Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not to like censorship...

63 replies

Greenfairydust · 09/04/2023 09:50

I am going to start this thread saying that I am not gender critical in any way.

But I am really concerned that threads are being deleted on the forum because they are discussing the Nike/DM controversy.

I disagree with gender critical feminists but I 100% support their right to discuss their concerns openly and this gives people like me a chance to put a counter-argument.

Censorship is never the answer.

OP posts:
TheKeatingFive · 09/04/2023 14:22

I would, though, if I wanted to keep talking to you. Not just agreeing blindly but also not dismissing you with "nope, you're mistaken"

If I started demanding access to African American only groups, services or privileges like scholarships, you would, I think, be compelled to have the 'you're mistaken' conversation at some point. No?

Greenfairydust · 09/04/2023 14:21

Thanks for the feedback everyone!

I felt a bit petulant/petty when I posted this but I am glad so many people are championing debate rather than blanket censorship.

I think people who are just posting insults/defamatory content/fake stuff on threads can rightfully expect to have comments deleted.

But I do believe people should be allowed to post their views on gender issues and then have others make a thought-through arguments as to why they disagree with these views, rather than just having them erased.

Somehow blanket deletion feels inappropriate.

OP posts:
Redebs · 09/04/2023 14:13

beastlyslumber · 09/04/2023 13:03

I agree, and feel the same way about the anti vax posts and any other posts really. As long as they're not breaking any laws I really don't see why MN feels the need to get involved. Inflammatory comments can be reported and deleted without taking down whole threads. People want to talk about this stuff!

Because when stupid ideas gain credibility through repetition, the consequences can result in deaths

beastlyslumber · 09/04/2023 14:11

JustAnotherPoster00 · 09/04/2023 13:51

I dont understand your use of the word woke there, could you explain what it means to me?

It means authoritarian and driven by ideology.

Redebs · 09/04/2023 14:10

Greenfairydust · 09/04/2023 09:50

I am going to start this thread saying that I am not gender critical in any way.

But I am really concerned that threads are being deleted on the forum because they are discussing the Nike/DM controversy.

I disagree with gender critical feminists but I 100% support their right to discuss their concerns openly and this gives people like me a chance to put a counter-argument.

Censorship is never the answer.

It's easy to say there should be no censorship, but do do really understand what that means?

We have societal values that are continually evolving. Some things are unacceptable and there is usually a bit of debate about them. Like this topic.

FOJN · 09/04/2023 14:04

Squiblet · 09/04/2023 13:31

What? How on earth did you get that from what I said?

My point was that if you want to disagree with someone but keep the dialogue open, you can't do it by ignoring their feelings and justifying that by pointing to the facts.

I'm very uncomfortable with the idea of naked males in previously female spaces, it makes me feel quite vulnerable. My feelings don't matter of course because the side you think we are obliged to maintain dialogue with think I should be punched, decapitated, killed or choked on girl dick and say so without any condemnation. Hardly surprising I'm not worried about hurting feelings by sticking to facts.

You'll forgive me if I'm struggling to see this group as the most vulnerable and oppressed.

FOJN · 09/04/2023 13:59

Squiblet · 09/04/2023 12:26

The facts are straightforward, yes. It's the people's feelings that are complex.

And, like it or not, it's a highly emotive topic that can't simply be settled by saying, "facts trump feelings, therefore you'll need to change all your emotions soz."

Emotions are individual.
How do you propose we legislate to accommodate everyone's feelings? Whose feelings should matter more?
Do we decide on weight of numbers?
Should the majority view win or does the minority view win because otherwise the minority will feel oppressed?
Do the "facts" of unintended consequences not matter if to mention them hurts someone's feelings.

But it's not going to help the GC cause to keep saying, "the facts are on our side so we're right and you're wrong". This will only entrench everyone's positions even deeper and make any kind of dialogue impossible.

The GC side did not assert the matter was decided "no debate" so we are not the ones who have made dialogue impossible. We are also not the side who resorts to violence to silence the people we disagree with which is perhaps why we have decided that sticking to the facts is the only way forward.

JustAnotherPoster00 · 09/04/2023 13:51

grayhairdontcare · 09/04/2023 10:36

I think it's fucking disgusting that people can't post their views and debate the issues surrounding gender.
It's wokeness at it finest by MNHQ

I dont understand your use of the word woke there, could you explain what it means to me?

grayhairdontcare · 09/04/2023 13:40

Of course you can.
The facts are facts!
I have no problem with him calling himself whatever he wants.
But the fact is he is not a woman.
I am not a man and never will be .
And no amount of foot stamping or whining will change that fact!
It's pure misogyny and making sure that all women of the world are looked upon and treated with utter contempt to allow people to do whatever they please!
It's fucking ridiculous and dangerous for every woman

Squiblet · 09/04/2023 13:31

grayhairdontcare · 09/04/2023 13:24

@Squiblet so you are basically saying that anyone can say or do anything a no one can be offended by it incase their feelings are hurt?
Absolutely ridiculous

What? How on earth did you get that from what I said?

My point was that if you want to disagree with someone but keep the dialogue open, you can't do it by ignoring their feelings and justifying that by pointing to the facts.

grayhairdontcare · 09/04/2023 13:24

@Squiblet so you are basically saying that anyone can say or do anything a no one can be offended by it incase their feelings are hurt?
Absolutely ridiculous

Jonei · 09/04/2023 13:10

It is entirely possible for private platforms to censor certain topics, creating a bias, within their talk guidelines. Generally known as censorship.

Lockheart · 09/04/2023 13:05

A privately owned forum enforcing its talk guidelines is not censorship. You are not a victim.

Only the government has the power to censor people.

MN could ban all mention of haricot beans or the colour blue if they so chose, and it still wouldn't be censorship.

Startwithamimosa · 09/04/2023 13:05

I'm surprisingly, I've seen very hateful ones in the past which have shocked me so I'm surprised now all of a sudden they're being deleted

Squiblet · 09/04/2023 13:05

But if I said my 'feelings' were that I was actually African America, that was my identity and it should be respected, you, rightly, wouldn't give that the time of day.

I would, though, if I wanted to keep talking to you. Not just agreeing blindly but also not dismissing you with "nope, you're mistaken" and thereby making you my lifelong enemy.

I'd hope that if we were to live in the same society, we would talk in a way that respected feelings and opened doors to compromise.

But I think, on this website, I'm in a minority.

beastlyslumber · 09/04/2023 13:03

I agree, and feel the same way about the anti vax posts and any other posts really. As long as they're not breaking any laws I really don't see why MN feels the need to get involved. Inflammatory comments can be reported and deleted without taking down whole threads. People want to talk about this stuff!

Jonei · 09/04/2023 12:58

It's really very simple. Misogyny at it's finest. The only added complexity is wide spread state sanctioned violence from men towards women, and women being silenced, losing their jobs, etc for speaking out. People thought the 1980s was bad? This is far far worse.

TheKeatingFive · 09/04/2023 12:54

But it's not going to help the GC cause to keep saying, "the facts are on our side so we're right and you're wrong". This will only entrench everyone's positions even deeper and make any kind of dialogue impossible.

But if I said my 'feelings' were that I was actually African America, that was my identity and it should be respected, you, rightly, wouldn't give that the time of day.

So why should these 'feelings' be respected and others not?

TheKeatingFive · 09/04/2023 12:51

If you need the other side to be censored in order to assert your pov, then that says it all really.

But what is motivating people to play along with this bollocks. That's my question.

grayhairdontcare · 09/04/2023 12:49

But the fact is he is not a woman.
He is a man !
I don't give a shiny shit who that offends.
He has no idea about needing breast support during exercise.
It's just wokeness gone crazy!

Squiblet · 09/04/2023 12:46

but facts trump feelings in all others areas of life.

No they don't. Facts and feelings are intertwined in nearly every sphere of public life. Look at gun control in the US - statistics show that countries with fewer guns in private hands experience fewer deaths by shooting, but many Americans have strong feelings about gun ownership, and the gun control campaigners have to take that into account. They can't just ignore it. Similarly, free speech - there are any number of things you could say that might be factually true but would cause huge offence. We all negotiate people's feelings all the time, as a way of maintaining societal cohesion.

I don't know much about the Nike issue, and certainly it should be discussed. But it's not going to help the GC cause to keep saying, "the facts are on our side so we're right and you're wrong". This will only entrench everyone's positions even deeper and make any kind of dialogue impossible.

grayhairdontcare · 09/04/2023 12:32

@Squiblet but facts trump feelings in all others areas of life.
No one is saying someone can't be comfortable in who the are or who they want to be.
But the fact is that unless you have xx chromosomes then you are not a biological woman and do not need to be paid of Nike to advertise a sports bra for breast you don't have !

Squiblet · 09/04/2023 12:26

FOJN · 09/04/2023 11:37

This issue is only complex if you believe it's possible for humans to change sex. It becomes much more straight forward if you accept the material reality of biological sex and do not think facts should be subordinate to peoples feelings.

The facts are straightforward, yes. It's the people's feelings that are complex.

And, like it or not, it's a highly emotive topic that can't simply be settled by saying, "facts trump feelings, therefore you'll need to change all your emotions soz."

SerendipityJane · 09/04/2023 11:56

The problem with censorship is that it follows the same path as the joke that ends "now we're just arguing about the price".

FOJN · 09/04/2023 11:37

BuffyTheCat · 09/04/2023 11:03

I agree: we need frank and civil discussion of these issues. It’s really complex and yet it’s constantly oversimplified by both sides.

This issue is only complex if you believe it's possible for humans to change sex. It becomes much more straight forward if you accept the material reality of biological sex and do not think facts should be subordinate to peoples feelings.