Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I know IABU.... Scottish Highlands tourism

290 replies

Firefightress1 · 08/04/2023 20:31

I know IABU as we were tourists before we moved to Skye but I'm absolutely gobsmacked by how busy it has been over the weekend. I know its not even the busiest time yet but I'm already struggling to get diesel to get to work and the coop is stripped bare. Had a campervan nearly drive into us earlier on the wrong side of the road at a junction and people parking in passing places on single track roads which means traffic is at a standstill.
We always followed the rules and pulled in/let people overtake but there seems to be a new selfish version of a tourist. I know we need to get used to it but people just blatantly disregarding signage and peeing/sh*tting all over the place is just awful!
I honestly don't remember it as bad as this when we were tourists but i guess we didnt live here then
There are so many facebook groups trying to make improvements but the tour buses and guides still insist on stopping at closed sights and encouraging groups to force open gates and move cones to gain access. Its causing so many issues to wildlife and repair operations that are badly needed.

OP posts:
2bazookas · 09/04/2023 17:44

I think if you live in a touristy area, you should be grateful for tourists, because they bring a lot to the economy.

You'd only think that; if you hadn't experienced the hell that motorhome holidays inflict on rural and island Scotland.
Because of distance, and transport costs, food here costs more. So Motorhome owners fill up the vehicle with cheap food and drink at Lidl before they leave home. To save money. So, they aren't buying island accommodation, or supporting local food shops or restaurants or pubs. They don't want to pay for a camp site with 20 other white tin boxes, so at night they park free in the supermarket car park, or in passing places on the single track roads. When they've eaten and drunk the mainland shopping they shit and piss on board. Then they pull in to a layby or car park at night and empty their lav on a beach, ditch, just anywhere.. They drive up at night to sleep in the queue for the non-bookable little ferry; which means tourists in cars, can't get on board ; and nor can locals who have an urgent need to get to the mainland for hospital appt because the Big ferry is broken , again. They drive miles down the middle of single track roads, can't reverse the monster to passing places, until they meet a junction and if they are foreign clean forget it's back to drive on the LEFT.

Firefightress1 · 09/04/2023 17:42

Whisper23 · 09/04/2023 15:44

Another Skye resident here. We moved here 18 months ago and I'm surprised by some of the comments about incomers not being welcome. I've not felt this at all, people have been very welcoming and friendly.

We're in a very quiet bit up beyond Dunvegan so the tourists are not a big issue in our immediate area. We get the odd campervan looking for somewhere to park up but not much else. The roads were busy when I drove into Portree yesterday though. Lots of people who don't seem to know how to drive on single track roads.

In other parts of the island the campervans are an absolute menace. I think numbers should be restricted somehow. I'm not far from Neist Point but I wouldn't even attempt to get there in summer due to the number of campervans. Personally I think there should be a toll on the bridge for campervans, with the money ringfenced to sort out the roads/potholes.

I love dunvegan, we go often to the dunvegan for food.
I can honestly say we've been made very welcome and have some lovely friends and social events here.
It's what you make it and if you try to integrate and get involved in the community then it's always welcome.

OP posts:
Whisper23 · 09/04/2023 17:33

Absolutely @2bazookas, that's why I drew a line when we were moving up here. In wouldn't move to anywhere dependent on ferries.

2bazookas · 09/04/2023 17:20

Oh well, at least your island had a bridge access so you can always escape, find a mainland smkt with food; fill up the car tank.

Spare a thought for the islands with a broken Calmac ferry service, where the Coop vans can't get to the island to fill up the shelves, where the fuel tanker didn't come so supply runs so low the garage has to ration it ( emergency services only).

alijangra · 09/04/2023 17:14

Firefightress1 · 09/04/2023 14:42

What's the rental market like in other tourist hot spots? Its pretty much non existent on Skye so businesses are really struggling to get staff as they can secure accomodation.
A lot of the hospitality workers are desperate to even get a static caravan yet all these houses lie empty and they still try to change holiday let prices for local workers looking for temp accomodation while they look for something more permanent.
So many restaurants and retail places have reduced hours as they can't get staff. Is it similar elsewhere?

Same on Isle of Lewis

Puffalicious · 09/04/2023 16:57

This same problem is everywhere. Went to a local park today to roll eggs/ have a sit down/ cuppa afterwards. It's in a very nice part of town. At the tables there were Coke cans/ plastic wrapper from the multi-pack, crisp packets and an abandoned Easter gift bag. I mean, WTF?! My sister lives beside it, so there everyday with the dog, and said she had to ask a man to stop peeing behind a tree ( 6 yo niece with her) and remind him there are toilets a 3 min walk away. People are so selfish, so no wonder on holiday when it's not their back yard they're even worse sometimes. I have no idea why people behave like this.

DisquietintheRanks · 09/04/2023 16:50

Where do you live @Windingdown where the local dog walkers never leave dog shit lying around? I live in a tourist area but that's pretty much a universal phenomenon. Ditto litter. Yes there's more of it in spring and summer but it's not like the locals never drop a crisp packet.

Windingdown · 09/04/2023 16:06

LetsPlayShadowlands · 09/04/2023 15:55

Finding dog shit in plastic bags on my walks disgusts me too. Who is to say that wasn't a local family out for a walk with their young child ehi got caught short? Oh never!!

I don't know if you live in the kind of rural area being discussed LetsPlayShadowlands. If you do you'll know that you get a fair idea of what and who is making the mess based on the time of year it happens. During tourist season - human shit, dirty nappies, rubbish dumped, public toilets turned into middens by people emptying portable loos, disposable BBQs, fires, volunteer search & rescue teams called out for people stuck in mud/climbing mountains in flip flops. Out of tourist season - nothing.

LetsPlayShadowlands · 09/04/2023 15:55

canina · 09/04/2023 15:50

Finding 2 lots of human shit/toilet paper on my walk this morning disgusts me.

Finding dog shit in plastic bags on my walks disgusts me too. Who is to say that wasn't a local family out for a walk with their young child ehi got caught short? Oh never!!

LetsPlayShadowlands · 09/04/2023 15:53

Fundays12 · 09/04/2023 12:12

As a local I can assure you many camper vans owners are a problem. Obviously not all as many are respectful, use proper campsite and tidy up after themselves. The ones that I have found are problematic are the ones that leave rubbish and feces all over the place and the ones that have no idea how to drive on single track roads or what the rules are around passing places etc. They come here too see the beauty of the Highlands then treat it like a waste ground. Also ones who want to climb our mountains but are ill prepared to do so wind up ending up being rescued.

The toilets issue you encountered was what I meant. The Highlands doesn't have the infrastructure to cope with the sheer volumes of tourists. Everything is so wide spread getting staff to clean them can be an issue too.

YOUR mountains? Hahaha.

canina · 09/04/2023 15:50

Finding 2 lots of human shit/toilet paper on my walk this morning disgusts me.

NatashaDancing · 09/04/2023 15:49

LetsPlayShadowlands · 09/04/2023 15:48

This attitude of tourists being 'other' disgusts me.

Same here.

LetsPlayShadowlands · 09/04/2023 15:48

This attitude of tourists being 'other' disgusts me.

PolkaDotMankini · 09/04/2023 15:47

It's very sad. We're currently en route back from a short holiday on a Scottish island (not Skye). We paid to leave our car on the mainland, hired bikes after the ferry crossing, had lunch at an independent cafe, drank at the pub, picked up litter on the beach and didn't use the beautiful scenery as a toilet. I hope that we were respectful and contributed to the economy rather than being a PITA.

Whisper23 · 09/04/2023 15:46

And I agree that something needs to be done about second homes. The two houses closest to us are empty all the time. In the 18 months we've been here one of them has had visitors once for about 5 days. The other one had had people there for maybe 2 weekends. Clamp down on second homes and air b&bs.

Whisper23 · 09/04/2023 15:44

Another Skye resident here. We moved here 18 months ago and I'm surprised by some of the comments about incomers not being welcome. I've not felt this at all, people have been very welcoming and friendly.

We're in a very quiet bit up beyond Dunvegan so the tourists are not a big issue in our immediate area. We get the odd campervan looking for somewhere to park up but not much else. The roads were busy when I drove into Portree yesterday though. Lots of people who don't seem to know how to drive on single track roads.

In other parts of the island the campervans are an absolute menace. I think numbers should be restricted somehow. I'm not far from Neist Point but I wouldn't even attempt to get there in summer due to the number of campervans. Personally I think there should be a toll on the bridge for campervans, with the money ringfenced to sort out the roads/potholes.

bossonext · 09/04/2023 15:28

canina · 09/04/2023 15:17

Where I used to take pride I now loathe commentators extolling the virtues of Scotland.

What, because of tourists?

canina · 09/04/2023 15:17

Where I used to take pride I now loathe commentators extolling the virtues of Scotland.

NatashaDancing · 09/04/2023 15:02

Firefightress1 · 09/04/2023 14:42

What's the rental market like in other tourist hot spots? Its pretty much non existent on Skye so businesses are really struggling to get staff as they can secure accomodation.
A lot of the hospitality workers are desperate to even get a static caravan yet all these houses lie empty and they still try to change holiday let prices for local workers looking for temp accomodation while they look for something more permanent.
So many restaurants and retail places have reduced hours as they can't get staff. Is it similar elsewhere?

Well Sturgeon's mother-in-law had until this week a spare, never used, luxury camper van. Maybe it could be offered up?

As for holiday homes, I know of an SNP MSP who bought one shortly after being elected. I don't mean a flat in Edinburgh but a house in a tourist village.

Firefightress1 · 09/04/2023 14:42

What's the rental market like in other tourist hot spots? Its pretty much non existent on Skye so businesses are really struggling to get staff as they can secure accomodation.
A lot of the hospitality workers are desperate to even get a static caravan yet all these houses lie empty and they still try to change holiday let prices for local workers looking for temp accomodation while they look for something more permanent.
So many restaurants and retail places have reduced hours as they can't get staff. Is it similar elsewhere?

OP posts:
Firefightress1 · 09/04/2023 14:30

ifthe · 09/04/2023 14:28

https://www.rightmove.co.uk/properties/132371306#/?channel=RES_BUY Offers over £300k (!!!) for 2 bedrooms on Harris. The worlds gone crazy.

Yep, the second homes market has pushed the prices skye high on the islands and they often get bought up as holiday lets so no one lives in them half the year. Very sad

OP posts:
Firefightress1 · 09/04/2023 14:29

Wiw, 8 pages! Its been really interesting to read about people's experiences.
Thanks for everyone's opinions and views, if visitors have a little understanding of the consequences of some of their actions then I'm sure we can all exist happily together and enjoy these beautiful places for years to come. We need tourism but we don't need inconsiderate entitled a-holes that think the highway code and country code doesn't apply to tham!

OP posts:
MrsAvocet · 09/04/2023 13:06

It is a fine line for the authorities to walk too - I don't think there are simple solutions. Where I live, parking is a big problem and there are polarised views locally. On one hand there are those who oppose all developments such as additional carparks toilet blocks etc on the grounds that the roads are over full already so we don't want to encourage more traffic and that such developments would be detrimental to the natural beauty of the area. On the other hand there are those who say we need more tourists for the economy and should be doing everything possible to accomodate them.
My personal view is somewhere in between. People come despite the parking being poor and there being no public toilets in our valley and when it gets really busy they park in dangerous places and pee in the bushes. I think there's probably room for some careful, fairly low scale developments that would improve the situation at the peak times without turning the place into a concrete jungle. There is also possibly potential for temporary carparks at peak times. There was a big hoo-ha last year when one of the local farmers started charging people to park in one of his fields and he was eventually stopped and fined. Personally I didn't see a problem with this, as people were parking on the verges, in residential streets etc otherwise and I think it was less obtrusive to have them parked in the field. Nobody wants to lose the natural beauty of the area, but we do benefit economically from visitors and they are going to come anyway. Preventing tourism is neither desirable nor feasible, but better attempts to control the situation and balance the needs of visitors and local residents would probably help everyone. But it's definitely not easy. I do get frustrated with the behaviour of some visitors, but then I have to ask myself, if I arrived to do a particular walk having driven for hours and spent a lot of money getting here but discovered the carpark was full, would I really turn round and go back home or would I try to find a patch of grass I could squeeze my car onto? I suspect if we are completely honest with ourselves, a lot of us would try to find a way to do the activity we had planned. There is no excuse for some of the worst behaviour but I do think some concessions are needed to accomodate visitors.

Fundays12 · 09/04/2023 13:00

Puffalicious · 09/04/2023 12:34

It's makes me so angry- I can't imagine what it's like for you living there. In my mind, fellow lovers of the outdoors and natural world would be like minded people who want to preserve our precious land and treat it with the reverence it deserves. It makes no sense to me at all. People are just beyond the pale sometimes.

Highland Council have a lot to contend with as it's such a huge area. I suppose I hadn't actually thought about no staff to clean them. The shop owner told me he applied to buy the toilets so he could maintain them properly, but it was a legal minefield. Shame.

It's infuriating as I love were I live as do most Highlanders. Most locals welcome tourists but not those that destroy our area. The way the lochs have been treated is awful at times. We spend a lot of time in the lochs over the summer and to see them getting ruined is horrible. They are naturally beautiful and clean but won't be if they carry on being destroyed.

The Highland council have such a vast array of land mass it's created a host of issues most councils don't have to deal with. We also have a low population generally so finding staff can be difficult at the best of times.

Swipe left for the next trending thread