Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I know IABU.... Scottish Highlands tourism

290 replies

Firefightress1 · 08/04/2023 20:31

I know IABU as we were tourists before we moved to Skye but I'm absolutely gobsmacked by how busy it has been over the weekend. I know its not even the busiest time yet but I'm already struggling to get diesel to get to work and the coop is stripped bare. Had a campervan nearly drive into us earlier on the wrong side of the road at a junction and people parking in passing places on single track roads which means traffic is at a standstill.
We always followed the rules and pulled in/let people overtake but there seems to be a new selfish version of a tourist. I know we need to get used to it but people just blatantly disregarding signage and peeing/sh*tting all over the place is just awful!
I honestly don't remember it as bad as this when we were tourists but i guess we didnt live here then
There are so many facebook groups trying to make improvements but the tour buses and guides still insist on stopping at closed sights and encouraging groups to force open gates and move cones to gain access. Its causing so many issues to wildlife and repair operations that are badly needed.

OP posts:
manontroppo · 09/04/2023 08:53

I’m on the fence about this. If tourists are a problem, why aren’t local councils paying for more traffic wardens and bin emptiers several times a day at peak season? A local council up north has just imposed a hotel tax which could pay for things like this, and afaik local councils can limit AirBnB style lets. We are currently on holiday now and the local beaches all have BBQ disposal areas, so you can safely get rid of your BBQ. Why aren’t you demanding more of your local councillors?

It’s not unreasonable to want to go on holiday, and the idea that we’ll all stay happily in a crappy B and B or overpriced hotel has long gone.

R11zz · 09/04/2023 08:51

I live near Skye too. There are many more tourists visiting. The holiday season is much longer too now. We just don’t have the infrastructure for the tourists. Highland council needs to spend money but since pot holes are never dealt with why should we expect money to be spent on helping tourists have a better experience. Broadford is also not getting an additional school but a brand new school.

FrostyFifi · 09/04/2023 08:28

I agree this thread has become embarrassing now. House price inflation and large tourist numbers is a global issue but apparently that's no barrier to a xenophobic rant.

midgemadgemodge · 09/04/2023 07:55

Scepticalwotsits · 09/04/2023 07:22

I get the concerns about right to roam and wild camping. But in Scotland it does not apply to motor homes, Camper vans or enclosed areas.

so if people are doing that it’s a case of it needs enforcement by police Scotland (and that is probably a problem in itself)

Wild camping doesn't apply to motor homes .... but in a lot of cases it is legal to park on a car park or lay-by and stay overnight

The problem shouldn't be someone legally parking overnight, moving on and leaving no trace

The problem is inconsiderate parking , hogging parking areas , leaving litter blocking roads

badgermushrooms · 09/04/2023 07:38

Hi @Trez1510 , "English" living in rural Scotland here wondering if you could clarify whether DH and I are welcome or should go back where we came from.

We are still of child producing age but due to DH's previous cancer treatment are needing some extra help to conceive. If we don't manage it before my ovaries finally give up the ghost should we pack up and take our useless, barren selves elsewhere?

We bought our flat (after it being on the market for 6 months) mostly using money from my mum's share of my late grandad's 2 bed semi in Fife, which I think you're saying is ok, but with a small contribution from my dad who unfortunately earned his money in That London. Does the latter override the former in terms of acceptability?

We both do jobs that our respective organisations (public sector and charity) find hard to recruit for. My job had to be readvertised originally as they needed 2 people and I was the only 1 suitable applicant. DH's only competition for his job was a South African lady, not sure if that's better or worse than The English? Anyway I suppose what I'm suggesting is perhaps there could be a special visa we could apply for for low paid unpopular work - I hear the Tories in government down south have some interesting ideas about that which would allow employers to get some benefit from us without us acquiring any sort of rights or ability to stay past our usefulness. You might want to have a chat with Suella, she's got some ideas you'd find yourself getting on very well with.

Dave7900 · 09/04/2023 07:32

bossonext · 09/04/2023 00:29

And?

And that as a result, Scots suffer with depression more than the English further south.

pleasehelpwi3 · 09/04/2023 07:28

If 'locals' didn't sell to 'outsiders' in the first place, villages would be still be viable. Of course people have the right to sell their property to the highest offer, and most will. It's unreasonable to ask the rest of us to subsidise economically failing villages.
As for people shitting in verges etc, of course that's unreasonable.

HomeTheatreSystem · 09/04/2023 07:24

Perhaps the question is, if these people in their current numbers, behaved with respect for their surroundings, ie took their litter with them, didn't scorch grass with bbqs, wash out their stuff in the Loch, would their presence still be resented?

Scepticalwotsits · 09/04/2023 07:22

I get the concerns about right to roam and wild camping. But in Scotland it does not apply to motor homes, Camper vans or enclosed areas.

so if people are doing that it’s a case of it needs enforcement by police Scotland (and that is probably a problem in itself)

thelittlestkiwi · 09/04/2023 07:18

I've seen lay-by's in NZ similarly draped in toilet roll and disgusting litter. Our problem was exacerbated by freedom campers converting hatchback cars with beds and travelling around for months spending very little.

A range of measures have been brought in - bans on camper vans without self contained toilets, bans on sleeping in vehicles in some areas and better facilities.

I can't believe people are being called NIMBY's cos they don't want tourists shitting everywhere.

TodayInahurry · 09/04/2023 07:09

The SNP passed a right to roam act, hence the destructive wild camping, when I imagine there are plenty of sites with toilets.

I imagine the Scottish government are far too busy fighting about trans issues to bother about real problems

Scepticalwotsits · 09/04/2023 07:02

Firefightress1 · 08/04/2023 20:38

We are surrounded by holiday homes, there's so many people on Skye that can't afford to get on the property ladder and these houses lie empty for 6 months of the year.
Something needs to be done to save island life, young people all leave as there are no opportunities or possibility of housing x

Tbh that’s not just a Skye issue. All over the UK.

near us a new built estate is going up on the edge of the village and the prices are 50k above the average village property for the similar type.

village already isn’t affordable with current prices for people wanting to stay here, and even though house prices are going down the houses recently which have been listed have upped their valuations to match the new build prices.

Also when the site was approved it was with an additional primary school and some shops.

these have now been dropped so it’s just an overload onto the current village services.

anyway a long tangent to say I feel for you but the issues you have with housing are UK wide

Pattydale · 09/04/2023 06:28

BeatriceFranklin · 08/04/2023 22:34

We’ve witnessed toilets being emptied and washed out in the loch. It’s feral behaviour.

This is unbelievable. Who are these people who want nature on the one hand but do this vile sort of stuff? Disgusting.

duvetcovereddissident · 09/04/2023 06:04

This thread is real eye opener- the whole of the country is seemingly overwhelmed with tourists. There must by literally millions of empty homes all over the UK as people move into holiday homes or take their tents or camper vans to the tourist places.

It would be interesting to see genuine numbers of bank holiday migrations, but I suppose it must be impossible to really know or work out, but it must be massive.

I live in London, and around here it seems normal, not a tourist area - but thinking about it, maybe a but quieter that normal so maybe this is a net donor area, and we have sent you lots of tourists

BitOutOfPractice · 09/04/2023 05:39

@Trez1510 the phenomenon of retirees and second home incomers certainly isn’t peculiar to Scotland. Ask anyone in Cornwall or Pembroke or Co Antrim or the Costa del Sol or anywhere that’s beautiful to live. They’ll tell you the same. I’m not sure what difference the nationality has, the outcome is the same.

Trez1510 · 09/04/2023 02:59

NatashaDancing · 09/04/2023 02:53

Oh and as for "talking funny" my husband's idiot, NAT supporting brother, thought it was hilarious to mock my accent the first time he met me, because despite having been born and brought up in Aberdeenshire, it wasn't apparently sufficiently "Scottish".

Okay, Uncle Tom, you're right it's perfectly acceptable for a gang of English children to bully a Scottish child in Scotland for speaking with a Scottish accent.
Gotcha! 🙄

NatashaDancing · 09/04/2023 02:53

Oh and as for "talking funny" my husband's idiot, NAT supporting brother, thought it was hilarious to mock my accent the first time he met me, because despite having been born and brought up in Aberdeenshire, it wasn't apparently sufficiently "Scottish".

NatashaDancing · 09/04/2023 02:49

This thread is indeed embarrassing. English people in denial that Scotland is a distinct country, not an extension of England

I'm Scottish. I'm embarrassed by the anti- English, xenophobic and hypocritical posts on here.

Trez1510 · 09/04/2023 02:42

NatashaDancing · 09/04/2023 02:28

The issue under discussion here is the impact on rural Scotland (and Cornwall) of settlers forcing young, local people out of their own communities.

Sorry, run that past me again - "settlers forcing people out"

I must have missed the reports of invasion by English geriatrics armed with swords, pillaging and evicting the locals.

Or perhaps it's the locals taking advantage of the Scottish sealed bids, offers over system for selling their houses?

This thread is deeply embarrassing.

One does not need to take up arms to 'force', it can be achieved by financial means e.g. sell an ex-council flat in London and take advantage of (what until recently was) Scotland's cheaper housing.

This thread is indeed embarrassing. English people in denial that Scotland is a distinct country, not an extension of England.

Since Brexit it has worsened. No longer can exclusive English conclaves be created in Spain, so there is a concerted attempt to do so in rural Scotland.

I have a friend who is a hotelier in a small West Coast village. Last year when we visited we barely heard a Scottish accent, and when we asked about the group of local waiting staff/customers with whom we'd previously had great banter, she said they'd all moved away due to lack of accommodation or it no longer feeling like home. She's also considering selling-up.

A few months ago, she was telling me about her wee grandson being bullied at school because he 'talked funny'. I was perplexed because his diction is perfect. It turned out he is the only Scot at the local village school, all the other children, as well as the teacher, being English. They were bullying him for having a Scottish accent in Scotland.

So, no, no swords required.

NatashaDancing · 09/04/2023 02:41

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I'll say it again - this thread is embarrassing.

Marchitectmummy · 09/04/2023 02:33

Skye has always been busy with tourists from April onwards. The things being described have always gone on.

Puffalicious · 09/04/2023 02:29

Trez1510 · 09/04/2023 02:21

I live in the vibrant, welcoming, multicultural tourist trap city of Glasgow.

So, no fainting here.

The issue under discussion here is the impact on rural Scotland (and Cornwall) of settlers forcing young, local people out of their own communities.

In Scotland, this is a particular issue given elderly people are not increasing the birth rate which is desperately needed if Scotland is to have the future workforce to, in amongst other things, wipe the arses of the retired English as well as elderly Scots.

But, yes I would prevent elderly people settling in Scotland from wherever they hail. It just so happens the incomers are predominately from England whilst elderly people from countries like, say, Italy, Peru or Libor tend not to view the country of Scotland attractive as a source of cheaper housing, free personal care etc. etc. etc.

BANG on the money.

I have family in Cornwall, and DS's GF in Northumberland- both places which I absolutely love and spend lots of time i. I hate what has happened to communities there, and it's just history repeating itself now in Scotland. It's so sad.

Trez1510 · 09/04/2023 02:29

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

NatashaDancing · 09/04/2023 02:28

The issue under discussion here is the impact on rural Scotland (and Cornwall) of settlers forcing young, local people out of their own communities.

Sorry, run that past me again - "settlers forcing people out"

I must have missed the reports of invasion by English geriatrics armed with swords, pillaging and evicting the locals.

Or perhaps it's the locals taking advantage of the Scottish sealed bids, offers over system for selling their houses?

This thread is deeply embarrassing.

Trez1510 · 09/04/2023 02:21

IceMagic · 09/04/2023 02:02

Well stop selling your homes to English people then. Or perhaps campaign to make it illegal for English people to move to a different area after a certain age. I live near London with loads of people who've moved from different countries. You'd probably faint with horror.

I live in the vibrant, welcoming, multicultural tourist trap city of Glasgow.

So, no fainting here.

The issue under discussion here is the impact on rural Scotland (and Cornwall) of settlers forcing young, local people out of their own communities.

In Scotland, this is a particular issue given elderly people are not increasing the birth rate which is desperately needed if Scotland is to have the future workforce to, in amongst other things, wipe the arses of the retired English as well as elderly Scots.

But, yes I would prevent elderly people settling in Scotland from wherever they hail. It just so happens the incomers are predominately from England whilst elderly people from countries like, say, Italy, Peru or Libor tend not to view the country of Scotland attractive as a source of cheaper housing, free personal care etc. etc. etc.

Swipe left for the next trending thread