Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Or is teaching 6 Yr old about crucixation out of order?

386 replies

Whostoblame · 08/04/2023 20:30

I might be over reacting but after multiple nights on the trot sleeping no more than 45-60 mins at a time I'm at the end of my tether. 6 year old goes to a non dom school and we are agnostic/atheist at home. School have been teaching them about Jesus and Easter etc including how Jesus was crucified. I now have a sobbing child every night who can't get the pictures out if her mind (and I'm not surprised!!)and subsequently cant sleep from about midnight, crying. Aibu to complain to school that 6 is way too young to be taught this?!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
whyhere · 09/04/2023 08:18

And Happy Easter everyone! (And Eid Mubarak, when the time comes :-) )

whyhere · 09/04/2023 08:11

Tarantellah · 08/04/2023 21:43

Does your child think it’s real? Perhaps you need to emphasise that it’s just a story and it’s not true, any more than Paw Patrol is true.

Oh gosh.... But it IS true. Jesus was a real person and many of the events in the New Testament are confirmed by secular historical documents. Of course each parent must judge for themselves how best to explain the events of Holy Week and Easter, but please at least try to be historically accurate!

Emotionalsupportviper · 09/04/2023 08:09

AlexandriasWindmill · 08/04/2023 21:58

The Mel Gibson film is an 18. There's no way they're showing it in schools.

That's a relief!

Aprilx · 09/04/2023 08:04

Whostoblame · 08/04/2023 21:59

Thanks to those that were helpful, giving an insight that it is in fact normal to be taught at this age (my girl is my oldest so haven't been through this before) and happy Easter to all who celebrate it.

I do not consider myself even Christian, but I went to a catholic school. I was taught about the crucifixion in my first year of school so aged about four and we went over it every year. Nobody was ever traumatised that I can recall, I definitely wasn’t. At that age, I don’t think I had any idea what a horrible thing it was.

Forgooodnesssakenow · 09/04/2023 07:58

OldFan · 09/04/2023 07:51

@CatchYouOnTheFlippetyFlop The thing with a lot of hymns/Christian art etc is that line is not the end of the hymn.

So yes that bit might be grim but the last verse apparently is 'Were you there when God raised him from the tomb?'

Also of course, the crucifixion isn't just the story of a bloke being crucified. It's when we all were offered salvation.

I get what you mean though, like when people talk about His Precious Blood and stuff.

It's when a certain group of people with a certain set of beliefs think we were offered what they consider salvation

Forgooodnesssakenow · 09/04/2023 07:57

HistoryFanatic · 08/04/2023 20:37

Well to a Christian it is fact. As long as they teach about all sorts of religions (believe they legally have to) I don't see an issue. Obviously age appropriate!

There's an age appropriate way to teach about torture and execution?

How would you go about that exactly?

Also if something is only. 'fact' to certain people it's not a fact, it's a belief with no evidence. Teaching it as fact is nonsense

OldFan · 09/04/2023 07:51

@CatchYouOnTheFlippetyFlop The thing with a lot of hymns/Christian art etc is that line is not the end of the hymn.

So yes that bit might be grim but the last verse apparently is 'Were you there when God raised him from the tomb?'

Also of course, the crucifixion isn't just the story of a bloke being crucified. It's when we all were offered salvation.

I get what you mean though, like when people talk about His Precious Blood and stuff.

borntobequiet · 09/04/2023 07:48

Humans are spectacularly evil.

This is what religion taught me. It also made me reject it.

I now see the indoctrination I received as a child (we had Doctrine lessons, so actual indoctrination) as a deliberate normalisation of cruelty, and the othering of those who thought differently, to the extent that they were worthy of eternal damnation. There’s really nothing good about it at all.

bitcharming · 09/04/2023 04:16

the Crown of thorns used to get me. Its sad the idea of him having to carry the cross uphill while being whipped.
oh gosh it's sad. I was like your little girl, empathy is a gift, I would praise her for being so kind and caring. She sounds like a lovely little thing.
Do not tell her it was a standard punishment. poor souls. Humans are spectacularly evil.

Sortyourlifeout · 09/04/2023 03:50

CatchYouOnTheFlippetyFlop · 08/04/2023 22:09

I used to go to a Catholic school and some of the hymns we sang in assembly were so fucked up.

'were you there when they crucified our lord? Were you there when they crucified our lord, woooah, Sometimes it causes me to tremble'

All sang to a joyful merry tune.

Fucking weird.

Lol, there's nothing joyful and merry about that tune 🤣

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 09/04/2023 00:52

What exactly is scaring her? The rising from the dead but? Or the hammering of nails through hands and feet?

ConcordeOoter · 09/04/2023 00:40

99.9999% of the time children aren't at all traumatised by hearing the story of Easter, so something else is going on with that has made it a very intense experience.

Perhaps they have homed in on telling you what you the stories want to hear. It happens.

OldFan · 08/04/2023 22:57

The story of Jesus being crucified and then coming back to his apostles to say 'oi, look at me mate, I'm still here, my body maybe rotting away but my soul lives on' is kindda the corner stone of Christianity.

@anunlikelyseahorse Hey his body rose too, he vanished from the tomb. Otherwise he'd be a bit more like a normal bloke. Though variations on it will happen to us all in the end now.

OldFan · 08/04/2023 22:51

*talk about Islam etc at school too, I mean.

OldFan · 08/04/2023 22:49

Do you mean the Crucifixion? It is Easter. If all they're saying is that he (was nailed to, maybe?) and died on a cross=fine. What do you think people learn at Sunday School, at a younger age? They presumably talk about Islam and other religions too sometimes.

If they went into extreme grizzly detail that'd be different.

Kids can be randomly freaked out by stuff and you can't necessarily know how it's going to hit them- most in the class probably haven't given it much more of a thought.

Watership Down terrified me for weeks when I was 8/9.

RumpleDumple · 08/04/2023 22:35

MysteryBelle · 08/04/2023 22:13

The world needs more people like you ❤️ Thank you, I am Catholic and I agree with you and appreciate your good will and logic.

Thank you xo

RumpleDumple · 08/04/2023 22:29

@whostoblame

Alpogies if i seemed harsh. I didn't explain myself. All i meant was that if you child is experiencing fairly extreme emotions on this topic, it can be easy as a parent to be outraged on their behalf and vocalise how such things should not be taught in schools, thereby exacerbating her emotions. Emotions which she might not understand why she is feeling them.

Her emotions ARE valid and I have no way of knowing what was and was not taught that day in class. However there is next to no chance that the barbarity of what crucifixion actually entailed would be even fleetingly mentioned so, assuming the discussion went along the lines of - nailed to cross, died, resurrected- , then I think your daughter is very empathetic and sensitive and that is no bad thing. But it is often tempting as a non believer to dismiss outright religious beliefs as nonsense, which have no right to be taught to kids.

I would speak to her teacher and ask what was taught, to gain a better understanding of your DD has reacted as she has.

Apologies if I came across as harsh

Flounder2022 · 08/04/2023 22:24

Waitymatey · 08/04/2023 22:17

@Flounder2022 - well it’s great that you have found your way onto this thread and can continue your education

Im a little confused by your comment. I went to catholic school and was raised catholic though my parents were not especially religious although my mam does have a faith.

However I have no faith and my son is not Christened. I am well aware of the story of Easter. My point was I am not fully aware of the details my son was taught apart from what I mentioned.

pizzaHeart · 08/04/2023 22:23

I think it’s normal to explain to 6 years old about Easter but without focusing on the details or graphic image of crucifixion. The fact that lots of PP’s children were ok with this didn’t prove anything. Maybe these children were ok because their teachers presented the idea in a really age appropriate way focusing on the story side or anything else, not on the details of crucifixion.
It’s a very upsetting image for 6 years old. Some posters are saying that we should teach children everything from the early age, surely not everything at once, we have words “age appropriate “ for a reason.

niugboo · 08/04/2023 22:20

See you’re lying to her. That’s going to feed anxiety.

The bigger picture might not be true but fact is people were persecuted and executed for their beliefs.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 08/04/2023 22:19

CatchYouOnTheFlippetyFlop · 08/04/2023 22:09

I used to go to a Catholic school and some of the hymns we sang in assembly were so fucked up.

'were you there when they crucified our lord? Were you there when they crucified our lord, woooah, Sometimes it causes me to tremble'

All sang to a joyful merry tune.

Fucking weird.

Wouldn't have called a spiritual with with a minor tonality (going from C F C to F - Am - F - Fm) as being in the slightest bit joyful and merry, but maybe the fact it was a spiritual confused people.

anunlikelyseahorse · 08/04/2023 22:17

cupofteaandabiccyplease · 08/04/2023 21:19

Why on earth in this day and age are schools or anyone else for that matter still peddling this nonsense?

Because learning about different regions is essential to understand different beliefs and different cultures. What you consider to be a load of old bilge is important to others. It's really not that difficult to understand, surely?
The story of Jesus being crucified and then coming back to his apostles to say 'oi, look at me mate, I'm still here, my body maybe rotting away but my soul lives on' is kindda the corner stone of Christianity.
Just as in primary they teach about Ramadan, because it's an essential part of Islam, or Diwali because it's important to Hindus.

Waitymatey · 08/04/2023 22:17

@Flounder2022 - well it’s great that you have found your way onto this thread and can continue your education

MysteryBelle · 08/04/2023 22:14

ReadersD1gest · 08/04/2023 22:11

That is not sung to a joyful, merry tune, op. Stop playacting.

Exactly. It is a somber mournful tune.

MysteryBelle · 08/04/2023 22:13

RumpleDumple · 08/04/2023 21:47

YABU. The world's major religions have both major historical, cultural and faith based significance (not that they always concur or have much overlap). Crucifixion is a fact. A man called Jesus, who inspired a 'new' religion is a historical fact. You don't have to be Christian to accept that these 2 things did happen.

I would expect a well rounded education to include a discussion on the significance of Easter (how it came about, why some people find it important etc). Knowing about this does.not for a second force people into a belief, does not force a faith upon them. It's a mention (at your DD's age) of something that did happen and which led to the Christian dominance in the western world that exists today. This dominance has shaped our lives, our world, ever since and is so important.

As a disclaimer, i am an athiest. I don't believe in God. But I believe that a knowledge of religion (different from believing and following in a religion) is as worthwhile as knowledge of any other aspect of history.

You can preface it with "some people believe" without denying the validity of their belief. And as an atheist, I'm aware that my non belief is God is just a belief, no more and no less valid as the beliefs in Catholicism or Hinduism etc.

I do detest the atheist idea that somehow they (we) have the automatic right to be dismissive of all other religious beliefs. And that we are somehow superior in our intellect by profession our non beliefs. I suspect you are feeding her hysteria by being vocal about how such things should it be taught in schools. I

The world needs more people like you ❤️ Thank you, I am Catholic and I agree with you and appreciate your good will and logic.