Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my parents are controlling?

135 replies

schoolissues1234 · 09/04/2023 15:10

Growing up in the 80s/90s my parents were quite controlling. It wasn't a very collaborative family dynamic, very much an old fashioned, parents decide, kids do as they are told at all times situation. My dad would get quite angry and shout at us and rules ranged from what we wore / what we did on holiday, down to what we discussed at dinner etc.

My sister and brother are fairly robust, or seem to be, but I suppose I have always been a bit different, more free spirited, but also more anxious... A lot of my issues with anxiety in my 20s/30s can probably stem back to a cold household, angry parents, never being comforted or my feelings listened to etc. It wasn't until I had therapy and built healthy friendships and relationships that I thought the way I felt was valid.

As I grew up, married and had kids I became very independent, but since my divorce six years ago and an illness (cancer) in my late 20s, my parents have played more and more of a role in my life again. I am the oldest child, nearly 40, own my own home, have a teenage and 10 year old child, work full time etc, yet they act like I can't be trusted and need their input on every last thing, from household purchases to bigger life and career decisions.

To begin with, over the years, I appreciated it, they helped with childcare or DIY etc but now it's got so extreme that I don't know what to do.

In this week alone I've had my holiday plans torn apart by them, had my dad turn up at my house while I worked to do the garden, and start nagging me about my finances, how clean my house was / how much washing I had put in the washing machine etc.

I feel like I am a child again, disappointing them and they are involved in every bit of decision making.

This is not how I want to live my life and I feel quite trapped. They are not the sort of people I can say this to, without getting very defensive. They are not acting like this with my (younger) brother and sister, who are both married with kids. It's like I am an idiot to them, incapable of taking care of anything.

I just want them to back off but I don't know how to handle it.

AIBU to ask, is this too much or quite normal?

OP posts:
schoolissues1234 · 10/04/2023 14:59

Yes it's the scoffing. When my dad came over the other day unannounced for gardening, he scoffed at me because I was working from my couch with a blanket on. I'd been out the night before and it was comfy. I wasn't going to sit there all day, but I really didn't need the scoffing. I felt like my personal space was hugely being invaded.

OP posts:
FictionalCharacter · 10/04/2023 14:42

PyjamaFan · 10/04/2023 14:28

Yes, their anxiety is mot up to you yo solve.

My Dad once couldn't get hold of me on the phone for a couple of hours. I was at work and then driving so obviously couldn't answer. He was really panicking.

I asked him to remember when he was my age (36 at the time) and asked if his parents knew where he was all the time when he was 36. He said no.

I think it brought home to him how ridiculous he was being. I also made it clear that I didn't actually have to answer my phone if I didn't want to!!

That’s exactly it isn’t it, they don’t realise until you point out how daft it would have been if they’d been in the same situation themselves.

Once when my birthday was coming up my dad asked me what I was doing for the day. I said I was working but would go out at the weekend. He acted completely shocked that I should have to go to work on my birthday. I asked him if he thought employers normally gave people their birthday off and asked whether he was given birthdays off when he was working. He just scoffed.

SpeckledlyHen · 10/04/2023 14:38

schoolissues1234 · 10/04/2023 09:10

@PyjamaFan Had a similar experience with being told I couldn't apply for a new job.

I think as others have said you need to start telling them much less about what you are doing in your life. You should have applied for the job and told them if and when you got offered it and after you had accepted it. You can change the dynamics of the relationship quite easily but you have to change how you interact with them.

PyjamaFan · 10/04/2023 14:28

Yes, their anxiety is mot up to you yo solve.

My Dad once couldn't get hold of me on the phone for a couple of hours. I was at work and then driving so obviously couldn't answer. He was really panicking.

I asked him to remember when he was my age (36 at the time) and asked if his parents knew where he was all the time when he was 36. He said no.

I think it brought home to him how ridiculous he was being. I also made it clear that I didn't actually have to answer my phone if I didn't want to!!

schoolissues1234 · 10/04/2023 14:19

That's a good idea!

OP posts:
coffeeisthebest · 10/04/2023 14:11

schoolissues1234 · 10/04/2023 13:47

Yes, he was a senior manager in his job before he retired, I think he needs something to manage and it's become me. They've told me before they are up at night worrying about me. I have a house, mortgage, no debts, full time well paid job and two healthy children er.......

My parents throw out that up all night worrying stuff too. I tend to give this back to them and ask if they have spoken to anyone about their anxiety. It is theirs, not yours. Good luck with better boundaries OP. It will be hard but you deserve to grow up.

schoolissues1234 · 10/04/2023 14:09

I don't really know why they see me like that. I'm very capable. I always felt like they saw me like that as a child too and struggled to make decisions for myself in my early 20s, kind of pulled it back after years and now it's gone full circle.

I was talking to them about applying for a job recently (obv now I know I shouldn't have) and my dad started warning me off because if people don't perform up to the role they can just get rid of them.

I have never so much as had a warning in previous jobs, have always been promoted and in fact am the boss in my current place. It's so ridiculous.

OP posts:
FictionalCharacter · 10/04/2023 14:04

schoolissues1234 · 10/04/2023 14:00

They have keys because they 'know what I am like' and I will most likely lose things (I really don't!)

This gets worse and worse. They really see you as a rather dim, ditsy child. Get those keys back somehow. Broken record technique if they moan and demand you give them to them again. “I’ve decided I’m keeping them Dad”. You don’t owe them an explanation.

schoolissues1234 · 10/04/2023 14:00

They have keys because they 'know what I am like' and I will most likely lose things (I really don't!)

OP posts:
schoolissues1234 · 10/04/2023 13:59

Yes, I think I knew deep down all of this wasn't right, but it's been so freeing to read all the replies from everyone and really validated my concerns.

OP posts:
FictionalCharacter · 10/04/2023 13:58

schoolissues1234 · 10/04/2023 13:47

He does have a spare car key.

There is no reason on earth why he needs one. How many other people do you know who give their dad their spare car key?! It’s your car, but even though you know he barges in to your property and does things you don’t want, you give him opportunities by giving him a key.

As for the “up at night worrying about you”, that is ridiculous. It’s another way of controlling you by guilt tripping. You have to let them run your life, otherwise you’re the cause of your poor old parents worrying! My late mother did the worrying thing too, in her case it was her way of trying to make me tell her every detail of my life so she could criticise, comment and interfere. It wasn’t hard for me to ignore her whinging “I worry about youuuu” over the phone in a fake sad wobbly voice, because it was so ridiculous and annoying.

Magenta82 · 10/04/2023 13:54

It would be a good idea to come up with a reason to get the car and house (I am assuming they have these too) back.
Then keep changing the subject when they ask for them. After a while you can say its working well without them having spare keys.

Justkeepingplatesspinning · 10/04/2023 13:54

You need to get your car and house keys back...
And I think a round the UK road trip sounds amazing!

Justkeepingplatesspinning · 10/04/2023 13:52

My parents were similar in being overly helpful to the point of it being controlling. They got worse after I had health issues and reverted to treating me like a child. Drawing very firm lines in the sand and grey rocking them helped to an extent, but it took a massive teenage-style row to get through to them. I hope it doesn't take that much for you.

schoolissues1234 · 10/04/2023 13:47

He does have a spare car key.

OP posts:
schoolissues1234 · 10/04/2023 13:47

Yes, he was a senior manager in his job before he retired, I think he needs something to manage and it's become me. They've told me before they are up at night worrying about me. I have a house, mortgage, no debts, full time well paid job and two healthy children er.......

OP posts:
FictionalCharacter · 10/04/2023 13:10

schoolissues1234 · 10/04/2023 13:02

@VivaDixie last time my car was up for MOT by dad actually booked it in for me and took it down there. I didn't ask him to - he told me he had done it. I imagine his head will explode next time I get my car sorted without his help.

He’ll be furious the first time, but he’ll get used to it, because it will be part of your new relationship with him - the one where you’ve made clear to him that you’re an independent adult.

I hope he doesn’t have a spare set of keys for your car?! If so, take it back. You own your property and your spaces. Your father has no need to be able to access them whenever he wants without your permission. And no this isn’t harsh - his “helping” is a hobby/ obsession of his, he does it because he wants to feel he’s done the correct things on your behalf, because you’re incapable. That isn’t what being helpful is.

schoolissues1234 · 10/04/2023 13:02

@VivaDixie last time my car was up for MOT by dad actually booked it in for me and took it down there. I didn't ask him to - he told me he had done it. I imagine his head will explode next time I get my car sorted without his help.

OP posts:
schoolissues1234 · 10/04/2023 13:01

It's reassuring to hear of others who have been in similar situation and are out the other side.

OP posts:
FictionalCharacter · 10/04/2023 12:32

You could start using the broken record technique to shut them down. Eg the plumbing issue:

Dad: who did you call, what did they do
You: It's fixed Dad, and it's fine
Dad: but you could have got it cheaper
You: It's fixed Dad, and it's fine
Dad: but but blah blah blah
You: It's fixed Dad, and it's fine.

Repeat the same words in the same tone of voice. It works. You're not discussing it with him so he gets nowhere and has to stop.

Holiday:
Dad: you can't do that [enter stupid reasons and spreadsheet]
You: I've booked it Dad, and we're going
Dad: blah blah petrol driving
You: I've booked it Dad, and we're going
Rinse and repeat.

As pp have said though, you tell them too much. No need to tell them about things you're getting fixed around the house. Your dad clearly sees this info as a wonderful opportunity to interfere (and in his mind, prove to himself that you're not capable and need him to take control).

Justyouwaitandseeagain · 10/04/2023 11:59

I have parents like this. I think circumstances in their lives have led to this but this isn't my responsibility. As others have said, I work hard to set and maintain boundaries. Deliberately keep decisions (big and small) confidential, careful about what I share in conversation and how often I talk with them etc

VivaDixie · 10/04/2023 11:56

I wasn't going to post as you have had some cracking advice on here. But the spreadsheet tipped me over the edge!!

My parents used to be like this, and still try to do so to an extent but I did what the majority have advised. I don't tell them anything until it is all sorted. They still have an opinion but I say 'well that is what we want to do '

Like you, many years ago when I was single I had a crack on my car door window. I got a replacement sorted but like your dad, mine quizzed me to the extreme, told me I had paid too much for it and why didn't I go to the scrap yard to see if they had a car window to sell me!! Luckily my boyfriend at the time helped me get my head straight and reassured me that was a batshit response.

Please book this holiday, I love the idea of a full UK road trip. Your kids will love it and will totally respect you for pushing back

Good luck it isn't easy at first and won't work overnight but you will get there x

Maple2023 · 10/04/2023 11:54

With the plumbing example I think you just have to be "yes it's sorted, anyway how is aunt X doing, I heard she got a new job..."
Total diversion

The other thing that you can do is you don't have to listen to it. This was a revelation for me when my mum kept on and on about how fat I was, how no man would want me, how ugly I was... I said to her one day if she started about my weight I would leave. She started, I left
I warned her, and I don't have to sit there and take it, I'm an adult

schoolissues1234 · 10/04/2023 11:49

Yes, this sounds quite similar to your sister.

At the start is was very much appreciated as I was in a desperate state, but six years later, it's completely suffocating..

OP posts:
bozzabollix · 10/04/2023 11:45

They’ve made a spreadsheet of fuel costs? My god…

Do they not have much else to do? I think they need hobbies to concentrate on, this sounds so unhealthy for you and them.

I am the sibling that doesn’t have this from parents who do it a bit with my sister. It takes being the aloof arsehole of the family, not getting as much help or resources, but it’s worth it. My sister is perceived to be the person who needs huge levels of help and advice, she’s had several disastrous relationships, has been a single mother for several periods of time, she does make some quite ruinous decisions and they feel they need to get involved. But all the time they’re there constantly ministering she can’t develop her own sense of self. It’s too smothering.

Through no fault of your own you’re probably also seen as the vulnerable one that needs saving. You’ve come out of the other side of illness and divorce and are building this new independent life. Maybe a gentle talk saying you’re thankful for all the help they’ve given but now it’s time for them to give attention to other areas of their lives. Because they really do need to find something a bit less smothering to be getting on with!

If that doesn’t work you’re going to need to do some straight talking and also stop accepting so much help, as others have said it infantilises you.

Swipe left for the next trending thread