Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To Slow Fade or Ghost Friends

156 replies

Grapefruit98 · 09/04/2023 10:48

Tell me about times you've slow faded or ghosted friends or acquaintances and why?

How did they react?

How do you feel now?

OP posts:
BananasinPyhamas · 10/04/2023 14:34

cadburyegg · 09/04/2023 12:13

I slow faded a friend who I'd met through the kids. We both had 2 kids who were similar ages. But her DD1 was just awful to my DS1, really unkind to him and my friend didn't discipline her at all so if I had allowed the play dates to continue then DS1 would have just been bullied. It was a shame because I got on really well with the mum.

This is so weird I've just done something similar
The mum is lovely and we got on great but her daughter was awful to mine and was bullying her. So bye felicia.

Grapefruit98 · 10/04/2023 14:33

herlightmaterials · 10/04/2023 14:24

And I think you could be happier if you played by the rules a bit more. You sound very shut down yourself, not an insult but just an observation, to the point that you contributed so little to your op that many posters assumed you were a journalist.

There's something really sad about feeling you can only mention difficult life circumstances to friends in passing and must pay to see a therapist if you need to discuss things in more depth, for fear of being dropped by your friends. It's not a healthy way to interact on either side of the fence.

I'm not going to ask if you're ND but I'm aware you could be. If that's the case you might want to ask yourself how your behaviour could look like narcissistic responses. I'm sure you wouldn't want to do that.

Are you a qualified psychiatrist, psychologist or therapist? I'm hoping not, given the massive ethical breach of 'diagnosing' a stranger on an internet forum.

That isn't particularly kind either. Interesting you're not criticising anyone else who posted admitting to the same behaviour.

OP posts:
ilovesooty · 10/04/2023 14:29

Grapefruit98 · 09/04/2023 11:33

Not a journalist. Just wondered what the split would be.

I've noticed from reading the forum for a year that maybe 60% of users are pragmatic in most situations (more likely to slow fade) whereas the other 40% are overly earnest and tend to have dramatic, direct interactions with people that lead to unnecessary drama.

overly earnest
unnecessary drama

So you're saying that you're in favour of ghosting people and you don't see any situations where direct communication might seem appropriate?

herlightmaterials · 10/04/2023 14:24

And I think you could be happier if you played by the rules a bit more. You sound very shut down yourself, not an insult but just an observation, to the point that you contributed so little to your op that many posters assumed you were a journalist.

There's something really sad about feeling you can only mention difficult life circumstances to friends in passing and must pay to see a therapist if you need to discuss things in more depth, for fear of being dropped by your friends. It's not a healthy way to interact on either side of the fence.

I'm not going to ask if you're ND but I'm aware you could be. If that's the case you might want to ask yourself how your behaviour could look like narcissistic responses. I'm sure you wouldn't want to do that.

herlightmaterials · 10/04/2023 14:19

Grapefruit98 · 10/04/2023 11:41

I haven't 'villainised' former friends at all. I wish them well. I just don't need to keep the relationships going.

People have casual friends. It's possible for one side to consider it a lot closer than the other.

You seem to be projecting an awful lot onto me - very angrily. You've also made very personal insults.

You've completely misunderstood me, op. I'm not angry at all and I didn't mean anything as an insult. I'm sorry if you don't like narcissistic thinking patterns called out but it was no more meant as an insult than I would mean the word 'disagreeable' as an insult - it's just a psychological term.

You're reading anger where there isn't any. However I do think you have a responsibility to go through life causing as little pain as possible - that doesn't mean that other people's happiness is your responsibility of course. I think you could be happier and could cause less pain to others. And perhaps there is an element of genuine confusion in your propensity to find others needy when they are probably just feeling lost. Instead of shutting the reactions of others down, I suggest you sit down and think if there's anything you can learn, since you were interested enough to ask the questions in your op.

burnoutbabe · 10/04/2023 14:16

Surely we all have friends who we say meet through work and maybe lunch alot but once you are no longer moaning about work together you meet and realise you don't have much in common.

So it's not that you don't like them or want to tell them to stop doing x, you are just less bothered to see them but would happily like their Facebook posts.

Tidsleytiddy · 10/04/2023 14:09

I was bullied and used as a free counselling service. I’ve ghosted as it drained the life out of me. Every other person that has come into contact with the person I ghosted has also disappeared. I’m not being the last man standing to be dumped on. I’ve got my own life. I was kind and tolerant for too long and had the piss ripped out of me with the neediness and having listen to the same subject gone over and over for ten years. My boundaries are now my boundaries. Do one, pest

Pootlie · 10/04/2023 13:10

OP I'm completely with you.

Friendships can be transient and seasonal and that is absolutely fine! A lot of people who have been ghosted or faded out are angry and outraged and devastated but possibly that's because they've invested way too much in the friendship and also in some cases maybe lack insight into how they interact with others and are completely shocked when a friend starts to disengage.

There are a tiny number of friends who you stick with throughout your life but the majority will fade out and in my opinion that's really healthy.

Grapefruit98 · 10/04/2023 12:43

JuneBridie · 10/04/2023 12:21

Don’t know what you mean by “angry”, I’m certainly not, just a bit confused by what you’re after.

You have an irritating posting style where you don’t actually answer questions, just spraff a load of word salad that’s probably supposed to impress us. It doesn’t.

in conclusion I’m glad you’re not my friend 🤣

It's interesting that I haven't personally insulted anyone on this thread, yet I'm being lectured on kindness and rudeness by people who do.

OP posts:
JuneBridie · 10/04/2023 12:21

Grapefruit98 · 10/04/2023 12:16

I think a lot of the people angry about this are unlikely to be the designated Therapy Friend or Problem Solver.

When you unintentionally give off Therapy Friend vibes, even strangers and people you barely know dump their problems on you.

People then set boundaries.

Don’t know what you mean by “angry”, I’m certainly not, just a bit confused by what you’re after.

You have an irritating posting style where you don’t actually answer questions, just spraff a load of word salad that’s probably supposed to impress us. It doesn’t.

in conclusion I’m glad you’re not my friend 🤣

Grapefruit98 · 10/04/2023 12:16

JuneBridie · 10/04/2023 11:57

I don’t really know what you want from the thread op.

You sound like a typical fair weather friend in that you’re only interested in being friends with people when they’re mentally stable and not asking anything from you. The minute their circumstances change and they require your support you’re out of there.

That’s not how friendship works.

I think a lot of the people angry about this are unlikely to be the designated Therapy Friend or Problem Solver.

When you unintentionally give off Therapy Friend vibes, even strangers and people you barely know dump their problems on you.

People then set boundaries.

OP posts:
JuneBridie · 10/04/2023 11:57

I don’t really know what you want from the thread op.

You sound like a typical fair weather friend in that you’re only interested in being friends with people when they’re mentally stable and not asking anything from you. The minute their circumstances change and they require your support you’re out of there.

That’s not how friendship works.

Grapefruit98 · 10/04/2023 11:41

herlightmaterials · 10/04/2023 11:36

I thought you'd find it weird.

Your options are not discard or be a hostage. There is a spectrum of responses between but you don't seem to see that.

It's interesting that you devalue and villainise people who were your friends a short time ago because they're of no further use to you - they're a friend when you want them and a needy hostage taker (if they don't submit to being ghosted) when you wish to discard them. That's how a narcissist thinks. In fact, this is exactly the same person with the same value and needs as well you first met them. The person who has changed is you.

It's also interesting that you can only process new information by thinking of yourself and how it would affect you. It's been pointed out to you that ghosting someone is confusing and will cause them distress - this is not confirmation that they're needy and don't deserve an explanation. That's how a narcissist thinks, though. To deal with people differently and give them an explanation would not really negatively affect you - other than to expose your self absorption - but your instinctive reaction is to feel trapped and look on yourself as a victim at the very suggestion. That's a histrionic response that allows you to look after your own interests without employing any cognitive empathy - another narcissistic response pattern.

I haven't 'villainised' former friends at all. I wish them well. I just don't need to keep the relationships going.

People have casual friends. It's possible for one side to consider it a lot closer than the other.

You seem to be projecting an awful lot onto me - very angrily. You've also made very personal insults.

OP posts:
herlightmaterials · 10/04/2023 11:36

I thought you'd find it weird.

Your options are not discard or be a hostage. There is a spectrum of responses between but you don't seem to see that.

It's interesting that you devalue and villainise people who were your friends a short time ago because they're of no further use to you - they're a friend when you want them and a needy hostage taker (if they don't submit to being ghosted) when you wish to discard them. That's how a narcissist thinks. In fact, this is exactly the same person with the same value and needs as well you first met them. The person who has changed is you.

It's also interesting that you can only process new information by thinking of yourself and how it would affect you. It's been pointed out to you that ghosting someone is confusing and will cause them distress - this is not confirmation that they're needy and don't deserve an explanation. That's how a narcissist thinks, though. To deal with people differently and give them an explanation would not really negatively affect you - other than to expose your self absorption - but your instinctive reaction is to feel trapped and look on yourself as a victim at the very suggestion. That's a histrionic response that allows you to look after your own interests without employing any cognitive empathy - another narcissistic response pattern.

Grapefruit98 · 10/04/2023 11:25

herlightmaterials · 10/04/2023 11:16

For a few months I reduce contact and hope it sets a new norm. It doesn't. They become more needy.

They don't become more needy. It's unfair of you to judge them that way when you are not being transparent about what you're doing. People don't think of themselves as commodities to be discarded (thankfully) so their first thought on realising that distance has come between you will be to fix it. When you continue on your plan (which only you know about) they're then likely to wonder, as a decent person does, if they've offended you or if you are withdrawal because you're not ok. This is how a friendship works. Not being a commodity but a person with feelings, this confusing treatment will likely eventually leave them feeling a degree of frustration and low self-esteem which they may try to resolve by getting clarity about just happened. That's perfectly normal behaviour from someone who doesn't understand you've left them in your trash can.

Eventually, when they realise what you've been doing and get the measure of you, they will probably be more than happy to be discarded by you. But your expectation that they will instantly reach that place just because they're no longer in favour with you in your mind is unrealistic and narcissistic.

You are literally making them behave in a way that you perceive as 'needy' by treating people like commodities and projections of your own imagination. Were you to say "You haven't done anything to offend me but I don't think we have much in common anymore. I don't give a toss about your feelings and I like to drop people when I feel this way so don't contact me again," I think you'd encounter a bit of disgust but very little neediness as that is just confusion.

That is a very weird response.

Have you stayed in close contact with everyone you've ever worked with or met at a hobby? Do you have a busy job? New hobbies?

Being friendly with someone for a bit isn't a hostage situation.

OP posts:
herlightmaterials · 10/04/2023 11:16

Grapefruit98 · 10/04/2023 10:53

A big part of it for me is that friendships are based on proximity mostly. I have a few good, long term friends who stay far away and we meet a few times a year despite that.

Then there are casual friends I worked with years ago. Or met at a hobby I'm no longer involved in. I have no reason to be in weekly contact with them. It's too much for me. We no longer have anything significant in common.

For a few months I reduce contact and hope it sets a new norm. It doesn't. They become more needy.

Eventually just not responding is easier.

For a few months I reduce contact and hope it sets a new norm. It doesn't. They become more needy.

They don't become more needy. It's unfair of you to judge them that way when you are not being transparent about what you're doing. People don't think of themselves as commodities to be discarded (thankfully) so their first thought on realising that distance has come between you will be to fix it. When you continue on your plan (which only you know about) they're then likely to wonder, as a decent person does, if they've offended you or if you are withdrawal because you're not ok. This is how a friendship works. Not being a commodity but a person with feelings, this confusing treatment will likely eventually leave them feeling a degree of frustration and low self-esteem which they may try to resolve by getting clarity about just happened. That's perfectly normal behaviour from someone who doesn't understand you've left them in your trash can.

Eventually, when they realise what you've been doing and get the measure of you, they will probably be more than happy to be discarded by you. But your expectation that they will instantly reach that place just because they're no longer in favour with you in your mind is unrealistic and narcissistic.

You are literally making them behave in a way that you perceive as 'needy' by treating people like commodities and projections of your own imagination. Were you to say "You haven't done anything to offend me but I don't think we have much in common anymore. I don't give a toss about your feelings and I like to drop people when I feel this way so don't contact me again," I think you'd encounter a bit of disgust but very little neediness as that is just confusion.

Grapefruit98 · 10/04/2023 10:53

A big part of it for me is that friendships are based on proximity mostly. I have a few good, long term friends who stay far away and we meet a few times a year despite that.

Then there are casual friends I worked with years ago. Or met at a hobby I'm no longer involved in. I have no reason to be in weekly contact with them. It's too much for me. We no longer have anything significant in common.

For a few months I reduce contact and hope it sets a new norm. It doesn't. They become more needy.

Eventually just not responding is easier.

OP posts:
AskMeMore · 10/04/2023 02:16

Was treated like this by someone who had been a very close friend. Totally shitty. I have no idea why. It seemed they had just made a "better" friend and decided to ditch me.

Blondewithredlips · 10/04/2023 01:25

Grapefruit98 · 09/04/2023 15:58

I don't think that's accurate. Also, it was the main thing he spoke about. Every conversation.

He can hire a therapist instead.

I agree OP. I have a friend that complains about her DH every time we meet. She goes on and on about him. She has enough money to leave but won't. I live on my own and she has no self awareness that I don't want her offloading onto me every time I see her.

Rogue1001MNer · 10/04/2023 01:02

I was brutally ghosted and dropped, and it hurt. 20+ yrs ago, and I remember it clearly enough to mention it now.

My bloody amazing young adult dd had a friend who was bloody difficult (lots of examples of friend behaving awfully). Dd was slow fading. Difficult friend chased. Dd told her "yes, I do have a problem with you.. it's x y x example; I need some space" the friend I'd VERY hurt.

But I think my DD fucking rocks

JackyinaTracky · 09/04/2023 23:47

I’ve been slow faded/ghosted loads of times. It used to really upset me and I’d spend ages thinking through what I said and how I said it. I got myself so tied in knots I was afraid to make new friends and afraid to speak. I’ve come to accept that whatever it is that people don’t like is so deeply a part of me that I don’t think I can change it. Sometimes I wish I knew the reason just to be sure, in case it case it is something I can work on but to be honest the hope that it might be them and not me is probably what keeps me sane. To have my biggest flaws and fears listed would be awful.
so… I think slow fade is probably the kindest of 2 options.

Eastersundayname · 09/04/2023 22:10

herlightmaterials · 09/04/2023 21:59

Your friends are resilient, pro active people now. When something comes along that shows a different side to them, you will drop them.

Quite a range between mentioning a problem 'in passing' (that's a low tolerance threshold you have there) and sitting down in front of a therapist. I'm surprised your therapist didn't encourage you to open up more to your friends. I suspect they did.

I suspect you're at the far end of a pendulum swing. You don't have to take this extreme position just because your last position was also extreme.

You're putting yourself under a lot of pressure and limiting the depth of the friendships you can have. The fact that you're wondering about how ghosted people react suggests to me that deep down you think it could be you one day. I know you won't see that now. But it's an odd thing for a resilient, proactive positive person to be ruminating about on a day when most people are usually very busy doing positive, proactive things. And you're doing it without a shred of empathy, either so it's not just checking you're a good person as we all do from time to time. I think you're struggling on some level.

That's what I thought.

OP needs a big dose of love ❤️

herlightmaterials · 09/04/2023 21:59

Grapefruit98 · 09/04/2023 16:55

There's a difference between mentioning a problem in passing to a friend and treating them like a therapist.

My friends are all resilient, pro-active people. They're ambitious and focus on positive things.

When I was upset about something I paid to see a therapist.

Your friends are resilient, pro active people now. When something comes along that shows a different side to them, you will drop them.

Quite a range between mentioning a problem 'in passing' (that's a low tolerance threshold you have there) and sitting down in front of a therapist. I'm surprised your therapist didn't encourage you to open up more to your friends. I suspect they did.

I suspect you're at the far end of a pendulum swing. You don't have to take this extreme position just because your last position was also extreme.

You're putting yourself under a lot of pressure and limiting the depth of the friendships you can have. The fact that you're wondering about how ghosted people react suggests to me that deep down you think it could be you one day. I know you won't see that now. But it's an odd thing for a resilient, proactive positive person to be ruminating about on a day when most people are usually very busy doing positive, proactive things. And you're doing it without a shred of empathy, either so it's not just checking you're a good person as we all do from time to time. I think you're struggling on some level.

Mary46 · 09/04/2023 19:19

No not nice agree. Sometimes it just fizzles out not much in common. Or flaky re meetups or the purse not opened lol so sometimes there good reasons to not want to meet..... or reduce the meetups

teaandtoastwithmarmite · 09/04/2023 19:14

YABU. Ghosting someone is horrible