Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my parents are controlling?

135 replies

schoolissues1234 · 09/04/2023 15:10

Growing up in the 80s/90s my parents were quite controlling. It wasn't a very collaborative family dynamic, very much an old fashioned, parents decide, kids do as they are told at all times situation. My dad would get quite angry and shout at us and rules ranged from what we wore / what we did on holiday, down to what we discussed at dinner etc.

My sister and brother are fairly robust, or seem to be, but I suppose I have always been a bit different, more free spirited, but also more anxious... A lot of my issues with anxiety in my 20s/30s can probably stem back to a cold household, angry parents, never being comforted or my feelings listened to etc. It wasn't until I had therapy and built healthy friendships and relationships that I thought the way I felt was valid.

As I grew up, married and had kids I became very independent, but since my divorce six years ago and an illness (cancer) in my late 20s, my parents have played more and more of a role in my life again. I am the oldest child, nearly 40, own my own home, have a teenage and 10 year old child, work full time etc, yet they act like I can't be trusted and need their input on every last thing, from household purchases to bigger life and career decisions.

To begin with, over the years, I appreciated it, they helped with childcare or DIY etc but now it's got so extreme that I don't know what to do.

In this week alone I've had my holiday plans torn apart by them, had my dad turn up at my house while I worked to do the garden, and start nagging me about my finances, how clean my house was / how much washing I had put in the washing machine etc.

I feel like I am a child again, disappointing them and they are involved in every bit of decision making.

This is not how I want to live my life and I feel quite trapped. They are not the sort of people I can say this to, without getting very defensive. They are not acting like this with my (younger) brother and sister, who are both married with kids. It's like I am an idiot to them, incapable of taking care of anything.

I just want them to back off but I don't know how to handle it.

AIBU to ask, is this too much or quite normal?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
coffeeisthebest · 13/04/2023 16:44

I had a similar dynamic OP, we got closer when I was really struggling mentally, and it was a closeness that I needed at the time, partly because I was talking a lot about the past, but then I moved forward out of it, and they didn't. We get on ok now but I have more space and better boundaries and far better mental health.

Dontcutthedaisies · 13/04/2023 13:50

Good for you OP. Use this thread if you need some support. It's not easy but you can start taking back control. I can't speak to anyone in RL as they all think my parents are super helpful and wonderful!

schoolissues1234 · 13/04/2023 13:15

I think after school when I moved out / went to university etc I probably had the best relationship I have had with my parents. It's all started to go backwards over the past six years. I think co-dependency to begin with when I was ill and was going through a divorce has led to bad habits from both sides. But whereas I have started to get my life on track it feels like they have ramped up the control. The weekend of the gardening / shouting about washing / spreadsheet is probably the final straw in a couple of years of bad behaviour. I am ready for this change and to take back control.

OP posts:
Dontcutthedaisies · 13/04/2023 11:59

Very similar situation to yourself OP. Perimenopausal rage helped me lay down some boundaries once I realised how detrimental their behaviour was to my mental wellbeing and started putting my own feelings first.
I do constantly have to reinforce them though, it's exhausting. My mother does the silent treatment which suits me fine as its gives me a few days peace and I'm stubborn as fuck so never tempted to 'make peace' when I know I've done nothing wrong.
As low contact as possible works for me and I tell them nothing.

zingally · 13/04/2023 10:22

I have gradually learnt over the years the old adage "what she doesn't know, can't hurt her" when it comes to my mum.

Only a couple of days ago though, I was having a bit of a moan on the phone to my mum about something that happened at work, and that I was going to put in a complaint. Well, mum launched into "mum mode" with a "well, you need to say X and Y and Z! And, and, and..." Well-intentioned, but completely out of touch and over the top.
In the end, I had to "remind" her that she hasn't had a job in 30+ years, and I'm probably more in touch with the working world than she is, and that I probably do know best.
There was a moment of pause, until she eventually said "you're probably right."

I think she just forgets/can't understand that her baby girl, her youngest child, is nearly 40!

schoolissues1234 · 13/04/2023 09:12

@AppallinglyReheated love the flower idea, might do that tomorrow.

OP posts:
SquigglyGum · 13/04/2023 05:43

My parents are similar in that they are undermining and don't really consider me a proper adult. I'm the most educated in the family, but df thinks I "talked my way into that course", like chatted up the professor during the interview or something. I've said that isn't true, obviously, and the fact that I got a distinction (Masters level) means nothing. I've married a man with a great job that pays well, and whike my career has taken a hit with having kids, I have earned a high salary in the past. But our lovely house and lifestyle in their mind is entirely down to dhs "real" job. It's so hard to hear. I can't defend myself any longer as I think it makes me feel worse..!

As other posters have said, limit the info, shut down the advice, and try to divert conversations away from that narrative and onto something where you're on equal footing.

AppallinglyReheated · 13/04/2023 04:32

Go on your holiday, it sounds fab!

Before that though... pick one thing you know they'd want to scoff at or stop you doing... and do it. Doesn't matter how small.

Go to the garden centre and buy a plant and stick it in your garden, and don't tell them a thing. Make a decision, for you, and do it with zero input from them.

Then do another... and another...

When it comes to conversation with them - learn how to shut it down.

Have stock responses, mine is just 'Mmmm'. And then I change the subject, and often, walk away as well if it's in person. If its at their place or somewhere I can just leave, I just leave. No drama or stropping just 'Mmm' and then 'ok well I'll be off now bye' and just go.

When there is the same non-interested response and no opportunity to continue things, they soon learn!

Coyoacan · 13/04/2023 03:12

@Stripedbag101 Obsessive much

Stripedbag101 · 12/04/2023 22:36

Is there gaslighting from @Coyoacan that sold me! Her poor, poor daughter😂.

therw is a therapist somewhere who knows a lot about @Coyoacan

wheresmymojo · 12/04/2023 21:35

Coyoacan · 10/04/2023 17:58

Don't me silly, I have stopped, I'm just explaining how it worked

Now we all think you're our Mum!

Newestname002 · 11/04/2023 00:47

@schoolissues1234

Before you next go on holiday change your locks so your parents don't have free range to your home. Don't warn them until that's done.

Also, Buy a programmable keysafe and have it installed somewhere discreet with a spare set of the new keys in. If you have to, absolutely in an emergency, give him the combination, but change the number at your earliest opportunity.

It will be tough to get your parents, your father especially, to back off but you need to do this for your own self respect and mental health. Good luck! 🌹

Fishonabike68 · 10/04/2023 20:38

I can sympathise with a lot of your experiences with your parents. It was similar in my family, until my Dad got sick, the family dynamic changed, and then things really came to a head.

I realised the only way to cope was to close up emotionally, to stop expecting closeness or any form of support from my parents. After that I started to feel more in control, and they started to change and actually make an effort. I think this approach has a name. I totally get what you say about the defensive attitude - now I've come to expect less, they're much much better behaved around me. Occasionally their old behaviour rears it's ugly head but it's much much rarer now. Best of luck to you.

schoolissues1234 · 10/04/2023 19:23

@Sceptre86 thank you, this sounds pretty sound advice to me 🤗

OP posts:
Sceptre86 · 10/04/2023 19:18

It's a really difficult one. As a 40 year old adult you shouldn't need their hands on support to live your life. If you do accept help then you can't in my view dictate how it is given. With parents like yours who if you give an inch take a mile it is not worth it in the long term.

I guess you could ask them to back off but that could lead to a fall out and as you don't want to go nc I don't think that would be the right option for you. Instead think I would step back so call less, be less available, when your dad was going on at you learn to shut the conversation down. So something like, 'I've heard you dad, thanks for the advice but I need to get the dinner on, see you next week'. Don't overshare, the less details they have the less they can pick apart.

Wherever they have helped you in thr past eg. childcare sort it out yourself, gardening use a gardener or do it yourself, going on holiday don't take a handout and go on the holiday you can afford. Ultimately it is your life op, you aren't used to taking control but ypu have done in the past and can do again. Your anxiety may well lead you to question yourself and that's totally normal but you sound more than capable. It will take time and won't necessarily be easy but you can do it if it is what you want.

Mary46 · 10/04/2023 18:53

I def agree say little. I was saying too much. Then got comments. So Im yes no. Holidays are last min deals. Siblings are same now we tell little. Pity it has be like this. Its negative too.

Godlovesall26 · 10/04/2023 18:52

I’d honestly forget the car keys for now, or it can quickly sound like nitpicking/alienation. As it’s been so long, I’d choose your battles

Godlovesall26 · 10/04/2023 18:50

VivaDixie · 10/04/2023 18:35

I meant to tag this one. This is a perfect response

Yes it’s what inspired me for the volunteering option, because it also includes enjoying well deserved retirement

FictionalCharacter · 10/04/2023 18:45

VivaDixie · 10/04/2023 18:35

This is perfect!

Someone recommended asking for the car keys back as you are thinking of part exchanging. Careful with that one as he will want to control that. Unfortunately you are going to have to just bite the bullet and get them back

Yes, it's not a good idea because he will immediately start researching what new car she needs. And he'd probably take her car and do the p/x himself! No need to lie anyway, better to be diplomatic but truthful, escalating to less diplomatic as needed.

sendbackaletterfromamerica · 10/04/2023 18:43

I've read this with such interest as I fell into this path about 8 years ago. It started off comforting and became really intrusive. My sibling said at the time, stop telling them so much. And it's true, that is the way to change the dynamic. I felt a bit mean withholding current information at first but now it's accepted and things are great between us all.

VivaDixie · 10/04/2023 18:35

jannier · 10/04/2023 18:21

Mum and dad I will always be grateful for the help you've given me when things were tough but my life is in a good place now and I have a good well paid managerial job where I'm trusted and capable of making very important decisions so I'm sure I'm capable of determining the best holiday for me and how to do my laundry why don't you take some time for you now and enjoy your retirement and worry less about me now I'm a grown woman.

I meant to tag this one. This is a perfect response

VivaDixie · 10/04/2023 18:35

This is perfect!

Someone recommended asking for the car keys back as you are thinking of part exchanging. Careful with that one as he will want to control that. Unfortunately you are going to have to just bite the bullet and get them back

Godlovesall26 · 10/04/2023 18:28

Godlovesall26 · 10/04/2023 18:24

Struggling young families might be worth a try, because you can phrase it as thanking them for being so wonderful for you, you’re in a better place, and it’s so sad that not everyone is so lucky (which isn’t meant to be hypocritical, it just went on way too long for you, and they’d probably be great at it if they’re inclined to)

(For what my experience is worth only ! I did a bit of that but a long time ago. It takes a lot of energy, time, availability, and confidence (which made me as a young student without a car quickly réalise I wasn’t).

Please don’t hesitate if you have more specific questions re volunteering now or in the future, I don’t wish to bother everyone with novels about it☺️

Godlovesall26 · 10/04/2023 18:24

Godlovesall26 · 10/04/2023 18:21

Volunteering might be worth a try also, I feel for your dad active stuff like gardening helping, shopping, etc for elderly or struggling young families maybe even more, might suit him well (I have a lot of volunteering experience so it’s just a guess, but he sounds like more of an ‘action’ type, I wouldn’t suggest say Samaritans)

Struggling young families might be worth a try, because you can phrase it as thanking them for being so wonderful for you, you’re in a better place, and it’s so sad that not everyone is so lucky (which isn’t meant to be hypocritical, it just went on way too long for you, and they’d probably be great at it if they’re inclined to)

Godlovesall26 · 10/04/2023 18:21

Godlovesall26 · 10/04/2023 18:16

An approach that will never work with my mum because she’s too much in her own world (she’d never be convinced to try therapy, it’s for crazy people) and she can be a bit mean with others as well, is hobbies : it sort of worked a little with one of my friends, as in her mum had a particular interest/talent, and she pushed and pushed, and she finally accepted. It’s not life changing but it’s rather recent and the mum seems happy, since she’s going back (also MH issues, but no narcissism like mine, she’s a nice mum deep down feelings wise really, just in actions she smothers her second (my friend, who is also the eldest girl) so much.
Little steps can help seemingly, I admit we were very surprised she stuck to it

Volunteering might be worth a try also, I feel for your dad active stuff like gardening helping, shopping, etc for elderly or struggling young families maybe even more, might suit him well (I have a lot of volunteering experience so it’s just a guess, but he sounds like more of an ‘action’ type, I wouldn’t suggest say Samaritans)