Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friend charged drinks and desserts to my hotel room.

583 replies

annaherrings · 09/04/2023 07:34

I was NY where we have an office (the company I work for that is). I was staying in a hotel (paid for by company). I had two friends from London who were in NY at the same time visiting for Easter break. They wanted to meet up and I invited them to my hotel for lunch/drinks. I do not expense my hotel charges as I never have work meetings at the hotel and our offices are where all meetings are held. We also eat out a lot and work pays for that. So I settle any incidentals bill myself - whereas the room is paid for.

We had lunch and everything was fine. I had to head back to my office so I settled up. The waiter asked what my room # was when I asked to charge it to the room as I had to go. So I told him/said it out loud. I signed the check/bill and left. Before leaving, the two girls said: 'We might stay for one more in the adjoining bar'. That was obviously fine. They are free to do what they want/go where they want.

Upon checking out; I see extra charges of 4 drinks and two desserts. Totalling $140 and I'm pretty sure two of the drinks were champagne. (It was a 5* hotel in Manhattan).

It stood out because I was only aware of the lunch total since it was the only thing I charged to my room throughout the entire stay. So it wasn't exactly hard to spot.

I asked the hotel for the actual receipt (the one which you sign your name/room # on). Sure enough, it wasn't my signature. They had even added on the 20% tip.

When I queried them (the girls) on it, they said the hotel staff (same waiter) immediately charged it to my room and didn't give them a chance to pay. They 'wanted' to tip (tipping is a big deal in the US) so they said they asked for a check/bill - and tipped via the room - meaning my card. Hence the receipt in front of me. They also wrote down my room # since they heard me say it out loud prior.

I do not believe they didn't have a chance to pay. If they really wanted to, they could have. They then said they assumed my work was paying (I work for a famous/large bank) so we aren't exactly short of company money - hence their 'assumption'.

They then said they did 'ask me' if it was ok to 'stay for one more at the adjoining bar' and that I was more than ok with it.

To clarify, they didn't 'ask' and moreover; no two grown women need to ask my permission as to where they can go. It is entirely up to them where they go and what they do.

I need up paying their bill as I didn't want any awkwardness. I haven't responded to their texts and TBH, I'd rather just never talk to them again. AIBU to think there was no misunderstanding here? I could never ever walk out of a place - 5* or not - and not pay. The audacity of charging anything to a friend's room - and not even telling them about it after the fact - is unbelievable to me. My DH says to drop it and leave it be and called it 'cheeky' but not worth losing friendships over. I suspect he just doesn't want to engage.

OP posts:
Werehalfwaythere · 09/04/2023 09:33

Theluggage15 · 09/04/2023 09:29

She already told them she was paying personally for the lunch, only an idiot would think a company would be paying anyway. I could settle a $300 bill myself as could many people. I wouldn’t dream of carrying on after the host had left unless I paid myself, how greedy to do otherwise. You sound just like them.

You sound a little defensive to be honest, this is AIBU. Not Judge Judy.

Werehalfwaythere · 09/04/2023 09:32

Dobby123456 · 09/04/2023 09:29

I think the first half of your post is fine. However, they asked 8f they could stay and order pudding. Adding on champagne was taking the piss!

But it wouldn't be taking the piss if they thought OP was getting reimbursed.

That's why it's important to know how clear OP was about who was ultimately paying.

SoShallINever · 09/04/2023 09:32

Blimey, if one of my friends treated us to a $326 lunch in a five star hotel I'd be thrilled and wondering how I could Thank her, (maybe send flowers and a note/make her afternoon tea when we got home). No way would I be adding on extras at her expense.
You have done the right thing asking for the money back. Its not about the $140, (I'm sure you can easily afford that) it's about the bloody principle of their actions. Completely outrageous and not how friends behave.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 09/04/2023 09:31

Brefugee · 09/04/2023 08:55

I used to travel a lot for work, lately part of my job in the accounting team has been approving expenses.

Generally (some companies may vary but most countries have similar rules about this because of tax issues): if you eat alone you pay. There may be more or less Per Diems (daily allowance) available. If you eat with colleagues and can convince the company that you discussed work, then usually you'll be able to expense it. Invite clients? have at it, but there may be limits depending on your/the clients position in the company.

But also. The hotel need to be aware this happened (i wouldn't have paid an invoice without my signature being on it - that's on the hotel).

And even if your friends thought you could expense it (i see they're teachers so may not have experience of expenses) the fact that they drank fucking champagne? no. That is CFery right there. Even if it's a genuine mistake you don't take the piss like this.

Expenses was a large part of my work at exjob, and receipts for entertainment were logged on the electronic system with a description of who you entertained, company they worked for and (briefly) what the meeting was about. And there were limits on spending depending on status in company (CEO could spend more than other people in certain areas).

Anything that didn't meet the criteria was rejected and not paid if the explanation didn't meet the procedures.

And even if your friends thought you could expense it (i see they're teachers so may not have experience of expenses) the fact that they drank fucking champagne? no. That is CFery right there. Even if it's a genuine mistake you don't take the piss like this

Used to work with a woman like this back in the 90s. Business class lounge on a business trip? champagne all round, company will pay. Complete freeloader. (Extended to other people's husbands, as well).

KittyAlfred · 09/04/2023 09:31

They obviously thought it was on expenses so decided to go crazy. It’s just a misunderstanding. They should pay you back, but whether you push for this or not depends on how much you need the money. If you’re minted then I’d probably leave it.

Theluggage15 · 09/04/2023 09:29

Werehalfwaythere · 09/04/2023 09:24

@Theluggage15 I thought the same of your comment.

She already told them she was paying personally for the lunch, only an idiot would think a company would be paying anyway. I could settle a $300 bill myself as could many people. I wouldn’t dream of carrying on after the host had left unless I paid myself, how greedy to do otherwise. You sound just like them.

Dobby123456 · 09/04/2023 09:29

Werehalfwaythere · 09/04/2023 09:14

I think I would have thought everything was in the company. That's what I'd assume if someone settled a $300+ meal without asking me to contribute. I mean, I'm in my 30s and don't know anyone who could afford to pay a $300+ lunch bill themselves. You must be extremely well paid.

I suspect it was a misunderstanding initially. Now, at the prospect of paying $70 each for a pudding and two drinks, they're panicking. Especially on teacher salaries. Perhaps they're hoping, given you presumably earn a LOT more than them, that you may not mind paying in this instance.

I guess it depends where the misunderstanding came from. If you were crystal clear that the meal was over and anything else is paid by them, then YANBU, they are taking advantage of you.

But if it was possible they thought either the company was paying (or reimbursing you), or they thought you'd agreed to them having the pudding etc as part of the meal you offered to pay, then YABU to suddenly lump them with a large bill they didn't think they'd owe.

Why did you offer to pay for lunch? I think that's likely where the misunderstanding came from. Why didn't you all just meet up somewhere normally priced and pay your own way? It almost feels a bit tacky to pay for a meal, have to rush off, and then expect guests to then pay the rest. You either pay for the whole meal, or you meet up elsewhere and pay your own ways.

I think the first half of your post is fine. However, they asked 8f they could stay and order pudding. Adding on champagne was taking the piss!

UnshakenNeedsStirring · 09/04/2023 09:29

They were CF. I hope you get your money back OP. Id drop them as friends. You dont need friends like this.

Werehalfwaythere · 09/04/2023 09:29

MsRosley · 09/04/2023 09:26

You're working very hard to present these two women as decent people who simply 'misunderstood', @Werehalfwaythere Thing is, decent people, people with actual moral principles who don't unconsciously view others as a resource, would be absolutely horrified when they realised the error they'd made, and rush in to reimburse OP. They wouldn't be making excuses. They'd be desperate to set things straight and full of apologies, especially given OP's generosity.

These aren't decent people, they're freeloaders who've been pulled up on it.

Perhaps. That's certainly possible (as I said in my comment).

But it is also possible that this is simply a misunderstanding with the OP not being clear enough in who's paying, given she paid for the meal and it's a company trip. There's lots of room for misunderstanding.

IF they misunderstood due to OP not being clear enough, then I don't think it's fair to expect them to pay.

It all depends on how clear the communication was from OP and only she knows that.

FiledAwayInABox · 09/04/2023 09:28

You don't need to drop them as friend but you need to understand what they are like. That's scummy behaviour.

MsRosley · 09/04/2023 09:26

You're working very hard to present these two women as decent people who simply 'misunderstood', @Werehalfwaythere Thing is, decent people, people with actual moral principles who don't unconsciously view others as a resource, would be absolutely horrified when they realised the error they'd made, and rush in to reimburse OP. They wouldn't be making excuses. They'd be desperate to set things straight and full of apologies, especially given OP's generosity.

These aren't decent people, they're freeloaders who've been pulled up on it.

Werehalfwaythere · 09/04/2023 09:24

@Theluggage15 I thought the same of your comment.

Dobby123456 · 09/04/2023 09:24

I once had to write a letter to the expenses departement explaining why I got a taxi to the hotel from the airport instead of taking the bus. Don't think I could have explained away champagne!

Werehalfwaythere · 09/04/2023 09:22

hallodarknessmyoldfriend · 09/04/2023 09:18

That's not the case at all. You should read OP's updates properly.

What did I misinterpret?

Werehalfwaythere · 09/04/2023 09:21

SmallAngryPenguinWoman · 09/04/2023 09:18

Oh please! What a load of absolute bollix 🤬🤬
It's OP's fault because she was kind enough to buy them lunch as a treat. Christ Almighty, some people are unbelievable - I guess the OP's friends aren't the only CFs.

If your friend offered to buy you lunch and zizzis, and left after main saying she needed to rush home for XYZ, and you said "ok, is it ok if we stay for pudding?" And she says yes, wouldn't you assume she's paying, given she offered to buy you lunch?

You may find my response bollox (what's bollix?) but people are allowed to think differently and offer alternative opinions. That's the whole point of AIBU. Stop trying to police what other people say.

FiddleLeaf · 09/04/2023 09:21

YANBU - They should pay up immediately and the fact they haven’t… I would be ditching them tbh.

Theluggage15 · 09/04/2023 09:19

Werehalfwaythere · 09/04/2023 09:14

I think I would have thought everything was in the company. That's what I'd assume if someone settled a $300+ meal without asking me to contribute. I mean, I'm in my 30s and don't know anyone who could afford to pay a $300+ lunch bill themselves. You must be extremely well paid.

I suspect it was a misunderstanding initially. Now, at the prospect of paying $70 each for a pudding and two drinks, they're panicking. Especially on teacher salaries. Perhaps they're hoping, given you presumably earn a LOT more than them, that you may not mind paying in this instance.

I guess it depends where the misunderstanding came from. If you were crystal clear that the meal was over and anything else is paid by them, then YANBU, they are taking advantage of you.

But if it was possible they thought either the company was paying (or reimbursing you), or they thought you'd agreed to them having the pudding etc as part of the meal you offered to pay, then YABU to suddenly lump them with a large bill they didn't think they'd owe.

Why did you offer to pay for lunch? I think that's likely where the misunderstanding came from. Why didn't you all just meet up somewhere normally priced and pay your own way? It almost feels a bit tacky to pay for a meal, have to rush off, and then expect guests to then pay the rest. You either pay for the whole meal, or you meet up elsewhere and pay your own ways.

Wow, what a load of crap.

hallodarknessmyoldfriend · 09/04/2023 09:18

Werehalfwaythere · 09/04/2023 09:14

I think I would have thought everything was in the company. That's what I'd assume if someone settled a $300+ meal without asking me to contribute. I mean, I'm in my 30s and don't know anyone who could afford to pay a $300+ lunch bill themselves. You must be extremely well paid.

I suspect it was a misunderstanding initially. Now, at the prospect of paying $70 each for a pudding and two drinks, they're panicking. Especially on teacher salaries. Perhaps they're hoping, given you presumably earn a LOT more than them, that you may not mind paying in this instance.

I guess it depends where the misunderstanding came from. If you were crystal clear that the meal was over and anything else is paid by them, then YANBU, they are taking advantage of you.

But if it was possible they thought either the company was paying (or reimbursing you), or they thought you'd agreed to them having the pudding etc as part of the meal you offered to pay, then YABU to suddenly lump them with a large bill they didn't think they'd owe.

Why did you offer to pay for lunch? I think that's likely where the misunderstanding came from. Why didn't you all just meet up somewhere normally priced and pay your own way? It almost feels a bit tacky to pay for a meal, have to rush off, and then expect guests to then pay the rest. You either pay for the whole meal, or you meet up elsewhere and pay your own ways.

That's not the case at all. You should read OP's updates properly.

SmallAngryPenguinWoman · 09/04/2023 09:18

Werehalfwaythere · 09/04/2023 09:14

I think I would have thought everything was in the company. That's what I'd assume if someone settled a $300+ meal without asking me to contribute. I mean, I'm in my 30s and don't know anyone who could afford to pay a $300+ lunch bill themselves. You must be extremely well paid.

I suspect it was a misunderstanding initially. Now, at the prospect of paying $70 each for a pudding and two drinks, they're panicking. Especially on teacher salaries. Perhaps they're hoping, given you presumably earn a LOT more than them, that you may not mind paying in this instance.

I guess it depends where the misunderstanding came from. If you were crystal clear that the meal was over and anything else is paid by them, then YANBU, they are taking advantage of you.

But if it was possible they thought either the company was paying (or reimbursing you), or they thought you'd agreed to them having the pudding etc as part of the meal you offered to pay, then YABU to suddenly lump them with a large bill they didn't think they'd owe.

Why did you offer to pay for lunch? I think that's likely where the misunderstanding came from. Why didn't you all just meet up somewhere normally priced and pay your own way? It almost feels a bit tacky to pay for a meal, have to rush off, and then expect guests to then pay the rest. You either pay for the whole meal, or you meet up elsewhere and pay your own ways.

Oh please! What a load of absolute bollix 🤬🤬
It's OP's fault because she was kind enough to buy them lunch as a treat. Christ Almighty, some people are unbelievable - I guess the OP's friends aren't the only CFs.

PickaxeForGardening · 09/04/2023 09:17

Ask for the money back and then end the friendship. As I get older I surround myself with only decent people. How dare they not check with you first.

DDivaStar · 09/04/2023 09:15

They thought they'd get a freebie through your work. Tell them what they owe you. Its cheeky but depending on your friendship I wouldn't disown them over it.

Werehalfwaythere · 09/04/2023 09:14

I think I would have thought everything was in the company. That's what I'd assume if someone settled a $300+ meal without asking me to contribute. I mean, I'm in my 30s and don't know anyone who could afford to pay a $300+ lunch bill themselves. You must be extremely well paid.

I suspect it was a misunderstanding initially. Now, at the prospect of paying $70 each for a pudding and two drinks, they're panicking. Especially on teacher salaries. Perhaps they're hoping, given you presumably earn a LOT more than them, that you may not mind paying in this instance.

I guess it depends where the misunderstanding came from. If you were crystal clear that the meal was over and anything else is paid by them, then YANBU, they are taking advantage of you.

But if it was possible they thought either the company was paying (or reimbursing you), or they thought you'd agreed to them having the pudding etc as part of the meal you offered to pay, then YABU to suddenly lump them with a large bill they didn't think they'd owe.

Why did you offer to pay for lunch? I think that's likely where the misunderstanding came from. Why didn't you all just meet up somewhere normally priced and pay your own way? It almost feels a bit tacky to pay for a meal, have to rush off, and then expect guests to then pay the rest. You either pay for the whole meal, or you meet up elsewhere and pay your own ways.

Rewis · 09/04/2023 09:12

I paid for lunch for all of us. It was $326 USD. They did know I was personally paying for it because they were joking about getting a job at the same company for the 'perks'. At which point, I said something along the lines of only the room being covered

Of course, they shouldn't have charged your room. But whether to end the friendship would depend if they paid back and if they did it maliciously. Or I actually cared about these people. Is it possible they misunderstood "only room being covered"? Cause you already paid for an expensive lunch. Maybe they wrongly figured that drink and desert were included in the lunch. At home, would you treat them to something like this? If they had paid for their own lunch, then they would obviously be CF. But them 'asking' to stay, you paying through the room, etc. Gives room for misunderstanding.

AliceMcK · 09/04/2023 09:12

MrsKHunt · 09/04/2023 08:49

Even if your company was paying they are seriously taking the piss and didn't care whether you'd get into bother because of it
Get the money and distance yourself

This is key. I knew a manager who was sacked for buying a round of drinks on his company card. The company was very generous with food, drinks and social events, but had very strict rules on the use of company funds. After a fully paid for social event with lots of free food and alcohol a group decided to continue the night and he bought the first round on his card, lost his job the next week. It wouldn’t have mattered if he had offered to pay it back, the rules were clear. People who don’t work in jobs with company cards or expenses don’t get this and how there is a fine line on what is and isn’t appropriate.

notimagain · 09/04/2023 09:11

I'm not sure too much blame can be shifted on to the hotel and it's procedures though it does sound as if the waiter was confused.

Extra items magically appearing on hotel bills at check out isn't completely unknown ( down to a mistake or scam by somebody, who knows?) and in my experience if confronted with an obviously rogue signature decent hotels will remove the offending transaction.

This all on the "friends".