Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I know IABU.... Scottish Highlands tourism

290 replies

Firefightress1 · 08/04/2023 20:31

I know IABU as we were tourists before we moved to Skye but I'm absolutely gobsmacked by how busy it has been over the weekend. I know its not even the busiest time yet but I'm already struggling to get diesel to get to work and the coop is stripped bare. Had a campervan nearly drive into us earlier on the wrong side of the road at a junction and people parking in passing places on single track roads which means traffic is at a standstill.
We always followed the rules and pulled in/let people overtake but there seems to be a new selfish version of a tourist. I know we need to get used to it but people just blatantly disregarding signage and peeing/sh*tting all over the place is just awful!
I honestly don't remember it as bad as this when we were tourists but i guess we didnt live here then
There are so many facebook groups trying to make improvements but the tour buses and guides still insist on stopping at closed sights and encouraging groups to force open gates and move cones to gain access. Its causing so many issues to wildlife and repair operations that are badly needed.

OP posts:
Dave7900 · 09/04/2023 00:12

Did you know that Scots are subjected to abnormally low barometric pressures more often than the English further south that cause depression among other this?

pleasehelpwi3 · 09/04/2023 00:11

I wonder if these NIMBYS feel the same way about other people's areas when they holiday in other popular places people live in....
I mean, have you seen the tourists with their suitcases on the tube? And as for anyone who isn't local going to Cornwall in the summer, how selfish is that?
I also wonder how many of those complaining about second homes voted for Corbyn, about the only politician who probably actually would have done something about them. (I've got a second home, well flat, not by choice, and yes I did vote for him.)
Yes tourists can be annoying, but unless you yourself have never been on holiday, don't take the holier than thou attitude. After all, take away the tourism in many places and you take away the jobs and the livelihoods (and the house prices.)
Not a Tory at all, indeed I'm a committed socialist but Norman Tebbit did have a point with his mischaracterised 'on yer bike speech' of the early 80s:

I grew up in the '30s with an unemployed father. He didn't riot. He got on his bike and looked for work, and he kept looking till he found it.

The point being that there isn't a god given right to live in an area, subsidised by the state, just because your family live there. People complain about second homes in Cornwall and Skye and places like that, which is understandable, but no-one ever complains about people in eg Brixton or Bermondsey in South London not being able to live where their families are from due to changing house prices, second homes, and gentrification. Are these people not white enough, or not middle class enough? Genuine question- or maybe people just think tough shit it's London?

In fact, the people with the largest amount of second homes- 25 according to this article- and all funded by our taxes- "belong" to the Royal Family.
https://www.purewow.com/entertainment/properties-owned-by-the-royal-family
I hope everyone moaning about second homes in tourist areas agrees with me that if we gave these parasites the boot there would be more money for better public services, including better jobs, training, housing and transport in places like Skye, Cornwall that would offer better paid jobs to locals- or anyone else for that matter- in these and other areas.

Just a bit of a rant, but it's so easy to moan at other people and feel smug, whilst all the while being totally hypocritical.

pleasehelpwi3 · 09/04/2023 00:10

I wonder if these NIMBYS feel the same way about other people's areas when they holiday in other popular places people live in....
I mean, have you seen the tourists with their suitcases on the tube? And as for anyone who isn't local going to Cornwall in the summer, how selfish is that?
I also wonder how many of those complaining about second homes voted for Corbyn, about the only politician who probably actually would have done something about them. (I've got a second home, well flat, not by choice, and yes I did vote for him.)
Yes tourists can be annoying, but unless you yourself have never been on holiday, don't take the holier than thou attitude. After all, take away the tourism in many places and you take away the jobs and the livelihoods (and the house prices.)
Not a Tory at all, indeed I'm a committed socialist but Norman Tebbit did have a point with his mischaracterised 'on yer bike speech' of the early 80s:

I grew up in the '30s with an unemployed father. He didn't riot. He got on his bike and looked for work, and he kept looking till he found it.

The point being that there isn't a god given right to live in an area, subsidised by the state, just because your family live there. People complain about second homes in Cornwall and Skye and places like that, which is understandable, but no-one ever complains about people in eg Brixton or Bermondsey in South London not being able to live where their families are from due to changing house prices, second homes, and gentrification. Are these people not white enough, or not middle class enough? Genuine question- or maybe people just think tough shit it's London?

In fact, the people with the largest amount of second homes- 25 according to this article- and all funded by our taxes- "belong" to the Royal Family.
https://www.purewow.com/entertainment/properties-owned-by-the-royal-family
I hope everyone moaning about second homes in tourist areas agrees with me that if we gave these parasites the boot there would be more money for better public services, including better jobs, training, housing and transport in places like Skye, Cornwall that would offer better paid jobs to locals- or anyone else for that matter- in these and other areas.

Just a bit of a rant, but it's so easy to moan at other people and feel smug, whilst all the while being totally hypocritical.

pleasehelpwi3 · 09/04/2023 00:10

I wonder if these NIMBYS feel the same way about other people's areas when they holiday in other popular places people live in....
I mean, have you seen the tourists with their suitcases on the tube? And as for anyone who isn't local going to Cornwall in the summer, how selfish is that?
I also wonder how many of those complaining about second homes voted for Corbyn, about the only politician who probably actually would have done something about them. (I've got a second home, well flat, not by choice, and yes I did vote for him.)
Yes tourists can be annoying, but unless you yourself have never been on holiday, don't take the holier than thou attitude. After all, take away the tourism in many places and you take away the jobs and the livelihoods (and the house prices.)
Not a Tory at all, indeed I'm a committed socialist but Norman Tebbit did have a point with his mischaracterised 'on yer bike speech' of the early 80s:

I grew up in the '30s with an unemployed father. He didn't riot. He got on his bike and looked for work, and he kept looking till he found it.

The point being that there isn't a god given right to live in an area, subsidised by the state, just because your family live there. People complain about second homes in Cornwall and Skye and places like that, which is understandable, but no-one ever complains about people in eg Brixton or Bermondsey in South London not being able to live where their families are from due to changing house prices, second homes, and gentrification. Are these people not white enough, or not middle class enough? Genuine question- or maybe people just think tough shit it's London?

In fact, the people with the largest amount of second homes- 25 according to this article- and all funded by our taxes- "belong" to the Royal Family.
https://www.purewow.com/entertainment/properties-owned-by-the-royal-family
I hope everyone moaning about second homes in tourist areas agrees with me that if we gave these parasites the boot there would be more money for better public services, including better jobs, training, housing and transport in places like Skye, Cornwall that would offer better paid jobs to locals- or anyone else for that matter- in these and other areas.

Just a bit of a rant, but it's so easy to moan at other people and feel smug, whilst all the while being totally hypocritical.

Firefightress1 · 09/04/2023 00:06

Hardbackwriter · 08/04/2023 22:57

Bit of a shame then that the person who sold your house to you chose to take your money rather than a local buyer, isn't it?

Not really when we have made a life here and are locals . They stipulated it was not to be a holiday let.

OP posts:
SaySomethingMan · 09/04/2023 00:04

MrsAvocet · 08/04/2023 23:51

and of course @Firefightress1you’ll be waiting for me to point out that you’ve presumably taken one of the homes on Skye that locals can’t now afford to buy. So you’re part of the problem!
That isn't necessarily true. Rural areas often need new people. If the area where I live depended on locals to fill all the healthcare and teaching jobs for example there would be even bigger problems than there are already. In my experience people who move here and genuinely make it their home, contributing to the community and the economy, are welcomed.
What the local people object to is rows of houses that are empty for months on end, particularly if they are owned by absentee landlords. Where I live, a particular issue is that the small houses which would previously have been fairly inexpensive are the ones most likely to be used as holiday homes. It's still relatively easy to find bigger homes here, but the type of places that would typically have been bought by first time buyers in the past are like hens' teeth. And there are lots of knock on effects which affect the permanent residents, like falling numbers in village schools and so on.
All communities need some population movement both inward and outwards to thrive but the problems arise when there is no genuine inward movement but enforced excessive outward movement.

A friend (English ) and his wife (Croatian) moved to Skye when they retired. They tried to fit in for two years but has to sell up and move back due to the hostility openly displayed towards them. They would greet and be ignored, walk into shops and people would swap from English to start Gaelic, while glaring at them. Not even their next door neighbours wanted to speak to them.

This was a few years ago though, so hopefully it’s better now. OP seems to feel welcome.

I think if you live in a touristy area, you should be grateful for tourists, because they bring a lot to the economy. Sure those who behave appallingly need to do better. However the way some people speak about tourists, you’d think they were disease-carrying vermin.

I live in a place with some beautiful walks and it can get very busy but i appreciate the difference the people who visit, make to our local economy.

Felixss · 08/04/2023 23:59

I've just been to Bute and west coast of Scotland to visit relatives. It's so packed unpleasant, I think since COVID people are holidaying more in the UK. I used to be able to hire accommodation for very cheap. I can't wait until it becomes unfashionable again and people piss off back abroad.

MrsMoastyToasty · 08/04/2023 23:54

I live near Bath, the whole city is a World Heritage site. Tourists are in the millions each year and the infrastructure isn't really there. The roads were built for horses and carriages not 50 seater coaches.

MrsAvocet · 08/04/2023 23:51

and of course @Firefightress1you’ll be waiting for me to point out that you’ve presumably taken one of the homes on Skye that locals can’t now afford to buy. So you’re part of the problem!
That isn't necessarily true. Rural areas often need new people. If the area where I live depended on locals to fill all the healthcare and teaching jobs for example there would be even bigger problems than there are already. In my experience people who move here and genuinely make it their home, contributing to the community and the economy, are welcomed.
What the local people object to is rows of houses that are empty for months on end, particularly if they are owned by absentee landlords. Where I live, a particular issue is that the small houses which would previously have been fairly inexpensive are the ones most likely to be used as holiday homes. It's still relatively easy to find bigger homes here, but the type of places that would typically have been bought by first time buyers in the past are like hens' teeth. And there are lots of knock on effects which affect the permanent residents, like falling numbers in village schools and so on.
All communities need some population movement both inward and outwards to thrive but the problems arise when there is no genuine inward movement but enforced excessive outward movement.

KnackeredGoat · 08/04/2023 23:42

Please don’t think all tourists are the same. My family a few generations back are from Scotland and we’ve visited a few times.

We did the NC500 years ago before it became popular. It was stunning. We didn’t have a camper. We stayed in B&Bs, hotels, glamping pods etc along the way. We ate in local places and contributed to the economy everywhere we went. I would never leave litter or park anywhere other than a designated space.

I think the behaviour of people in general is much worse recently. There was a thread earlier about the theatre that had to call the police because people were singing and ruining the show, then kicked off when they were asked to stop. I don’t know why people are becoming so disrespectful but I think it has a lot to do with the ‘fast society’ we like in. Whatever we want is almost always instantly accessible. Shops, food, entertainment. People have forgotten how to be patient and respectful.

Trez1510 · 08/04/2023 23:36

RideACockHorseToSunburyCross · 08/04/2023 23:16

"No second home till everybody have their first home for starters"

What does this mean? Surely a second home is exactly that?

I took it to mean ..... no second home for anyone until everyone has their first home.

Tauranga · 08/04/2023 23:36

I live in the borders which is still ignored by the majority of overseas tourists thank god.

FairlySane · 08/04/2023 23:31

My family have lived in a village in Scotland now dubbed the poshest in Scotland. Over run with English retirees and English 2nd absentee home owners. More recently international art dealers have fucked the soul out of the place. What’s left for us ? 5 generations, and still being colonised. Fuck

ProudToBeANorthener · 08/04/2023 23:28

Try living in the north of 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿 England; it’s been horrendous since Covid restrictions eased and lifted. We crave rain and cold to keep them at bay. They’re worse than midges and worse still leave litter and. everywhere. 😡

Citygirlrurallife · 08/04/2023 23:24

Gosh this thread makes me so sad. We’ve lived abroad for 10years, moved home last summer and I’ve been so excited for weekend trips around the U.K. to finally show it off to the DC

Trixiefirecracker · 08/04/2023 23:21

Queues! Not cues. Can’t even type I’m so incensed! 😂

Trixiefirecracker · 08/04/2023 23:20

Welcome to the Lake District. We live just outside but can’t get anywhere this weekend without being stuck in massive cues. I understand the the lakes has anyways been traditionally busy (possibly unlike Skye) but it’s so much worse since lockdown. Took an hour and a half to get in to town to do our weekly shop, instead of 20mins and longer on the way home. People just park up wherever they want and piss and shit everywhere.

MissDollyMix · 08/04/2023 23:19

BitOutOfPractice · 08/04/2023 23:13

I’ve been around the Tower of London today and the crowds were INSANE. I mean I know it’s London but I have genuinely never seen it so crowded and I used to work very nearby and pass every day. It was BONKERS.

Sorry I know this was about Skye but I think it’s the same all over.

and of course @Firefightress1 you’ll be waiting for me to point out that you’ve presumably taken one of the homes on Skye that locals can’t now afford to buy. So you’re part of the problem!

Interesting you say that- I’ve been in and around London my whole life and although I haven’t been back for a couple of months - when I last visited at Christmas the crowds were like nothing I’ve ever seen in my life! Yes, London is always busy at Christmas (I’m well used to it), but this was a whole other level!

RideACockHorseToSunburyCross · 08/04/2023 23:16

"No second home till everybody have their first home for starters"

What does this mean? Surely a second home is exactly that?

BitOutOfPractice · 08/04/2023 23:13

Paloma66 · 08/04/2023 21:13

I'm in London. I've never seen so many people as I did in central London yesterday. It's crazy. We couldn't walk across Westminster Bridge, it was dangerous.

Your comments about house prices etc apply in many places all over the country.

I’ve been around the Tower of London today and the crowds were INSANE. I mean I know it’s London but I have genuinely never seen it so crowded and I used to work very nearby and pass every day. It was BONKERS.

Sorry I know this was about Skye but I think it’s the same all over.

and of course @Firefightress1 you’ll be waiting for me to point out that you’ve presumably taken one of the homes on Skye that locals can’t now afford to buy. So you’re part of the problem!

Thursa · 08/04/2023 23:12

There are a few NC500 pages on FB. I’ve seen people show off their vans, ready to come north, and it’s full of tins of food. “Calum” the stag is now a must see on the route. Pictures of people hand feeding him. One family happily feeding him a Mr Kipling apple pie. Photos of people walking their dogs close to sheep, and through cemeteries. Climbing on monuments, or putting up washing lines on them. Open fires. Scorched earth and Tyre tracks beside the camper van parked up for the beautiful view. People posting wondering if they’re going to be able to buy food and fuel on the route…

TheHateIsNotGood · 08/04/2023 23:07

Interesting point about selling your home to the highest bidder rather than the best (eg: local) buyer.

I want to sell within 2 years and move to a smaller property locally - I am seriously considering local buyers only when I do. I've done similar before so putting conscience before money isn't a new concept to me.

Probably explains why I'm not economically well off but that's fine by me.

Transparent2 · 08/04/2023 23:06

PerpetualStudent · 08/04/2023 20:51

YANBU - I’m Highlands too, there’s a place near me where people often wild camp and the same spots get used as a wild toilet over and over until it’s an open sewer, complete with loo roll and wet wipes festooning surrounding trees 🤢 This all runs downhill into a Loch the grubbers then happily swim in?!

I always thinks who travels to be surrounding by all this natural beauty, just to literally shit on it…

Is this place next to a road? If it is, they’re not wild camping. Wild camping is is well away from roads and it’s only OK when it’s done responsibly, which means no litter including faeces.

Matchymatchylemonscratchy · 08/04/2023 23:02

We have the same in Australia. Some Coastal towns have got inundated in holiday periods to the point that there are traffic jams and you can’t actually make it to the beach.

It started as a result of border closures and the accomodation prices went nuts too.

I did hear on the news yesterday that Easter numbers are way down. Not surprising given the rents some airbnb are going for now and the cost of living increases we are all experiencing.

MrsMoastyToasty · 08/04/2023 23:01

Mull and Iona remain less spoilt than Skye ( we have family on Mull and have also visited the other 2 islands) I think primarily because the first 2 don't have a road bridge for access to and from the mainland.
We've been visiting Mull for 30 years and the Balamory years saw an increase of families with preschoolers.

Swipe left for the next trending thread