Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think DPs ex is ridiculous?

347 replies

DrMaxwell · 09/04/2023 14:53

So, DP and his ex have shared care of their 3 DC, a week at a time. During termtime they swap on a Friday with one parent dropping at school and the other collecting. The arrangement is to swap back around 3ish during holidays.

Last week the DC said that their mum had gone to her home country to visit her parents as they are unwell. Might have been helpful to know in case of emergency but otherwise not our business.

She emailed telling DP to drop the kids at a childminder at 3pm. He replied asking if she could confirm when she was returning to the country and he was happy to drop them home when she got back, but didn't feel comfortable leaving them with a childminder with no idea how long they'd be there. She wouldn't give any information and insisted he drop them off at 3pm. He said no and that he'd drop them back to her. 3pm came and she said she'd called the police saying he was refusing to return the children against a court order. We didn't hear any more until 8pm when she messaged saying she was home and wanted the kids back.

I know this is a really petty issue but it's been irritating me all weekend.

OP posts:
CandleInTheStorm · 10/04/2023 14:07

AllOfThemWitches · 10/04/2023 14:04

If he was that bothered he could have asked the childminders name to look up or ask on drop off for proof of their qualifications/safeguarding info.

She wouldn't have told him though?

I bet she would have, had he asked the name of the person he was dropping off to. Or he could have asked her at the door. No childminder would mind being asked as they are trained in safeguarding and would support a parent who didn't know them finding out if they are safe.

AllOfThemWitches · 10/04/2023 14:07

If he was uncomfortable with the situation he wouldn't have been alright with dropping the children off at the childminders at all. But as has been pointed out repeatedly, he didn't have an issue with the children staying with the childminder. His issue was not knowing his ex's plans.

OP clearly stated he felt 'uncomfortable.' Why are you so adamant that she's lying?

BadNomad · 10/04/2023 14:07

The ex's complaint to the police wasn't a false report though. He did actually refuse to return the children as per the court order.

AllOfThemWitches · 10/04/2023 14:05

4 times during lockdown I had the police at my door because my ex had reported me for having parties. Each time the police found nothing happening. They told me that they were getting lots of false reports.

Yes, the police, or threats of police, seem to be a popular weapon with people who hate their exes.

BadNomad · 10/04/2023 14:04

AllOfThemWitches · 10/04/2023 13:55

Interesting that you assume it's a punishment rather than a dad genuinely feeling uncomfortable with a situation. How was she 'punished' exactly?

If he was uncomfortable with the situation he wouldn't have been alright with dropping the children off at the childminders at all. But as has been pointed out repeatedly, he didn't have an issue with the children staying with the childminder. His issue was not knowing his ex's plans.

She was punished by being told he wasn't going to return the children because she wouldn't do what he wanted. She arranged and paid for childcare. She then had to spend time communicating this chaos to the childminder, and will have lost money for nothing, all while trying to get home, with the worry of a sick relative being left behind.

AllOfThemWitches · 10/04/2023 14:04

If he was that bothered he could have asked the childminders name to look up or ask on drop off for proof of their qualifications/safeguarding info.

She wouldn't have told him though?

CandleInTheStorm · 10/04/2023 14:03

Interesting that OP hasn't come back!

CandleInTheStorm · 10/04/2023 13:58

Ponderingwindow · 10/04/2023 13:32

If the children have not used this childminder before, then it is a random person. Dad dropping the children at a strangers home is simply irresponsible parenting and it would be his fault of something happened to them.

It's more likely the dc have been to this childminder before, especially as the mum is using them whilst abroad. It just sounds like the dp was using this excuse to score points. I'm sure if the situation was the childminder was picking the dc up from school for the mum, like they probably have before, or provided holiday care, there wouldn't be a problem. He only kept them because the mum refused to give him information about her itinerary. If he was that bothered he could have asked the childminders name to look up or ask on drop off for proof of their qualifications/safeguarding info.

Addymontgomeryfan · 10/04/2023 13:57

AllOfThemWitches · 10/04/2023 13:51

Oh come on, people often misuse emergency services, I had ex's mother send them round to mine to do a 'welfare check' once. They were baffled and behaviour like that got her a bollocking in court. It was literally done to 'punish' me.

4 times during lockdown I had the police at my door because my ex had reported me for having parties. Each time the police found nothing happening. They told me that they were getting lots of false reports.

AllOfThemWitches · 10/04/2023 13:55

BadNomad · 10/04/2023 13:53

Yet you don't have a problem with OP's DH "punishing" his ex for not telling him her plans.

Interesting that you assume it's a punishment rather than a dad genuinely feeling uncomfortable with a situation. How was she 'punished' exactly?

BadNomad · 10/04/2023 13:53

Yet you don't have a problem with OP's DH "punishing" his ex for not telling him her plans.

AllOfThemWitches · 10/04/2023 13:53

BadNomad · 10/04/2023 13:50

Yeah, maybe next time when switchover happens the ex will refuse to hand the children over until after 8pm to keep things equal. I'm sure OP and her DH will be fine about it if that is totally inconvenient for them.

If she wants to be absolutely ridiculous, she probably will. And yeah, they can't really contest it but that doesn't make it any less ridiculous. Again, I'd feel most sorry for the kids.

AllOfThemWitches · 10/04/2023 13:51

Oh come on, people often misuse emergency services, I had ex's mother send them round to mine to do a 'welfare check' once. They were baffled and behaviour like that got her a bollocking in court. It was literally done to 'punish' me.

BadNomad · 10/04/2023 13:50

AllOfThemWitches · 10/04/2023 13:44

And have you seen the threads by women who don't want to hand their kids over for very valid reasons and how often they are actually advised to just breach court orders?

My guess is that nothing will happen in this situation except the two parents will continue to bicker with each other, try and get one over on each other and basically subject the kids to all the stupid petty drama.

Yeah, maybe next time when switchover happens the ex will refuse to hand the children over until after 8pm to keep things equal. I'm sure OP and her DH will be fine about it if that is totally inconvenient for them.

BunnyRabbitSandwich · 10/04/2023 13:48

Your DP was being ridiculous. Let it go.

BadNomad · 10/04/2023 13:47

And have you seen the threads by women who don't want to hand their kids over for very valid reasons and how often they are actually advised to just breach court orders?

Yes, as per my previous post, a lot of people (women) think children belong to the mothers and she has the right to determine what happens to them at all times. Those people are wrong. And "valid" is subjective. What they think is valid is not always what the courts or anyone else thinks is valid. Hence, why courts need to get involved when parents can't agree on what is right, good and valid for their children.

CandleInTheStorm · 10/04/2023 13:47

AllOfThemWitches · 10/04/2023 13:30

Hes made the drama? She called the police...

Yes, he's made the drama by not dropping the kids at the childminder at 3pm as asked because his ex refused to give him information about her plans beyond what he needed to know. Calling the police was her setting that boundary.

My ex dp had a terrible co parenting relationship with his ex due to this type of controlling behaviour. They used to drop their dd off in a carpark halfway (they lived 50 miles apart.) Ex dp hated her father and instead of just not looking at her father in the car on exchange of their dd in carpark, he wanted to control the situation to the point he TOLD her NOT to bring her father with her to pick dd up and if she did he would drive away. She, not wanting to be dictated to, brought the father along in the car (baring in mind, the father was just sitting in the car so there was no exchange in words/ looks) and ex dp got so raged as he pulled up and saw the father he drove way and drove home. The mum called the police and ex dp had to drive back to return their dd to her. Dramatic, yes, could she have called him and tried to resolve it? Yes. But he had form to manipulate the situation and she would have ended up having to listen to his abuse, listen to the whole boring "gripe" story of why he hates the father and he would have most likely manipulated it all to get his way. So calling the police set a boundary, nipped it in the bud and after the policeman had to listen to ex dps story of why he hates the father, the policeman just said "well maybe just not look at him if he's in the car at drop off." Ex dp never did that again, so sometimes one dramatic thing can save a whole series of drama where the ex tries to control the situation, in this case because he wanted information that was none of his business beyond "drop off at 3 to childminder. "

melj1213 · 10/04/2023 13:45

AllOfThemWitches · 10/04/2023 13:35

She trusts him enough to leave the country, knowing they are in his care and knowing she could not get back quickly in an emergency. It doesn't sound as those she has much of an issue with his ability to parent, yet they simply couldn't just stay with him a few more hours while she was not there and she was so worried, she had to involve the police. Yeah, that doesn't sound at all like petty behaviour.

They could not stay there as the Ex had set up childcare on her terms, as per the court order and the OPs DP was happy to abide by this until he realised he didn't have the details about Ex's itinerary. (He wasn't doing this to help her out and save childcare costs, he was doing it to exert control because she had put up boundaries to stop him being involved in her life more than necessary)

He then changed the plans and refused to follow the court order until he had received information that the Ex was not legally obliged to share with him.

She insisted he follow the agreed plan as her itinerary was not his business, all he needed to know was that he was to drop the DC off at the CMs at 3pm and she would be picking them up later.

He continued to refuse to do this and so she informed the police that her Ex had breached the court order and refused to hand over their children to her appointed childcare at the agreed time in order for the situation to be officially recorded, just in case she needed it for any future court proceedings.

I don't see what the Ex has done wrong? She could have told him the information he wanted but she isn't obliged to and, depending on the situation and wider context, it may have been worse for her if she had done so and so she did the right thing by stonewalling him and telling him only what he needed to know - that the children were to be taken to a specific place at a specific time and left with a specific person until their mother returned.

AllOfThemWitches · 10/04/2023 13:45

Pubesofsoberness · 10/04/2023 13:43

I wouldn't drop my dc to a cm not knowing if their dad was in the country or not.

And you would rightly be supported in that decision. I wouldn't either.

AllOfThemWitches · 10/04/2023 13:44

BadNomad · 10/04/2023 13:40

Yes. It's what people think to do when their exes refuse to return their children. They panic. Have you not seen the threads on MN when a father refuses to bring children back after contact? They get told to call the police/ask for a welfare check/lie and say he's dangerous/call social services/get a solicitor/get a court order. She only did what a lot of people do. She knows he had no right to do what he did and wrongly assumed the police would help.

And have you seen the threads by women who don't want to hand their kids over for very valid reasons and how often they are actually advised to just breach court orders?

My guess is that nothing will happen in this situation except the two parents will continue to bicker with each other, try and get one over on each other and basically subject the kids to all the stupid petty drama.

Pubesofsoberness · 10/04/2023 13:43

I wouldn't drop my dc to a cm not knowing if their dad was in the country or not.

BadNomad · 10/04/2023 13:40

AllOfThemWitches · 10/04/2023 13:29

I guess calling the police over it was reasonable though 😆

Yes. It's what people think to do when their exes refuse to return their children. They panic. Have you not seen the threads on MN when a father refuses to bring children back after contact? They get told to call the police/ask for a welfare check/lie and say he's dangerous/call social services/get a solicitor/get a court order. She only did what a lot of people do. She knows he had no right to do what he did and wrongly assumed the police would help.

melj1213 · 10/04/2023 13:37

Crumpleton · 10/04/2023 13:23

So, DP and his ex have shared care of their 3 DC, a week at a time.

In answer to some questions, we don't know if she uses the CM usually, DP wasn't aware of her before this occasion.

Based on this info IMO your DP is NBU it's shared custody between the two of them and if done by the courts his ex should have at some point definitely introduced the CM to your DP so he would know that his DC were being placed with someone qualified to do so.

It's not nessassarily controlling his ex when he has no knowledge of the CM, there's a chance he may just want to know his DC are being left in safe hands.

Not every father is out to make life difficult for the ex, there is a possibility, even in the world of MN they may genuinely care about their DC.

I have never felt the need to officially "introduce" my childcare to my ExDH and I have never felt the need to vet the childcare my ExDH uses either.

It's irrelevant now as DD is 13 so doesn't have childcare but even when she was younger if it was a babysitter or other childcare only I was using, on my time, that I was paying for then my ExDH had no need to any information. As we co-parent amicably if I needed childcare ExDH was always the first port of call I'd ask but if he wasn't available then the only follow up I'd give him was "Don't worry, I've got Friday night sorted now", o wouldn't be going into detail about who/what/where/when/why my childcare was who it was, it would be a courtesy to let him know I had it covered.

The only time I'd ever officially "introduce" ExDH to any childcare was if there was a possibility that he would be the one picking DD up from them and so they both needed to know who the other one was - eg one after-school club would only release children to someone on the list of "approved collectors" so even though DD only ever used the ASC a couple of days a week when she was with me due to my work schedule I had ExDH (along with my parents, one of my siblings and Ex PILs) on that list, just in case of emergency, and they were all aware that DD attended along with the address/contact number.

Gondala · 10/04/2023 13:36

I would imagine she contacted the police purely as evidence that the court order had been breached, should it ever be needed in future court proceedings. Most people would be aware the police wouldn't do anything.

AllOfThemWitches · 10/04/2023 13:35

She trusts him enough to leave the country, knowing they are in his care and knowing she could not get back quickly in an emergency. It doesn't sound as those she has much of an issue with his ability to parent, yet they simply couldn't just stay with him a few more hours while she was not there and she was so worried, she had to involve the police. Yeah, that doesn't sound at all like petty behaviour.