Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my parents are controlling?

135 replies

schoolissues1234 · 09/04/2023 15:10

Growing up in the 80s/90s my parents were quite controlling. It wasn't a very collaborative family dynamic, very much an old fashioned, parents decide, kids do as they are told at all times situation. My dad would get quite angry and shout at us and rules ranged from what we wore / what we did on holiday, down to what we discussed at dinner etc.

My sister and brother are fairly robust, or seem to be, but I suppose I have always been a bit different, more free spirited, but also more anxious... A lot of my issues with anxiety in my 20s/30s can probably stem back to a cold household, angry parents, never being comforted or my feelings listened to etc. It wasn't until I had therapy and built healthy friendships and relationships that I thought the way I felt was valid.

As I grew up, married and had kids I became very independent, but since my divorce six years ago and an illness (cancer) in my late 20s, my parents have played more and more of a role in my life again. I am the oldest child, nearly 40, own my own home, have a teenage and 10 year old child, work full time etc, yet they act like I can't be trusted and need their input on every last thing, from household purchases to bigger life and career decisions.

To begin with, over the years, I appreciated it, they helped with childcare or DIY etc but now it's got so extreme that I don't know what to do.

In this week alone I've had my holiday plans torn apart by them, had my dad turn up at my house while I worked to do the garden, and start nagging me about my finances, how clean my house was / how much washing I had put in the washing machine etc.

I feel like I am a child again, disappointing them and they are involved in every bit of decision making.

This is not how I want to live my life and I feel quite trapped. They are not the sort of people I can say this to, without getting very defensive. They are not acting like this with my (younger) brother and sister, who are both married with kids. It's like I am an idiot to them, incapable of taking care of anything.

I just want them to back off but I don't know how to handle it.

AIBU to ask, is this too much or quite normal?

OP posts:
jannier · 10/04/2023 18:21

Mum and dad I will always be grateful for the help you've given me when things were tough but my life is in a good place now and I have a good well paid managerial job where I'm trusted and capable of making very important decisions so I'm sure I'm capable of determining the best holiday for me and how to do my laundry why don't you take some time for you now and enjoy your retirement and worry less about me now I'm a grown woman.

FictionalCharacter · 10/04/2023 18:17

Stripedbag101 · 10/04/2023 17:55

You need to stop - you are damaging your relationship.

my mum gives this excuse - I just see you as little girl. If you want an adult relationship with your daughter she shouldn’t have to constantly correct you.

I agree - don't even let her know you want to treat her like a child. My mother infantilised me to an extreme and it was one of the things that destroyed our relationship. I ended up really disliking her and going LC, at times NC.

Godlovesall26 · 10/04/2023 18:16

An approach that will never work with my mum because she’s too much in her own world (she’d never be convinced to try therapy, it’s for crazy people) and she can be a bit mean with others as well, is hobbies : it sort of worked a little with one of my friends, as in her mum had a particular interest/talent, and she pushed and pushed, and she finally accepted. It’s not life changing but it’s rather recent and the mum seems happy, since she’s going back (also MH issues, but no narcissism like mine, she’s a nice mum deep down feelings wise really, just in actions she smothers her second (my friend, who is also the eldest girl) so much.
Little steps can help seemingly, I admit we were very surprised she stuck to it

Godlovesall26 · 10/04/2023 18:08

PP have given great advice about approaches to begin to solve this in a happy as possible way for all, so I would definitely give that approach a good long try.

Tbf, although I’m probably biased, it does sound like they do do some things that are either helpful (gardening) or that in their eyes is (that spreadsheet!).

I say biased bc I have a controlling mum who will show up / call and only spend her time shouting about how everything I do / have done is a disaster. She has I think undiagnosed personality disorders (my two previous therapists brought it up, and actually agreed on which, in 2 different countries, which was very helpful for me). Anyway enough about me, all this to say she’s never lifted an actual finger and I was actually in care some of my childhood because she couldn’t cope with life (still can’t).

My dad used to be the complete opposite, absolutely absent, but we’re in a decent place now where he just gives advice if (rarely still) asked (bit of history re if he’d been here more I may not have been in care), and it’s lovely.

All this to say, hope it makes you feel better that at least your garden is good☺️ (kidding of course, the idea is just that it’s not healthy right now but hopefully will be soon🍀

Cranarc · 10/04/2023 18:03

I am not suggesting they have any sort of personality disorder (though they might, given what you say) but I recommend you have a look at the Out of the Fog website. There are a lot of sensible suggestions about how to manage difficult relationships and claim back your autonomy. And the forum is full of very helpful people should you wish to check it out.

Stripedbag101 · 10/04/2023 18:01

Sorry when you said she pulls me up each and every time I took it it was an ongoing thing.

not being silly at all (mum, is that you😂😂).

Coyoacan · 10/04/2023 17:58

Don't me silly, I have stopped, I'm just explaining how it worked

Stripedbag101 · 10/04/2023 17:55

Coyoacan · 10/04/2023 17:38

I would treat my dd like that if she let me, not because I think she's stupid or incapable, just a hangover from when she was a child. However she pulls me up each and every time

You need to stop - you are damaging your relationship.

my mum gives this excuse - I just see you as little girl. If you want an adult relationship with your daughter she shouldn’t have to constantly correct you.

ilovebagpuss · 10/04/2023 17:54

It was probably lovely for them to be helpful and involved when you were unwell and vulnerable. I can see how easy it would be for that to creep up into unwanted control so slowly you probably didn't worry at first.
Is there a longer term possibility of putting more miles between you as I find this cuts out a lot of that popping by to interfere.
I appreciate that's a bit cowardly as I hate confrontation but sometimes even all the boundaries can't put some people off from calling by.
My MIL is very much of the about to call out the army school of thought if she can't get in touch with us after a day! 2 grown adults and teen kids we won't have just been beamed up! I had to remind her that we are nearly 50 and it was her anxiety causing all the fuss for nothing. It does make you feel you are being tracked though.
I think your holiday sounds great, we did similar in reverse a few years ago and stayed in a hotel in Carlisle on the way to Skye. We all loved the road trip aspect.

Coyoacan · 10/04/2023 17:38

I would treat my dd like that if she let me, not because I think she's stupid or incapable, just a hangover from when she was a child. However she pulls me up each and every time

DrunkenKoala · 10/04/2023 17:25

Agree with everyone saying don’t give them too much information about yourself.

My mum is very similar to your dad and I remember reading a quote about the more knowledge someone has of you, the more power they have over you. It really struck a chord with me and I started to be more vague with her after that. This was when I learnt that her behaviour was more about controlling me than actually just having my best interests at heart. I’ve been non contact with her for a number of years and can honestly say I feel a weight has been lifted off my shoulders.

I will say the one thing that puzzled me (and continues to puzzle me) was that although (according to her) I was the incompetent one who needed her input and guidance, whenever she needed help with something I was always the first person she asked - obviously wasn’t that incompetent hey.

Royalbloo · 10/04/2023 17:11

All I know is that when I started genuinely behaving like an adult, and didn't tell them as much, and relied on them much less, there was greater respect and less meddling.

I'm obviously not a therapist, but I have found that every relationship has multiple behaviours from the two parties involved, and if you don't like the way someone behaves towards you, SOMETIMES (heavily caveated) you can change the dynamic by changing your own behaviour.

Stripedbag101 · 10/04/2023 17:07

Okay then - but I’m that case I do think it’s harsh to tell a grown woman making her own living raising two teenagers etc to stop acting like a child.

I see an adult struggling with boundaries with controlling parents. Not someone acting like a child.

perhaps that was the case for you - but perhaps not. Perhaps you are big too harsh on yourself. There are a lot of personality types out there which make for difficult adult relationships. It’s not usually a case of ‘growing up’.

I have emotionalIy immature parents. They have very little empathy and can be quite selfish. It has taken a bit of therapy for me to see that’s not my fault. It’s still very hard to navigate and I have had to significantly reduce what I tell them. Never did a therapist tell me to act like an adult.

Royalbloo · 10/04/2023 16:56

I wasn't speaking of ALL posters but replying to the OP.

My parents don't know when my MOT is due because I've not told them or asked them.

They don't have a spare key because I've never given them one.

Sometimes, especially as the OP was seriously unwell, we enjoy a certain amount of "parenting", which is understandable and somewhat comforting when you feel you need looking after a bit. I get it, but then when you're feeling more capable, others still regard you as needing them, as that's the dynamic of the relationship you've helped to create.

Stripedbag101 · 10/04/2023 16:40

Royalbloo · 10/04/2023 16:17

Someone once said to me, "Of you want to be treated like an adult, start acting like one."

It hurt at the time but they were 100% correct.

so I. Your case your parents were controlling because you think you weren’t taking on adult responsibilities?

I think for the majority of folk on this thread we are acting as adults - the problem is our parents struggle to deal with that and have become locked in a cycle of condensation and control.

but it’s great your issue was so easily resolved😊

Dustybarn · 10/04/2023 16:21

Boundaries are really hard to enforce but sometimes you have to. As you find it hard, could you counter the next volley of advice with a gentle: “thanks Dad, I appreciate your input but this is something I need to sort out myself. I’ll let you know what I decide”. If you do this enough times he will get the hint. Also don’t share so much information and just do everything yourself before they even know there is an issue. The PP’s suggestion of sorting out the car MOT in advance is a good example. And go on that holiday but don’t tell them when. Just go.

Royalbloo · 10/04/2023 16:17

Someone once said to me, "Of you want to be treated like an adult, start acting like one."

It hurt at the time but they were 100% correct.

Createausername1970 · 10/04/2023 15:47

Re your car MOT. You don't have to wait a year for the next MOT. Get it done yourself after 9 or 10 months. So when your dad starts to say it needs doing, you can tell him it's done.

Ask for the car keys back as you are thinking of part exchanging it and the dealer will want both sets.

Buy them a nice bouquet of flowers with a card, write in some lovely words about how much you love them and really appreciate their help over the years, but go on to say you are concerned they are becoming too dependent on you and you are concerned about them.

Turn the tables, start quizzing them about what they have been doing.

schoolissues1234 · 10/04/2023 15:43

It's interesting to read so many people in similar situations. Makes it feel less lonely and like there is hope.

OP posts:
cushioncovers · 10/04/2023 15:37

My father sounds very similar to yours op. There's no easy answer but what I have started to do is not tell him things he doesn't need to know everything I do or where I go and also be firm and consistent with my replies to his negativity.

schoolissues1234 · 10/04/2023 15:33

I love that thanks @BraveGoldie !

OP posts:
billy1966 · 10/04/2023 15:32

BraveGoldie · 10/04/2023 15:20

OP definitely something you need to retrain them on. I think you are right that seeing you struggling and being able to rescue you during the divorce has stuck them in that mode.

As you haven't talked to them about it before, I think it would be fair to be pleasant, but also firm and clear.... with examples. You can say it as a positive thing- looking forward.

"Mum, dad.... I want to thank you for doing an amazing job supporting me through my divorce. I know it was a terrible time and it must have been scary for you. You guys stepped in with lots of practical and emotional support and I'll always be grateful.

However, we're now at a different stage. I'm all better now. I'm very successful in my job. I have two healthy happy children. I can manage my financiers, house, garden, and car, just like my siblings can. I am happiest and can flourish best when I am playing a fully adult role. But I think we have all got stuck in a bit of a rut because of the divorce - of you feeling you have to treat me like a child and take care of me, and me turning to you for help when I don't really need it.

I'd like to reset. Id like you to stop worrying about me, because Im fine. I'd like you to make a conscious effort to treat me like an adult, just like siblings. I'd like you only to step in in unusual circumstances and when I ask for it. I'm also going to be conscious in standing on my own two feet and making my own decisions, it might feel a bit weird for all of us to start with, but I know we'll all be happier. And it doesn't mean we'll see each other less - but I want to enjoy seeing you, rather than have you worry/ stepping in to teach me or fix things.

What do you think?"

Then, if they kick off or don't do it, you can get firmer/ tougher......

This is definitely worth trying to set your mind at rest.

But your parents are SO controlling and completely disrespectful of you, I would expect tantrums, tears and hysterics.

I would go so far to expect a health crisis with one of them to punish you.

By all means call me a bad minded old woman!🤷🏻‍♀️😁

I think it will take a lot of drama and tears and even a period of low contact to resolve this, if its even possible to resolve.

Your parents level of controlling you is actually both creepy and scary.

Their ascertain that they are awake at nights worrying about you, when it is patently unnecessary, is very manipulative and extremely unkind.

I don't think they are as kind as you think.

They like you helpless, it gives them purpose in their lives, perhaps a joint focus in their marriage, rather than their marriage and each other!

They are quite batshit.

Thinking you have people so close to you whom view you so negatively and incompetent, is really not good for your mental health, and as for the example it sets your children🙄.

Good luck.
Wishing you the best.

BraveGoldie · 10/04/2023 15:20

OP definitely something you need to retrain them on. I think you are right that seeing you struggling and being able to rescue you during the divorce has stuck them in that mode.

As you haven't talked to them about it before, I think it would be fair to be pleasant, but also firm and clear.... with examples. You can say it as a positive thing- looking forward.

"Mum, dad.... I want to thank you for doing an amazing job supporting me through my divorce. I know it was a terrible time and it must have been scary for you. You guys stepped in with lots of practical and emotional support and I'll always be grateful.

However, we're now at a different stage. I'm all better now. I'm very successful in my job. I have two healthy happy children. I can manage my financiers, house, garden, and car, just like my siblings can. I am happiest and can flourish best when I am playing a fully adult role. But I think we have all got stuck in a bit of a rut because of the divorce - of you feeling you have to treat me like a child and take care of me, and me turning to you for help when I don't really need it.

I'd like to reset. Id like you to stop worrying about me, because Im fine. I'd like you to make a conscious effort to treat me like an adult, just like siblings. I'd like you only to step in in unusual circumstances and when I ask for it. I'm also going to be conscious in standing on my own two feet and making my own decisions, it might feel a bit weird for all of us to start with, but I know we'll all be happier. And it doesn't mean we'll see each other less - but I want to enjoy seeing you, rather than have you worry/ stepping in to teach me or fix things.

What do you think?"

Then, if they kick off or don't do it, you can get firmer/ tougher......

dizzygirl1 · 10/04/2023 15:14

Same with mine.
I rent and they seem to think I'll crawl back to them 400 miles with all my stuff one day! No I move and sort myself out.
Latest suggestion is they sell up so we buy together, NEVER. I mentioned it to teen DC and they were horrified as if we visit its just awful.
They constantly critise but do it 'lovingly, dor your best '.
I had a promotion last year, they've been asking lately 'how are you coping with the job' when I say well, really well (as I'm waiting for another promotion) the response 'oh yes, that's it, not good buy we all have to do it'

Stripedbag101 · 10/04/2023 15:00

This is really difficult. I have the same issue with my parents.

my dad will explain really basic things to me then repeatedly ask if I understand. He will tell me I have overpaid for pretty much everything I buy, and give me instructions on how to do the most basic of tasks. For example if I am ordering a Chinese in the phone he will be talking in my ear explaining to me what the food order is and what I should say. When I call him out on it he gets offended and huffy, or he laughs at me.

he recently called at my house as I was leaving for a meeting - he told me not to speak at the meeting incase I got myself into trouble! I am a senior finance director on a six figure salary and I was chairing the meeting!

I have done a lot of reading up on assets g boundaries. Nothing really works apart from distance. Which is sad. I don’t tell my did too much about my life becomes he tries to take over. The fact that he views me as
incapable of undertaking the most basic of tasks really did a number on my self confidence as a young adults.

i am sorry I can’t offer any words of wisdom - but the less he knows about your life the less he can comment and finish your choices.