Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I know IABU.... Scottish Highlands tourism

290 replies

Firefightress1 · 08/04/2023 20:31

I know IABU as we were tourists before we moved to Skye but I'm absolutely gobsmacked by how busy it has been over the weekend. I know its not even the busiest time yet but I'm already struggling to get diesel to get to work and the coop is stripped bare. Had a campervan nearly drive into us earlier on the wrong side of the road at a junction and people parking in passing places on single track roads which means traffic is at a standstill.
We always followed the rules and pulled in/let people overtake but there seems to be a new selfish version of a tourist. I know we need to get used to it but people just blatantly disregarding signage and peeing/sh*tting all over the place is just awful!
I honestly don't remember it as bad as this when we were tourists but i guess we didnt live here then
There are so many facebook groups trying to make improvements but the tour buses and guides still insist on stopping at closed sights and encouraging groups to force open gates and move cones to gain access. Its causing so many issues to wildlife and repair operations that are badly needed.

OP posts:
HomeTheatreSystem · 09/04/2023 12:39

Tallisker · 09/04/2023 12:26

It took nearly an hour to get out of a supermarket car park yesterday in a well known Lake District town. I've never seen so many cars, even by Lake District standards it was rammed.

The rubbish left behind is just awful, and ignorant visitors chop down tree branches to make fires on the lake shores, as if green living wood will burn. Just idiotic behaviour.

But litter is a problem everywhere and getting worse. Most roadsides are an eyesore, even motorways. How did this behaviour become the norm?

Re behaviour, I think that there is an element (significant) who know that any applicable sanctions will never be applied and anyone asking them to clean up their mess will be given an earful or worse. I hate this kind of appalling anti-social inconsiderate behaviour but without effective deterrents it won't stop.

Puffalicious · 09/04/2023 12:34

Fundays12 · 09/04/2023 12:12

As a local I can assure you many camper vans owners are a problem. Obviously not all as many are respectful, use proper campsite and tidy up after themselves. The ones that I have found are problematic are the ones that leave rubbish and feces all over the place and the ones that have no idea how to drive on single track roads or what the rules are around passing places etc. They come here too see the beauty of the Highlands then treat it like a waste ground. Also ones who want to climb our mountains but are ill prepared to do so wind up ending up being rescued.

The toilets issue you encountered was what I meant. The Highlands doesn't have the infrastructure to cope with the sheer volumes of tourists. Everything is so wide spread getting staff to clean them can be an issue too.

It's makes me so angry- I can't imagine what it's like for you living there. In my mind, fellow lovers of the outdoors and natural world would be like minded people who want to preserve our precious land and treat it with the reverence it deserves. It makes no sense to me at all. People are just beyond the pale sometimes.

Highland Council have a lot to contend with as it's such a huge area. I suppose I hadn't actually thought about no staff to clean them. The shop owner told me he applied to buy the toilets so he could maintain them properly, but it was a legal minefield. Shame.

Tallisker · 09/04/2023 12:26

It took nearly an hour to get out of a supermarket car park yesterday in a well known Lake District town. I've never seen so many cars, even by Lake District standards it was rammed.

The rubbish left behind is just awful, and ignorant visitors chop down tree branches to make fires on the lake shores, as if green living wood will burn. Just idiotic behaviour.

But litter is a problem everywhere and getting worse. Most roadsides are an eyesore, even motorways. How did this behaviour become the norm?

BeatriceFranklin · 09/04/2023 12:24

Fundays12 · 09/04/2023 12:12

As a local I can assure you many camper vans owners are a problem. Obviously not all as many are respectful, use proper campsite and tidy up after themselves. The ones that I have found are problematic are the ones that leave rubbish and feces all over the place and the ones that have no idea how to drive on single track roads or what the rules are around passing places etc. They come here too see the beauty of the Highlands then treat it like a waste ground. Also ones who want to climb our mountains but are ill prepared to do so wind up ending up being rescued.

The toilets issue you encountered was what I meant. The Highlands doesn't have the infrastructure to cope with the sheer volumes of tourists. Everything is so wide spread getting staff to clean them can be an issue too.

👏👏👏👏👏

Fundays12 · 09/04/2023 12:12

Puffalicious · 09/04/2023 11:49

'They' are not all of us. This 'they' has just been to Morar- 4 nights in a great campsite (pricey but worth it), spent locally in shops/ restaurants/ gift-shops/ local ferry and lots of time on the amazing beach leaving not a trace.

Not all campervan owners are 'clowns' or 'scum' as quoted previously on this thread.

The only issue was coming home and the toilets at Glencoe are closed for renovation and the ones at Ballahuilish due to vandalism. Where are you supposed to pee? The gift shop owner kindly let me and DS use theirs, but I bought things whilst there.

As a local I can assure you many camper vans owners are a problem. Obviously not all as many are respectful, use proper campsite and tidy up after themselves. The ones that I have found are problematic are the ones that leave rubbish and feces all over the place and the ones that have no idea how to drive on single track roads or what the rules are around passing places etc. They come here too see the beauty of the Highlands then treat it like a waste ground. Also ones who want to climb our mountains but are ill prepared to do so wind up ending up being rescued.

The toilets issue you encountered was what I meant. The Highlands doesn't have the infrastructure to cope with the sheer volumes of tourists. Everything is so wide spread getting staff to clean them can be an issue too.

Puffalicious · 09/04/2023 11:49

Fundays12 · 09/04/2023 10:19

I live in the Highlands and yes it's been ruined by tourists. Not all the tourists but the camper vans are definitely a huge issue. We don't have the infrastructure, roads, public toilets etc to cope with all the tourists. They come here to view the beautiful areas and leave behind rubbish, mess and sewage.

'They' are not all of us. This 'they' has just been to Morar- 4 nights in a great campsite (pricey but worth it), spent locally in shops/ restaurants/ gift-shops/ local ferry and lots of time on the amazing beach leaving not a trace.

Not all campervan owners are 'clowns' or 'scum' as quoted previously on this thread.

The only issue was coming home and the toilets at Glencoe are closed for renovation and the ones at Ballahuilish due to vandalism. Where are you supposed to pee? The gift shop owner kindly let me and DS use theirs, but I bought things whilst there.

AffIt · 09/04/2023 10:55

manontroppo · 09/04/2023 08:53

I’m on the fence about this. If tourists are a problem, why aren’t local councils paying for more traffic wardens and bin emptiers several times a day at peak season? A local council up north has just imposed a hotel tax which could pay for things like this, and afaik local councils can limit AirBnB style lets. We are currently on holiday now and the local beaches all have BBQ disposal areas, so you can safely get rid of your BBQ. Why aren’t you demanding more of your local councillors?

It’s not unreasonable to want to go on holiday, and the idea that we’ll all stay happily in a crappy B and B or overpriced hotel has long gone.

Because in many small communities, there simply aren't enough people!

Most small communities only benefit from tourism for around 4-6 months of the year. Although some of the bigger hotels and resorts might bring in seasonal workers and accommodate them on site, it's not uncommon for the people who actually live there year round to have two or even three jobs, as you can't rely on year-round tourism.

So at the height of the season, the local population will be flat-out anyway.

The alternative might be to bring people in from other areas, but populations are small up here anyway - Scotland has a total population of 5.5 million, most of whom (myself included) live in the central belt, far from the rural tourist hot spots - so you'd just be stripping away a resource from another community.

Added to that, the sort of jobs you're talking about are generally minimum wage at best, and people - assuming they own a car - may be unwilling or unable to pay out the high cost of fuel (and fuel in remote areas is generally more expensive than in towns and cities).

The council could bus them in? Perhaps, but again you're talking about remote areas that can be hours apart, so adding hours of commuting time onto a physical, low-paid job?

It's not a simple fix, I'm afraid.

TooBored1 · 09/04/2023 10:33

Firefightress1 · 08/04/2023 20:38

We are surrounded by holiday homes, there's so many people on Skye that can't afford to get on the property ladder and these houses lie empty for 6 months of the year.
Something needs to be done to save island life, young people all leave as there are no opportunities or possibility of housing x

Sadly it's the same in Devon and Cornwall too.

manontroppo · 09/04/2023 10:31

NatashaDancing · 09/04/2023 10:24

If there is insufficient infrastructure to support the tourists then of course that's a failure of local and national government. Tourism is a major source of income. As others have said, the locals are very happy to take the tourist money.

Is it still the case that out of the 28 ministerial posts (out of a total of 64 MSPs) Yousaf still hasn't appointmened a minister for tourism?

I very much agree with this. It’s not difficult to sort out residents’ parking passes, improving rubbish collection and penalising crap parking. Tourists are going to come so you might as well manage it properly.

I also note that in France there are shedloads of well advertised Elsan disposal points - most motorway/A road lay-bys have them. Never seen this in the U.K.

NatashaDancing · 09/04/2023 10:24

AgnesX · 09/04/2023 09:53

Part of the problem is that a lot of people don't spend money locally and the local councils who are responsible for cleaning and facilities don't see any benefit.

As for the potshots at the government, oh please🙄

If there is insufficient infrastructure to support the tourists then of course that's a failure of local and national government. Tourism is a major source of income. As others have said, the locals are very happy to take the tourist money.

Is it still the case that out of the 28 ministerial posts (out of a total of 64 MSPs) Yousaf still hasn't appointmened a minister for tourism?

Fundays12 · 09/04/2023 10:19

I live in the Highlands and yes it's been ruined by tourists. Not all the tourists but the camper vans are definitely a huge issue. We don't have the infrastructure, roads, public toilets etc to cope with all the tourists. They come here to view the beautiful areas and leave behind rubbish, mess and sewage.

AgnesX · 09/04/2023 10:18

KimberleyClark · 09/04/2023 10:00

We do, we use supermarkets, cafes, pubs, gift shops, boat trips and DH usually gets some of the Island whiskies. Last year we caught a ferry to Lewis too and had a couple of nights in Stornoway.

That's great to hear but I have heard some people quite happily admit to making a point of "going cheap" and spending as little as they can because "the UK is expensive".

FrostyFifi · 09/04/2023 10:11

People talking about charging to enter national parks - in the US these are separate, managed areas of wilderness with an entire dedicated workforce to run and manage them. They are not inhabited.

There simply isn't anything like that in the UK. Even the designated national parks areas are working, farmed inhabited areas. How would you charge entry, and who?
The suggestion of confiscating road-legal vehicles for driving on a public road is ridiculous.

As I've said early, antisocial behaviour from visitors makes me really angry but has absolutely nothing to with people moving to the area to be residents, and some of the attitudes here towards individuals who are working and contributing to communities is awful. There are some islands that would be uninhabited now, such as Coll, if new people hadn't settled there.

And I'm not sure how anyone in their right mind can be defending the SNP at present.

KimberleyClark · 09/04/2023 10:00

AgnesX · 09/04/2023 09:53

Part of the problem is that a lot of people don't spend money locally and the local councils who are responsible for cleaning and facilities don't see any benefit.

As for the potshots at the government, oh please🙄

We do, we use supermarkets, cafes, pubs, gift shops, boat trips and DH usually gets some of the Island whiskies. Last year we caught a ferry to Lewis too and had a couple of nights in Stornoway.

AgnesX · 09/04/2023 09:53

Part of the problem is that a lot of people don't spend money locally and the local councils who are responsible for cleaning and facilities don't see any benefit.

As for the potshots at the government, oh please🙄

dottiedodah · 09/04/2023 09:51

On South Coast here.busy from mar /Apr to October!in New forest not far away. 40mph limit still people exceeding this ponies Hurt .lots of litter. On our well known seaside town. Beaches strewn with rubbish . Some woodland destroyed by fires.i think you have a rosy view when you move somewhere you enjoyed on holiday. My dp did the same when we decamped from London!

Beamur · 09/04/2023 09:50

I went to Skye once about 12 years ago and despite how lovely it is, hated how busy and crammed with motorhomes it was. I can imagine it has only got much worse.
It's a twin issue (in many many places) of lack of infrastructure for the numbers of visitors and poor behaviour arising from mass tourism.
I think we need the domestic tourism market but how we make it work for visitors and residents I don't know.

LlynTegid · 09/04/2023 09:45

Tourists showing no consideration for others and local customs/practices, agree is unacceptable. Unreasonable to complain about volumes or be surprised at them on a four day bank holiday weekend with OK weather.

I hope if the OP goes to the Med for a holiday they are not the kind of person who expects only 'British' food and never speaks a word of the local language.

TheMilkWhisperer · 09/04/2023 09:44

Sad to hear this as we’ll be on holiday in Scotland this summer including a week on Skye.

I would say in the tourists defence
a) you can’t easily get to Skye without a car - and touring it you absolutely need one (there’s no airport nearby).
b) the accommodation is super expensive and to get it you seem to have to book months in advance

so I can understand why there are so many camper vans..

Still you’d think the local authorities would be well aware of this as well. Such a shame that they want the tourism but aren’t prepared to pay for the infrastructure to go with it.

sst1234 · 09/04/2023 09:41

Oh look little engalanders, sorry scotlanders complaining about tourism which brings money in. With the economy up the creek, you would think they would be grateful. This insular, small island mentality seems to be getting worse in this country.

Blame the Scottish government for not providing facilities for tourists. It’s their job to promote tourism and make money for the economy. But I guess they are too busy worrying about how dudes can call themselves women. That takes precedence.

RideACockHorseToSunburyCross · 09/04/2023 09:16

"I took it to mean ..... no second home for anyone until everyone has their first home."

What a bizarre idea

EyesOnThePies · 09/04/2023 09:10

WillHe · 08/04/2023 21:56

The tourists in North Cornwall all look so miserable. Taking the entire family to the supermarket.
Parking, so they needn't pay or walk further than necessary to the beautiful, wild thing they've gone to Instagram.
Just so impatient, ned to drive really fast without giving way or reversing.
Camped out in vans, shitting in the dunes, telling the local teens off for building beach bonfires & playing guitar (locals enjoying their local stuff) before going home to get into work the next day serving tourists.
The tourists always seem to use those disposable bonfires and then bury them in the sand for the local, up early dog walkers to find still hot the next day or set fire to the bins meaning the volunteer fire brigade have to leave their families & jobs to sort out the mess.

It's mostly the fact the most people seem to find most of their holidays very stressful.

I think the sale of disposable barbecues should be banned.

They are a fire hazard as directly on the ground, generate huge waste of valuable finite resources, and are a health hazard: the food just gets covered in carcinogenic soot as the grill is so close to the charcoal, and there isn’t enough of it to burn to a good hot charcoal bed.

Inthesamesinkingboat · 09/04/2023 09:10

@manontroppo i think part of the issue is that people always think what they are doing is on the right side of the line, but it is other people who are the problem. “I was fine when I was a tourist, but tourists now are worse”

or if you look at home owners there is a spectrum from “I was born in the village” through to “I was from the local town and moved out” to “I am from England and moved here to work” then “I moved here to retire” and then “I love it here so bought a second home”. Wherever people sit on this spectrum they seem to view that as the line of acceptability and everything beyond that as ruining it.

There are some people who are awful with litter, but in the main the tourists I come across are much as they always were (ok there are more, but there are more people bloody everywhere). I think the OP is just now looking at it through a locals lens. (When she was a tourist she was fine 😉)

nonevernotever · 09/04/2023 08:57

TodayInahurry · 09/04/2023 07:09

The SNP passed a right to roam act, hence the destructive wild camping, when I imagine there are plenty of sites with toilets.

I imagine the Scottish government are far too busy fighting about trans issues to bother about real problems

Umm actually the right to roam (actually a right of responsible access) was Passed in the first Scottish parliament, so a labour/lib Dems coalition....

NatashaDancing · 09/04/2023 08:53

Trez1510 · 09/04/2023 02:59

Okay, Uncle Tom, you're right it's perfectly acceptable for a gang of English children to bully a Scottish child in Scotland for speaking with a Scottish accent.
Gotcha! 🙄

I never said it was ok for your grandchildren to be bullied over their accent. It was just an example of that sort of idiocy working both ways.

As for calling me "Uncle Tom" carry on making a fool of yourself and showing your true colours.

Swipe left for the next trending thread