesWaistcoat · 09/04/2023 16:33

Some of this feels familiar in my own life. How are you set financially, can you outsource 'parental help' like the gardening to a monthly/fortnightly professional gardener? Pay someone to put a lock on any side gate (and don't give them the key/code) and and extra lock on the front door/back door or change locks. White-lie and say it's for extra security. If pressed say a trusted local friend has a spare key. If they keep on be abrupt and firm, they'll kick off but they'll just have to deal with it.

I'm single and have an awful habit of feeling like I need parental permission to do anything in life. I'm also aware I share bits and pieces conversationally without really thinking. I'm making a concerted effort to put stop to it and being suitably vague instead.

Pashy · 09/04/2023 16:31

Your parents sound a bit like mine- generous but everything comes with strings, and they like to exert control.

I’m the youngest and have two little left siblings. I’m the only one that doesn’t have my parents interfere.

To be honest, I think it’s because my siblings allow our parents to do too much for them. They’re very happy to have our parents help with, say, the purchase of a car, but then get miffed when parents then get involved in the choosing of that car.

Same with things like gardening, childcare, getting work done around the house etc.
It’s very clear that my parents only do “favours” that have strings attached so no idea why my siblings are then surprised when the same things happens over and over again.

They’ll happily take my parents’ money, but then act shocked when they encounter interference in relation to how that money’s spent.

I love my parents but I involve them in nothing until it’s a fait accompli. If they offer unsolicited advice, I remind them that it’s my own money I’m spending, and ask if their parents would have been able to dictate what car they drove/layout of their house etc.

I’m at the stage now where my parents know and respect my boundaries, and they don’t interfere.

As a result, I haven’t had as many gifts from them over the years as my siblings have had, but it’s a fair trade.

BellaJuno · 09/04/2023 16:24

Aquamarine1029 · 09/04/2023 15:44

They are not acting like this with my (younger) brother and sister, who are both married with kids.

I wondering if it's because your brother and sister have proper boundaries in place and simply won't entertain this type of controlling bullshit from your parents.

I say this gently, but all of this really is a "you" problem. You're letting this happen and you're letting them impact the choices you make, which is really silly considering you're 40 years old. You absolutely can put a stop to all this, you just have to stand up for yourself.

There is this dynamic with my best friend’s family but quite honestly, it’s because my friend’s sibling tells them too much of the minutiae of their life. They speak / text almost daily so for example, the parents would know where the sibling is thinking of going on holiday and offer an opinion whilst my friend just tells them when they’ve already booked etc.

FictionalCharacter · 09/04/2023 16:23

schoolissues1234 · 09/04/2023 16:08

I didn't ask him, he just turned up. Although he has been doing gardening for a few years after an initial offer. It's one of many things I started off being grateful for, but I don't care enough about the favour to put up with being berated like a child while I work a senior management role from home. It makes me feel insecure and like they think I am a failure, which may be me just projecting my childhood a little, as I was always the 'difficult one' as I was nervy and anxious.

Did you let him in or does he have a key? If the latter you should get it back.
If the former, tell them very clearly that you cannot have them coming round while you’re working. Next time he rocks up (having ignored what you said) don’t open the door, and point out that you did say they couldn’t visit while you’re working.

Things like this will be hard for you and no doubt they’ll moan a great deal, but you’ll have to do it if you don’t want this to be your life.

wheresmymojo · 09/04/2023 16:23

And honestly, from experience you have to push back hard a handful of times and after that they do eventually stop.

Mine forget and try now and then but I don't actually have to push back anymore...now I can just leave a three second pause and raise one eyebrow and they back track!

wheresmymojo · 09/04/2023 16:21

schoolissues1234 · 09/04/2023 16:08

I didn't ask him, he just turned up. Although he has been doing gardening for a few years after an initial offer. It's one of many things I started off being grateful for, but I don't care enough about the favour to put up with being berated like a child while I work a senior management role from home. It makes me feel insecure and like they think I am a failure, which may be me just projecting my childhood a little, as I was always the 'difficult one' as I was nervy and anxious.

Well, you were nervy and anxious because you had two overbearing parents who are controlling.

Time to put a stop to it.

But also time to put a stop to continuing to take on the story about your childhood - nervy, anxious, difficult, etc.

You need to drop that narrative about yourself.

What are three positive ways you would describe yourself now?

BellePeppa · 09/04/2023 16:18

I know it’ll be all tied up with your childhood but you are just sitting back and allowing them to control your life. Why? As an adult what are you afraid of if you tell them to back off and that you won’t be ‘controlled’ by them. As others have said, they can only control you if you let them.

wheresmymojo · 09/04/2023 16:17

How do you react when they do this?

My parents are very similar to yours. I just stonewall that kind of conversation until they give up.

So for example when my mother was going on and on about how much I was spending on my wedding, I just keep pointedly pushing every comment back to her own life...

"Well, you had a wedding and got to decide how much you spent on your wedding already so it's a bit of a moot point"

"Well that's nice. If you get married again, you do that then"

"If you have a second marriage, I'm sure that would be a lovely idea"

Eventually if she persists then I say "I don't remember asking for any advice on this topic so it's a bit of a waste of effort to give me any since I don't intend to take it".

Yes, it's blunt but it shuts them up.

schoolissues1234 · 09/04/2023 16:08

I didn't ask him, he just turned up. Although he has been doing gardening for a few years after an initial offer. It's one of many things I started off being grateful for, but I don't care enough about the favour to put up with being berated like a child while I work a senior management role from home. It makes me feel insecure and like they think I am a failure, which may be me just projecting my childhood a little, as I was always the 'difficult one' as I was nervy and anxious.

OP posts:
MeMyBooksAndMyCats · 09/04/2023 16:06

If you're WFH why is he turning up? Tell him to leave, you're working.
If they have a spare house key I'd suggest taking it off them.

FictionalCharacter · 09/04/2023 15:57

No it’s not normal. If you want to put a stop to this you’ll have to be very firm, endure their defensiveness, reduce contact and distract yourself if they whinge. They’ve reverted from being helpful back to being interfering and controlling.

Your father was wrong to come round while you were working, and proceed to berate you. When you’re WFH you’re at work, and there should be no visitors in the house talking at you and distracting you. I assume he decided to do your garden, you didn’t ask him? (Someone else messing with my garden would be a complete dealbreaker for me). Does he have a key or did you let him in? Either way this could be an easy first step - no more visits to “help” while you are working. You take the key back or don’t let them in while you’re working.