Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My mil is nice .. I just don’t LOVE her ..

113 replies

Lkakpk · 08/04/2023 20:49

So a bit of background been with my husband 10 years - married 3 . We have two young kids . My dh has a brother and his brother is VERY reliant on my in laws for help with their kids . On the other hand I rely very much on my mother and father and my partner is equally really close to my family . Has always been the same even before kids .
my mil is a nice lady and tries to help a lot but I feel it bothers her that our kids have a closer bond with my family. She is a bit of a socially awkward person . Sometimes chatty . Sometimes not - ( I actually think she may be on the spectrum ) Anyway , my husband leaves all contact really to me so it annoys me more . She will text me to see kids / ask how we are etc . My bug bear is I feel when I see her alone she’s a lot nicer than when my husband is present . When my husband is present she talks and looks at him as if I’m a spare part at times and I’m the second class citizen . She constantly talks about how our kids are just like their dad and if anyone says anything to compliment me she just looks uncomfortable and never agrees . Recently his fil was unwell and I had text asking how he is . She left the message annd didn’t reply and later unbeknown to my husband he text the same and yet she replied to him . This all seems petty but it annoys me that I’m the one ( out of respect for my dh ) who keeps the relationship going and yet she does irritating things like this . My dh is a quiet laid back guy and I feel she just pretends to like me as she knows by not she would lose contact . Frustrating thing is she can be SO nice so it’s almost like if I was to bring this us ( which I have in past ) it’s like I’m being nasty to his mum - dh doesn’t see it but fil does make jokes about his wife and her precious sons . What is it with mums and their sons ?! How would you handle this lady ? I know she’s not worst mil in world but I look at my own mother with my sil and she’s SO nice to her , would never make her fee l anything other than equal to her son ( my brother ) anyone got a similar mil ? Am I unreasonable in expecting to be treated like her adult son ( or at least pretend to )

OP posts:
Lkakpk · 11/04/2023 00:13

@Lovepeaceunderstanding I really feel you are missing the original point . I don’t want my mother in law to love me , that’s never been the issue . The issue is she relies on me solely for contact yet doesn’t really treat me the way she should considering that fact alone . I don’t want love , maybe just show some appreciation or at least treat me like a human woman and not just that woman who birthed my grand kids and is so lucky to be with my son 🤣

OP posts:
caringcarer · 11/04/2023 00:11

I have a great relationship with my MiL. I invited her to help me choose my wedding dress. She has loved me ever since. She has no DD's of her own. My dh jokes, although actually half believes, she likes me more than him. He is not close to his Mum at all. I get her Mother's Day cards and send her flowers. I pick her up a bouquet of flowers or a box of chocs to take when we visit. I send her post cards from holiday and remember her birthday and until FiL died her wedding anniversary. I bring her back gift from holiday and send her recipes I think she will like and ring her to chat each week. My own Mum died 10 years ago and I got closer to MiL afterwards.

Lovepeaceunderstanding · 11/04/2023 00:10

When my parents were quiet old they told me that they saw my husband of decades as their son, they loved him as my brother and myself. If you truly want that relationship with your in laws perhaps put in the effort my husband did. For decades he behaved like their son, he was there for them, cared for them, laughed with them, played with them. In the end he helped me to look after them, gave my dad a home in his final years and grieved with me when we lost them. He EARNED their love. What have you done to earn the love of your PIL?

BlueJellycat · 11/04/2023 00:00

I don't always like my mil but I do love her. I have known her as long as dh after all.

Lkakpk · 10/04/2023 23:57

@Fooksticks mine too , another way of saying I don’t want to agree with you in any way on this topic 🤣

OP posts:
Fooksticks · 10/04/2023 23:54

I've just realised my mil will sometimes say to me 'is that so' 😂

I like my IL they are nice people and never rude to me but it helps for me to remember that in priority order it goes DC, dh then me.

And that seems fair as it's the same for my DP.

Lkakpk · 10/04/2023 23:48

@saraclara also I must add re his illness . She never text him . Just me . Go figure 🤣

OP posts:
Lkakpk · 10/04/2023 23:46

@saraclara no I don’t ask if he wants to see his parents as he’s in his 30s and I’m not there to nourish his relationship - I wouldn’t expect him to ask me when I’m seeing my parents .
As for his mum , that would all be fine in terms of contacting me but she’s very transparent in her intentions , an example of this would be recently - she text asking how everyone was I replied , she then mentioned our niece and finished with let me know when I can see the kids ? I replied with a time to see the kids and asked her something regarding our niece . She didnt reply . That to me is blatant got what I wanted now so no need for further chat . That to me is rude . Its things like that that get my back up . I don’t want another mother , I have that . All I want is consistency in her approach . She’s very hot or cold depending on what she wants and she’s not very smart in hiding it unfortunately .

OP posts:
saraclara · 10/04/2023 23:39

Lkakpk · 10/04/2023 23:26

I thought I should add a bit of insight to this as I feel it’s becoming more about my husbands lacks of relationship with mil . I’m fact that’s not quite true , my dh is a quiet guy not so much into small talk so he’s not the type to ring his mum for a chat so to speak . However there is no dispute and there is no issue with their relationship - that’s just how it is and has always been even pre our life together .
I am more of a social person and more of a planner so in general I make plans for our weekends etc and before anyone says this is controlling , no this is just how we live . My husband is very chill and would rather I take the lead on this however I do feel my husbands lack of small talk leads her to try and get info out of me ie how he is / how is work etc . Which is one of the things that grate on me .

I feel quite sorry for her then. If she has a quiet and somewhat taciturn son, she is going to turn to you for connection to you both and the grandkids.

When you plan for weekends, do you ever ask your DH whether he's been in contact with his parents/wants to see them? Or do you just plan want you want to do? I appreciate that he shouldn't need to be asked, but it seems that he's just lazy and would rather that you sort his life for him.
And yes, make it clear that when his mum messages him because she's worried about his illness, he needs to answer her. Not leave it so that she's forced to contact you to ease her mind.

Lkakpk · 10/04/2023 23:26

I thought I should add a bit of insight to this as I feel it’s becoming more about my husbands lacks of relationship with mil . I’m fact that’s not quite true , my dh is a quiet guy not so much into small talk so he’s not the type to ring his mum for a chat so to speak . However there is no dispute and there is no issue with their relationship - that’s just how it is and has always been even pre our life together .
I am more of a social person and more of a planner so in general I make plans for our weekends etc and before anyone says this is controlling , no this is just how we live . My husband is very chill and would rather I take the lead on this however I do feel my husbands lack of small talk leads her to try and get info out of me ie how he is / how is work etc . Which is one of the things that grate on me .

OP posts:
saraclara · 10/04/2023 23:26

*sons can have good, warm, healthly relationships with their own mothers

Such men are often sneered at on here and called mummy's boys.

Lkakpk · 10/04/2023 23:20

@ImAvingOops you are right and your insight into it makes complete sense . For what it’s worth , your daughter in law is probably very much missing out you seem fair minded and kind .

OP posts:
Cardamoney · 10/04/2023 22:42

longdistanceclaraaa · 10/04/2023 21:08

See I just don't get this attitude.

Where is the son (DH) in this? Why are all of the women in your scenario squabbling for a place in the queue? Why can't a DIL have a relationship with her mother that is hers and nothing to do wit her MIL? And which says nothing about the MIL or her place in the queue?

In a healthy 2020s marriage, surely sons can have good, warm, healthly relationships with their own mothers and ensure that that relationship is sustained appropriately within his marriage and with his own children. Why do the sons of slighted MILs always seem to get a free pass, as if none of this was anything to do with them?

Mothers and fathers should BOTH raise their sons well and then no one should need to demonise a poor DIL for speaking to her mum more than her MIL.

You’re completely missing the point. It’s not a case of “squabbling for a place in the queue”. No one is squabbling, just stating facts. No one is saying that a woman shouldn’t have a relationship with her own mother that has nothing to do with MIL. My relationship with my DM was completely separate from that with my MIL. But if I had to choose to see my DM rather than MIL I would. And since my DH considers me first in his life he would choose to put my wishes first rather than his mother’s. Therefore his DM loses out. Nothing to do with poor mother-son relationships , everything to do with a man putting his wife and her wishes first. And women generally prefer their own mothers to their MILs. You can argue this is a DH problem, but whoever’s problem it is , it’s his DM who is at the receiving end of it. What I am saying is that there is a responsibility for all parties to give some consideration to each other - not just “your mother, your problem”. Of course sons can have a really healthy relationship with their own mothers, but the problem sometimes seems to be that some DILs only seem happy with if their DH /DM’s relationship fits in to a pattern that suits the DIL. Too little and they aren’t interested. Too much and they’re interfering.

longdistanceclaraaa · 10/04/2023 22:06

ImAvingOops · 10/04/2023 16:33

There's quite a lot to unpick here. Firstly you are bound to see your mum more favourably than your mil - she raised you, instilled her values, you love her. You say your mum has a great relationship with your sil - your sil may or may not agree. Either way, they are different people and you shouldn't expect to feel the same bond with your mil that you do with your own mum!

Secondly, step back from contacting/organising:managing the relationship. Your husband is perfectly capable of texting his mum or arranging to see her. If he doesn't bother, it's not on you. He's not a child, I'm sure he manages his work relationships so let him manage his personal ones. You'll feel less resentment when you step back.

I also had a mil who would take a mile if you gave an inch. I insisted on phone calls to arrange mutually convenient times instead of just dropping round, as in-laws would turn up and stay all day. It's not unreasonable to want agreed visits.

I also think your perspective on in-laws will change when your own children grow up and find partners - this will come around quicker than you think it will. I have a dil who I think isn't very fond of me. She's polite and civil but that's it. That's despite me doing my best to help her out when needed and giving more support than either of her own parents. You can't force a bond if it isn't there. But it's okay because I have taken her out of the equation - I contact my son directly and it's on him to maintain his relationship with me. And that's how it should be really. Dil and I didn't choose each other - our connection is via him.

So step back a bit and stop thinking you have to manage all interactions.

I think this reflection on the MIL perspective is spot on.

longdistanceclaraaa · 10/04/2023 21:15

A quick additional comment, my husband is perfectly capable of having any WhatsApp groups with whichever family members he so chooses. As am I. They don't necessarily need to involve the other (but may of course depending in relationships). Cultivate your relationships with your sons and rely on that.

ImAvingOops · 10/04/2023 21:14

@Lkakpk with my dil, she lived with us for a couple of years after things went sideways with her own family and because we have very different ways of living, and outlooks, things became a bit fraught by the time she snd DS moved out. While she was here I did treat her the same way as I did my own kids, she was very much valued as her own person. But what I'm getting at is that you can't force a relationship if the other person doesn't want it.
All you can do is step back, be polite but let your husband facilitate his own relationship with his mum. It isn't your job to make sure she sees him or the kids - it's up to her don to do it. You'll feel better once you stop feeling responsible and accept that you can do your best but how other people feel isn't within your control.

longdistanceclaraaa · 10/04/2023 21:08

Cardamoney · 10/04/2023 20:56

It can be difficult to be the MIL of a DIL. A DIL is (almost) always going to prioritise her own mother. I certainly did. There was a thread a while back from someone who had lost her own mum and felt bad about resenting her MIL because it was as if the MIL’s “competition” had been removed. That can be how it feels as the mother of a son. You know that you are no longer the no.1 woman in your son’s life, but then you’re also relegated behind the DIL’s mother as well. It can be tough. When I read some of the less kind comments on MN from the mothers of young children about their MILs I do think they will see things differently when their children (especially sons) are older. MILs are human beings who were once DILs too. You may be one yourself some day and then the boot will be on the other foot. And the easiest solution for WhatsApp groups is to have one including your child and partner and yourselves. Then there’s no excuses.

See I just don't get this attitude.

Where is the son (DH) in this? Why are all of the women in your scenario squabbling for a place in the queue? Why can't a DIL have a relationship with her mother that is hers and nothing to do wit her MIL? And which says nothing about the MIL or her place in the queue?

In a healthy 2020s marriage, surely sons can have good, warm, healthly relationships with their own mothers and ensure that that relationship is sustained appropriately within his marriage and with his own children. Why do the sons of slighted MILs always seem to get a free pass, as if none of this was anything to do with them?

Mothers and fathers should BOTH raise their sons well and then no one should need to demonise a poor DIL for speaking to her mum more than her MIL.

Katherine1985 · 10/04/2023 21:04

I loved my mother in law. She only had sons and I definitely knew she appreciated me as a person in her life, not just wife to her DS and mother of her DGC. DH completely took responsibility for communicating with her and later when she was housebound, visited alone or just with DC as well as all of us going.

Some of this is because before I met him she went through a horrendous divorce after FIL’s long affair so DH had quite a sense of responsibility for her in his early 20s.

But then my SMIL (the former affair partner) was a whole other story and did everything she could to make my life miserable. OP’s MIL sounds positively cuddly compared to her!

Cardamoney · 10/04/2023 20:56

It can be difficult to be the MIL of a DIL. A DIL is (almost) always going to prioritise her own mother. I certainly did. There was a thread a while back from someone who had lost her own mum and felt bad about resenting her MIL because it was as if the MIL’s “competition” had been removed. That can be how it feels as the mother of a son. You know that you are no longer the no.1 woman in your son’s life, but then you’re also relegated behind the DIL’s mother as well. It can be tough. When I read some of the less kind comments on MN from the mothers of young children about their MILs I do think they will see things differently when their children (especially sons) are older. MILs are human beings who were once DILs too. You may be one yourself some day and then the boot will be on the other foot. And the easiest solution for WhatsApp groups is to have one including your child and partner and yourselves. Then there’s no excuses.

Lkakpk · 10/04/2023 20:17

@Skybluepinky yes I agree

OP posts:
Lkakpk · 10/04/2023 20:16

@saraclara yes I do think this makes a lot of sense .
Shes not a bad person and there is times I think oh she is who she is there is no malice but then certain things she does just gets my back up ie ignoring texts when my fil was sick and I asked how he was , turning up unannounced when she always makes a big deal out of saying she never wants to be intrusive . But yes , I get her social awkwardness may add to this

OP posts:
saraclara · 10/04/2023 20:08

I do wonder if some MILs are not so much jealous as a bit scared of their DILs. DILs do seem to be those who hold the reins in their relationships and with the children. Certainly if I had boys and read Mumsnet, I'd be pretty scared of getting things wrong, and be only too aware that my realtionship with my DGCs in particular would hinge on the DIL. Certainly that's the case with my friends who have sons.

Consequently I imagine that the relationship might tend to be less relaxed and less confortable. And if this lady is a bit socially awkward, I can imagine that it feels safer, when you're together, for her to look to your D in conversations.

Lkakpk · 10/04/2023 19:38

@saraclara I think with daughters it’s different as in general ( not all obviously ) woman are more into small talk etc so I don’t think your situation is abnormal atall .
I just can’t put my finger on it … she’s very hot and cold . At our wedding my dad even noticed it . He was saying to her how lovely my husband is etc and what a good match we are . She never agreed just made a comment about how she loved her son too 🤣 yet still , it’s me who she contacts etc .

OP posts:
Lkakpk · 10/04/2023 19:34

@Ladybug14 yes I think this is route I’ll go down from now on !

OP posts:
saraclara · 10/04/2023 19:19

Lkakpk · 09/04/2023 00:45

@Somanycats absoultley not no and nor would I want her too !!? My issue is she almost treats me like a second class citizen in conversation when we are all present ie directing all convo to her son … for me that’s rude and nothing to do with love

When my DDs visit with their partners, I probably do the same thing. I like their partners, but when we are all together, it's my daughters and I that are likely to lead conversations, rather than their partners, and I'm probably more likely to be talking about things that interest or involve them. Sometimes I have to remind myself to directly ask their partners about their lives/jobs/ things that interest them.

Isn't that fairly normal? I imagine that it's the offspring that talk to their parents most, and vice versa in most families.

I did love my MIL very much, and she loved me (and adored her grandkids). I think conversation was more equal there when we visited, but it took some years to get to that point (maybe add much as a decade) as I'm quite quiet (as are my DD's partners).