Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Or is teaching 6 Yr old about crucixation out of order?

386 replies

Whostoblame · 08/04/2023 20:30

I might be over reacting but after multiple nights on the trot sleeping no more than 45-60 mins at a time I'm at the end of my tether. 6 year old goes to a non dom school and we are agnostic/atheist at home. School have been teaching them about Jesus and Easter etc including how Jesus was crucified. I now have a sobbing child every night who can't get the pictures out if her mind (and I'm not surprised!!)and subsequently cant sleep from about midnight, crying. Aibu to complain to school that 6 is way too young to be taught this?!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Forgooodnesssakenow · 09/04/2023 14:38

LlynTegid · 09/04/2023 09:49

I don't think it unreasonable to be taught about the crucifixion at age 6. Also even if you are of no religion, knowing about why Good Friday is a bank holiday and Easter important to a significant number of people is no bad thing.

Being taught at 6 that there is a religious festival marked by some religions perfectly fine.

Being told as if it was fact that Jesus died for our sins, rose again and that he was brutally tortured and murdered probably not so much.

Opens kids up to wondering what the hell they've done that was so bad it travelled back in time and murdered a mild mannered Jewish man. It sure as shit would have my 5 year old reopening the question about whether his granny who died is coming back. And the boy asks questions very literally and needs all the details of everything and won't be fobbed off so it'd be a nightmare.

There is absolutely no reason to traumatise children with religious rhetoric, none at all.

ReadersD1gest · 09/04/2023 14:37

Not all children are psychopaths
Now you're just being offensive. And extremely unintelligent. Just stop.

Forgooodnesssakenow · 09/04/2023 14:34

OMG12 · 09/04/2023 13:02

Actually it’s entirely appropriate to teach this. Much of the culture of western civilisation involves this concept. People were crucified by an oppressive regime ) it is likely this included an historical person called Jesus) it is part of our language, culture and history. Kids really generally take this stuff in their stride. I was a very sensitive child- no effect, my son v sensitive - no effect.

it’s important kids learn this stuff, it’s important they learn of historical atrocities, it’s important they learn of things that shape society and individuals.

Given society today I am very pro kids learning how people have been treated historically. People who challenged the Jewish priests, really good Christian’s who didn’t bow down to Rome, women who didn’t fit in with what was expected of them.

Kids need to learn these things far more than many of the things pushed on them by adults these days.

knowing the Bible (whether you believe it as literal truth or not) and this history of Christianity is extremely valuable on many levels in western society.

Knowing Christianity and the larger abrahamic religions does explain the reasoning behind most atrocities and wars at least. Oh and it's a good starting point for explaining the flawed reasoning behind most bigotry.

Tandora · 09/04/2023 14:33

bellac11 · 08/04/2023 20:41

Im an atheist but the crucifixion is a fact, crucifying people was just a standard public execution, nothing more, nothing less

Whether you believe all the other guff around it, thats another matter but the actual act of executing the person known as Jesus (Joshua ben Joseph) was just something done to others as well

Does she understand that up to a point people used to be hanged in the UK, kids tend to love all that gory stuff.

Just because it’s fact doesn’t mean it’s appropriate for a 6 year old?! There are a lot of “facts” about the world that we don’t share with 6 year olds.

“kids tend to love all that gory stuff”. Clearly you have no experience of sensitive children. Not all children are psychopaths.

ReadersD1gest · 09/04/2023 14:30

All those who say teaching about the crucifixion does or did no harm to young children , well, how do they know?
From personal experience, how do people "know" most things?

Forgooodnesssakenow · 09/04/2023 14:28

LlynTegid · 09/04/2023 09:49

I don't think it unreasonable to be taught about the crucifixion at age 6. Also even if you are of no religion, knowing about why Good Friday is a bank holiday and Easter important to a significant number of people is no bad thing.

At 6? Is it ok to teach your 6 yr old about the electric chair? Lethal injection? Hanging?

OMG12 · 09/04/2023 13:02

Thindog · 09/04/2023 12:30

All those who say teaching about the crucifixion does or did no harm to young children , well, how do they know?
Children do not always confide in teachers or even their parents ,when something disturbs them.They might brood at night, have bad dreams, play out worries or exhibit poor behaviour.They cannot always articulate why and what has upset them.
I am sure that children with high levels of wellbeing, natural empathy, and quite normal reaction ,would find details of the crucifixion unsettling.It’s not appropriate to teach this.

Actually it’s entirely appropriate to teach this. Much of the culture of western civilisation involves this concept. People were crucified by an oppressive regime ) it is likely this included an historical person called Jesus) it is part of our language, culture and history. Kids really generally take this stuff in their stride. I was a very sensitive child- no effect, my son v sensitive - no effect.

it’s important kids learn this stuff, it’s important they learn of historical atrocities, it’s important they learn of things that shape society and individuals.

Given society today I am very pro kids learning how people have been treated historically. People who challenged the Jewish priests, really good Christian’s who didn’t bow down to Rome, women who didn’t fit in with what was expected of them.

Kids need to learn these things far more than many of the things pushed on them by adults these days.

knowing the Bible (whether you believe it as literal truth or not) and this history of Christianity is extremely valuable on many levels in western society.

Thindog · 09/04/2023 12:30

All those who say teaching about the crucifixion does or did no harm to young children , well, how do they know?
Children do not always confide in teachers or even their parents ,when something disturbs them.They might brood at night, have bad dreams, play out worries or exhibit poor behaviour.They cannot always articulate why and what has upset them.
I am sure that children with high levels of wellbeing, natural empathy, and quite normal reaction ,would find details of the crucifixion unsettling.It’s not appropriate to teach this.

mbosnz · 09/04/2023 12:14

My daughter was shown a film of the crucifiction at roughly the same age. I was fucking ropable. This was by a bunch of evangelists allowed in by the school to proselytise. (I schooled her up on evolution and we got our own back. . .)

OMG12 · 09/04/2023 12:08

OldFan · 08/04/2023 22:57

The story of Jesus being crucified and then coming back to his apostles to say 'oi, look at me mate, I'm still here, my body maybe rotting away but my soul lives on' is kindda the corner stone of Christianity.

@anunlikelyseahorse Hey his body rose too, he vanished from the tomb. Otherwise he'd be a bit more like a normal bloke. Though variations on it will happen to us all in the end now.

Now, I don’t think this is altogether correct. John 20:14 (after saying his body was no longer in the tomb) “Having said this, she turned around and saw Jesus standing, but she did not know that it was Jesus. 15 Jesus said to her, “Woman, why are you weeping? Whom are you seeking?” Supposing him to be the gardener”

now why, looking at Jesus did Mary Magdalene who was one of the people who spent so much time with Jesus not recognise him
and mistake him as a Gardner if he appeared as a resurrection in his bodily form?

LlynTegid · 09/04/2023 09:49

I don't think it unreasonable to be taught about the crucifixion at age 6. Also even if you are of no religion, knowing about why Good Friday is a bank holiday and Easter important to a significant number of people is no bad thing.

PuddlesPityParty · 09/04/2023 09:18

CatchYouOnTheFlippetyFlop · 08/04/2023 22:09

I used to go to a Catholic school and some of the hymns we sang in assembly were so fucked up.

'were you there when they crucified our lord? Were you there when they crucified our lord, woooah, Sometimes it causes me to tremble'

All sang to a joyful merry tune.

Fucking weird.

Omg I remember that hymn too! Lol at the time it seemed normal but you’re right it’s really creepy to think about a bunch of kids singing that 😳

MysteryBelle · 09/04/2023 09:17

Magenta82 · 09/04/2023 09:03

Can you point me to the secular documents that confirm the existence of Jesus? Or even a similar figure? It was my understanding that the Romans, who kept extensive records, have records of some biblical figures, such as John the Baptist, but not Jesus.

Start with Josephus. And then you’ll find other sources and documents. Very interesting. I minored in Latin so took Roman history classes. Majored in Greek so can read Paul’s letters. It is all very fascinating. You can find all the information you’re seeking very easily, it is common knowledge.

Wiltingredrose · 09/04/2023 09:11

@Sortyourlifeout thats what Christian’s always say. My family are lovely, the church I grew up in was loving and kind. It’s not the people who are the problem it’s the message of Christianity and the source material (the Bible)! If there’s a problem with Christianity people always like to say “you were taught it wrong” or “those people weren’t real Christians”. It’s totally patronising and undermines peoples experiences. I am not stupid, I studied theology and went to a main stream church for 30 years. When I had children the scales fell from my eyes and I realised how fucked up the message is. At some point I had to teach my child Jesus died for their sins. It’s telling people they are sick and then saying you have the medicine.

I don’t have a problem with people being religious. However don’t pretend that the main message isn’t sin and Jesus dying for your sins. You can explain it in any way you like but John 3:16 says Jesus died for my sins. Why? I didn’t ask him to do that and won’t take on the guilt! I don’t believe in heaven and hell and don’t need religion to help me love my neighbour and treat people well.

Magenta82 · 09/04/2023 09:03

whyhere · 09/04/2023 08:11

Oh gosh.... But it IS true. Jesus was a real person and many of the events in the New Testament are confirmed by secular historical documents. Of course each parent must judge for themselves how best to explain the events of Holy Week and Easter, but please at least try to be historically accurate!

Can you point me to the secular documents that confirm the existence of Jesus? Or even a similar figure? It was my understanding that the Romans, who kept extensive records, have records of some biblical figures, such as John the Baptist, but not Jesus.

Sortyourlifeout · 09/04/2023 09:01

Wiltingredrose · 09/04/2023 08:48

It’s a horrible thing to teach a child. I grew up in a Christian household and learnt about the crucifixion at a young age. You are also taught that Jesus died for your sins. The message is that you killed Jesus. Christianity is cruel and fucked up! You are burdened with guilt at a young age and it messes you up.

Not if it's done properly! Nobody should be 'frightened' into being a Christian. That's not what it's about.

Being a Christian should be a joy and a pleasure to talk about. It's not all about fear and condemnation.

Unfortunately some 'branches of the church' can't move on from 'You're going to burn in hell if you don't repent'. Or from the notion that being gay is a sin and women should be stuck in the kitchen. Some of the large churches (and some smaller ones) need to have a long look at what they teach, because;

All of the above is wrong IMO. Jesus was (and is) about LOVE. Jesus was (and is) about building communities. Jesus was (and is) about HOPE. Jesus was (and is) about looking after one another.

Wiltingredrose · 09/04/2023 08:48

It’s a horrible thing to teach a child. I grew up in a Christian household and learnt about the crucifixion at a young age. You are also taught that Jesus died for your sins. The message is that you killed Jesus. Christianity is cruel and fucked up! You are burdened with guilt at a young age and it messes you up.

Sortyourlifeout · 09/04/2023 08:36

Emotionalsupportviper · 09/04/2023 08:09

That's a relief!

Suspect you already knew that though!

Sortyourlifeout · 09/04/2023 08:34

Forgooodnesssakenow · 09/04/2023 07:57

There's an age appropriate way to teach about torture and execution?

How would you go about that exactly?

Also if something is only. 'fact' to certain people it's not a fact, it's a belief with no evidence. Teaching it as fact is nonsense

Most of the greatest scholars and historians - many of them atheists - agree that this event happened. It's not just something that was made up.

They will agree that there was some bloke who went around performing miracles and was crucified by those in power. Now whether you believe that this man was the Son of God (and whether you believe in God at all) is another matter.

Sortyourlifeout · 09/04/2023 08:29

borntobequiet · 09/04/2023 07:48

Humans are spectacularly evil.

This is what religion taught me. It also made me reject it.

I now see the indoctrination I received as a child (we had Doctrine lessons, so actual indoctrination) as a deliberate normalisation of cruelty, and the othering of those who thought differently, to the extent that they were worthy of eternal damnation. There’s really nothing good about it at all.

You are correct, there is nothing good about what you were taught and the way you were taught it.

I'm so sorry you went through that.

Sleepyandconfused · 09/04/2023 08:25

Your child has never seen a church or a historical building with a crucifix statue? Or even a crucifix necklace?! YAB a bit precious.

Emotionalsupportviper · 09/04/2023 08:24

Forgooodnesssakenow · 09/04/2023 07:57

There's an age appropriate way to teach about torture and execution?

How would you go about that exactly?

Also if something is only. 'fact' to certain people it's not a fact, it's a belief with no evidence. Teaching it as fact is nonsense

Unfortunately the "torture and execution" parts are facts. People are still being crucified for their faith today. Christians are still persecuted in some parts of the world. However, I agree that too much graphic detail about ANY subject of this type eg Holocaust, Holodomor, Year Zero is inappropriate.

The belief part comes with the resurrection and ascension - these can't be proven and must be taken on faith.

You believe it or you don't. That's what faith is - trust.

It doesn't deny facts any facts (because there is no proof either that it didn't happen) - but accepts that there are no facts to support it and trusts in God.

Butchyrestingface · 09/04/2023 08:21

I struggle to see how you could teach the story of Easter to anyone and miss out the way where the main character got nailed to a cross.

But I speak as someone who was raised Catholic and lapsed and was taught the story well before school age. We all knew about it by the OP's daughter's age in school and I don't remember any hysterics.

Emotionalsupportviper · 09/04/2023 08:18

whyhere · 09/04/2023 08:18

And Happy Easter everyone! (And Eid Mubarak, when the time comes :-) )

And to you and all others here, too, my dear.

Emotionalsupportviper · 09/04/2023 08:18

NeverDropYourMooncup · 08/04/2023 22:19

Wouldn't have called a spiritual with with a minor tonality (going from C F C to F - Am - F - Fm) as being in the slightest bit joyful and merry, but maybe the fact it was a spiritual confused people.

Most spirituals I have heard are very mournful, born from the horror of slavery, but have a note of hope. Some are joyful, though eg Micheal Row the Boat Ashore, and Down by the Riverside.

Swipe left for the next trending thread