Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friend charged drinks and desserts to my hotel room.

583 replies

annaherrings · 09/04/2023 07:34

I was NY where we have an office (the company I work for that is). I was staying in a hotel (paid for by company). I had two friends from London who were in NY at the same time visiting for Easter break. They wanted to meet up and I invited them to my hotel for lunch/drinks. I do not expense my hotel charges as I never have work meetings at the hotel and our offices are where all meetings are held. We also eat out a lot and work pays for that. So I settle any incidentals bill myself - whereas the room is paid for.

We had lunch and everything was fine. I had to head back to my office so I settled up. The waiter asked what my room # was when I asked to charge it to the room as I had to go. So I told him/said it out loud. I signed the check/bill and left. Before leaving, the two girls said: 'We might stay for one more in the adjoining bar'. That was obviously fine. They are free to do what they want/go where they want.

Upon checking out; I see extra charges of 4 drinks and two desserts. Totalling $140 and I'm pretty sure two of the drinks were champagne. (It was a 5* hotel in Manhattan).

It stood out because I was only aware of the lunch total since it was the only thing I charged to my room throughout the entire stay. So it wasn't exactly hard to spot.

I asked the hotel for the actual receipt (the one which you sign your name/room # on). Sure enough, it wasn't my signature. They had even added on the 20% tip.

When I queried them (the girls) on it, they said the hotel staff (same waiter) immediately charged it to my room and didn't give them a chance to pay. They 'wanted' to tip (tipping is a big deal in the US) so they said they asked for a check/bill - and tipped via the room - meaning my card. Hence the receipt in front of me. They also wrote down my room # since they heard me say it out loud prior.

I do not believe they didn't have a chance to pay. If they really wanted to, they could have. They then said they assumed my work was paying (I work for a famous/large bank) so we aren't exactly short of company money - hence their 'assumption'.

They then said they did 'ask me' if it was ok to 'stay for one more at the adjoining bar' and that I was more than ok with it.

To clarify, they didn't 'ask' and moreover; no two grown women need to ask my permission as to where they can go. It is entirely up to them where they go and what they do.

I need up paying their bill as I didn't want any awkwardness. I haven't responded to their texts and TBH, I'd rather just never talk to them again. AIBU to think there was no misunderstanding here? I could never ever walk out of a place - 5* or not - and not pay. The audacity of charging anything to a friend's room - and not even telling them about it after the fact - is unbelievable to me. My DH says to drop it and leave it be and called it 'cheeky' but not worth losing friendships over. I suspect he just doesn't want to engage.

OP posts:
BlueHeelers · 09/04/2023 13:37

Werehalfwaythere · 09/04/2023 09:14

I think I would have thought everything was in the company. That's what I'd assume if someone settled a $300+ meal without asking me to contribute. I mean, I'm in my 30s and don't know anyone who could afford to pay a $300+ lunch bill themselves. You must be extremely well paid.

I suspect it was a misunderstanding initially. Now, at the prospect of paying $70 each for a pudding and two drinks, they're panicking. Especially on teacher salaries. Perhaps they're hoping, given you presumably earn a LOT more than them, that you may not mind paying in this instance.

I guess it depends where the misunderstanding came from. If you were crystal clear that the meal was over and anything else is paid by them, then YANBU, they are taking advantage of you.

But if it was possible they thought either the company was paying (or reimbursing you), or they thought you'd agreed to them having the pudding etc as part of the meal you offered to pay, then YABU to suddenly lump them with a large bill they didn't think they'd owe.

Why did you offer to pay for lunch? I think that's likely where the misunderstanding came from. Why didn't you all just meet up somewhere normally priced and pay your own way? It almost feels a bit tacky to pay for a meal, have to rush off, and then expect guests to then pay the rest. You either pay for the whole meal, or you meet up elsewhere and pay your own ways.

I think we’ve found one of your “friends “ on this thread @annaherrings

Glitterybee · 09/04/2023 13:36

Wow this is so cheeky!

honestly I wouldn’t want to be friends with them moving forward.

Partyandbullshit · 09/04/2023 13:34

I experienced this sort of thing A LOT when I first moved to NY. It’s literal champagne taste on a beer budget.

There’s a type of woman who comes to NYC for a long weekend or 7 days, thinking it’s going to be all Sex and The City (shows my age!), strutting around in stilletoes and oversized shades, hailing yellow cabs and going to galleries and brunches. Wants the sexy bars and super fancy food, and feels permissive and full of abandon because It’s Abroad. Little do they realise the truth is the exact opposite and that their pounds don’t buy them anywhere near enough dollars. The disconnect leaves them in a quandary (want it, can’t have it), and this is precisely the thing that ends up happening. What’s the point of saving up and spending so much money getting here/ paying for accommodation if you’re going to spend your time in Pret and McDonald’s and eating pizza?

As a now very long term resident, I put up with this sort of thing three times before I got my radar and started sending lists of places to stay, restaurants and bars, and keeping very firm boundaries around myself.

In your shoes, I would have no qualms saying I need to submit my expenses with an explanation of who I was entertaining to justify and allocate the cost to this/that client, and that obviously I can’t lie given I wasn’t even there, I was in the actual office some blocks away (actually, you know, working). That I would appreciate them sending the money for the drinks etc they enjoyed together to XXX bank details. Hope they enjoy the rest of their stay.

It’s one thing not understanding how different industries operate. But this is flagrant theft. NO WAY did a waiter in a different bar/restaurant just assume the tab was going on a room - they wouldn’t even have KNOWN which room to ring it up on. The receipt is presented, the waiter asks if you want to charge it or pay - and these girls opted to charge. There are separate lines on the receipt to fill in. They’re not mortified that they didn’t know how things work and cocked up big time and please take our money. No. They’re now lying to dig deeper. They’re taking you for a mug: they’re teachers possibly on strike, you’re in banking, you owe them/ they’re going to help themselves to what you have because you can afford it and they can’t. And, no way I could ever spend any time with someone who treats me like that. Far from friendship, it’s worse than no relationship at all.

Bunnichick · 09/04/2023 13:33

OP I think your friends are cheeky. If it was a genuine misunderstanding then a real friend will offer to send you the money immediately. Then again they probably wouldn't have spent $150 on drinks if they thought they were paying do they won't want to pay, but why should you?

Interested go see how they respond!

Mycatisfatafatcat · 09/04/2023 13:33

She said the company paid for the room. Then she charged lunch to the room.

Katrinawaves · 09/04/2023 13:32

whynotwhatknot · 09/04/2023 13:29

they were cfs they knew you had to pay for it yourself

i woldnt be impressed with hotel just accpeting it to be charged to the room though what if anyone walked in and did that-i would have refused to pay it

Somebody walking in off the street would not know the name of the guest staying in the room. By using OP’s name, the friends were implicating her in the charge.

whynotwhatknot · 09/04/2023 13:29

they were cfs they knew you had to pay for it yourself

i woldnt be impressed with hotel just accpeting it to be charged to the room though what if anyone walked in and did that-i would have refused to pay it

MyLoveIsYourLove0xO · 09/04/2023 13:29

Cheeky feckers!
Hope they pay you back!

MoltenLasagne · 09/04/2023 13:25

Yes, agree with @Cozzadelsol - they either thought they were ripping you off, or they knew they were putting you in a dodgy position with your company.

For my workplace this would minimum be a disciplinary if I hadn't caught something being falsely charged to my corporate card.

Cozzadelsol · 09/04/2023 13:21

annaherrings · 09/04/2023 07:34

I was NY where we have an office (the company I work for that is). I was staying in a hotel (paid for by company). I had two friends from London who were in NY at the same time visiting for Easter break. They wanted to meet up and I invited them to my hotel for lunch/drinks. I do not expense my hotel charges as I never have work meetings at the hotel and our offices are where all meetings are held. We also eat out a lot and work pays for that. So I settle any incidentals bill myself - whereas the room is paid for.

We had lunch and everything was fine. I had to head back to my office so I settled up. The waiter asked what my room # was when I asked to charge it to the room as I had to go. So I told him/said it out loud. I signed the check/bill and left. Before leaving, the two girls said: 'We might stay for one more in the adjoining bar'. That was obviously fine. They are free to do what they want/go where they want.

Upon checking out; I see extra charges of 4 drinks and two desserts. Totalling $140 and I'm pretty sure two of the drinks were champagne. (It was a 5* hotel in Manhattan).

It stood out because I was only aware of the lunch total since it was the only thing I charged to my room throughout the entire stay. So it wasn't exactly hard to spot.

I asked the hotel for the actual receipt (the one which you sign your name/room # on). Sure enough, it wasn't my signature. They had even added on the 20% tip.

When I queried them (the girls) on it, they said the hotel staff (same waiter) immediately charged it to my room and didn't give them a chance to pay. They 'wanted' to tip (tipping is a big deal in the US) so they said they asked for a check/bill - and tipped via the room - meaning my card. Hence the receipt in front of me. They also wrote down my room # since they heard me say it out loud prior.

I do not believe they didn't have a chance to pay. If they really wanted to, they could have. They then said they assumed my work was paying (I work for a famous/large bank) so we aren't exactly short of company money - hence their 'assumption'.

They then said they did 'ask me' if it was ok to 'stay for one more at the adjoining bar' and that I was more than ok with it.

To clarify, they didn't 'ask' and moreover; no two grown women need to ask my permission as to where they can go. It is entirely up to them where they go and what they do.

I need up paying their bill as I didn't want any awkwardness. I haven't responded to their texts and TBH, I'd rather just never talk to them again. AIBU to think there was no misunderstanding here? I could never ever walk out of a place - 5* or not - and not pay. The audacity of charging anything to a friend's room - and not even telling them about it after the fact - is unbelievable to me. My DH says to drop it and leave it be and called it 'cheeky' but not worth losing friendships over. I suspect he just doesn't want to engage.

I am so sorry you're in this position OP. You must not only be angry, but also upset that two 'friends' would treat you like this.

There are only two scenarios to explain what happened when you left. Firstly they knew you would have to pay the extra bill, but thought 'fuck it let's order champagne' after you buying them a lovely lunch.

Or secondly, they thought your company was footing the bill and thought 'fuck it let's order champagne' fraudulently on your companies tab.

The second scenario could have got you fired, but they don't seem to care.

They are greedy and conniving. I would not want anything to do with either of them ever again 😕

WimpoleHat · 09/04/2023 13:16

I don't know why op chose a super expensive hotel.

She was there on business. She met her friends in the equivalent of her lunch hour. She probably chose it because she knew it and it was convenient.

Phoebo · 09/04/2023 13:13

Rosula · 09/04/2023 12:40

I agree. I don't know why op chose a super expensive hotel.

Why is that relevant? It's not as if OP was expecting them to pay for the lunch.

Her work probably chose where OP stayed

Phoebo · 09/04/2023 13:12

Emotionalsupportviper · 09/04/2023 12:56

You must be extremely well paid.

So? @Werehalfwaythere

OP may be extremely well-paid, but that doesn't mean she has to subsidise every CF this side of the equator.

Not to mention she already personally paid for lunch. Definitely can see the other CF on this thread!

sjxoxo · 09/04/2023 13:11

I think it’s cheeky for $140!! If it was an average price I’d prob not care. However you should tell them you are paying personally and that their cost was $140. They should reimburse you on this occasion! If it was my best mates I wouldn’t begrudge them a drink but I’d mind at $140!

CementTrucker · 09/04/2023 13:09

Emotionalsupportviper · 09/04/2023 12:56

You must be extremely well paid.

So? @Werehalfwaythere

OP may be extremely well-paid, but that doesn't mean she has to subsidise every CF this side of the equator.

The implication seems to be that op should magnanimously overlook this because her friends are just poor impoverished teachers who made an innocent and understandable mistake.

Absolute rubbish!

Irridescantshimmmer · 09/04/2023 13:06

Demand that they pay you and cut them off.

They are CF.

HomeTheatreSystem · 09/04/2023 13:05

When I queried them (the girls) on it, they said the hotel staff (same waiter) immediately charged it to my room and didn't give them a chance to pay.

That's OK then: they were expecting to pay but due to it going on your tab, they didn't pay then but can now.

Nosleepforthismum · 09/04/2023 13:03

I think it’s easy to see who else are CF’s on this thread! OP you did nothing wrong and your “friends” are arseholes. They knew exactly what they were doing and it’s disgraceful they are now trying to wriggle out of paying you back.

As a side note, it’s basic etiquette that if you know someone else is picking up the bill, you don’t order champagne and the most expensive items on the menu.

Duckingella · 09/04/2023 13:00

They deliberately expensed it to your room;I bet they wouldn't have ran up that bill if they were paying especially the champagne.They are CF's.

AliceOlive · 09/04/2023 12:58

Rosula · 09/04/2023 12:54

The hotel would presumably charge it to OP's card anyway.

Yeah, and it would be extremely embarrassing and bad form to do this. OP stays in this hotel for work and likely her company has a relationship with the hotel, also. I would not want this getting back to my employer. It would definitely result in a WTF from my boss and the travel office.

OP will either get the $ from these jokers or pay herself. Either way I’m sure it will be a while before inviting anyone to lunch at her hotel again.

BrainWontWorkAnymore · 09/04/2023 12:58

Teachers know how expenses work. If you have a course to attend, you may be able to claim travel expenses. However, food and drink is NEVER included. The obvious reason is that you would have to eat /drink anyway, even if you weren’t on the course. It’s up to you whether you take a meal deal / packed lunch or eat out. It’s your choice, it’s your money.

Emotionalsupportviper · 09/04/2023 12:56

You must be extremely well paid.

So? @Werehalfwaythere

OP may be extremely well-paid, but that doesn't mean she has to subsidise every CF this side of the equator.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 09/04/2023 12:56

Rosula · 09/04/2023 12:54

The hotel would presumably charge it to OP's card anyway.

But they can't if the bill doesn't match the signature they hold on the reservation/check in. Otherwise people would he charging food and drinks to random bedrooms all over the place.

Emotionalsupportviper · 09/04/2023 12:54

AliceOlive · 09/04/2023 12:48

In a 5 star Manhattan hotel, I would think they were asking if it was a public bar or only for guests. It would never cross my mind they meant “can we charge everything to your room.”

I can see where they might have been thinking of the hotel as a club that only allows members to pay, but then why not text “We really enjoyed the hotel bar. It went on your room so please let us know the total and we will send it.”

In a 5 star Manhattan hotel, I would think they were asking if it was a public bar or only for guests. It would never cross my mind they meant “can we charge everything to your room.”

That's what I would have assumed if they had asked me. Some hotels only allow guests (and their guests) to use their facilities

Rosula · 09/04/2023 12:54

Baabaa75 · 09/04/2023 10:27

Tbh you should have refused to pay the hotel for it. It's not your signature, you didn't order the food/drinks, if they've let someone charge something to your room without your authorisation that's on the hotel not you. Give them your friends address, they can go after them, it is fraud after all 🤷

The hotel would presumably charge it to OP's card anyway.