Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want to tell friend to stop spouting religion at me?!

87 replies

4GodSake · 08/04/2023 22:34

I have a very good friend who happens to have found religion about 5 years ago, she's married to a man she met at the church she attends and seems very happy which is great!

My issue is she will mention things to me when I see her sometimes, say she's prayed for me, send me messages with videos of sermons or links to social media posts about finding Jesus ect

She doesn't do this ALL the time I admit, just occasionally but I don't know why I just feel offended almost when she does it? She knows I'm not interested, I've told her before I struggle with the idea of religion and there being a God and that I personally don't believe in it.

AIBU to want her to just respect that and accept she's not going to change my mind with a YouTube video? AIBU to be insulted that she won't just accept what I believe in the same way I have her? I don't send her links to atheist speakers, for example, I don't see what the difference is.

Would I be unreasonable to rock the boat about this given that it's not super frequent but does piss me off when it happens?

OP posts:
MyLoveIsYourLove0xO · 09/04/2023 00:34

sadieshavingashindig · 08/04/2023 23:02

Just say "alright Dot Cotton" every time she does it until it pisses her off so much she never tries it with you again.

Do this!

ShodanLives · 09/04/2023 00:22

Minierme · 09/04/2023 00:11

I’m a practising Christian and it’s a big part of my life so it would be hard not to mention to friends at all. But I sent this thread to my atheist friend to get her take. She said that she just sees it as my hobby and she tells me about her hobbies (in great detail sometimes!) that I have no interest, in so it’s balanced 😂 While I obviously don’t see my faith as a hobby I do think she has a point. Friendships are about taking a interest (or at least listening patiently) about things you don’t particularly care about because the other person does and you care about them.

If her hobby was golf, and you told her that your not interested in golf but she kept sending you videos about why everyone should play golf, wouldn't that get annoying?

Although not entirely comparable since gold doesn't involve people going to hell.

LaPerduta · 09/04/2023 00:17

Evangelicals are so bloody tedious.

Minierme · 09/04/2023 00:11

I’m a practising Christian and it’s a big part of my life so it would be hard not to mention to friends at all. But I sent this thread to my atheist friend to get her take. She said that she just sees it as my hobby and she tells me about her hobbies (in great detail sometimes!) that I have no interest, in so it’s balanced 😂 While I obviously don’t see my faith as a hobby I do think she has a point. Friendships are about taking a interest (or at least listening patiently) about things you don’t particularly care about because the other person does and you care about them.

Aria2015 · 09/04/2023 00:01

If it occasional I'd just let it slide (assuming she's a good friend otherwise). I have something similar in my life, instead of getting offended, I just try and look it at it like the equivalent of a hobby. I have some friends who have interests (hobbies) that I'm not into, but I still will politely listen to them chat about it (occasionally) because I know it means something to them.

vdbfamily · 08/04/2023 23:59

If she is your friend, is it not possible to discuss how you feel. Have you tried telling her why you struggle to believe. Have you told her you don't like being sent stuff? I guess you have a choice but to read it and actually, if she sends you links to stuff, why not do the same, providing it is reasoned debate and not just offensive.

Backtoblack1 · 08/04/2023 23:55

I’ve had similar happen to me and was offended. I just totally ignored anything that was sent to me.

whumpthereitis · 08/04/2023 23:53

‘It’s not a bad thing’
-When you’re repeatedly ignoring a clearly stated boundary and still pushing your ideology on someone who you know full well doesn’t want to hear it, yes, it is indeed a ‘bad thing’.

AnorLondo · 08/04/2023 23:44

If you asked her not to and she keeps doing it anyway that shows what little respect she has for you and your beliefs.

jessyjo2 · 08/04/2023 23:35

Friendofdennis · 08/04/2023 22:42

Well if she believes in Jesus as Saviour then she would see it as her responsibility to let you in on the good news. She would also believe in heaven and hell and wants you to go up rather than down. If she didn’t occasionally mention God to you then she would be showing that she couldn’t care less about you.

I agree with what you are saying here. But guess its getting the balance right between telling OP what its all about and respecting OP's point of view.

howdoesatoastermaketoast · 08/04/2023 23:34

Yeah @Exhibity 'God is real like justice beauty and love not real like beer bricks and tables" was the line me and some very Christian friends could agree on but I can see how it might offend people / come across as patronising so I wouldn't bring it up if I could help it.

Quveas · 08/04/2023 23:29

Friendofdennis · 08/04/2023 22:42

Well if she believes in Jesus as Saviour then she would see it as her responsibility to let you in on the good news. She would also believe in heaven and hell and wants you to go up rather than down. If she didn’t occasionally mention God to you then she would be showing that she couldn’t care less about you.

I am a Christian. I don't see it as my responsibility to let anyone "in" on the good news. I do not believe in a literal heaven or hell, and if it's as simplistic as all that then most everybody I know is going down so I may opt to join them. I accept I might occasionally mention God or something, but so does my atheist best friend - it isn't a taboo subject or banned word - but I care very much about my friends without needing to try to convince them of anything.

Faith is so much more complex that this simplistic litany.

Exhibity · 08/04/2023 23:28

howdoesatoastermaketoast · 08/04/2023 23:25

@Exhibity thanks for the feedback

I get what you're saying though and it's a good explanation 😊

howdoesatoastermaketoast · 08/04/2023 23:25

@Exhibity thanks for the feedback

Exhibity · 08/04/2023 23:22

howdoesatoastermaketoast · 08/04/2023 23:14

OP I do not think you are being unreasonable and I like you but it bugs me that you're going to hell is an awkward vibe to be getting from a friend - I do however have a little experience in this area I can share. Let's call it a thought experiment you can share with your friend

We're going to be dividing the world into two categories I like the terms abstract and concrete, but what I might call abstract you (which is to say your friend) might prefer to call spiritual and material.

  1. you're sitting on a chair in a pub in front of you is a table and on the table you have some beer, in a glass.

The beer, the glass it's in, the table the glass is sitting on, the chair you're sitting on these are concrete, material things and there are certain questions that we can ask (and answer) about concrete / material things.

Things like what does it weigh? how dense is it? what is it's temperature? what is it's chemical composition / molecular structure? Material things are made of elements that appear on the periodic table.

But there are other things too, abstract concepts invented by people, but which may be profoundly impactful on the way someone lives their life. I'm talking about things like love justice honour beauty. People are capable of having profound relationships with abstract concepts. An artist, penniless spending their money on paint not food whilst they obsess over getting their picture just so could be said to have a profound relationship with beauty.

A lawyer might have a profound relationship with justice.

You can't weigh justice or write down the chemical formula of honour but these things are still incredibly real to people even though they aren't equally important to everyone.

You can't ask how much God weighs, it isn't the right sort of question. You can't use a thermometer to take a temperature reading of God, you can't write down the chemical formular or say what atoms he's made of because those aren't the right sorts of questions to ask about God.

People have worshipped hundreds of Gods that we know about and the range and variation in the Gods and Goddesses is much much wider than the range and variation in the people that worshipped them, which is enough to convince me that people invent Gods not vice versa. But just because God isn't real in the same way as the pint of beer or the beer glass or the table is real, doesn't mean he's not real at all. God's real in the same way as love, honour, justice, fairness and beauty are real.

Some people work for a pittance trying to get innocent people on death row acquitted, some people take holy orders and live a life of religious prayer and seclusion. Whilst these things might be abstract concepts that only live within the minds of humans it doesn't mean they aren't real or profound to people and capable of having a dramatic impact on how they live their life.

In short by all means talk to God but if he starts to talk back seek professional help.

I'd find that a bit patronising tbh . I'm not sure you'd get anyone with strong religious views that they can't keep to themselves to see your point.

MrsDoylesDoily · 08/04/2023 23:19

Friendofdennis · 08/04/2023 22:42

Well if she believes in Jesus as Saviour then she would see it as her responsibility to let you in on the good news. She would also believe in heaven and hell and wants you to go up rather than down. If she didn’t occasionally mention God to you then she would be showing that she couldn’t care less about you.

That's a shit excuse.

No need to push it onto anyone.

howdoesatoastermaketoast · 08/04/2023 23:14

OP I do not think you are being unreasonable and I like you but it bugs me that you're going to hell is an awkward vibe to be getting from a friend - I do however have a little experience in this area I can share. Let's call it a thought experiment you can share with your friend

We're going to be dividing the world into two categories I like the terms abstract and concrete, but what I might call abstract you (which is to say your friend) might prefer to call spiritual and material.

  1. you're sitting on a chair in a pub in front of you is a table and on the table you have some beer, in a glass.

The beer, the glass it's in, the table the glass is sitting on, the chair you're sitting on these are concrete, material things and there are certain questions that we can ask (and answer) about concrete / material things.

Things like what does it weigh? how dense is it? what is it's temperature? what is it's chemical composition / molecular structure? Material things are made of elements that appear on the periodic table.

But there are other things too, abstract concepts invented by people, but which may be profoundly impactful on the way someone lives their life. I'm talking about things like love justice honour beauty. People are capable of having profound relationships with abstract concepts. An artist, penniless spending their money on paint not food whilst they obsess over getting their picture just so could be said to have a profound relationship with beauty.

A lawyer might have a profound relationship with justice.

You can't weigh justice or write down the chemical formula of honour but these things are still incredibly real to people even though they aren't equally important to everyone.

You can't ask how much God weighs, it isn't the right sort of question. You can't use a thermometer to take a temperature reading of God, you can't write down the chemical formular or say what atoms he's made of because those aren't the right sorts of questions to ask about God.

People have worshipped hundreds of Gods that we know about and the range and variation in the Gods and Goddesses is much much wider than the range and variation in the people that worshipped them, which is enough to convince me that people invent Gods not vice versa. But just because God isn't real in the same way as the pint of beer or the beer glass or the table is real, doesn't mean he's not real at all. God's real in the same way as love, honour, justice, fairness and beauty are real.

Some people work for a pittance trying to get innocent people on death row acquitted, some people take holy orders and live a life of religious prayer and seclusion. Whilst these things might be abstract concepts that only live within the minds of humans it doesn't mean they aren't real or profound to people and capable of having a dramatic impact on how they live their life.

In short by all means talk to God but if he starts to talk back seek professional help.

4GodSake · 08/04/2023 23:09

StillMedusa · 08/04/2023 23:04

I'd be very tempted to send her 'Thank you God' Grin (I love Tim Minchin!) but that wouldn't be kind.
I think, if she's a good friend, I'd be honest and say, look I value our friendship but please stop sending me links and videos as I am not going to change my mind (and then send her Tim....)

I wonder how Sam's mum is 😀

OP posts:
StillMedusa · 08/04/2023 23:04

I'd be very tempted to send her 'Thank you God' Grin (I love Tim Minchin!) but that wouldn't be kind.
I think, if she's a good friend, I'd be honest and say, look I value our friendship but please stop sending me links and videos as I am not going to change my mind (and then send her Tim....)

Exhibity · 08/04/2023 23:04

Why should a person have to 'try not to be offended' ?
Stop the offensive behaviour and they won't have to.

sadieshavingashindig · 08/04/2023 23:02

Just say "alright Dot Cotton" every time she does it until it pisses her off so much she never tries it with you again.

Magenta82 · 08/04/2023 23:01

4GodSake · 08/04/2023 22:58

Like if I joined a satanic cult tomorrow she couldn't stop me praying to Lucifer about her but I'm sure she wouldn't want to know.

Exactly my point!
I'd be so tempted to tell her that I was doing exactly that OP!

InSpainTheRain · 08/04/2023 23:00

I think you need to tell her honestly and calmly that you would like her to stop. However she won't so perhaps distance yourself and find other friends.

4GodSake · 08/04/2023 22:58

Like if I joined a satanic cult tomorrow she couldn't stop me praying to Lucifer about her but I'm sure she wouldn't want to know.

OP posts:
4GodSake · 08/04/2023 22:57

PurpleBugz · 08/04/2023 22:50

I think it's reasonable to ask her not to send videos etc. tell her you know you can come to her with questions if you have them but prefer not to have the religion pushed at you.

But as a Christian myself I can say she's not gonna stop prying for you. Try not to get offended when she says it. It's a bit like saying she was thinking of you? It's not a bad thing

If she wants to privately pray for me then I can't stop her. But just don't tell me about it

OP posts: